This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
A Level results
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
The Dolphin 16 Aug 20 8.40am |
|
|
One thing that hasn't been publicised too much is that the Teachers themselves predicted grades that were way too high overall. They share the blame on this but the media are leaving them alone! Just saying.
|
cryrst The garden of England 16 Aug 20 9.27am |
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
One thing that hasn't been publicised too much is that the Teachers themselves predicted grades that were way too high overall. They share the blame on this but the media are leaving them alone! Just saying.
Exactly and the reason for this up grading is to make the little pettles feel good. When life hits its goner get soooooo real for these kids. Bash HMG it's easier.
|
Mapletree Croydon 16 Aug 20 9.52am |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Exactly and the reason for this up grading is to make the little pettles feel good. When life hits its goner get soooooo real for these kids. Bash HMG it's easier.
The issue is simple. It is about relative success. If all teachers overpredicted, and by the same amount, there would not be a problem. Self evidently.
|
Sportyteacher London 16 Aug 20 10.29am |
|
|
It's getting so bad that Gavin Williamson in A-Level Music has downgraded ABBA to ACDC
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 16 Aug 20 11.27am |
|
|
Apparently the algorithm mainly works that if a school were getting a certain percentage in each exam grade in a subject then that is the percentage this year that get that grade. From that it suggests those that usually peak at exam time have lost out and those who don’t do as well have had a bit of a result. We hear about those who’ve been downgraded but not from those who must’ve been upgraded.
COYP
|
BlueJay UK 16 Aug 20 2.27pm |
|
|
The whole year was botched up, so they may as well have just gone with the teachers grade predictions. Talk about creating a problem.
|
The Dolphin 16 Aug 20 3.33pm |
|
|
You are not wrong Bluejay - not wrong at all!I The little live would be happy that they were super intelligent even though that hadn't taken an exam and Boris would have been praised - orange not because now he would be accused of dumbing down education! Still - it would probably have been the easiest solution.
|
cryrst The garden of England 16 Aug 20 3.48pm |
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
You are not wrong Bluejay - not wrong at all!I The little live would be happy that they were super intelligent even though that hadn't taken an exam and Boris would have been praised - orange not because now he would be accused of dumbing down education! Still - it would probably have been the easiest solution.
The easiest solution isnt always the correct solution. I understand what blue is saying but surely if the teachers results were given; once these kids get to uni or work they will be found out big time. Then the kick back wont be at the teachers, I think it can be guessed who it will come to. I also think it somewhat shows that boris isnt going to be the pushover he is being portrayed as. Conviction is stuck by and appeals are being offered for free. Maybe some of these kids will take stock and realise their grade is what they themselves were actually expecting and they are being driven by the media circus and mummy and daddy thinking their little cherub is the next einstein.
|
Sportyteacher London 16 Aug 20 4.53pm |
|
|
Simple truth is that debacle surrounding both A-levels and GCSE levels (inevitable in the case of the latter) is quite simply tip of the iceberg regarding Department for Education (DfE) ineptitude in. recent years. I refer you to Meg Hillier, Head of Public Accounts Committee who only last summer cited DfE as 'top of the list regarding Departmental concerns'. A General Election followed by COVID-19 and the usual overlong summer recess has so far put pay to further cross party scrutiny of The Keystone Cops in charge of the education of 93% of the country's children and young people:
[Link]
Too many parents really need to probe further as to what is going on out there eg. unresolved Dept behaviour issues still allowed to continue at industrial scale as revealed by:
[Link]
+
[Link]
Must-watches!
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 17 Aug 20 2.49am |
|
|
Let's have some accountability from Ofqual, plenty of civil servants there earning very good salaries but don't recall anyone fronting up to explain what is going on.
Head of Ofqual on around 200K
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 17 Aug 20 3.00am |
|
|
I saw a girl interviewed who needed three Cs to get into " art college " and was downgraded including a U in art.
What is the point of encouraging young people to waste years and money on University doing a course that only requires 3 Cs.
Much more sensible to look for learning at work or doing an apprenticeship.
The idea that a degree is a requirement for a good job is wrong IMO.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
Badger11 Beckenham 17 Aug 20 7.13am |
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
I saw a girl interviewed who needed three Cs to get into " art college " and was downgraded including a U in art.
What is the point of encouraging young people to waste years and money on University doing a course that only requires 3 Cs.
Much more sensible to look for learning at work or doing an apprenticeship.
The idea that a degree is a requirement for a good job is wrong IMO.
Agreed.
I am actually doing an online history of art course for fun it is a lot more academic that you would think and like any subject you have to learn a great deal and then write papers to demonstrate your knowledge and understanding. So why lower the bar to that level I think they are desperate for money and students.
Unless you are planning a career that needs an art degree all you are doing is saddling yourself with a lot of debt. As you say they would be better off avoiding university and getting a practical transferable skill for the job market. They can always do what I have done which is sign up to an online course if that is their interest.
