You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thanks Roy
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Thanks Roy


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Westina Flag 04 Jan 21 10.33pm

You have been great in taking over from the idiot before you and establishing Palace as a decent Premiership team.
We all will be in debt to you for your cool calm management and steadying the boat.. we are by far a much better team now after your management.We are an established Premier team.
I would think it fair to say that this maybe your last six months before you take a well deserved rest from the rigours of the big game .
We are in mid table .
You have nothing to lose.
Let’s give it a real go in the second half of this crazy season.
We will not go down as there are so many struggling teams, but we could really surprise a few if we have a good attacking go..
Play Wilf and Eze on opposite wings Benteke and Bats up front.. we might lose a few but at least we can be fulfilled as Palace supporters that we have had a real go.
Give it a go Roy please.....

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 04 Jan 21 11.35pm

Please Roy.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Jan 21 8.14am

That was just a well disguised good old moan that should've been posted in the 'Roy out'

Get into the real world.

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Jan 21 9.34am

Seems a little harsh to be critical of a fan who has the simple aspiration of seeing his team play better football.
Perhaps to follow a team that includes Eze as one of the first names on the teamsheet as opposed to one that will only be included if he ‘learns ‘ from Schlupp and Townsend.

 

Westina Flag 05 Jan 21 10.38am

Thanks Patrick.. I thought harsh too.
I am not or never have been in the Roy out brigade.
Just want us to be more progressive in a season where we now have an real opportunity to push on.
We put 3 past Man U,4 past Leeds and 5 past WBA in games where we were on the front foot.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Jan 21 10.59am

Originally posted by Westina

Thanks Patrick.. I thought harsh too.
I am not or never have been in the Roy out brigade.
Just want us to be more progressive in a season where we now have an real opportunity to push on.
We put 3 past Man U,4 past Leeds and 5 past WBA in games where we were on the front foot.

We are in the bottom half of the table, with some teams below us having games in hand, we have an aged squad lacking in pace,mobility and energy so I do not feel as comfortable about our position as you are.

Of course, like you, I would like to see more progressive, front-foot football but alas I totally understand why Mr Hodgson takes a pragmatic approach and his style has seen us stay in the PL for the 3 seasons he has been at the helm.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 05 Jan 21 12.04pm

There is so much wishful thinking in all football supporters. And the Palace support is no different.
Merely putting out teams packed with known attack minded players is OK if that theory applies to all the defensive positions as well as the recognised forward positions.. This applies to the very best sides in the world. Even they have problems at times .
Palace just don’t have that luxury . And Roy could only do what some ask for if he wants to lose his job. Because he only plays a part in taking Palace forward . It’s the club it’s self that needs to be upgraded , It’s my opinion we are a much better side than we were before Hodgson. But the improvements throughout the club are slow as the money pot is not huge. And it costs a lot to give any manager exactly what is needed to crack the Premier league top end on a regular basis playing open fan pleasing football.
So many smaller clubs try to play a more open game in the premier league , most end up relegated , some going into free fall. You could say it’s pointless as it doesn’t gather enough points to remain in the division let alone progress in the division.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Jan 21 12.22pm

Originally posted by Putitout

There is so much wishful thinking in all football supporters. And the Palace support is no different.
Merely putting out teams packed with known attack minded players is OK if that theory applies to all the defensive positions as well as the recognised forward positions.. This applies to the very best sides in the world. Even they have problems at times .
Palace just don’t have that luxury . And Roy could only do what some ask for if he wants to lose his job. Because he only plays a part in taking Palace forward . It’s the club it’s self that needs to be upgraded , It’s my opinion we are a much better side than we were before Hodgson. But the improvements throughout the club are slow as the money pot is not huge. And it costs a lot to give any manager exactly what is needed to crack the Premier league top end on a regular basis playing open fan pleasing football.
So many smaller clubs try to play a more open game in the premier league , most end up relegated , some going into free fall. You could say it’s pointless as it doesn’t gather enough points to remain in the division let alone progress in the division.

I am viewed on here as a glumbucket and a merchant of doom and I accept that on occasions I have been well-versed in sucking the positivity out of a discussion on HOL.

There is a divergence between how many view the squad and how I have assessed it in terms of its strength.My view is that in general it is an aged squad with a dearth of energy,vitality,vim,vigour,mobility and pace with several players in the 'Twilight' of their careers and past their best.

We simply do not possess the players to play high-octane, front-foot football which many would like and I understand the pragmatism displayed by our very experienced manager.
There have been some dire,turgid displays but Mr Hodgson has kept us in the PL for 3 seasons on a limited spend and many will argue that the end has justified the means.He has met his objectives.

Edited by Willo (05 Jan 2021 12.26pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 05 Jan 21 12.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

We are in the bottom half of the table, with some teams below us having games in hand, we have an aged squad lacking in pace,mobility and energy so I do not feel as comfortable about our position as you are.

Of course, like you, I would like to see more progressive, front-foot football but alas I totally understand why Mr Hodgson takes a pragmatic approach and his style has seen us stay in the PL for the 3 seasons he has been at the helm.

Willo, do you have that post on cut and paste?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jan 21 12.48pm

Originally posted by Willo

We are in the bottom half of the table, with some teams below us having games in hand, we have an aged squad lacking in pace,mobility and energy so I do not feel as comfortable about our position as you are.

Of course, like you, I would like to see more progressive, front-foot football but alas I totally understand why Mr Hodgson takes a pragmatic approach and his style has seen us stay in the PL for the 3 seasons he has been at the helm.


