You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Farm to Fork Thread
November 21 2026 9.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Farm to Fork Thread


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Dec 20 11.06pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I can't help notice you are in the European Union, where farmers have a little more predictability about their future.

UK farmers are a mixed bunch but many are outstanding, which is why UK farming is so excellent. They are highly imaginative. But they aren't magicians.

Irish farming is overall not as good. It is big on dairy farming specifically. Vets are not called to sick pigs in Ireland and this is the way we are going with male calves that are surplus to the dairy industry. Calves and pigs are worth significantly less than the cost of a vet, so it can be cheaper to simply let them die.

The UK Government has made clear it aims to emasculate the small farmers, especially on upland farms.

Farmers have slammed Defra Secretary George Eustice's 'laughable' claim that sheep producers could diversify into beef in the event of the lamb price crashing following a no-deal.

Environment Secretary George Eustice made the controversial comments on the BBC's Andrew Marr Show on Sunday 15 November.

Host Andrew Marr highlighted that sheep farmers could be 'devastated' in the event of a no-deal between the UK and EU following the transition period, as 90% of the sector's exports are sent to the bloc.

Mr Eustice replied: "That's not correct. It's also the case that the UK is by far and away the largest producer of lamb in the EU, some 35% of it.

"We would sell it, but it would increase prices in the EU. You have to accept tariffs do also have an impact on prices. The price of lamb would rise in the EU.

That would also mean that demand in the EU for lamb would go down and there would be a fall in prices here in the UK in the short term."

The minister did, however, admit that lamb tariffs could cause disruption for farmers, adding that "mixed farmers could always diversify into beef because the UK would be importing less from Ireland".

It's a huge area, in fact I believe it's the EU's biggest expense. I read articles about how new EU countries are now taking their slice, putting huge pressure on traditional EU countries like Ireland but more so, as usual France. So the EU gravy train may not have been as reliable as people supposed.

My main point is around structure really. I suspect you can see what I mean. I don't doubt the quality you speak of but everything I've seen in Ireland is pretty stringent. Of course, we have our law breakers. There was an article not so long ago that I might try to find about how a massive slice of the EU subsidy in Ireland was going to a very small set of producers, 3 off the top of my head. I dread to think what they're like.

Around here, we are so close to farms, and they have ways of selling direct, that have really only popped up in the last few years. For instance, my turkey will be from 'The friendly farmer' at the market. It will be twice the supermarket price, but well worth it.

A friend of mine, well more drinking buddy from college, inherited a large enough farm nearby. He offered a package deal delivery service across the area. We subscribed for a couple of years. Plenty we know still do. It was different prices, but we paid 15 a week for a box of organic vegetables straight from the farm. We're just not a big family and couldn't justify it anymore. Basically, he bought a large van and grew, packaged and delivered himself, so tough but obviously could make a lot more than selling to supermarkets. Realistically, what we were paying 15 for the supermarket would probably pay 50c.

For dairy, there are large co-ops here, often consistening of a large number of small farmers. They took up the mantle of being milkmen. Delivering straight to the customer - again cutting out the silly supermarket prices.

These are the type of things that I believe farmers can do - and have seen them doing. There needs to be a different approach, relying on government probably isn't the best plan going forward. This won't answer everything or be for everyone. The big guys can sell to the supermarkets, less costs. The small guys should consider selling to the more discerning and making the money themselves. Bring the stuff to the people. If it's better people will pay more and the profit is straight to the person who needs it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Dec 20 8.23am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

It's a huge area, in fact I believe it's the EU's biggest expense. I read articles about how new EU countries are now taking their slice, putting huge pressure on traditional EU countries like Ireland but more so, as usual France. So the EU gravy train may not have been as reliable as people supposed.

My main point is around structure really. I suspect you can see what I mean. I don't doubt the quality you speak of but everything I've seen in Ireland is pretty stringent. Of course, we have our law breakers. There was an article not so long ago that I might try to find about how a massive slice of the EU subsidy in Ireland was going to a very small set of producers, 3 off the top of my head. I dread to think what they're like.

