You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman looking to mend broken Hearts?
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Freedman looking to mend broken Hearts?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 15 Nov 19 12.47am

Got nothing but admiration for him, his issues were between him and parish, never the club, fans need to remember that and let's look at Parish, which manager enjoyed working with him and stayed with it and didn't criticise him?

 


This was once a quality forum....

Charles Flag Forest Hill 15 Nov 19 10.10am

Bearing in mind the whole story still really only amounts to a rumour.......

Dougie seemed to be hardly more than a smokescreen for continuing to work with Iain Moody after his questionable sense of humour forced his resignation. Since everyone now knows about that, maybe his role is over?

Supposing Dougie has been contributing more than that, he made some excellent signings as Manager and the club has made some excellent signimgs while he's been DoF - Cahill, Kouyate, McCarthy for instance.

Last summer's apparently disappointing activity will make more sense if rumours turn out to be true that a Zaha for Batshuhayi swap based deal only awaits the end of Chelsea's tranfer ban. We might see more of Camasara then too.

 

JohnB Flag 15 Nov 19 11.45am

Dougie has always had some magical hold over Parish. You only have to read the Holloway interview where he refers to the amount of time Parish would telly Holloway what Dougie would have done if he were still there.

I like Dougie, he's been a great servant to the club. However, I would much rather, if we go down the route of having a DoF type role, have someone who is much more qualified doing it.

Player recruitment and overall forward thinking strategy in terms of the playing squad and style of play has always been where we are lacking. Either trust the manager to get his players in or appoint a DoF with a real vision and long term strategy who can get players that the manager will happily put into the system.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 16 Nov 19 7.54am

Not for me. Hope he goes. I dread the window, the ridiculous last minute stuff, the lack of signing the players we need (right back, striker) in countless windows, since he’s been in that role.
Above all, I just don’t see what he adds and I don’t like that he left, failed miserably, and we think that means he’ll be a great DoF.

Would rather Roy moved upstairs and we got a young manager in who could learn under his watchful eye.

Edited by Helmet46 (16 Nov 2019 7.54am)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Nov 19 11.15am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

as a manager for us he was awesome - remember Bolasie, Murray, Delaney and Moritz for a combined total of 300k - and they were prem class - but he's lost it, Hearts looks like a good opportunity for him to find it again

..he received so much abuse! Fans moaned to death about the endless one goal games, very very much like Hodgson but because we were playing in a lower league he had more consistency with the low scoring wins that was all. if Hodgson had Bolasie and Murray today we would be so much better in the opposition box lol

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Nov 19 11.19am

Originally posted by HesHereHesThere

Yeah but didn’t our chairman have to get him in a headlock in a car park and tell how him how the team should be playing before we then rocketed up the table...

That was the rumor wasn't it

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Nov 19 11.26am

Originally posted by JohnB

Dougie has always had some magical hold over Parish. You only have to read the Holloway interview where he refers to the amount of time Parish would telly Holloway what Dougie would have done if he were still there.

I like Dougie, he's been a great servant to the club. However, I would much rather, if we go down the route of having a DoF type role, have someone who is much more qualified doing it.

Player recruitment and overall forward thinking strategy in terms of the playing squad and style of play has always been where we are lacking. Either trust the manager to get his players in or appoint a DoF with a real vision and long term strategy who can get players that the manager will happily put into the system.

Requires a long term manager, where lot and lots of clubs fail, look at Arsenal now, Wenger was slowly trying to rebuild and their fans wouldn't have it lol replacing managers for a fix never ever works out, the fix only involves the players, never the manager ..even for our Dutch manager he couldn't cope with our players lack of ball control and passing and he got the bullet!

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Nov 19 6.55am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Got nothing but admiration for him, his issues were between him and parish, never the club, fans need to remember that and let's look at Parish, which manager enjoyed working with him and stayed with it and didn't criticise him?

What rubbish, he left for more money, taking the main staff with him, this in the middle of the season when it is hard to find a new manager, unless you can find another Greedman. Year, he really cared about the club and fans.
He was an assistant coach at Southend going nowhere with his life and career when Parish rescued him with the Palace job, so much for loyalty.
If you want to leave, do it close season, not in the middle, leaving the club that has made you in the s**t.

Yes, he was a great player, but has gone from hero to zero.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Nov 19 8.45am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

What rubbish, he left for more money, taking the main staff with him, this in the middle of the season when it is hard to find a new manager, unless you can find another Greedman. Year, he really cared about the club and fans.
He was an assistant coach at Southend going nowhere with his life and career when Parish rescued him with the Palace job, so much for loyalty.
If you want to leave, do it close season, not in the middle, leaving the club that has made you in the s**t.

Yes, he was a great player, but has gone from hero to zero.

In actual fact Freedman didn't quite leave in mid-season, he left in October after 11 games with the club in 4th place and winning 6 of his last 8 games in charge.

