You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A major clear-out, an overhaul , a new squad ?
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

A major clear-out, an overhaul , a new squad ?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
TheBigToePunt Flag 25 Mar 21 11.14am

Originally posted by Ian-VI

Totally agree with you, if at £40-50,000 a week at most.

Completely agree. As sorely tempting as it is to take this opportunity to throw a few underperformers out on thier ears, ultimately the object of the exercise is to have the best squad you can. Each player should be retained unless we certainly have a better one secured to replace them. Even if retained on his current salary (as unpleasant a thought as that is), Benteke is better than nothing, quite literally.

To be fair, if Benteke was at another club this year, playing exactly as he had for us, we'd probably be happy enough to get him on a free transfer. That's exactly what we have in front of us.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 25 Mar 21 12.14pm

Originally posted by palace99

agree it is a mess of our own making.

However, of the 16, 3 have already signed extensions (Kelly, Jeff and Macca) so it's actually 13. Of those there are 2 goalies nowhere near the bench let alone the 1st team and CW who is just a deadweight.

Then there are a few whose injury records are so poor they can't be relied on - Sakho and McCarthy etc, so it is in everyone's interest if they left.

Of the remaining 8 i expect at least 4 to stay (e.g. Cahill, Mitchell, Andros and Ward or Clyne - not both).

So we definitely need about 4 or 5 new players but clearly that's better than 16


So taking Kelly, Jeff and Mac out of it, we're currently looking at losing the following then...

GK - Hennessey, Henderson
CB - Dann, Cahill, Sakho
WB - van Aanholt, Mitchell, Clyne, Ward
CM - McCarthy
WF - Townsend
FW - Batshuayi, Wickham, Benteke


Assuming that Ferguson is going to be fit next season, I'd suggest...

Keep - Mitchell, Clyne, Townsend
Keep on reduced terms - Dann, van Aanholt, Benteke
Get rid of - Hennessey, Henderson, Cahill, Sakho, McCarthy, Batshuayi, Wickham, Ward

Harsh on Ward perhaps who has been great for us but we don't need three right backs plus Kelly who can cover there.

So that potentially leaves us needing a third choice goalkeeper, at least two CBs, another CM (RLC on loan would be ideal) and another striker. Frankly we need another winger option as well.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

TheBigToePunt Flag 25 Mar 21 12.37pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


So taking Kelly, Jeff and Mac out of it, we're currently looking at losing the following then...

GK - Hennessey, Henderson
CB - Dann, Cahill, Sakho
WB - van Aanholt, Mitchell, Clyne, Ward
CM - McCarthy
WF - Townsend
FW - Batshuayi, Wickham, Benteke


Assuming that Ferguson is going to be fit next season, I'd suggest...

Keep - Mitchell, Clyne, Townsend
Keep on reduced terms - Dann, van Aanholt, Benteke
Get rid of - Hennessey, Henderson, Cahill, Sakho, McCarthy, Batshuayi, Wickham, Ward

Harsh on Ward perhaps who has been great for us but we don't need three right backs plus Kelly who can cover there.

So that potentially leaves us needing a third choice goalkeeper, at least two CBs, another CM (RLC on loan would be ideal) and another striker. Frankly we need another winger option as well.

There was talk that Mitchell had signed a new deal?

[Link]

I agree that if Ferguson gets fit we may not need both Clyne and Ward, but given the year the young man has had I'd retain both Ward and Clyne for at least another year, just in case. Plus, we know Ward and Clyne are good enough, we have no idea about Ferguson yet. We could also push one of the three to left back at a squeeze if Mitchell gets injured. Not ideal, but possible.

For me the main areas to strengthen are at centre back, and on the wing. Our centre backs are literally knackered. Even though we miss him in midfield, Koyate can stay at the back where he's done well, but Sakho can leave, Dann can as well (with thanks for great service), leaving only Cahill and Tomkins, presuming the former stays. A new, younger centre back is a must. We also desperately need a direct and pacey winger to carry the fight. If we can get really good players in those two positions, everything else is a bonus.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Mar 21 1.23pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt


I agree that if Ferguson gets fit we may not need both Clyne and Ward, but given the year the young man has had I'd retain both Ward and Clyne for at least another year, just in case.

