This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Elwissthebest
Agree with Doombear. We should accept £40m without hesitation. Not that it is likely to be offered. Wilf has been disappointing for a while and his value plummets by the month. He wouldn't start for any of the 'Big Six' (as in ESL) and in the current climate I can't see any of them paying £40m to put him on the bench. There is a case to be made that he would be dynamite if surrounded by better players, but I'm not convinced. Agreed. He should have been dropped ages ago. He needs to realise who pays has wages and start earning them. Arsenal must have been delighted the other week. They spent a fortune on Pepe in stead of Zaha and were vindicated. He has come good and is younger and keen while Wilf did very little but whined all through the 90 minutes. This summer may show him that his dream of European football and winning trophies is just that, a dream. His only hope is that Chelski decide to go for him as they may win something before he is past it. I wonder if his team mates are beginning to get fed up with his attitude. Eze always looked for him but it was notable in the last few games that Townsend got more of the ball and the days of “give it to Wilf” may be over.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Here we go again... 'Sell him! Drop him! Make him take a pay cut! Sell him for scrap value! I don't like his body language! I don't like his facial expression when someone else scores!' Last season he was our top scorer, top assist provider, and best player. Yet again. And yes, he was miles and miles better than Eze, who has potential but at the moment seems to excel largely against Sheffield United. Yup.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by michaelpearce
the first clubs in the press are Spurs watch this space more to come Rule out Spurs, waiting on new manager.
Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Here we go again... 'Sell him! Drop him! Make him take a pay cut! Sell him for scrap value! I don't like his body language! I don't like his facial expression when someone else scores!' Last season he was our top scorer, top assist provider, and best player. Yet again. And yes, he was miles and miles better than Eze, who has potential but at the moment seems to excel largely against Sheffield United. I think this has moved beyond facial expressions. Wilf is arguably still our best player (although only if you ignore recent performances), but he doesn't want to be at Palace and has publicly stated this. Football isn't just about stats and points on the board. I got more joy this season from Mitchell scoring his first goal with his shoulder than anything Wilf did, even if in the grand scheme of things his contribution on paper was a fraction of Wilf's. Of course we shouldn't give him away for peanuts, but equally I think it would be detrimental to keep him tied up under the holmesdale. Each to his own, but don't act like your opinion is superior just because people have the audacity to question Wilf's future role at the club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
West Ham won't pay him his reputed requirement of £200.000 per week and I doubt whether Everton would either Makes more sense for him to play second fiddle at a club where they will match his current pay, but he'll get more chance of trophies. I think
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet. |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Here we go again... 'Sell him! Drop him! Make him take a pay cut! Sell him for scrap value! I don't like his body language! I don't like his facial expression when someone else scores!' Last season he was our top scorer, top assist provider, and best player. Yet again. And yes, he was miles and miles better than Eze, who has potential but at the moment seems to excel largely against Sheffield United. On assists, he was joint 5th with 2, same as McArthur who played 12 games less. Eze, Townsend, Ayew and Schlupp got more. [Link] Knock everyone's penalties off and he isn't top scorer. According to whoscored he wasn't our best player - [Link] Zaha had a really fast start. 4 goals and 0 assists in his last 21 games paints a different story, a fairly concerning one. You're entitled to your opinion, and undeniably he's a good player. However, based on his form in the last 6 months there is a very valid question around taking £40m for a guy who is 29 in November vs getting that form of the last 6 months for another 2 years and him going for free.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I think this has moved beyond facial expressions. Wilf is arguably still our best player (although only if you ignore recent performances), but he doesn't want to be at Palace and has publicly stated this. Football isn't just about stats and points on the board. I got more joy this season from Mitchell scoring his first goal with his shoulder than anything Wilf did, even if in the grand scheme of things his contribution on paper was a fraction of Wilf's. Of course we shouldn't give him away for peanuts, but equally I think it would be detrimental to keep him tied up under the holmesdale. Each to his own, but don't act like your opinion is superior just because people have the audacity to question Wilf's future role at the club. Debating whether or not to sell at £40m is perfectly reasonable , as is contemplating the effect of retaining a player who so desperately wants to play for a bigger team whilst he still can. My point is twofold; firstly, and without attributing this argument to you personally if you haven't made it, the idea that Zaha is some kind of malignant influence, sulking about the place downing tools is plainly wrong on the statistical evidence alone. He's wanted to move for years, but has always produced for us when the move doesn't happen. Secondly, he is very simply and quite plainly our best player, and I cannot fathom the logic in selling your best player unless you are absolutely certain that your side will be better for it. Yes we could re-invest the money, but in who? Who will carry the weight Zaha has? That's my point about Eze, who we have all warmed to greatly, but who is miles and miles away from being as effective a winner of points as Zaha. When Eze scored at Sheffield United the number of posts attributing significance to Zahas (evidently insufficiently exuberant) celebration was in double figures within half an hour. I wasn't trying to come across all superior to anyone, but to be honest nonsense like that needs to be given the appropriate short shrift. Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 May 2021 2.33pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
