You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > January Window Inquest
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

January Window Inquest


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 01 Feb 20 1.05pm

Kouyate, Guita, Schlupp, McArthur, Luka, Townsend, PVA, Tomkins and Ayew togethers wages are less than Benteke, Sakho, Meyer and Wilf, and only wilf is a regular, until this is sorted out then its not rocket science why we are struggling financially

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 01 Feb 20 1.22pm

Let's not just look at this window look back over the last few. We have only spent £2,5 m on Ayew and only signed one player under 25 Meyer who is a first team signing.

We have clearly got serious money problems and the AWB money - which we drew down a loan against has gone ....where?

Dougie needs sacking as what does he do? We don't sign players and that is a key part of his job.

We also operate double standards - demanding all of the money up front say for AWB and from what I hear one of the reasons we lost out on players this time was we wanted to pay little up front and lots over time.

Our club is being mismanaged and I fear that we will sell Wilf simply to balance the books not move us on.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Feb 20 1.35pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Let's not just look at this window look back over the last few. We have only spent £2,5 m on Ayew and only signed one player under 25 Meyer who is a first team signing.

We have clearly got serious money problems and the AWB money - which we drew down a loan against has gone ....where?

Dougie needs sacking as what does he do? We don't sign players and that is a key part of his job.

We also operate double standards - demanding all of the money up front say for AWB and from what I hear one of the reasons we lost out on players this time was we wanted to pay little up front and lots over time.

Our club is being mismanaged and I fear that we will sell Wilf simply to balance the books not move us on.

Good post. Given what Meyer earns I thought he was brought in to be a regular starter; RH obviously has different ideas, which begs the question, considering the expenditure and lack of game time why was Meyer brought in? Surely there were other players available?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Feb 20 1.35pm

Originally posted by bexleydave


Pierrick is in the U18s and has played seven minutes of PL football; that doesn't make him a "senior player". Who's the 23rd then?

Keepers
1) Guaita
2) Hennessey
3) Henderson

Defenders
4) Joel Ward
5) James Tomkins
6) Mamadou Sakho
7) Scott Dann
Martin Kelly
9) Gary Cahill
10) Patrick Van Aanholt

Midfield
11) James McArthur
12) James McArthy
13) Andros Townsend
14) Luka Milivojevic
15) Chiek Kouyate
16) Max Meyer
17) Jairo Reidewald
1 Jeffrey Schlupp
19) Brandon Pierrick

Attackers
20) Wilf Zaha
21) Jordan Ayew
22) Christian Benteke
23) Cenk Tosun

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Feb 20 1.40pm

I can understand, people are disappointed, but the January window is the panic purchase window. We are sitting midtable and picking up points regularly, so there was never going to be an influx of purchases, like the Allardyce window.
West Ham are panicking and paid way over the odds for Bowen. As for Ferguson, if we bought him and he spent 2 years on the treatment table like Wickham, who would get the blame.
Tosun looks a good loan signing, he will score a few goals.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 01 Feb 20 1.44pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Kouyate, Guita, Schlupp, McArthur, Luka, Townsend, PVA, Tomkins and Ayew togethers wages are less than Benteke, Sakho, Meyer and Wilf, and only wilf is a regular, until this is sorted out then its not rocket science why we are struggling financially


Not true Benteke was on a deal worth 120 a week we don't know what his current deal is you would think it was decreased it 100% wont of gone up.

You have just made up numbers most those players are on around 60+ each

We have money people need to stop saying we don't you can't sell a player for 60m and then claim we don't have any the wages had been reduced so we use around 80% max of tv money on them.

Another thing people are blaming Dougie come on use your brains hes a SP puppet how is it his fault

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 Feb 20 1.50pm

Look it's clear that the Americans have no interest in investing any further and want out..!!

Now whether that's because they want to run the club and Parish won't relinquish his stake/control is just pure speculation - we do not know what is happening behind the scenes.

If you believe some of the threads Hodgson said that he and Parish had been asking the American's for money to invest in the window - but clearly nothing doing.

I he move suspect that the move for Fergurson broke down due to WBA not wanting to do a structured deal "on the never never" and that the injury thing is a bit of a smoke screen - boys played 21 games this season no problems.

Upside is that we have PVA, Milo and Andros all back - if you look at it conversely to have them now available after the window and translate to transfer value/new players available - what would have been their cost in the window?

