You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who was our least effective player v Brighton .
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who was our least effective player v Brighton .


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Spiderman Flag Horsham 24 Feb 21 9.12am

Originally posted by CT Charlie

I think Jairo sort of knows positioning, but he is so slow that it doesn't matter. Eze, by contrast, looks unsure of where he's supposed to be, and so he is constantly caught between places. He should continue to be on the pitch constantly, the better to learn. The better a defender he can become, the more fluid will be our transition from defense to attack.

Jairo may appear slow, but does a lot of the unnoticed “donkey work” but still managed to be in Brighton’s box calling for the ball when Tekkers scored. IMO should build our midfield around him, get a Gallagher type next to him

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Feb 21 9.26am

Originally posted by HKOwen

good rant, I agree with your comments 100&.

The bedwetters and Roy hate club just wan't let go even when we win away at Brighton and have our best points haul after this number of games ever.

"It's a waste of time telling stupid people"

There are opinions and then there are bandwagon jumping lemmings.

You are mostly abusive whatever the subject. This is a board with opinions, now I appreciate some lack the intellectual ability to rationally put forward an argument but if you want to deal in abuse only can I suggest you post on the NSC.

Edited by Eaglecoops (24 Feb 2021 9.28am)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 24 Feb 21 9.50am

Originally posted by HKOwen

good rant, I agree with your comments 100&.

The bedwetters and Roy hate club just wan't let go even when we win away at Brighton and have our best points haul after this number of games ever.

"It's a waste of time telling stupid people"

There are opinions and then there are bandwagon jumping lemmings.

I don't suppose you see the irony that you are part of a bandwagaon of lemmings who are constantly wetting the bed and jumping on other people's posts about football... on a football forum?

I suppose it is a waste of time... you're right on that.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Feb 21 10.06am

Thought we had a good line up was surprised with how awful we were especially with the simple task of passing and we never seem to be able to win 50/50s we give up too easily in possession often just falling over, not sure if it's down to anyone or the players quite confusing considering Eze was hardly noticeable when we needed him to carry the ball, we miss the likes of Schlupp very badly, very disappointed with management and our players, performance was horrendous, result absolutely out of this world lol ...in my book Eze was our least effective player because we know he can run with the ball.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Feb 21 10.08am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I don't suppose you see the irony that you are part of a bandwagaon of lemmings who are constantly wetting the bed and jumping on other people's posts about football... on a football forum?

I suppose it is a waste of time... you're right on that.

I've had my bad day's ..but you're ultimately right.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 24 Feb 21 10.17am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Thought we had a good line up was surprised with how awful we were especially with the simple task of passing and we never seem to be able to win 50/50s we give up too easily in possession often just falling over, not sure if it's down to anyone or the players quite confusing considering Eze was hardly noticeable when we needed him to carry the ball, we miss the likes of Schlupp very badly, very disappointed with management and our players, performance was horrendous, result absolutely out of this world lol ...in my book Eze was our least effective player because we know he can run with the ball.

I wondered if the 'siege' mentality took something away from the concentration of players on the day? That's my only explanation for it as it was noticeable and for all their faults we're better than some of what we showed in possession.

I'll say it again however I still feel it was the right call, I was dreading conceding a boatload of goals and on the day the set up stacked the odds in our favour and paved the way for an albeit highly unlikely win!!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Putitout Flag Oxford 24 Feb 21 11.08am

Eze, wasn’t the only one struggling to get anything going, in that mid field. And not just in this last game. Eze, doesn’t really have an excuse, any more than the others.
In the modern game, he can not just rely on being dangerous going forward, he has to be reliable in danger areas ,and he isn’t yet.
They all had bad moments , Monday night, Jairo, was all over the place at times using his leg like wand , a problem they all suffered, when he should have been making a real contact, Milo, at at least can bite, but was full of rough edges, Townsend, as ever tried hard, and came up with that cross,. Can’t tackle, and their goal may well not have happened , if he had not stood ball watching , whilst their wing back wandered around behind him , whilst he stood there clueless.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 24 Feb 21 12.20pm

Originally posted by midlandspalace

This whole thread is just a whingefest, from the title heading onwards. What a waste of energy. We did win the game, our ninth victory of the season. Still, now you can waste some more of it whinging at me.

i am sure you'll be the first to whinge if we play the same tactics v Fulham and lose 2 or 3 nil

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 24 Feb 21 2.54pm

How's the Roy Out bandwagon?

We have the most points ever in the PL after this many games.

It's not that long ago Charlton decided Curbishley needed replacing and where are they now.

I don't have a problem with setting the season target as survival and anything more than that is a bonus.

Take the odd scalp, score the odd worldie or two, that's enough for me.

The game is about results, as our manager said, there are no prizes for possession, corners etc.

The vast majority of the Roy Out brigade tend to damn with feint praise and even moan when we win if it's "lucky ".

NO problem with opining Roy should go if any objective reason's rather than it's no fun to watch us performing poorly.

Well, amazingly it has been like that since a football was first kicked.

