You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The real reason............
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The real reason............


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
glaziermart Flag 17 May 21 10.48am

Why a lot of us want shot of Roy? It is not because we do not appreciate the job he has done over the past 4 years, and it has nothing to do with his obvious dignity or that he is gent. We keep seeing the pro Roy brigade bringing all of these things up, as if this is these are the most important things. It is the sheer negativity that has driven most of us bonkers. Yesterday proved that this team can play when the shackles are off. We were awesome at times. But we know when next season starts, Roy will revert to type. Our brilliant under 18's will not be gradually filtered into the squad (which we know a Howe or a Lampard would try to do) - Roy simply prefers experienced old pros, but is not just that. The constant selection of favourites, keeping the same eleven, even when it sometimes needs tweaking either because of the opposition or one or two are tired. Then there is his use of substitutes (virtually non-existent) or if he does use them, it is far too late in the game. He even said it is remarkable that the same old pros are still here 4 years later. That is nothing to be proud of, it is total mismanagement which i would blame the board for, but Roy seems happy in the main for it to have happened, and only seems to want to sign journeyman pros. Lastly the myth that he has not been backed. the truth is we overspent massively before he arrived, due to the vanity of Pardew which Parish was happy to go along with, ridiculous fees spent on Sakho and Benteke, and then under Allardyce we were actually the biggest spenders in the January 2017 window, over spending probably on Van Aanholt, Schlupp, and Luka. So when he arrived he had a squad packed with internationals, far better than Pulis ever inherited. The squad just got older over time and now needs a massive overhaul. Unfortunately Roy is not the man to do it. This why Roy has to go, nothing to do with being a gent, being loyal or any of those things. We need a young hungry manager with the drive to want to do this. As was proved yesterday, this team can play and should have been allowed to before. But we just need to get the age of the squad down.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 17 May 21 11.08am

I think this a fair assessment.

Not so long ago I saw an interview with Jimmy Bullard, and one of the things discussed was about him leaving Fulham. He said that when Roy took over, he told him that he wanted to play in a more functional style to suit the team. Bullard said he was used to doing things more spontaneously, and which pushed him towards leaving. Maybe that why we don't see any creative central midfield players - remember what happened to Camarrasa.

I am not looking for the team to pushing for Europe or even a top 10 place, but rather football which is worth watching and gives you some encouragement.

The only thing I would say, is that without players that Allardyce brought in that January (Schlupp, PVA, Luke and on loan Sakho), we would most defiantely got relegated that season.

 

EddieMac Flag 17 May 21 11.22am

Originally posted by glaziermart

Why a lot of us want shot of Roy? It is not because we do not appreciate the job he has done over the past 4 years, and it has nothing to do with his obvious dignity or that he is gent. We keep seeing the pro Roy brigade bringing all of these things up, as if this is these are the most important things. It is the sheer negativity that has driven most of us bonkers. Yesterday proved that this team can play when the shackles are off. We were awesome at times. But we know when next season starts, Roy will revert to type. Our brilliant under 18's will not be gradually filtered into the squad (which we know a Howe or a Lampard would try to do) - Roy simply prefers experienced old pros, but is not just that. The constant selection of favourites, keeping the same eleven, even when it sometimes needs tweaking either because of the opposition or one or two are tired. Then there is his use of substitutes (virtually non-existent) or if he does use them, it is far too late in the game. He even said it is remarkable that the same old pros are still here 4 years later. That is nothing to be proud of, it is total mismanagement which i would blame the board for, but Roy seems happy in the main for it to have happened, and only seems to want to sign journeyman pros. Lastly the myth that he has not been backed. the truth is we overspent massively before he arrived, due to the vanity of Pardew which Parish was happy to go along with, ridiculous fees spent on Sakho and Benteke, and then under Allardyce we were actually the biggest spenders in the January 2017 window, over spending probably on Van Aanholt, Schlupp, and Luka. So when he arrived he had a squad packed with internationals, far better than Pulis ever inherited. The squad just got older over time and now needs a massive overhaul. Unfortunately Roy is not the man to do it. This why Roy has to go, nothing to do with being a gent, being loyal or any of those things. We need a young hungry manager with the drive to want to do this. As was proved yesterday, this team can play and should have been allowed to before. But we just need to get the age of the squad down.

Don’t forget in your analysis the reason why Roy has played the same players over and over again.

Schlupp has been injured for the majority of the season.
Tomkins has played a handful of games all year.
Cahill has been injured a lot.
Sakho is finished as a player.
McArthur has missed most of the season.
McCarthy has missed a lot of the season.