Around here, we are so close to farms, and they have ways of selling direct, that have really only popped up in the last few years. For instance, my turkey will be from 'The friendly farmer' at the market. It will be twice the supermarket price, but well worth it.

A friend of mine, well more drinking buddy from college, inherited a large enough farm nearby. He offered a package deal delivery service across the area. We subscribed for a couple of years. Plenty we know still do. It was different prices, but we paid 15 a week for a box of organic vegetables straight from the farm. We're just not a big family and couldn't justify it anymore. Basically, he bought a large van and grew, packaged and delivered himself, so tough but obviously could make a lot more than selling to supermarkets. Realistically, what we were paying 15 for the supermarket would probably pay 50c.

For dairy, there are large co-ops here, often consistening of a large number of small farmers. They took up the mantle of being milkmen. Delivering straight to the customer - again cutting out the silly supermarket prices.

These are the type of things that I believe farmers can do - and have seen them doing. There needs to be a different approach, relying on government probably isn't the best plan going forward. This won't answer everything or be for everyone. The big guys can sell to the supermarkets, less costs. The small guys should consider selling to the more discerning and making the money themselves. Bring the stuff to the people. If it's better people will pay more and the profit is straight to the person who needs it.

And you think farmers haven’t been doing these things in England and Wales?

For decades mate

And loads of them have glamping pods or shepherd’s huts. They have all had to diversify, many many years ago.

And that brings us back to using surplus areas for mini industrial estates. Irish farmers went mad on them, then got badly caught out in the financial crash. My firm ended up with loads of part completed buildings.

So is that what we want from farming? Real Estate businesses whilst we import low quality food from countries rapidly destroying the world’s soil.

Edited by Mapletree (10 Dec 2020 8.23am)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Dec 20 9.57am

Originally posted by Mapletree

And you think farmers haven’t been doing these things in England and Wales?

For decades mate

And loads of them have glamping pods or shepherd’s huts. They have all had to diversify, many many years ago.

And that brings us back to using surplus areas for mini industrial estates. Irish farmers went mad on them, then got badly caught out in the financial crash. My firm ended up with loads of part completed buildings.

So is that what we want from farming? Real Estate businesses whilst we import low quality food from countries rapidly destroying the world’s soil.

Edited by Mapletree (10 Dec 2020 8.23am)

I suggested keeping farming. You went on a rant about development and diversification. Read my post, it suggests ways to bring produce to the consumer. You want to turn it anti Irish go ahead. You seem to know loads about it. This isn't 2003.It certainly doesn't warrant your response. You're just backing up people's theories that farmers love to moan and cry poverty. I gave successful real examples of farming. You want to go glamping, hardly going to ruin the topsoil is it? In fact, UK and Ireland are nothing to do with the world's supply of topsoil.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Dec 20 9.06pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I suggested keeping farming.

Yes, and I said UK farmers are way ahead of you on that but you didn't absorb that point.

You went on a rant about development and diversification. Read my post, it suggests ways to bring produce to the consumer.

I didn't go on a rant, I said not only do UK farmers try to sell locally and also via e.g Abel and Cole, but also find other ways to innovate and diversify. They have had to. But they still earn £50k per year per farm

You want to turn it anti Irish go ahead. You seem to know loads about it. This isn't 2003.It certainly doesn't warrant your response. You're just backing up people's theories that farmers love to moan and cry poverty.

You think Irish farming is as good as the UK? Or even is reasonably ethical? It has a poor reputation.

[Link]

I am not a farmer. I have given you the facts on income, you make up your own mind

I gave successful real examples of farming.

These were simply old hat but they work when you have the support of the CAP.

You want to go glamping, hardly going to ruin the topsoil is it?

Did I say that it did? Quite the opposite, farmers should do everything in their power to survive. But I don't think they should turn over large parts of their farm to industrial usage, as has happened so much.

In fact, UK and Ireland are nothing to do with the world's supply of topsoil.