On assists, he was joint 5th with 2, same as McArthur who played 12 games less. Eze, Townsend, Ayew and Schlupp got more. [Link] Knock everyone's penalties off and he isn't top scorer. According to whoscored he wasn't our best player - [Link] Zaha had a really fast start. 4 goals and 0 assists in his last 21 games paints a different story, a fairly concerning one. You're entitled to your opinion, and undeniably he's a good player. However, based on his form in the last 6 months there is a very valid question around taking £40m for a guy who is 29 in November vs getting that form of the last 6 months for another 2 years and him going for free. Rather than assists, I am thinking of chances created, which either sky or bt showed recently, and he was (as you'd expect) ahead by some distance. He is the top scorer - why would you take penalties away? I don't see why the opinion of whoscroed should be given any weight - even the most sophisticated formula cannot quantify the extent to which Zaha occupies opposing defenders, or the oppositions managers plans, or gives hope to his teammates when they know that even at his worst he can produce something from nothing. We have nobody like him when he isn't there. The question of whether to cash in is perfectly reasonable, and the answer (as always) depends on how his contribution is assessed against the cost of replicating that contribution in his absence, against the fee we'd get. The thing I've little time for is people acting like he wouldn't be a loss - that just nonsense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Debating whether or not to sell at £40m is perfectly reasonable , as is contemplating the effect of retaining a player who so desperately wants to play for a bigger team whilst he still can. My point is twofold; firstly, and without attributing this argument to you personally if you haven't made it, the idea that Zaha is some kind of malignant influence, sulking about the place downing tools is plainly wrong on the statistical evidence alone. He's wanted to move for years, but has always produced for us when the move doesn't happen. Secondly, he is very simply and quite plainly our best player, and I cannot fathom the logic in selling your best player unless you are absolutely certain that your side will be better for it. Yes we could re-invest the money, but in who? Who will carry the weight Zaha has? That's my point about Eze, who we have all warmed to greatly, but who is miles and miles away from being as effective a winner of points as Zaha. When Eze scored at Sheffield United the number of posts attributing significance to Zahas (evidently insufficiently exuberant) celebration was in double figures within half an hour. I wasn't trying to come across all superior to anyone, but to be honest nonsense like that needs to be given the appropriate short shrift. Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 May 2021 2.33pm) ambrose7 makes a good point though, in that the last 6 months he hasn't been performing that well and really hasn't been our best player. At the end of the season Eze was starting to show more of an influence while Wilf just repeatedly ran down blind alleys, lost possession and got frustrated. It was also noticeable that teams stopped doubling up on him like they used to. Personally, in an ideal world, he'll change his mind with a new manager and commit the rest of his days to us. I never doubt his effort, but when he isn't happy it really does seem to show in his performances. If he isn't committed to us though then I want him to go as for me personally I don't want a player who believes he is being held against his will.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Here we go again... 'Sell him! Drop him! Make him take a pay cut! Sell him for scrap value! I don't like his body language! I don't like his facial expression when someone else scores!' Last season he was our top scorer, top assist provider, and best player. Yet again. And yes, he was miles and miles better than Eze, who has potential but at the moment seems to excel largely against Sheffield United.
As for Zaha being our best player - before the New Year yes, since then, no. IMHO both Eze (especially in a central role) and Benteke have performed better than Wilf as attacking players this calendar year. IMO Zaha has made far too many poor decisions in recent months through being either selfish or too clever when a quick lay-off or cross could have reaped rewards for the team.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
ambrose7 makes a good point though, in that the last 6 months he hasn't been performing that well and really hasn't been our best player. At the end of the season Eze was starting to show more of an influence while Wilf just repeatedly ran down blind alleys, lost possession and got frustrated. It was also noticeable that teams stopped doubling up on him like they used to. Personally, in an ideal world, he'll change his mind with a new manager and commit the rest of his days to us. I never doubt his effort, but when he isn't happy it really does seem to show in his performances. If he isn't committed to us though then I want him to go as for me personally I don't want a player who believes he is being held against his will.
Edited by doombear (26 May 2021 3.20pm)
|
|
|
Athletico Madrid
|
|
|
Bogota Juniors, Perth Glory, Celtic, PSG, Ajax, Monaco, AC Milan, Everton, Spurs.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.