We have Ward has basically our only fit right back all year. There have been times over the last couple of years when we have no fit striker at the club.

Howe or Lampard wouldn’t know where to start with these problems.

It is very easy to pick one game against Villa and say look what we can do. Have a look back through our starting 11’s and subs bench for the last couple of years and it may change your mind.


Edited by EddieMac (17 May 2021 11.22am)

 

glaziermart Flag 17 May 21 12.04pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Don’t forget in your analysis the reason why Roy has played the same players over and over again.

Schlupp has been injured for the majority of the season.
Tomkins has played a handful of games all year.
Cahill has been injured a lot.
Sakho is finished as a player.
McArthur has missed most of the season.
McCarthy has missed a lot of the season.

We have Ward has basically our only fit right back all year. There have been times over the last couple of years when we have no fit striker at the club.

Howe or Lampard wouldn’t know where to start with these problems.

It is very easy to pick one game against Villa and say look what we can do. Have a look back through our starting 11’s and subs bench for the last couple of years and it may change your mind.


Edited by EddieMac (17 May 2021 11.22am)

No it won't change my mind. Compared to what Pulis inherited, it was by contrast an embarrassment of riches. We also had players like Cabaye and Loftus-Cheek in addition to most of the players we have now who were younger. I'm sorry, but those of us with longer memories cannot remember squads as talented as this with internationals everywhere

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 May 21 12.06pm

Originally posted by glaziermart

Why a lot of us want shot of Roy? It is not because we do not appreciate the job he has done over the past 4 years, and it has nothing to do with his obvious dignity or that he is gent. We keep seeing the pro Roy brigade bringing all of these things up, as if this is these are the most important things. It is the sheer negativity that has driven most of us bonkers. Yesterday proved that this team can play when the shackles are off. We were awesome at times. But we know when next season starts, Roy will revert to type. Our brilliant under 18's will not be gradually filtered into the squad (which we know a Howe or a Lampard would try to do) - Roy simply prefers experienced old pros, but is not just that. The constant selection of favourites, keeping the same eleven, even when it sometimes needs tweaking either because of the opposition or one or two are tired. Then there is his use of substitutes (virtually non-existent) or if he does use them, it is far too late in the game. He even said it is remarkable that the same old pros are still here 4 years later. That is nothing to be proud of, it is total mismanagement which i would blame the board for, but Roy seems happy in the main for it to have happened, and only seems to want to sign journeyman pros. Lastly the myth that he has not been backed. the truth is we overspent massively before he arrived, due to the vanity of Pardew which Parish was happy to go along with, ridiculous fees spent on Sakho and Benteke, and then under Allardyce we were actually the biggest spenders in the January 2017 window, over spending probably on Van Aanholt, Schlupp, and Luka. So when he arrived he had a squad packed with internationals, far better than Pulis ever inherited. The squad just got older over time and now needs a massive overhaul. Unfortunately Roy is not the man to do it. This why Roy has to go, nothing to do with being a gent, being loyal or any of those things. We need a young hungry manager with the drive to want to do this. As was proved yesterday, this team can play and should have been allowed to before. But we just need to get the age of the squad down.

I have been “ Pro Roy “ because my perception of the club as a whole clearly differs from the Anti Roy Brigade.

I have posted on many occasions that I agree, the football his teams have produced have rarely excited. But I understand the reasons behind why Hodgson sets his teams up, something that either the Anti Roy folks either don’t get or simply choose to ignore .

If you want to disagree with his team selections, use of subs, tactics - fine. Go on a Chelsea fans website and you will see the same there - fans questioning all of those things. And they are 4th in the league and are in 2 cup finals !

In the 4 years that Roy has been at Palace I would argue that there has been a distinct lack of young talent coming through the ranks. Yes, we now have a very useful collection of players now at U18 level and it’s been widely reported that we are planning to fast track those players deemed good enough - eg Rak-Sakyi- into the first team. And you don’t KNOW that Howe or Lampard would be any more likely to promote younger players - Lampard had no choice when he first became Chelsea manager. Then the transfer embargo got lifted and guess what - major money spent on an influx of expensive players.

It is not a myth that he hasn’t been financially backed it’s a fact ! You even gave the reasons why ! There was no money left after Allardyce went.

Now a squad rebuild of the size required is likely to take longer than the 12 month cycle that Hodgson has been operating in. And if I was Parish, I would be looking for a younger man to do the job. But I still think this Roy situation is more complex than people realise

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 May 21 12.17pm

Oh great. Yet another thread on the same subject as all of the others

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 17 May 21 12.21pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I have been “ Pro Roy “ because my perception of the club as a whole clearly differs from the Anti Roy Brigade.

