You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy (rumour)
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy (rumour)


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
ambrose7 Flag Croydon 03 Aug 20 10.26pm

Would we really have to replace this year, given it's widely thought that Riedewald could have played more games, as could Schlupp if he'd stayed fit? And if an injury crisis were to pick up, Meyer could have played more games and Dreher's now fit to backfill the bench?

CM is the one position we are relatively flush and we may well be bringing in Eze and/or Gallacher. If that £5m allows us to buy a player in another position we otherwise couldn't afford, it could well be worth it.

How many times this season have we looked to the bench, seen McCarthy, Riedewald, Meyer, Kelly, Dann, Pierrick and wished we had a solid attacking option?

For context, £5m and the other 2 years of McCarthy's wages - with that you're not a million miles from affording the silly contract Ryan Fraser wants for a couple of years. He may not be the right option but it makes you think what this could actually be.

Instead of sell McCarthy and buy someone twice the price to replace him, it's more likely sell McCarthy, play Riedewald or a player we're looking to buy regardless, and put the money towards a forward.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

the.universal 03 Aug 20 11.16pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

Would we really have to replace this year, given it's widely thought that Riedewald could have played more games, as could Schlupp if he'd stayed fit? And if an injury crisis were to pick up, Meyer could have played more games and Dreher's now fit to backfill the bench?

CM is the one position we are relatively flush and we may well be bringing in Eze and/or Gallacher. If that £5m allows us to buy a player in another position we otherwise couldn't afford, it could well be worth it.

How many times this season have we looked to the bench, seen McCarthy, Riedewald, Meyer, Kelly, Dann, Pierrick and wished we had a solid attacking option?

For context, £5m and the other 2 years of McCarthy's wages - with that you're not a million miles from affording the silly contract Ryan Fraser wants for a couple of years. He may not be the right option but it makes you think what this could actually be.

Instead of sell McCarthy and buy someone twice the price to replace him, it's more likely sell McCarthy, play Riedewald or a player we're looking to buy regardless, and put the money towards a forward.

In which case I’d rather sell Riedewald. I put him in the Meyer bucket of undoubtedly talented player but not one that Roy sees fit to rely on too much. The case for keeping them both could be that our next manager after Roy will get more out of them.

 


Vive le Roy!

Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Aug 20 7.52am

West Ham and Newcastle also interested. Can’t see why WH would want/need him

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 04 Aug 20 8.35am

There are a few more I would sell before him. Not sure why Newcastle, West Ham and Villa have come sniffing?

 

jeeagles Flag 04 Aug 20 8.39am

I like him. Currently I think our midfield should be Reidewald, Luka, and McCarthy. All 3 can pass and are relitively solid.

With only 16 starts, 29 years old, a poor injury record, and one year left on his contract. I think we should cash in.

£5m doesn't seem enough when Jedi went for £4m.

I'd prefer to offload McArther, but you can only sell the players other sides want to buy.

With Luka, McCarthy, Kayoute, McArthur, Schlupp, Riedewald, Meyer, Dreher, Kirby who can all play in this position it will really take a colosal injury crisis. Even when jedinak was injured I have some vague memories of Ward filling in.

Many fans have been saying we need to offload players at get in quality. Yet now the same people think we need squad players as back up. I don't think we have the luxury of having both. We can't hoard a lot of average players if we want to make space for a few good players.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 04 Aug 20 8.46am

Originally posted by jeeagles

I like him. Currently I think our midfield should be Reidewald, Luka, and McCarthy. All 3 can pass and are relitively solid.

With only 16 starts, 29 years old, a poor injury record, and one year left on his contract. I think we should cash in.

£5m doesn't seem enough when Jedi went for £4m.

I'd prefer to offload McArther, but you can only sell the players other sides want to buy.

With Luka, McCarthy, Kayoute, McArthur, Schlupp, Riedewald, Meyer, Dreher, Kirby who can all play in this position it will really take a colosal injury crisis. Even when jedinak was injured I have some vague memories of Ward filling in.

Many fans have been saying we need to offload players at get in quality. Yet now the same people think we need squad players as back up. I don't think we have the luxury of having both. We can't hoard a lot of average players if we want to make space for a few good players.

[Link]

There does appear to be a lot of interest in him. It would be good business to sell to the highest bidder, provided they have a younger alternative in mind who is at least as effective. Or a young Palace player who could step up?

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 04 Aug 20 8.51am

Originally posted by Petereagle

[Link]

There does appear to be a lot of interest in him. It would be good business to sell to the highest bidder, provided they have a younger alternative in mind who is at least as effective. Or a young Palace player who could step up?