Both Wickham and Bolasie weren't the same after similar injuries and I think that Ferguson was bought as a central defender and not as a full back even though he can play there

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 25 Mar 21 2.25pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Both Wickham and Bolasie weren't the same after similar injuries and I think that Ferguson was bought as a central defender and not as a full back even though he can play there

All true, he's also very young and utterly untried at this level. Many of us have perhaps presumed that he was bought to go straight into the first team, but that is a sizable presumption.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 25 Mar 21 5.37pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


So taking Kelly, Jeff and Mac out of it, we're currently looking at losing the following then...

GK - Hennessey, Henderson
CB - Dann, Cahill, Sakho
WB - van Aanholt, Mitchell, Clyne, Ward
CM - McCarthy
WF - Townsend
FW - Batshuayi, Wickham, Benteke


Assuming that Ferguson is going to be fit next season, I'd suggest...

Keep - Mitchell, Clyne, Townsend
Keep on reduced terms - Dann, van Aanholt, Benteke
Get rid of - Hennessey, Henderson, Cahill, Sakho, McCarthy, Batshuayi, Wickham, Ward

Harsh on Ward perhaps who has been great for us but we don't need three right backs plus Kelly who can cover there.

So that potentially leaves us needing a third choice goalkeeper, at least two CBs, another CM (RLC on loan would be ideal) and another striker. Frankly we need another winger option as well.

Decent call. I would replace Cahill for Dann, if he wants another year. I think Dann is gone at this level since his ACL injury.

Maybe Ward for Clyne too - lower wages and less injuries might be key.

PVA looks like he's going so maybe only Tekkers on reduced terms, but i doubt he'll accept.

5 key areas to focus on this summer IMHO.
A winger
A young centre back
A different striker option e.g. someone fast
A younger centre mid option potentially with some creativity (if that exists - RLC would be ideal if he stays fit)
A versatile defender - like Ferguson, but fit!!

However, if Wilf goes it will be panic stations.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 25 Mar 21 5.45pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


So taking Kelly, Jeff and Mac out of it, we're currently looking at losing the following then...

GK - Hennessey, Henderson
CB - Dann, Cahill, Sakho
WB - van Aanholt, Mitchell, Clyne, Ward
CM - McCarthy
WF - Townsend
FW - Batshuayi, Wickham, Benteke


Assuming that Ferguson is going to be fit next season, I'd suggest...

Keep - Mitchell, Clyne, Townsend
Keep on reduced terms - Dann, van Aanholt, Benteke
Get rid of - Hennessey, Henderson, Cahill, Sakho, McCarthy, Batshuayi, Wickham, Ward

Harsh on Ward perhaps who has been great for us but we don't need three right backs plus Kelly who can cover there.

So that potentially leaves us needing a third choice goalkeeper, at least two CBs, another CM (RLC on loan would be ideal) and another striker. Frankly we need another winger option as well.

Trigger happy. I’d be keeping Sakho and probably give Wickham one more chance to come right too. Quality players. Sakho the best CB at the club when fit. Give them a one year extension and see how they go with a decent preseason.

And he’s, swap cahill for Dann. Love Scotty, but he’s past it.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 26 Mar 21 10.16am

Originally posted by sprites

Trigger happy. I’d be keeping Sakho and probably give Wickham one more chance to come right too. Quality players. Sakho the best CB at the club when fit. Give them a one year extension and see how they go with a decent preseason.

And he’s, swap cahill for Dann. Love Scotty, but he’s past it.

Sakho has played 4 league games this season and played 14 last season. In the 4 years of his contract he only played more than 20 games a season once.
He is one of the top earners on over £100k a week.
He is also 31 now and currently injured.
IMHO it would be madness to offer him a contract unless on massively reduced terms, which he almost certainly won't accept.

