You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Eng V Scot
November 22 2026 7.22pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Eng V Scot


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Pete53 Flag Hassocks 19 Jun 21 9.19am

I know these "domestic" internationals can be tough affairs, but, in the end, if we can't beat Scotland then our chances of progressing much beyond the round of 16 look slim.

We looked uninspired and lacking the imagination to breakdown the Scot's defence.

Harry Kane looks worryingly out of form - going through a Benteke period?

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 19 Jun 21 9.23am

Originally posted by Pete53

I know these "domestic" internationals can be tough affairs, but, in the end, if we can't beat Scotland then our chances of progressing much beyond the round of 16 look slim.

We looked uninspired and lacking the imagination to breakdown the Scot's defence.

Harry Kane looks worryingly out of form - going through a Benteke period?

I know what you mean but in reality not beating Scotland may actually give us a better chance of doing just that!

Topping the group we'd face Fra/Por/Ger but finish second and we'd likely play Sweden.

... but I'm just searching for positives after a poor performance.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Jun 21 9.25am

Originally posted by Pete53

I know these "domestic" internationals can be tough affairs, but, in the end, if we can't beat Scotland then our chances of progressing much beyond the round of 16 look slim.

We looked uninspired and lacking the imagination to breakdown the Scot's defence.

Harry Kane looks worryingly out of form - going through a Benteke period?

Yup you have to be able to break down a defensive team like Scotland. I think Croatia will win because the Scots have no choice now they have to attack which will suit Croatia.

As for Kane is he injured he lacked pace? Or maybe its the transfer speculation that is getting to him.

Either way I would drop him for the next game and play the Everton lad.

We seem to have quite a few of our key players out of sorts at the moment, Kane, Rashford, Sterling even Foden seems a bit iffy.

 


One more point

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 19 Jun 21 9.27am

Originally posted by Pete53

Harry Kane looks worryingly out of form - going through a Benteke period?

Not so much out of form, just over hyped and over rated (IMHO).

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Jun 21 9.28am

Originally posted by samprior

I know what you mean but in reality not beating Scotland may actually give us a better chance of doing just that!

Topping the group we'd face Fra/Por/Ger but finish second and we'd likely play Sweden.

... but I'm just searching for positives after a poor performance.

If we were Germany or Brazil I could believe it's a cunning plan however we don't seem to be able to score more than 1 goal at tournament football so I doubt it.

Let's hope we do an Italy and get better as the tournament progresses.

 


One more point

daven Flag Hailsham 19 Jun 21 9.38am

What is now called "game management" , where you can hold on to a lead or even a draw if it is beneficial, also applies to "group management" which countries like Italy and Germany are masters of.
In the past we have been naive of these tactics and been knocked out early in competitions and wondered how other countries got further than us.
I was hoping for a draw last night because it keeps us in second place and a draw in our last game makes sure that we finish second and a next game against Sweden,Slovakia or Spain, and opposed to finishing first and having possibly France or Portugal next.
I prefer to give Southgate the benefit of doubt that he knows how to get us as far in the tournament as possible.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Jun 21 9.45am

I'm with sampior on this.

No goal conceded no effort expended no injuries
and strolling to 2nd place.

Anyone who believes Southgate makes all the decisions in the current set up is dillusional. There is a tech heavy team who have planned every minutae for months to one purpose. Another "lacklustre" draw next week would fulfil stage one of the plan.

Perhaps I am just a cynic and we really are as sh1t as we looked last night?

 

Leecpfc Flag Praying for love in a lapdance... 19 Jun 21 10.01am

It was like watching a Palace match.

 


Raised on a diet of broken biscuits

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Jun 21 10.34am

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Not so much out of form, just over hyped and over rated (IMHO).

Agreed.

A world class player can still perform when the side isn't set up for him.

Kane is very good but like most England players he's over hyped.

And Helmut45 made some excellent observations on Southgate. He is there because he's a 'yes' man, not because he's the best English manager available.

Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Jun 2021 10.39am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 19 Jun 21 11.06am

Originally posted by silvertop

I'm with sampior on this.

No goal conceded no effort expended no injuries
and strolling to 2nd place.

Anyone who believes Southgate makes all the decisions in the current set up is dillusional. There is a tech heavy team who have planned every minutae for months to one purpose. Another "lacklustre" draw next week would fulfil stage one of the plan.

Perhaps I am just a cynic and we really are as sh1t as we looked last night?

We’re not sh1t but we are not as good as we think. If we then constrain the team by playing negative football, which only serves to exploit the weaknesses of the players you have - rather than their strengths - then you get what we got.

His tactics are those you would use to avoid relegation whereas with the players we have they should have been to win the prize. The evidence to support that is within our own club. It’s the same tactics, almost a mirror image. We beat those below us and lose to those above (generally) and survive. It’s why Wilf gets so frustrated - he’s not a bloody defender and wants to bomb forward and attack ( so Foden, Sterling, Sancho etc). But there’s nothing there so we go backwards. We were playing a team ranked 40 places below us and he was trying to nick a goal. I suspect he was so scared of losing to Scotland he gave them the level of respect he would give Germany. If he does that in the knockout stages - we’re toast. God knows what he said to the players to elicit that performance.