Maybe Boateng is ready to step up?

[Link]

 

jeeagles Flag 04 Aug 20 8.54am

Originally posted by Petereagle

[Link]

There does appear to be a lot of interest in him. It would be good business to sell to the highest bidder, provided they have a younger alternative in mind who is at least as effective. Or a young Palace player who could step up?

There is an Eze answer to that one.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 04 Aug 20 9.23am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Currently I think our midfield should be Reidewald, Luka, and McCarthy. All 3 can pass

Are you thinking of the right person?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Aug 20 9.34am

Originally posted by JRW2

Are you thinking of the right person?


Perhaps jeeagles hasn't seen him play over the last year and is thinking back to those halcyon days when Luka could pick good passes more often than not.

The question is whether or not Luka can get his mojo back both in terms of passing and free kicks/corners.

 

The Beger Flag Croydon 04 Aug 20 9.48am

Originally posted by Petereagle
[Link]

There does appear to be a lot of interest in him. It would be good business to sell to the highest bidder, provided they have a younger alternative in mind who is at least as effective. Or a young Palace player who could step up?

That reports references 90min.com
[Link]

From the article "90min understands that". This how fake news works, unverified source, list several clubs, more clubs more clicks.

Right now, with no news conferences, they can say anything because the manager will not refute it.

 


I am not a bot. No, seriously, I'm not.

Putitout Flag Oxford 04 Aug 20 9.53am

Originally posted by The Beger

That reports references 90min.com
[Link]

From the article "90min understands that". This how fake news works, unverified source, list several clubs, more clubs more clicks.

Right now, with no news conferences, they can say anything because the manager will not refute it.


This has to be the case. If not regardless of what people here think of McCarthy, he must be one hell of a player, with that lot fighting to get him.

 

jeeagles Flag 04 Aug 20 10.25am

Originally posted by doombear

Perhaps jeeagles hasn't seen him play over the last year and is thinking back to those halcyon days when Luka could pick good passes more often than not.

The question is whether or not Luka can get his mojo back both in terms of passing and free kicks/corners.

Fair comment. In comparison to McArthur, Luka, Kayoute it would be a big step up.

I don't really think Kayoute should be played as a centre midfielder at all.

I like McArthur too, I wish other players matched his effort.

A bigger question remains about the decline in the basic ability of many of our players and our poor set peices. In terms of passing, it seems partly down to lack of movement amongst the team giving players on the ball no options.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Aug 20 10.49am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Fair comment. In comparison to McArthur, Luka, Kayoute it would be a big step up.

I don't really think Kayoute should be played as a centre midfielder at all.

I like McArthur too, I wish other players matched his effort.

A bigger question remains about the decline in the basic ability of many of our players and our poor set peices. In terms of passing, it seems partly down to lack of movement amongst the team giving players on the ball no options.

I agree about Kouyate. I think he's more of a CB. With the injuries to Tomkins and Cahill, both of whom may well struggle to be back for the start of the new season, we may need to play him alongside Dann.

I think McArthur is on the decline, sadly, and am not sure how much he will feature next season.

You are right about the lack of movement. I seem to recall many occasions where a player looked up, couldn't see a forward pass, get closed down, pass sideways/backwards or even lose the ball. Occasionally there were some good interplay, often involving PvA and Wilf.

As for McCarthy, I think he may have 2 years left on his contract and if so, I'm inclined to keep him for the coming year.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 04 Aug 20 11.23am

I think if we can make a few million in profit it’s a good move for everyone.

He’s not quite good enough to displace our starters and I’d rather have Jairo coming off the bench.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 Aug 20 12.33pm

Have we signed him yet?

 


Red and Blue Army!

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 04 Aug 20 12.40pm

As long as we avoid a midfield next season with McCarthy, MacArthur and Kouyate, I don't mind selling any of them. Make room for some creativity..hopefully!

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 04 Aug 20 12.49pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

As long as we avoid a midfield next season with McCarthy, MacArthur and Kouyate, I don't mind selling any of them. Make room for some creativity..hopefully!

Celtic in the mix now apparently

[Link]

One way or another, it does look like he will move on, at a decent price for a 29 year old. But what happens after, ie he does go, is the question...

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 04 Aug 20 12.52pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

There is an Eze answer to that one.

Not as a defensive midfielder!

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 04 Aug 20 1.42pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

Celtic in the mix now apparently

[Link]

One way or another, it does look like he will move on, at a decent price for a 29 year old. But what happens after, ie he does go, is the question...


Maybe they would talk sense for Edoard. If they are that keen.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy (rumour)