I don't understand your point. Of course they use topsoil. And yes, they are eroding it. 3 million tonnes of topsoil erodes from the UK every year. The UK is 30 to 40 years away from “the fundamental eradication of soil fertility” in parts of the country according to Michael Gove when he was environment secretary.

Here is an article on soil degradation in Ireland.

[Link]


Edited by Mapletree (10 Dec 2020 9.10pm)

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 10 Dec 20 9.28pm

If it's legal or about to become legal I would be growing cannabis. Either for medical or recreational use.
Either that or some high end crop you aren't going to make any money selling spuds & onions

 


Pro USA & Israel

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 10 Dec 20 9.34pm

Little bit of a tangent out here in Slovakia, Goat & sheep cheese is hugely popular, yet you'll never find goat or lamb in the shops/restaurants, I'm assuming the livestock that is raised here is exported elsewhere.
Pork on the other hand is eaten so much its considered a vegetable.

Its also not uncommon here for back gardens to be used to raise livestock.
I helped with the slaughter of a pig this time last year, (from bolt to brain to dinner plate) its kind of a traditional family thing they do in the countryside, not a pleasant thing but glad I did it.
Also a surreal experience carrying a giant severed pigs head up a block of flats to my inlaws house

Edited by Ouzo Dan (10 Dec 2020 9.36pm)

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Dec 20 10.11pm

Originally posted by Ouzo Dan

Little bit of a tangent out here in Slovakia, Goat & sheep cheese is hugely popular, yet you'll never find goat or lamb in the shops/restaurants, I'm assuming the livestock that is raised here is exported elsewhere.
Pork on the other hand is eaten so much its considered a vegetable.

Its also not uncommon here for back gardens to be used to raise livestock.
I helped with the slaughter of a pig this time last year, (from bolt to brain to dinner plate) its kind of a traditional family thing they do in the countryside, not a pleasant thing but glad I did it.
Also a surreal experience carrying a giant severed pigs head up a block of flats to my inlaws house

Edited by Ouzo Dan (10 Dec 2020 9.36pm)

My daughter tells me all this is the way forward. Back to having kitchen gardens. She thinks there’s money in sheep and goat milk.

I hope you had a drip proof plastic bag.

Pigs work well with forests by the way. Unlike deer which are disastrous.

Edited by Mapletree (10 Dec 2020 10.12pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Dec 20 10.13pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

If it's legal or about to become legal I would be growing cannabis. Either for medical or recreational use.
Either that or some high end crop you aren't going to make any money selling spuds & onions

You are originally from Croydon then Jim.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 11 Dec 20 12.00pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Here is an article on soil degradation in Ireland.

[Link]


Edited by Mapletree (10 Dec 2020 9.10pm)

You can tell me all you like but it's quite clear that their not ahead in any way. You're basically spouting rubbish about Irish stuff that you think you know.

I can go to any number of places and buy direct from the farmer - no problem.

You have not absorbed my point that the actual, real issue of farming is price. Because it's a business.

The real and central issue of your hallowed Welsh sheep farmers is the price they get for the lamb - it's just not worth it. It's hardly such a stretch of the imagination to say that they need to do something about how they bring their goods to market. Like every other business in both of our countries have to. And probably much of the Western world.


Farmers wonder why they get bad feelings against them. This is why, they try quick fixes, they want subsidies, then they don't work and they complain. I fully understand but don't listen because if you don't change the stuff you talk about happens.

So if the farmers want to carry on bleating, so be it. As for farmers being miles ahead it's f***ing laughable. I'm literally living smack bang in the middle of loads of extensive farming with absolutely no sign of degradation or anything that would do it. I'm in the far west of Ireland.

Seeing as my grandfather became a sheep farmer I know plenty. The way he did it was to breed rare breed sheep - which remain in demand. He sold up in the end and is a multi millionaire. Don't worry, I got sod all. You're not dealing with someone who you can sway or tell anything.