'A bird in the hand' comes to mind. Fulham's two games in hand are against Spurs (away) and another of the teams below us, Burnley. Burnley's other game in hand is against one of the Manchester clubs.

Having said that I agree with your comments in the later thread, namely that most of our players are too old or ill-equipped to play the high-pressing and more open play desired by some. If the Liverpool game taught us anything, surely it taught us that.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Jan 21 12.53pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Willo, do you have that post on cut and paste?

Nay,nay and thrice nay.
You have probably witnessed the sentiments before, however it was not ready-made and duplicated on here.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Jan 21 12.56pm

Originally posted by doombear


'A bird in the hand' comes to mind. Fulham's two games in hand are against Spurs (away) and another of the teams below us, Burnley. Burnley's other game in hand is against one of the Manchester clubs.

Having said that I agree with your comments in the later thread, namely that most of our players are too old or ill-equipped to play the high-pressing and more open play desired by some. If the Liverpool game taught us anything, surely it taught us that.

There is a saying "A bird in the hand is worth two in Shepherd's Bush".
My old 'Bird' now my wife hails from around that vicinity and on occasions used to watch Fulham play,as well as QPR when she was a young lass.

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Jan 21 2.11pm

Perhaps the point being made in the original post which has been lost is that we can win, and win well, playing good football.
Our most negative performances against the likes of Chelsea, Burnley and Newcastle have resulted in defeats in any event.
Defend strongly by all means with our ageing defenders, and allow Zaha and Eze to flourish.
None of us can say for sure that playing attractively will result in worse results.
We weren’t exactly on the front foot playing attractively when we had that terrible losing run at the end of last season .

I’m content with our points total so far this season, and playing attacking football against Man U, Leeds, WBA has made a significant contribution.
Like the original poster, I would like that to continue and don’t see it as contentious.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Jan 21 2.23pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Perhaps the point being made in the original post which has been lost is that we can win, and win well, playing good football.
Our most negative performances against the likes of Chelsea, Burnley and Newcastle have resulted in defeats in any event.
Defend strongly by all means with our ageing defenders, and allow Zaha and Eze to flourish.
None of us can say for sure that playing attractively will result in worse results.
We weren’t exactly on the front foot playing attractively when we had that terrible losing run at the end of last season .

I’m content with our points total so far this season, and playing attacking football against Man U, Leeds, WBA has made a significant contribution.
Like the original poster, I would like that to continue and don’t see it as contentious.

Leeds can be very 'Open' and defensively are hardly watertight.Only struggling WBA have conceded more goals than Leeds.
At WBA we scored 4 goals when they were down to 10 men but of course credit to the team for taking advantage of the situation.

Overall,given the make-up of our squad the pragmatism of Mr Hodgson is in my humble opinion the better option whilst accepting that on many occasions the football has been abject and far from entertaining.

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Jan 21 2.26pm

We’ll have to agree to disagree.
Football is to be enjoyed not endured.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jan 21 3.54pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

We’ll have to agree to disagree.
Football is to be enjoyed not endured.


I think a lot depends on who the opponents are. I would like to see us being more adventurous against the teams around and below us and (when they're misfiring as Manure were in our second game) against bigger teams.

Ultimately (whether we like it or not) football in the PL is a results business due to (to use that quaint old term) 'filthy lucre'. Money is king in the PL, sadly, and if we want to continue playing against the big boys then a pragmatic approach is most likely to keep us there.

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Jan 21 4.14pm

If Schlupp had not been injured on Saturdays we are unlikely to have had the pleasure of witnessing Eze’s goal on Saturday - already acclaimed as a candidate for goal of the season.
Many pragmatists were acclaiming the decision not to start Eze thinking ‘how can ensure that we not lose ‘ as opposed to ‘how can we flourish.’
I’m reasonably pragmatic but don’t understand why it’s seen as risky to start Eze against a poor team without a win all season.
People can say Eze had a couple of indifferent games prior to Saturday so should be the scapegoat.
That seems unfair to me.
The likes of Luka and Ayew have been poor over considerably longer periods and retained their places.
Roy’s doing a sound job, but this does not mean having to buy into his philosophy wholesale.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Jan 21 4.27pm

Hodgson has never bettered Tony Pulis's finish - 11th, despite Hodgson saying this is his best squad. We're going nowhere very slowly with Hodgson, and I'm guessing the board are happy with that.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 06 Jan 21 10.32am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Hodgson has never bettered Tony Pulis's finish - 11th, despite Hodgson saying this is his best squad. We're going nowhere very slowly with Hodgson, and I'm guessing the board are happy with that.

There is every chance we have reached our ceiling , with Hodgson , or any other option. It’s the financial stature of the club that will break through that ceiling, on a permanent basis. Even if we had a manager get us in the to six, without huge financial certainty to back him, he would be gone in two minutes,
Technically not going forward we go no where But if we don’t go down , it’s not all bad. Because this club will not get richer stuck in the Championship.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Jan 21 10.43am

I think most people see the PL as 3 leagues relegation fodder, mid table and top 6.

Everton have spent a fortune and now have a world class manager and yet they still have not quite made the step up from mid table team to top 6/7.

They may do this season but it just shows how hard it is to make that next step. I see Palace as the top of a group of clubs that are potential relegation candidates out next step is to become solid mid table like Everton and Southampton.

 


One more point

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thanks Roy