Anyone really think Pep or Klopp, with that group of players, would have set them up like that? Of course not. Southgates purely a survival manager and not a winner. (And that survival instinct includes his own job in my view).


Edited by Helmet46 (19 Jun 2021 11.35am)

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 19 Jun 21 11.08am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Agreed.

A world class player can still perform when the side isn't set up for him.

Kane is very good but like most England players he's over hyped.

And Helmut45 made some excellent observations on Southgate. He is there because he's a 'yes' man, not because he's the best English manager available.

Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Jun 2021 10.39am)

Kane looked like he was playing injured.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Jun 21 11.16am

Originally posted by sickboy

Kane looked like he was playing injured.

He certainly looked static didn't he.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

IMilburn Flag Chiang Rai / Rayong 19 Jun 21 11.23am

Exactly what I found myself thinking.

Two stodgy holding midfielders, full backs contributing nothing going forward, front three replicating Townsend (Foden), Benteke (Kane) and Zaha (Sterling), creative midfielder (Eze / Mount) having no options ahead of him, baled out as necessary by the keeper and centre backs, and no plan B.


Originally posted by Leecpfc

It was like watching a Palace match.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 19 Jun 21 11.38am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

He certainly looked static didn't he.

In those tactics he was to England what Benteke is to us.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Jun 21 11.39am

Originally posted by Helmet46

We’re not sh1t but we are not as good as we think. If we then constrain the team by playing negative football, which only serves to exploit the weaknesses of the players you have - rather than their strengths - then you get what we got.

His tactics are those you would use to avoid relegation whereas with the players we have they should have been to win the prize. The evidence to support that is within our own club. It’s the same tactics, almost a mirror image. We beat those below us and lose to those above (generally) and survive. It’s why Wilf gets so frustrated - he’s not a bloody defender and wants to bomb forward and attack ( so Foden, Sterling, Sancho etc). But there’s nothing there so we go backwards. We were playing a team ranked 40 places below us. He was trying to nick a goal. If he does that in the knockout stages - we’re toast.

Anyone really think Pep or Klopp, with that group of players, would have set them up like that? Of course not. Southgates purely a survival manager and not a winner. (And that survival instinct includes his own job in my view).


Edited by Helmet46 (19 Jun 2021 11.31am)

Southgate's club managerial record (Middlesbrough) :

2006-07 : 12th in PL
2007-08 : 13th in PL
2008-09 : 19th in PL Relegated
2009-10 : Sacked after 13 games with Middlesbrough in 4th place.

U21s :
Finished bottom of the group in the 2015 European Championship Finals.


Edited by Willo (19 Jun 2021 11.39am)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 Jun 21 12.02pm

Originally posted by Leecpfc

It was like watching a Palace match.

Scotland were like us in the Championship, England just like the Hodgson version.

 


Red and Blue Army!

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 19 Jun 21 12.11pm

Not about the game or players/manager, but connected because of fans & the *ahem*unbiased reporting of the 'Telegraph' . . .

[Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 19 Jun 21 12.27pm

Originally posted by Willo

Southgate's club managerial record (Middlesbrough) :

2006-07 : 12th in PL
2007-08 : 13th in PL
2008-09 : 19th in PL Relegated
2009-10 : Sacked after 13 games with Middlesbrough in 4th place.

U21s :
Finished bottom of the group in the 2015 European Championship Finals.


Edited by Willo (19 Jun 2021 11.39am)

Which rather proves my point. Those that claim it was Freedmans team that took us up can discount Southgate finishing 12th as you could argue that’s someone else’s team. When he put his own stamp on it he finished 13th and then got relegated.
He was doing OK (ish - 4th) in the championship but that’s his level, I reckon, but they sacked him.
We do not have a tactical footballing genius in charge. This bloke is not the messiah.

Edited by Helmet46 (19 Jun 2021 12.35pm)

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 19 Jun 21 12.50pm

The Scots reacted like they’d won the tournament, this is as good as they get and their best performance. England were poor and still comfortably got a point.

Enjoy your point Scotland, but you’ll still be going home early, maybe see you in another 23 years at a major tournament

 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Jun 21 12.59pm


An England team manager just gets a few days to weeks with players the position is less about their club manager abilities with players and more about their understanding of players and how they fit the tactics.

I agree with the criticisms of Southgate but personally I think you could take most managers and give them the England job and it would be the same result.

It's more about the number of quality players available for England and how they fit the tactics used. I certainly would like to think a better tactical manager would do better with this particular set of players but hey ho.

When the Premiership was started we were told many times that it would improve the England team....errr...it didn't.

In my view, until they set the rules to increase the number of England qualified players in Premiership squads things won't change.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Eng V Scot