The issue in Ireland is far more complicated than you are making out or the article wants to tell us. Rather than practice related, there is a wider issue with water. Surprise surpruse in Ireland. A lot of farm land being flooded and a lot of top soil being diluted or washed away. That does happen around here. There are no fast crops or intensive farming anywhere near me that I have seen. So it's not an issue. Could well be more of an issue at the border or in the East.

My point about top soil is global, I should have been clearer. The issues are the deserts and the forests. My point being that UK and Ireland are not going to change percentages of world top soil. We're quite clearly too small.

You're not dealing with Irish country bumpkin mate. I do actually understand your points but am making mine. Every time you say 'we' re ahead, we tried that'. Quite clearly not true, it has not been tried enough. My glamping point is that it doesn't hurt anything. Let them do it.

Market gardening and new techniques are already making this irrelevant and I'm sure you know about it.

However, I do fully realise your concerns and share them. I'm not trying to fob you off. I can see the argument.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Mapletree Flag Croydon 13 Dec 20 4.15pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

You can tell me all you like but it's quite clear that their not ahead in any way. You're basically spouting rubbish about Irish stuff that you think you know.

Well, let's start with some facts. The average milk yield per cow in Ireland is 5,000 litres per year, in the UK 8,000. Ireland survives on EU exports. And its farmer survive on the CAP. Where they are very capable is in playing the system. They have a remarkable number of 'young farmers' for example, who happen to receive a grant but somehow never seem to grow into older farmers.

I can go to any number of places and buy direct from the farmer - no problem.

And if you lived in the countryside in the UK you would have the identical same experience. And would have done for as long as I have been alive. Plus UK producers have a history of setting up cooperative retail organisations. For example Northern Foods. India has had a recent such experience with its White Revolution. The only thing different about Ireland is it is so rural relatively speaking.

You have not absorbed my point that the actual, real issue of farming is price. Because it's a business.

The real and central issue of your hallowed Welsh sheep farmers is the price they get for the lamb - it's just not worth it. It's hardly such a stretch of the imagination to say that they need to do something about how they bring their goods to market. Like every other business in both of our countries have to. And probably much of the Western world.

Currently prices are good. The problem is not inefficiency it is a lack of a level playing field. Ask the EU how that works. The other EU countries have been far better at supporting their farmers.


Farmers wonder why they get bad feelings against them. This is why, they try quick fixes, they want subsidies, then they don't work and they complain. I fully understand but don't listen because if you don't change the stuff you talk about happens.

This is complete BS. They don't try quick fixes, they are very efficient and high quality. They generally don't bend the rules.

So if the farmers want to carry on bleating, so be it. As for farmers being miles ahead it's f***ing laughable. I'm literally living smack bang in the middle of loads of extensive farming with absolutely no sign of degradation or anything that would do it. I'm in the far west of Ireland.

Hmm, do they plough? If they do, they are degrading the land. Did you read the link I provided?

Seeing as my grandfather became a sheep farmer I know plenty. The way he did it was to breed rare breed sheep - which remain in demand. He sold up in the end and is a multi millionaire. Don't worry, I got sod all. You're not dealing with someone who you can sway or tell anything.

Yes, rare breeds can be a money spinner. But clearly not for everyone or everyone would be doing it.

The issue in Ireland is far more complicated than you are making out or the article wants to tell us. Rather than practice related, there is a wider issue with water. Surprise surpruse in Ireland. A lot of farm land being flooded and a lot of top soil being diluted or washed away. That does happen around here. There are no fast crops or intensive farming anywhere near me that I have seen. So it's not an issue. Could well be more of an issue at the border or in the East.

My point about top soil is global, I should have been clearer. The issues are the deserts and the forests. My point being that UK and Ireland are not going to change percentages of world top soil. We're quite clearly too small.

You're not dealing with Irish country bumpkin mate. I do actually understand your points but am making mine. Every time you say 'we' re ahead, we tried that'. Quite clearly not true, it has not been tried enough. My glamping point is that it doesn't hurt anything. Let them do it.

They do do it. You blame UK farmers and say they bleat but don't change. That is such nonsense.