I have posted on many occasions that I agree, the football his teams have produced have rarely excited. But I understand the reasons behind why Hodgson sets his teams up, something that either the Anti Roy folks either don’t get or simply choose to ignore .

If you want to disagree with his team selections, use of subs, tactics - fine. Go on a Chelsea fans website and you will see the same there - fans questioning all of those things. And they are 4th in the league and are in 2 cup finals !

In the 4 years that Roy has been at Palace I would argue that there has been a distinct lack of young talent coming through the ranks. Yes, we now have a very useful collection of players now at U18 level and it’s been widely reported that we are planning to fast track those players deemed good enough - eg Rak-Sakyi- into the first team. And you don’t KNOW that Howe or Lampard would be any more likely to promote younger players - Lampard had no choice when he first became Chelsea manager. Then the transfer embargo got lifted and guess what - major money spent on an influx of expensive players.

It is not a myth that he hasn’t been financially backed it’s a fact ! You even gave the reasons why ! There was no money left after Allardyce went.

Now a squad rebuild of the size required is likely to take longer than the 12 month cycle that Hodgson has been operating in. And if I was Parish, I would be looking for a younger man to do the job. But I still think this Roy situation is more complex than people realise

Good response NEILLO. You just saved me a lot of tapping on my mobile. I agree totally that Roy has done a great job with the poor hand he was dealt. So right about other clubs too - even Liverpool fans find fault with Klopp.

I have posted before that we must trust Mr Parish to make the right decisions about our future. And I stick with that.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 May 21 12.31pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Oh great. Yet another thread on the same subject as all of the others

Yay! It's a happy happy Roy day!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 17 May 21 1.29pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Oh great. Yet another thread on the same subject as all of the others

This is where moderators should merge the threads. There is nothing new to say, just coming from a different angle.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 17 May 21 1.49pm

Originally posted by glaziermart

No it won't change my mind. Compared to what Pulis inherited, it was by contrast an embarrassment of riches. We also had players like Cabaye and Loftus-Cheek in addition to most of the players we have now who were younger. I'm sorry, but those of us with longer memories cannot remember squads as talented as this with internationals everywhere

Our squad has improved since pulis but it has fallen into relative decline in this division.

 

Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 17 May 21 2.25pm

I completely agree with the OP. It's time for Roy to go before we all die of boredom.

 

YT Flag Oxford 17 May 21 2.59pm

To the OP....the extravagant spending didn't end with Big Sam. £9 million spent on Sorloth in January 2018.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 17 May 21 4.23pm

To the OP
I suspect that you will find that Hodgson's reference to being amazed that he's still got the majority of the squad he inherited is not that he's happy to have it but that he's amazed that this ageing squad has been able to avoid a relegation battle yet again. He's made it very clear on more than one occasion in the past that the squad needs rejuvenating and he has shown delight at the progress Eze and Mitchell have made and some of the U18s are making. The idea that Hodgson has it in for youth is IMHO a myth created by the 'Roy Out' brigade.

Edited by doombear (17 May 2021 4.23pm)

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 17 May 21 4.44pm

Originally posted by doombear

To the OP
I suspect that you will find that Hodgson's reference to being amazed that he's still got the majority of the squad he inherited is not that he's happy to have it but that he's amazed that this ageing squad has been able to avoid a relegation battle yet again. He's made it very clear on more than one occasion in the past that the squad needs rejuvenating and he has shown delight at the progress Eze and Mitchell have made and some of the U18s are making. The idea that Hodgson has it in for youth is IMHO a myth created by the 'Roy Out' brigade.

Edited by doombear (17 May 2021 4.23pm)

Really ? Could you honestly see Roy doing what Leicester done on Saturday and stick in a 19 year old in the cup final, or what Sheff Utd did yesterday by playing a 17 year old up front ?

I read somewhere today in one of those 'News Now' features, he was trying to justify having three goalkeepers in yesterday's squad, and saying that he could have put one of the U23's on the bench but it was pointless as they wouldn't have played no matter what.

 

Robk Flag 17 May 21 5.02pm

Unfortunately sometimes the grass isn’t greener on the other side .. remember a certain F de Boer.... he tried to change things immediately and it simply doesn’t work...yes I totally agree about the younger players , they should be given a chance but perhaps a more cautious approach with Sean Dyche would be a safer option if indeed Roy does go....

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 17 May 21 6.58pm

Tragic post .. big Sam bought JS , Pva and Luka in 17 , 4 years later they are regular prem first team players with relatively little outlay .. Pva I would say is off, JS is actually missed when not playing and Luka may be past his best but he cost 6m, so we real value tbh.