When he joined Bolton they were 18th and they finished the season in 7th place.


Edited by Willo (17 Nov 2019 8.59am)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Nov 19 9.33am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

If you want to leave, do it close season, not in the middle, leaving the club that has made you in the s**t.

Surely it has to work both ways as we have sacked managers mid season

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 17 Nov 19 3.23pm

he was entitled to go - there is no unconditional loyalty in any job, but it was a bad decision for Palace and for him, he has never got back to the level he was when we dragged us up the championship, his astuteness picking players back then was remarkable so his recruitment role here made sense but he hasn't managed to repeat the trick for whatever reason - there was an interesting quote about available players too often being either too expensive for us or not good enough, but if Bournemouth with their Subbuteo stadium can attract the right type of player than so can we - we need to recruit better recruiters than the likes of Freedman and Moody.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 18 Nov 19 6.55am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Surely it has to work both ways as we have sacked managers mid season

Yes we have, but only out of desperation when staring at relegation, not for monetary reasons.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 18 Nov 19 7.00am

Originally posted by Willo

In actual fact Freedman didn't quite leave in mid-season, he left in October after 11 games with the club in 4th place and winning 6 of his last 8 games in charge.

When he joined Bolton they were 18th and they finished the season in 7th place.


Edited by Willo (17 Nov 2019 8.59am)

That's all very well Willo, but the amount of games he had won or lost and league positions at Palace and Bolton are irrelevant, my point was about the way he left and the damage it could and nearly did do to the club.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 18 Nov 19 7.03am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

he was entitled to go - there is no unconditional loyalty in any job, but it was a bad decision for Palace and for him, he has never got back to the level he was when we dragged us up the championship, his astuteness picking players back then was remarkable so his recruitment role here made sense but he hasn't managed to repeat the trick for whatever reason - there was an interesting quote about available players too often being either too expensive for us or not good enough, but if Bournemouth with their Subbuteo stadium can attract the right type of player than so can we - we need to recruit better recruiters than the likes of Freedman and Moody.

Bournemouth have a billionaire owner and broke ffp rules to get promoted and still splash the cash regularly.
Don't be fooled by the "plucky little Bournemouth " story.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Nov 19 8.30am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

That's all very well Willo, but the amount of games he had won or lost and league positions at Palace and Bolton are irrelevant, my point was about the way he left and the damage it could and nearly did do to the club.

I understand your sentiments and of course he was vilified for the action he took.

I believe the point I was making was that he didn't desert a 'sinking ship' and departed for a club much lower in the table so I suppose he took a bit of a gamble.

We of course were promoted the season he left so perhaps some might opine that having left us in 4th place, this provided the platform for our promotion.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 18 Nov 19 9.02am

Originally posted by Willo


We of course were promoted the season he left so perhaps some might opine that having left us in 4th place, this provided the platform for our promotion.

There is no arguing that point as he did just that

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 18 Nov 19 6.22pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

What rubbish, he left for more money, taking the main staff with him, this in the middle of the season when it is hard to find a new manager, unless you can find another Greedman. Year, he really cared about the club and fans.
He was an assistant coach at Southend going nowhere with his life and career when Parish rescued him with the Palace job, so much for loyalty.
If you want to leave, do it close season, not in the middle, leaving the club that has made you in the s**t.

Yes, he was a great player, but has gone from hero to zero.

Spot on. However good he was as a player, he’s never a club legend anymore. For the record, I don’t think he was a great player at all... decent, but not great.

 

auk Flag 18 Nov 19 8.52pm

I doubt if Dougie was ever a contender for the Hearts job.

He and his family are settled here, and he had bad experiences in management at Bolton and Forest.

He’s certainly not in the bookies’ top ten for the job.

Jack Ross is 2/1 and Gary Holt is 4/1.

Higher odds are being offered for Scot Gemill, David Moyes, Stuart McCall, Michael O’Neill, Paul Hartley, Steve Robinson and Steven Pressley.

There’s no reason to believe that Dougie is not doing a good job at Palace, inevitably with tight budgetary constraints.

Also he seems to be relatively secure - and he would forfeit that if he returned to the ups and downs of day-to-day management.

It would be interesting to know more about his job description and how he has been contributing.

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 18 Nov 19 9.06pm

Is this purely speculation from the press linking every Scottish manager, past and present to a vacant big job or more wishful thinking on our behalf that we might be shot of him. Considering his managerial record and his previous wage demands , I can't see this happening.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 19 Nov 19 7.32am

Originally posted by CPFC1965

Is this purely speculation from the press linking every Scottish manager, past and present to a vacant big job or more wishful thinking on our behalf that we might be shot of him.

If you look back at the beginning of the thread you will see the links to newspapers articles

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Freedman looking to mend broken Hearts?