I presume the Wickham comment is a joke.

Palace's accounts are due end of March, so will probably be available early April online.
They are likely to show a reasonable loss for 2020 and the loss will be even greater this season (as no matchday income for the whole season).

With our wage bill being so high (78% of revenue i think) this is clearly an area that needs addressing ASAP as the current wages are unsustainable.

Some fans don't get it

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Mar 21 10.34am

Originally posted by palace99

Sakho has played 4 league games this season and played 14 last season. In the 4 years of his contract he only played more than 20 games a season once.
He is one of the top earners on over £100k a week.
He is also 31 now and currently injured.
IMHO it would be madness to offer him a contract unless on massively reduced terms, which he almost certainly won't accept.

I presume the Wickham comment is a joke.

Some fans don't get it

Before insulting others whose opinions don't co-incide with yours there is sensible reasoning in the opinion that you are rubbishing.

You say that Sakho won't accept reduced terms as if you know him and his thinking but then you go on to say that it's madness to offer him a new contract as he is injured too often. Won't other clubs be aware of his injury record too or will they be stupid enough to offer him his current salary knowing that he will only play for half a season?

Likewise to replace Wickham with a younger Premier League quality striker is likely to cost far in excess of keeping him on for another year which is money that you yourself have indicated that we can't afford.

If Wickham stays injury free for the rest of the season and shows his fitness in the development squad games plus the odd cameo for the first team I think it could be very cost effective to keep him on

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 26 Mar 21 4.03pm

Now is the time to blood fringe or youngsters who Roy feels have a point to prove for next season. If there are none, then that's too bad.

I would also look to who would make the cut and start searching.

By now Parish knows who will be manager next season, if not, he's a fool...

This is pre season.

 


This was once a quality forum....

aashman12 Flag 26 Mar 21 4.31pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

According to transfermarkt.co.uk we have 16 players out of contract...

[Link]

... and you simply can't replace / recruit that many players at once. Remember when we tried to sign an entire new squad when we came up under Holloway? It was a shambles.

We signed Stephen Dobbie, Dwight Gayle, Jerome Thomas, Jose Campana, Elliot Grandin, Marouane Chamakh, Florian Marange, Jimmy Kebe, Jack Hunt, Adrian Mariappa, Barry Bannan, Adlene Guedioura, Scott Dann, Joe Ledley and Jason Puncheon. With the exception of 2/3 of them, that's a shocking list.

We should have been undertaking this process over the last 4/5 transfers windows rather than sitting idly by and hoping that the bargain bin would provide at the very last minute. This is a mess of our own making and we're going to have to renew about 10 30+ years old as a consequence.

6 of them were/are very good signings. Dann and ledley weren't Holloway signings

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Mar 21 4.35pm

Originally posted by aashman12

6 of them were/are very good signings. Dann and ledley weren't Holloway signings

They were both signed by Tony Pulis.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 26 Mar 21 9.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

They were both signed by Tony Pulis.

was Pardew our worst man in the transfer market ?

Dougie was maybe the best ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Mar 21 11.08pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

was Pardew our worst man in the transfer market ?

Dougie was maybe the best ?

Some of the Pardew signings :
Benteke,Wickham,Tomkins,Townsend,Souare,Cabaye.

Some of the Freedman signings :
Ward,Delaney,Jedinak,Bolasie,Murray,Gabbidon.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 27 Mar 21 8.25am

An overhaul is inevitable, it's just a matter of deciding the criteria that underlines it.
For one, it would be good to see a sensible wage structure in place. For example, bringing in Clyne who reportedly is on near £90k, keeping Meyer on the bench earning £100k a week, while his teammates earn 40k less, retaining the services of sicknote players and players who don't look interested - all can go.
The club should aim to bring the wage bill down along with the average age. I don't think it will be that painful a procedure.
Zaha needs to be built into the equation, and that means letting him go, we've been a one man team for far too long.
Probably a two or three season transformation with a new man at the helm.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (27 Mar 2021 8.41am)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 29 Mar 21 4.15am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Before insulting others whose opinions don't co-incide with yours there is sensible reasoning in the opinion that you are rubbishing.