Roy didn’t spend big on Tekkers or Sakho .. in fact the only real purchases have been Sorloth (some how we hoodwinked RBL into 20m) and Eze last season who will seem a bargain at 20 mill or so.

Roy’s remit is to keep us in the PL that’s it , it’s about hard cash .. ask any Sunderland, Portsmouth etc etc if they would like to be bored with PL football or stuck in Div 1 for years. Unless there is big investment in the team then Roy will stick with what he has as it works and that’s the job he’s given by our board.

So yes it’s hard to watch but until we get 37-40 points on the board we will predominately play the percentages and win ten against the bottom ten and pick up a few points against the top 6 .. winning at old Trafford etc. Every team in from 10th place down is in exactly the same position ..

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 17 May 21 7.34pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Really ? Could you honestly see Roy doing what Leicester done on Saturday and stick in a 19 year old in the cup final, or what Sheff Utd did yesterday by playing a 17 year old up front ?

I read somewhere today in one of those 'News Now' features, he was trying to justify having three goalkeepers in yesterday's squad, and saying that he could have put one of the U23's on the bench but it was pointless as they wouldn't have played no matter what.


As is often the case, what was written about yesterday's bench was a carefully selected edit. I listened to what Hodgson ACTUALLY said and I explained that in the thread questioning Hodgson's sanity. Of course, you could go to the CPFC website and listen to Hodgson's answer to the journalist for yourself but if you are anti-Hodgson you may decide you don't want to. What he said made perfect sense to me by the way.

As to your question, yes I can. He did it with Dreher a couple of seasons back, so if the youngster is deemed ready, Hodgson will play him IMO.

Edited by doombear (17 May 2021 7.36pm)

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 17 May 21 8.12pm

Originally posted by doombear


As is often the case, what was written about yesterday's bench was a carefully selected edit. I listened to what Hodgson ACTUALLY said and I explained that in the thread questioning Hodgson's sanity. Of course, you could go to the CPFC website and listen to Hodgson's answer to the journalist for yourself but if you are anti-Hodgson you may decide you don't want to. What he said made perfect sense to me by the way.

As to your question, yes I can. He did it with Dreher a couple of seasons back, so if the youngster is deemed ready, Hodgson will play him IMO.

Edited by doombear (17 May 2021 7.36pm)

Surely one could make a case for a youngster showing his potential once he is in the first team. Would AWB have been put on the field otherwise if we weren't rife with injuries or Mitchell ?

I sometimes feel that giving a youngster the limelight sometimes prompts them into showing what ability they have and some will be up to standard and some won't.

What i dont understand is the reluctance to try 1 or 2 in the last 10 mins when he usually feels is the right time for a sub. Especially now we are safe it would be nice to see a couple of the upcoming talents. I mean they have shown the possess some great qualities in their respective divisions in U18 and U23.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 May 21 10.08pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Don’t forget in your analysis the reason why Roy has played the same players over and over again.

Schlupp has been injured for the majority of the season.
Tomkins has played a handful of games all year.
Cahill has been injured a lot.
Sakho is finished as a player.
McArthur has missed most of the season.
McCarthy has missed a lot of the season.

We have Ward has basically our only fit right back all year. There have been times over the last couple of years when we have no fit striker at the club.

Howe or Lampard wouldn’t know where to start with these problems.

It is very easy to pick one game against Villa and say look what we can do. Have a look back through our starting 11’s and subs bench for the last couple of years and it may change your mind.


Edited by EddieMac (17 May 2021 11.22am)

This will only confuse him.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 May 21 10.12pm

Originally posted by kev64

Tragic post .. big Sam bought JS , Pva and Luka in 17 , 4 years later they are regular prem first team players with relatively little outlay .. Pva I would say is off, JS is actually missed when not playing and Luka may be past his best but he cost 6m, so we real value tbh.

Roy didn’t spend big on Tekkers or Sakho .. in fact the only real purchases have been Sorloth (some how we hoodwinked RBL into 20m) and Eze last season who will seem a bargain at 20 mill or so.

Roy’s remit is to keep us in the PL that’s it , it’s about hard cash .. ask any Sunderland, Portsmouth etc etc if they would like to be bored with PL football or stuck in Div 1 for years. Unless there is big investment in the team then Roy will stick with what he has as it works and that’s the job he’s given by our board.

So yes it’s hard to watch but until we get 37-40 points on the board we will predominately play the percentages and win ten against the bottom ten and pick up a few points against the top 6 .. winning at old Trafford etc. Every team in from 10th place down is in exactly the same position ..

Exactly.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The real reason............