So it ain't all bad.

But it seems there is now a complete impasse between Parish and the Americans and that if that ain't sorted before the summer/next season we really will be relegation candidates next year.

So this need sorting between now and the end of the season.

The quicker we get to securing our Premiership survival and status for next season the more attractive we are for new Investors to buy the Americans out and the longer Parish has to complete those negotiations.

Then to kick off the summer window with investment, funds and a clear strategy in place.

Beyond that Roy ain't getting any younger - he is doing a an excellent job IMO - but that will need addressing. Personally I'd go all out for Eddie Howe - think he would be good for us. Think Bmuff are doomed this season.

In summary think we have more than a strong enough squad, with the "walking wounded" now available to secure a comfortable mid season finish with time/games to spare.

For the reasons I mentioned above the real worry is that if we/Parish doesn't get someone to buy out the American's then next season could be when things really begin to unravel.

On today, think Roy will have the boys right up this and with the injured players returning will make us all the stronger, can see 3-1 Palace.

COYP..!!

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 01 Feb 20 2.00pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Not true Benteke was on a deal worth 120 a week we don't know what his current deal is you would think it was decreased it 100% wont of gone up.

You have just made up numbers most those players are on around 60+ each

We have money people need to stop saying we don't you can't sell a player for 60m and then claim we don't have any the wages had been reduced so we use around 80% max of tv money on them.

Another thing people are blaming Dougie come on use your brains hes a SP puppet how is it his fault

Benteke would still be on 120k a week if you offer him a contract on less he is entitled to a free transfer which would negate any point in extending it. all the others are on between 65 and 32.5 if you believe the figures which I do

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 01 Feb 20 2.36pm

I'm sorry I just don't accept the 'we got a shed load of cash for AWB so we have money,' arguement.

The simple fact that in the last 3 windows we have paid out virtually nothing to my mind points to a distinct lack of readies.

Where has it gone? It's hard to tell as our ownership structure makes a follow the money exercise almost impossible, but it is a structure which makes money disappear very easily into offshore structures away from the taxman.

My guessing is we needed to sell simply to pay the bill's inc the yanks. We will sell Wilf in the summer again simply to feed the money machine.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 01 Feb 20 2.36pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

If we're lucky with injuries we will actually be stronger than in the last 10 games or so, as Townsend missing has really hurt our game and Ward is a much better right-back than Kelly. If however we have similar injury problems then we will be worse off in terms of numbers as we have one less senior player than when the window opened (albeit Roy never played Camarassa) and we have loaned/sold some of our more senior youth players. Ferguson would probably have been behind PvA and Ward this season barring injuries anyway, so if they stay fit in the short-term it would have made little difference if we'd signed him.

I'm fed up as I was hoping for someone new to add some excitement and interest, but with players returning we should be more than capable of at least securing another 10 points. Today's opponents have looked to go for it to build on a strong season, we have consolidated, and that to me is the biggest disappointment.

Spot on. If ever there was a club that needed this then it is us, particularly attack wise. Think our transfer policy this season has been a shambles. Let's hope for something this afternoon against Utd, however small. COYP !!

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 01 Feb 20 5.36pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

That's 21, so who are the other 4? Plus Tosun and Schlupp are expected to be out for another three or four weeks and there's no return date for Sakho. Without assuming an ostrich position and putting on red and blue tinted spectacles, I find it difficult to be persuaded that "no more squad players are needed".

And I'm even less persuaded after today's shambles.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

davehuggins Flag 01 Feb 20 6.17pm

We most certainly feel like a club in decline, this is purely by a lack of investment. Stadium, we were promised "the money for this is ring-fenced" and will start soon!! We went crazy spending on Benteke, Sakho etc and I was thinking wow we are serious but now since US investment it has all IMO gone wrong.

 

pax3908 Flag 01 Feb 20 6.21pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

And I'm even less persuaded after today's shambles.

What an inept pile of toothless s***e, why we let Wickham go and kept the statue Benteke, and failed so miserably in this window, if we don't go down and Roy jack it in l will be very surprised, they aren't worth the entrance money, and you could almost think run by a bunch of amateurs, why would you want to play for a team like this, when the management have no desire or so it appears!!! Just thoroughly disgusted!!