Market gardening and new techniques are already making this irrelevant and I'm sure you know about it.

No idea about what you are talking. A few experiments but nothing that really moves the dial. Maybe you really believe floating cows is the way forward, maybe it is but I have this slight suspicion it ain't going to change the world.

[Link]

However, I do fully realise your concerns and share them. I'm not trying to fob you off. I can see the argument.

The concerns for farmers in Ireland are just not on the same level as the UK. The UK Government not only is moving away from the CAP but has made it clear it won't put in place any balancing supports. It is killing off much of the UK farming industry which won't be able to compete in its local markets any more.

Overall, agriculture contributed around £24 billion of revenues and around £8.5 billion of Gross Value Added to the UK economy in 2015.

In contrast the UK's fishing and fish processing industries contribute £1.4 billion to the UK economy.

The UK Music Industry contributes £5.8bn. What is it with fishing?

Edited by Mapletree (13 Dec 2020 9.52pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 13 Dec 20 5.24pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

The concerns for farmers in Ireland and just not on the same level as the UK. The UK Government not only is moving away from the CAP but has made it clear it won't put in place any balancing supports. It is killing off much of the UK farming industry which won't be able to compete in its local markets any more.

Overall, agriculture contributed around £24 billion of revenues and around £8.5 billion of Gross Value Added to the UK economy in 2015.

In contrast the UK's fishing and fish processing industries contribute £1.4 billion to the UK economy.

The UK Music Industry contributes £5.8bn. What is it with fishing?

Fishing has always been evocative for an island nation that used to pride itself on sea power. Reliance on imports for food is maybe 2 centuries old now.
UK is high in Agricultural machinery I believe. Ireland used to be around 40% reliant on agriculture: it's around 20% these days. Of course most goes to the UK so there are massive concerns.
No ploughing around here, more or less. Unless it's the ploughing championships.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Mapletree Flag Croydon 13 Dec 20 6.17pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Fishing has always been evocative for an island nation that used to pride itself on sea power. Reliance on imports for food is maybe 2 centuries old now.
UK is high in Agricultural machinery I believe. Ireland used to be around 40% reliant on agriculture: it's around 20% these days. Of course most goes to the UK so there are massive concerns.
No ploughing around here, more or less. Unless it's the ploughing championships.

If that is true and your fresh produce and e.g. cereal locally are grown without ploughing I shall be surprised and impressed

However, the attached seems to imply that the Irish farmers don't have an equivalent to the various experiments being carried out in the UK and a few other countries.

[Link]

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Dec 20 10.58am

Originally posted by Mapletree

If that is true and your fresh produce and e.g. cereal locally are grown without ploughing I shall be surprised and impressed

However, the attached seems to imply that the Irish farmers don't have an equivalent to the various experiments being carried out in the UK and a few other countries.

[Link]

If you look at Irish geography you would find the Far west of Ireland, where I live, has no arable or very little crop farming. All extensive sheep and cattle. Yes, we're miles behind, be gosh be gorra. Top o t'morning t ya squire. It's been literally a year since I have been out of this region. Ask the people in the Pale about the wheat, if you can understand their thick Irish brogue.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Mapletree Flag Croydon 14 Dec 20 12.38pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

If you look at Irish geography you would find the Far west of Ireland, where I live, has no arable or very little crop farming. All extensive sheep and cattle. Yes, we're miles behind, be gosh be gorra. Top o t'morning t ya squire. It's been literally a year since I have been out of this region. Ask the people in the Pale about the wheat, if you can understand their thick Irish brogue.

In that case I suggest you look at the Nitrates Directive and the derogation that applies to Irish farming.

It explains why Irish Beef farms can make a profit due to their high stock levels.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Dec 20 2.41pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

In that case I suggest you look at the Nitrates Directive and the derogation that applies to Irish farming.

It explains why Irish Beef farms can make a profit due to their high stock levels.

One of the funny things, well not funny, is that we can never reach our emission targets due to the way cattle are categorised. We're evil polluters without even knowing it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Farm to Fork Thread