You say that Sakho won't accept reduced terms as if you know him and his thinking but then you go on to say that it's madness to offer him a new contract as he is injured too often. Won't other clubs be aware of his injury record too or will they be stupid enough to offer him his current salary knowing that he will only play for half a season?

Likewise to replace Wickham with a younger Premier League quality striker is likely to cost far in excess of keeping him on for another year which is money that you yourself have indicated that we can't afford.

If Wickham stays injury free for the rest of the season and shows his fitness in the development squad games plus the odd cameo for the first team I think it could be very cost effective to keep him on

Cheers for that Midlands. Took the words out of my mouth.

 

BelfastEagle Flag 29 Mar 21 7.58am

Who cares if Sakho can’t find another club ? My only concern is that he is off our wage roll as soon as possible.

With regards to a Wickham how many false dawns have we had ? How many hundreds of thousands of pounds of wages have been wasted ? In my opinion thinking that he is a “cost effective” option really underlines why we are in the current situation with regards to the squad. We need to draw a line under Wickham and wish him well.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 29 Mar 21 9.29am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Before insulting others whose opinions don't co-incide with yours there is sensible reasoning in the opinion that you are rubbishing.

You say that Sakho won't accept reduced terms as if you know him and his thinking but then you go on to say that it's madness to offer him a new contract as he is injured too often. Won't other clubs be aware of his injury record too or will they be stupid enough to offer him his current salary knowing that he will only play for half a season?

Likewise to replace Wickham with a younger Premier League quality striker is likely to cost far in excess of keeping him on for another year which is money that you yourself have indicated that we can't afford.

If Wickham stays injury free for the rest of the season and shows his fitness in the development squad games plus the odd cameo for the first team I think it could be very cost effective to keep him on

Sakho will definitely have to take reduced terms - probably in France, where he and his wife want to live.

Any striker option other than Wickham is a positive as Wickham is so rarely fit he can't be relied on.

Doesn't have to be a Prem signing - so for a lower divison option who has potential - Watkins started at Exeter etc. Peterborough seem to be good at unearthing strikers over the last 10 years or so. There are options.
Also CW is in the same mode as Tekkers - go for someone different e.g. small and fast.
How will we ever have a plan b if all our strikers are of a similar size and style?

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 04 Apr 21 7.19pm

this sumer is going to be so interesting...

bearing in mind our last set of published account, without the AWB money we would have lost best part of £40, given covid lost revenue and spending on eze & ferguson, sorloth aside we could be looking at £60m loss these set of delayed accounts.

in my mind, i think anybody assuming we will spend £50m will be very disappointed.

i can see the majority of players given new contracts, mainly for amortisation reasons, but can see sakho, mccarthy, wickham, kelly & hennessey let go to save us approx £250k a week in wages.

we will sign 2 x youngsters & 2 x freebies to replace them.

i genuinely expect us to spend less than £20m this summer, and i am happy with that.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


cryrst Flag The garden of England 04 Apr 21 7.39pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

this sumer is going to be so interesting...

bearing in mind our last set of published account, without the AWB money we would have lost best part of £40, given covid lost revenue and spending on eze & ferguson, sorloth aside we could be looking at £60m loss these set of delayed accounts.

in my mind, i think anybody assuming we will spend £50m will be very disappointed.

i can see the majority of players given new contracts, mainly for amortisation reasons, but can see sakho, mccarthy, wickham, kelly & hennessey let go to save us approx £250k a week in wages.

we will sign 2 x youngsters & 2 x freebies to replace them.

i genuinely expect us to spend less than £20m this summer, and i am happy with that.

Best part of 40 quid, I might be able to help Steve out with that one. only pulling your chain

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > A major clear-out, an overhaul , a new squad ?