This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Is Cahill our best ever centre back?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Ginger Pubic Wig Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Mar 20 6.13pm |
|
|
Peak Scott Dann was a special player. Seems to have been forgotten. And as straight up defenders, Tomkins and Kelly are great. Sakho at his top is also a magnificent player who hugely improves us.
Many good names mentioned. Cannon, Moore, Thorn, Young...half the time it's how well drilled they are to get the details right in individual matches
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 02 Mar 20 6.23pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
He's especially good considering the way our expansive football and lack of holding midfielders leaves the central defenders so exposed.
Ha ha ha ha ha ha.
COYP
|
matthau South Croydon 02 Mar 20 6.52pm |
|
|
Anyone remember just how good Craig Moore was? the Australian we had for a short stint. He was one of the best CB's I have seen as a palace fan, literally nothing got past him.
|
martin2412 Living The Dream 02 Mar 20 7.00pm |
|
|
I can't believe nobody's mentioned Mickey Droy.
Edited by martin2412 (02 Mar 2020 7.01pm)
|
monkey Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 02 Mar 20 7.01pm |
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
Grew up lucky enough to watch Cannon and Gilbert who I always considered to be our best ever centre halves.
Think I have to reconsider after this season.
Pretty much the complete player. Does the lot. Very composed, great in the air, brilliant positioning and excellent at marshalling defenders around him.
In my humble opinion I think he probably is.
What does everyone else think?
Still Billy Gilbert for me, he had all this and pace as well
|
glazedallover Allier 02 Mar 20 7.03pm |
|
Originally posted by matthau
Anyone remember just how good Craig Moore was? the Australian we had for a short stint. He was one of the best CB's I have seen as a palace fan, literally nothing got past him.
Yup. Great player. Really good on the ball as well.
|
martin2412 Living The Dream 02 Mar 20 7.07pm |
|
|
Ian Evans - until George Best broke his leg.
|
dg1937 02 Mar 20 7.18pm |
|
|
Glad 'beak' mentioned Alan Stephenson, I was going to but didn't want to show my age!
Has Mel Blyth been mentioned (he probably has), he was bloody good too.
Like Willo I saw Jim Cannon's debut and was right behind the goal when he scored. I believe that win against Chelsea ended a long unsuccessful run in London derbies.
Like others on here I have been eating humble pie having been seriously unimpressed by Cahill's signing. I do think Cahill may very well be the pick of the bunch.
|
deleted 25 02 Mar 20 7.49pm |
|
|
I think Tomkins is our best centre back at the moment
Cannon probably our most important player, we would have gone down to the third division in the 80's without him.
|
sprites Auckland 02 Mar 20 7.53pm |
|
Originally posted by Bangell
In my relatively short life, Sakho's performances for that half-season when he first arrived at the club were the best example of centre-back play I've ever seen for Palace. He was an absolute beast defensively, and we saw an instant improvement in our play with his balls forward. We beat West Brom in our first or second game and this one centre-back had boosted the level of the whole team.
Unfortunately, injury means he might never get back to that level.
As for Cahill, fantastic, solid defender and a great organiser too. He and Dann don't have much pace between them but have shown in the last couple of games what excellent footballing brains they've got.
Agreed.
|
braunstoneagle the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 02 Mar 20 8.07pm |
|
|
sakho for me but cahill not far behind him.
cant wait for those 2 to get a run of games together alongside each other
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway
|
Tom-the-eagle Croydon 02 Mar 20 8.29pm |
|
Originally posted by matthau
Anyone remember just how good Craig Moore was? the Australian we had for a short stint. He was one of the best CB's I have seen as a palace fan, literally nothing got past him.
Yep I remember him. Big blonde Aussie. Absolutely cracking player. Think we may of signed him from QPR but may be wrong.
Was not with us long but I remember as you say, nothing got past him.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit
|
EddieMac 02 Mar 20 8.32pm |
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
Yep I remember him. Big blonde Aussie. Absolutely cracking player. Think we may of signed him from QPR but may be wrong.
Was not with us long but I remember as you say, nothing got past him.
Signed from Glasgow Rangers
|
Jamesrichards8 02 Mar 20 8.43pm |
|
|
We're overstocked in the CB department, that's for sure. I'm a big Martin Kelly fan, Cahill is obviously undroppable at the moment and Tomkins is obviously very good, good enough for England at times. Sakho on form is as good as any of them, but off form is somewhat of a liability. It pains me to see any of them on the bench at any time to be honest. Scott Dann is probably my favorite Palace player though, for his reliability and quiet leadership over the years. I can almost guarantee that we'd have been relegated if Pulis had not signed him that January.
When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...
|
Loz83 Crawley 02 Mar 20 9.24pm |
|
|
i love all of our cb's ,we really are spoilt for choice! for me on form sakho is the best as his passing is top quality! Scott Dann at the moment though is an absolute beast, hes rolling back the years. hes been perfection the last 2 games, what a f***ing hero he is!
|
Casual Orpington 02 Mar 20 9.32pm |
|
|
For Me Cahill is the best out of our current lot. Cahill and Tomkins should be the best partnership, but this season I think our best 2 have been Cahill and Kelly. Dann looks too slow now, but probably our best at set pieces. Sakho needs to go, if we can get a buyer , too injury prone now. Kouyate is obviously decent at Center back as he plays there for his country. All in all must be our strongest position in the squad, f*ck knows How they all play in training games.
|
supernaut Armagh 02 Mar 20 9.55pm |
|
|
Alan Stephenson was another one of my heroes, a different era but a great player.
Supernaut - Ireland's premier Black Sabbath tribute band Facebook: [Link]
Palace Forever!
|
PA Bedfordshire 02 Mar 20 9.59pm |
|
Originally posted by martin2412
I can't believe nobody's mentioned Mickey Droy.
Edited by martin2412 (02 Mar 2020 7.01pm)
Exactly! Just read through this thread for the first time and was waiting to see Mickey get a nod. What a mountain of a man he was!! Loved watching him play.
|
kevlee born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 02 Mar 20 11.09pm |
|
|
A few names seem to have slipped through the net. What about Leif Andersen? Ian Evans? And legend Paddy McCarthy? It all depends on the time they were playing. I mean imagine Billy Gilbert playing today. He wouldnt last 5 minutes! I would love to have seen Billy playing against Patrick Bamford - one of the biggest arseholes ever to have played for us, and see him kick his balls off!
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978
|
Mapletree Croydon 02 Mar 20 11.17pm |
|
Originally posted by kevlee
A few names seem to have slipped through the net. What about Leif Andersen? Ian Evans? And legend Paddy McCarthy? It all depends on the time they were playing. I mean imagine Billy Gilbert playing today. He wouldnt last 5 minutes! I would love to have seen Billy playing against Patrick Bamford - one of the biggest arseholes ever to have played for us, and see him kick his balls off!
Evans was special. Feck George Best.
|