This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
The easy immediate solution is: look how it is done on the continent and stop with this ridiculous use of lines in a 3D pattern, projected on a 2D screen. Where does the shoulder stop and the arm begin? How accurate is the moment when the footage is stilled to measure? While I genuinely doubt it is as accurate as they seem to think it certainly is totally spoiling the game. Last weekend 4 good goals were killed by this ludicrous use of VAR. Not even necessarily the VAR itself being the problem but the use of it.
Originally posted by JRW2
Whether this is a new idea or has already been discussed I don't know, but it came into my mind when reading Willo's mention on the Southampton Match thread of what happens in cricket. I suggest that, as in cricket, both sides should be entitled to ask for a review of a limited number of decisions. I don't know what that number is in cricket, but in football I would limit it to two reviews per team in any one match (with successful reviews counting towards that number). Given that refs might be reluctant to admit they'd made an error, I would retain what is known in cricket as the Third Umpire to judge the reviews. But I wouldn't allow the latter to step in of his own accord - only if asked to by a captain, via the ref. And he should be given a maximum time (30 seconds?) in which to adjudicate. I believe that, knowing that they had only two reviews available, captains would only contest decisions that were "clear and obvious" - which is what we all want, and should eliminate appeals against, for example, offside decisions based on the length of a finger nail.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Whether this is a new idea or has already been discussed I don't know, but it came into my mind when reading Willo's mention on the Southampton Match thread of what happens in cricket. I suggest that, as in cricket, both sides should be entitled to ask for a review of a limited number of decisions. I don't know what that number is in cricket, but in football I would limit it to two reviews per team in any one match (with successful reviews counting towards that number). Given that refs might be reluctant to admit they'd made an error, I would retain what is known in cricket as the Third Umpire to judge the reviews. But I wouldn't allow the latter to step in of his own accord - only if asked to by a captain, via the ref. And he should be given a maximum time (30 seconds?) in which to adjudicate. I believe that, knowing that they had only two reviews available, captains would only contest decisions that were "clear and obvious" - which is what we all want, and should eliminate appeals against, for example, offside decisions based on the length of a finger nail. Cricket gives the umpire a half balls width, leniency must be built in for the refs sake, we must not undermine the man in the middle too much.
|
|
|
Originally posted by beak
Cricket gives the umpire a half balls width, leniency must be built in for the refs sake, we must not undermine the man in the middle too much. Originally the narrative about VAR was that the referee in the middle would be making the final decision. Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2019 4.34pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
The present 'lines' system seems to be inaccurate and I am not sure if there is any synchrony in offside decisions between the precise moment the ball is kicked and when the action is stopped - surely this may be subject to human error by the VAR technicians? The referee on the pitch should be the sole and final arbiter of VAR checks. Therefore, do as everywhere else in the world and let the ref. review it on the pitchside screen. It is absurd that another ref. sat in the comfort of a room has the final word. This is an area of contention we are shown a still picture and the line is drawn between defender and striker however this all depends on the exact moment the ball is kicked, one frame wrong and we are looking at the wrong picture. Ian Wright on MOTM felt that VAR should be checked against the players feet which is my preference. That still would not resolve the issue above but as he said the striker would at least be able to time his run better knowing that. In the case of Wilf he was leaning forward but his feet were behind the defender. As others have also suggested if there is doubt then VAR should not overturn the original decision.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
This is an area of contention we are shown a still picture and the line is drawn between defender and striker however this all depends on the exact moment the ball is kicked, one frame wrong and we are looking at the wrong picture. Ian Wright on MOTM felt that VAR should be checked against the players feet which is my preference. That still would not resolve the issue above but as he said the striker would at least be able to time his run better knowing that. In the case of Wilf he was leaning forward but his feet were behind the defender. As others have also suggested if there is doubt then VAR should not overturn the original decision. The original idea was "Clear and obvious" in relation to VAR in general, not a forensic examination deeming whether a miniscule part of the body was fractionally ahead of the second last opponent and taking what seems like an eternity arriving at a decision. Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2019 8.47am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
The original idea was "Clear and obvious" in relation to VAR in general, not a forensic examination deeming whether a miniscule part of the body was fractionally ahead of the second last opponent and taking what seems like an eternity arriving at a decision. Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2019 8.47am) Clear and obvious was my understanding too but not according to this article; not for offside anyway.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Clear and obvious was my understanding too but not according to this article; not for offside anyway. Indeed the article mentions that "Clear and obvious" does not apply to offsides but pundits have asserted that when they went to Stockley Park in pre-season for an explantion they were provided with handouts specifying "Clear and obvious". Chris Kamara at the weekend referred to his handout and didn't mention that offsides were excluded.A great deal of confusion reigns.
|
|
|
This is the view of IFAB. I suspect there will be changes next season. Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2019 9.25am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Indeed the article mentions that "Clear and obvious" does not apply to offsides but pundits have asserted that when they went to Stockley Park in pre-season for an explantion they were provided with handouts specifying "Clear and obvious". Chris Kamara at the weekend referred to his handout and didn't mention that offsides were excluded.A great deal of confusion reigns. It seems to be the FA’s interpretation of offside rather than the official line. As you say, confusion reigns.
|
|
|
Head and feet are primary scoring parts.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
It seems to be the FA’s interpretation of offside rather than the official line. As you say, confusion reigns.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Head and feet are primary scoring parts. Correct. If the head and/or feet [foot] is over the line. The end. Simples. Arm pit, torso, knee, elbow... complete nonsense foot and/or head. Choose one and stick with it. If it is not clear then its a goal. It need not be so complicated. I agree with VAR because some if not most of our referees and linesman are; A) Incompetent; and/or B) biased (Martin Atkinson et al); and/or C) make genuine errors. VAR should and can eliminate these issues. The principle is a great idea as it makes it 'fair'. It is the incompetent and arrogant application that is poor.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
I don't think that IFAB will change the offside law.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.