Hindsight is wonderful

The term bedwetters is not particularly perjorative and in my opinion is a good way to describe the mind set of some on this board.

As for posting on NSC, that is much more abusive than calling someone a bedwetter.

Anyway, enough time spent on this

If we beat Fulham then Roy really has to go.....

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You are mostly abusive whatever the subject. This is a board with opinions, now I appreciate some lack the intellectual ability to rationally put forward an argument but if you want to deal in abuse only can I suggest you post on the NSC.

Edited by Eaglecoops (24 Feb 2021 9.28am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Uphill Flag Bedford 24 Feb 21 5.03pm

Here is how I saw it:
Guaita 6
Ward 6
Mitchell 6
Cahill 7
Kouyate 8
Luka 4 (2 for 'captaincy'
Riedewald 6
Eze 5
Townsend 6 (9 for 'that cross'
Ayew 8
Mateta 6 (10 for his goal)
Benteke 6 (10 for his goal)

The defence in combination - magnificent
Ayew Man of the Match - involved in both goals
Laying the ghost - 'We don't win without Wilf'

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 25 Feb 21 9.22am

Given we had been shipping goals for fun it was hardly surprising Roy set the team up narrow and compact. In effect we had a line of 4 protected by a line of 5 / 6 making us hard to break down and limiting the number of clear-cut chances they had. The 2 goals we scored were bonuses really.
So to pick out the worst player based on that set up is a bit futile really.
However what I did like is the team showed some fight and resilience which had been lacking in the previous 2 defeats.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Feb 21 9.43am

Originally posted by HKOwen


If we beat Fulham then Roy really has to go.....

I’m glad we see it the same way. Oh and if you are going to use words like pejorative then at least make the effort to spell them correctly. This is the problem with Roy supporters, no attention to detail, just look at the points and assume everything is ok.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 25 Feb 21 9.45am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Given we had been shipping goals for fun it was hardly surprising Roy set the team up narrow and compact. In effect we had a line of 4 protected by a line of 5 / 6 making us hard to break down and limiting the number of clear-cut chances they had. The 2 goals we scored were bonuses really.
So to pick out the worst player based on that set up is a bit futile really.
However what I did like is the team showed some fight and resilience which had been lacking in the previous 2 defeats.


It certainly proved that they could still be motivated. Every other question mark, was left open. Every player has to take credit for getting a result , but this didn’t hide the many failings embedded in the team, ball retention and distribution remains a major problem throughout the side this being not the only problem but one most in the side suffer from. No body was glaringly worse than anybody else.
And after all the hard work side of this paid off.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 25 Feb 21 9.53am

Originally posted by HKOwen

How's the Roy Out bandwagon?

We have the most points ever in the PL after this many games.

It's not that long ago Charlton decided Curbishley needed replacing and where are they now.

I don't have a problem with setting the season target as survival and anything more than that is a bonus.

Take the odd scalp, score the odd worldie or two, that's enough for me.

The game is about results, as our manager said, there are no prizes for possession, corners etc.

The vast majority of the Roy Out brigade tend to damn with feint praise and even moan when we win if it's "lucky ".

NO problem with opining Roy should go if any objective reason's rather than it's no fun to watch us performing poorly.

Well, amazingly it has been like that since a football was first kicked.

Hindsight is wonderful

The term bedwetters is not particularly perjorative and in my opinion is a good way to describe the mind set of some on this board.

As for posting on NSC, that is much more abusive than calling someone a bedwetter.

Anyway, enough time spent on this

If we beat Fulham then Roy really has to go.....

It's certainly true that some sections of the Charlton fan base wanted him out but the board did offer him a new contract which he declined.

Curbs did a great job on a limited budget and presumably the board said more of the same please. At that time Curbs was very much a manager on the up and had been linked with Liverpool and England so probably figured it was time to move onto a bigger club.

Curbs was a young manager on the way up Roy has fewer days in front of him than behind.

 


One more point

palace99 Flag New Mills 25 Feb 21 10.05am

Originally posted by Putitout


It certainly proved that they could still be motivated. Every other question mark, was left open. Every player has to take credit for getting a result , but this didn’t hide the many failings embedded in the team, ball retention and distribution remains a major problem throughout the side this being not the only problem but one most in the side suffer from. No body was glaringly worse than anybody else.
And after all the hard work side of this paid off.

where we are now reminds me a little of Coppell's last season (1st spell) when we were relegated on the last day (1993?).
Coppell had us playing in a really solid formation with Wright and Bright adding the flair upfront.
It had got us to 3rd only a couple of seasons before.
Then Wright left and we were never quite the same.
At the end of the next season we were playing Coleman, a centre back, as an emergency forward.

Beginning of the next season we started with Coleman still upfront.
We did buy Armstrong that season (but to replace Bright, rather than to play with him) but it was clear we were in a downward trend and the team didn't really have an effective style of play.

This end of season we will be at the same cross roads.
I'm hoping for a different outcome!!!

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who was our least effective player v Brighton .