 

General Flag 01 Feb 20 6.23pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

I'm sorry I just don't accept the 'we got a shed load of cash for AWB so we have money,' arguement.

The simple fact that in the last 3 windows we have paid out virtually nothing to my mind points to a distinct lack of readies.

Where has it gone? It's hard to tell as our ownership structure makes a follow the money exercise almost impossible, but it is a structure which makes money disappear very easily into offshore structures away from the taxman.

My guessing is we needed to sell simply to pay the bill's inc the yanks. We will sell Wilf in the summer again simply to feed the money machine.

As soon as it became public how much money the Man Utd owners are able to cream off the business for fees and debts and expenses etc etc I stopped even wanting to know what could happen if unscrupulous people invest in Palace.

When it happened I thought that is the end of transparency and trust in the people at the top of the tree.

Literally imagine how much them people need to earn to keep their and all their connections lifestyles where it is!

And imagine how many businesses you could set up to supply CPFC with all it needs to run..

Blah blah they won’t be here like we are in 10, 20, 40, 50 years time so couldn’t give a tosh what happens long term

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Feb 20 6.25pm

I can only imagine that Benteke has some incriminating photos of Parish that are locked away in a private vault somewhere, because why he is still at the club is an absolute mystery.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 01 Feb 20 7.20pm

Just need to make it through this season now. Roy will walk at the end. Zaha will go. Benteke and Sakho should be sold. New manager, a massive summer where we should be looking at 6-7 players and a completely different team next year, might not work but atleast itll be exciting.

Actually bored now of watching us give it to zaha every attacking phase and hoping for the best. Love the guy, our greatest player but big changes needed.

 

EddieMac Flag 01 Feb 20 7.25pm

Originally posted by rikz

Just need to make it through this season now. Roy will walk at the end. Zaha will go. Benteke and Sakho should be sold. New manager, a massive summer where we should be looking at 6-7 players and a completely different team next year, might not work but atleast itll be exciting.

Actually bored now of watching us give it to zaha every attacking phase and hoping for the best. Love the guy, our greatest player but big changes needed.

Very true. All I care about now is just staying up somehow. This season is a write off. Unless we go on a ten game winning run I can’t see Roy being given a new contract.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 02 Feb 20 12.23am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Very true. All I care about now is just staying up somehow. This season is a write off. Unless we go on a ten game winning run I can’t see Roy being given a new contract.

Honestly couldnt care less if it's a young English manager, old foreign one, we play 442, 352, 443, possession based passing team, high pressing, defensive minded counter attacking, a physical team. I could not care aslong as it's something different. Weve been a one man team now for far too long. I'm bored of it. Watching zaha constantly fouled, watching him constantly moaning for being fouled. Watching him trying to take on the whole defense running back and forward 20 times on the edge of their box, having absolutely no faith in any other attacking player in our squad.

When we had bolasie, we was one of the most exciting teams to watch as a fan and neutral, we had on average 20% possession but we was direct and meaningful. It was end to end and exciting, this is just dire now and has been for a few years.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 02 Feb 20 1.13am

Originally posted by rikz

Honestly couldnt care less if it's a young English manager, old foreign one, we play 442, 352, 443, possession based passing team, high pressing, defensive minded counter attacking, a physical team. I could not care aslong as it's something different. Weve been a one man team now for far too long. I'm bored of it. Watching zaha constantly fouled, watching him constantly moaning for being fouled. Watching him trying to take on the whole defense running back and forward 20 times on the edge of their box, having absolutely no faith in any other attacking player in our squad.

When we had bolasie, we was one of the most exciting teams to watch as a fan and neutral, we had on average 20% possession but we was direct and meaningful. It was end to end and exciting, this is just dire now and has been for a few years.


Second that! Only hope any new manager make sure our players are capable of the most simple basic of football - being able to pass the ball to a teammate when under no pressure.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Feb 20 9.57am

The Manager wanted to strengthen the squad and he was open and vocal about that.

The hierarchy clearly agreed but ultimately failed to deliver. Time, effort and energy wasted on a transfer that never looked likely to happen, outbid on another and a failed medical into the mix as well. I know some of that is outside the club's control but overall it's a shambles.

While it's true that we now have players returning from injury, a new signing can have a refreshing effect on both the team and the fans.

I think we are about to embark on a battle against the drop because it looks like a typical Palace season in reverse at the moment.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > January Window Inquest