One more point
|
Tom-the-eagle Croydon 17 Aug 20 7.19am |
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
I saw a girl interviewed who needed three Cs to get into " art college " and was downgraded including a U in art.
What is the point of encouraging young people to waste years and money on University doing a course that only requires 3 Cs.
Much more sensible to look for learning at work or doing an apprenticeship.
The idea that a degree is a requirement for a good job is wrong IMO.
Could not agree more.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit
|
nimblehippo 17 Aug 20 8.33am |
|
|
As a teacher, It’s an omnishambles, but no easy answer. No standardised mocks, inaccurate grade predictions, so can’t trust them. Few pupils actually get their predicted grades - I missed mine.
That being said, the pencil pushers need to have a long hard look at themselves - the system has probably worked fine for the majority, but it’s the outliers who have been screwed over - those at the top and bottom. And the ministers were far too slow to see this was a disaster - especially after Scotland. The school would have to wildly off to countenance dropping someone more than one grade - but perhaps some schools tried to over grade in anticipation of grades being cut - hard to know without seeing exact details.
Also, it’s not a private/state thing - did u hear about the private school pupil predicted a B/C but given a U as she was bottom of her bright class and someone in a previous year got a U. Sadly some top state pupils will be affected, but one would hope the Universities would honour the places and trust their judgement more than an algorithm’s. I’d almost have mandated that from the top and required all Unis to honour their offers. Also schools that were improving will have been rather shafted. I’d also suggest that the Private school grades were perhaps deemed more accurate and backed up with plenty of data - a friend of mine worked hours trying to make sure his predicted grades were heavily backed up by data, including comparisons to 5 years worth of students and their relative performances on the same tests over that period. The message from the top was to make sure the grades weren’t questionable in the slightest. My experience of teaching in comps is that teachers are a lot more hopeful in their predicted grades. Thankfully I know teach younger ages so didn’t have to deal with this fiasco.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 17 Aug 20 9.27am |
|
|
The same number of places will be available at universities regardless of the A level results. So some establishments will have to lower their expectations of potential students if they are to fill their halls.
In fact there may be even more spaces available than usual as there will, in all probability, be less foreign students in the coming year.
Clearing will likely be a busy job this year.
I do trend to agree with the posters here who say University shouldn't be the route for everyone. We desperately need to get back to promoting apprenticeships in all skilled and semi-skilled jobs. You can earn yourself a fine living as a Plumber, Electrician, Engineer etc etc and these do not require a degree, although to some of the kids out there, it does require you to work however!
|
cryrst The garden of England 17 Aug 20 10.25am |
|
|
Not everyone will want to get a skill. Lots might be more than happy to sweep,stack and generally do a non skilled job. Why all this about grades and apprenticeships. Someone has to do the menial work. This can lead to great riches. I know a company with the name of a chess piece. The two owners started off with a bucket and sponge cleaning windows. Now they are millionaires with a huge business. Not everyone starts at the top.
|
nimblehippo 17 Aug 20 10.54am |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Not everyone will want to get a skill. Lots might be more than happy to sweep,stack and generally do a non skilled job. Why all this about grades and apprenticeships. Someone has to do the menial work. This can lead to great riches. I know a company with the name of a chess piece. The two owners started off with a bucket and sponge cleaning windows. Now they are millionaires with a huge business. Not everyone starts at the top.
Indeed - intelligence is great, but hard work and initiative will get you far. University was a waste of time for me, but a prerequisite to the sort of jobs I wanted to do. Didn’t really learn much more than I had at A-level.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 17 Aug 20 11.30am |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Not everyone will want to get a skill. Lots might be more than happy to sweep,stack and generally do a non skilled job. Why all this about grades and apprenticeships. Someone has to do the menial work. This can lead to great riches. I know a company with the name of a chess piece. The two owners started off with a bucket and sponge cleaning windows. Now they are millionaires with a huge business. Not everyone starts at the top.
The why is because we have a shortage of home grown skilled labour that needs to be filled. It is also nice to see ambition in youngsters and whilst menial jobs are important and necessary I'm not sure there are many kids at school who dream of having one.
Yes, I too know of people from low income jobs that have built up decent companies and that is to be applauded. If you have the tenacity to be capable of doing that, then good on you.
|
Sportyteacher London 17 Aug 20 12.53pm |
|
|
Further thought is that it will be hard to sack Gavin Williamson when he previously operated as Chief Whip and 'knows where the bodies are buried'.
|
The Dolphin 17 Aug 20 12.55pm |
|
|
In reply to Nimblehippo there are obviously many sides to this. Those who got a Uni place need to back off to help clear the decks whether they like their grades or not because they are sorted. Those who were never going to get good grades should be parked for now as well as they are just crowding the space. However - there are definitely those who must wonder what happened and they do need to be heard and asap for their sakes. Everyone has a part to play from the Government down - Teachers and Universities included. No system is ever right and this was always going to be the toughest one ever but there are a few wrongs that need righting so let's hope that those in most need get the help.
|