This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The issue is who is deciding what people can say online. If they are the same kind of people who support wokeism, then we must resist them at all costs. It's a two pronged thing in a way as the law of the day applies in any given territory, but also social media outlets have their own terms and conditions too. I think people left and right ultimately both fall into a trap of wanting the government to take the reins thinking that will be better somehow. On the left due to the emphasis on hate speech (whatever our view of that), and on the right wanting top down rules imposed on social media due to their own political biases. Both of these desires for government action can have aspects to them that are well intentioned (as well as the opposite), but I see them all as leading to a place where the government of the day becomes so involved across the board that it can always call the shots in one foul swoop. It leads to more of a beady eye on the law abiding and building profiles on them that can be used or exploited, politically, socially and otherwise. The behaviour of a few hateful individuals, or biased tech companies is rather convenient in getting them to this place. It may be difficult for alternative platforms to gain support, advertising, or stay online, but if there is a big enough audience for something and talented people behind it, it will eventually get a footing, and this is much preferable than relying on the government for anything. I think that's generally an approach that comes back to bite people no matter their politics. As for the most mainstream platforms such as FB, Twitter and so on, I'd rather them put algorithms in place that can flag accounts that clearly go too far in terms of targetting individuals, so that it never sees the light or day to begin with. It can't be an impossibility to achieve that, and where they fail to do so, it inevitiably becomes highlighted in such a way that magnifies how widespread it is and that isn't really useful to them or us.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by mezzer
I heard an MP at PMQs today say that 105 accounts were identified as posting racist abuse and only 6 had been taken down. Maybe he was only talking about certain accounts so I may have got this wildly wrong, but I'd imagined it was literally in the thousands of racist posts. In a population of 60 million (say), 105 accounts = 0.000175% of the population. Let's say it was 1000 times more than that, it still equates to around 99.9% of the population as being against racist posts.
I would wager that the majority of these racist posts were from abroad, and that most of them aren't even real people stating their true opinion. It's an easy way for foreign governments and individuals to disrupt. Where it is people in this country, most of them seem so dim that they've practically got their family photo album attached to their account, rather than any attempt to stay anonymous. No doubt it's not much fun if you're the targetted individual, so I can well understand them wanting action taken or systems put in place to stop these comments even appearing, but you're right to also highlight the other side of the coin, that 99.9%+ would never dream of posting racist abuse at anyone, and have zero respect for those doing so.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
I would wager that the majority of these racist posts were from abroad, and that most of them aren't even real people stating their true opinion. It's an easy way for foreign governments and individuals to disrupt. Where it is people in this country, most of them seem so dim that they've practically got their family photo album attached to their account, rather than any attempt to stay anonymous. No doubt it's not much fun if you're the targetted individual, so I can well understand them wanting action taken or systems put in place to stop these comments even appearing, but you're right to also highlight the other side of the coin, that 99.9%+ would never dream of posting racist abuse at anyone, and have zero respect for those doing so. This has been doing the rounds - it is apparently the same source that is used by the PFA:-
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
This has been doing the rounds - it is apparently the same source that is used by the PFA:- Has that been verified Becky? I went on the SEMrush website and there's no sign of it.
Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by becky
This has been doing the rounds - it is apparently the same source that is used by the PFA:- Good spot. I doubt it's too far off the mark.. and in some territories making such statements probably isn't against the law, so calls for accounts here to linked to IDs for the sake of the handful of idiots does seem very OTT and something unlikely to change anything. Better to make changes to algorithms, combined with investigating the few actual UK cases using existing powers, rather than viewing all UK users as potential racists in the making who need to hand over their papers.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mezzer
Has that been verified Becky? I went on the SEMrush website and there's no sign of it. I don'tknow (to be honest), but a number of US people were all pointing out that India as 'an Area 9' (whatever that is!) is one of the main centres for bots - which could account for the figures there
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
I don'tknow (to be honest), but a number of US people were all pointing out that India as 'an Area 9' (whatever that is!) is one of the main centres for bots - which could account for the figures there
s***, all anybody has to do is download the Opera browser and switch it to the VPN option and they can pretend to be posting from abroad. Hence why social media is ultimately froth. And should be treated accordingly.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by madcap_v2
I have no issue with linking my ID to my social media accounts, I had to do so to verify my twitter account. Saw something this morning where a female football fan was repeatedly targeted by someone on instagram, who when blocked, would just set up another account. Even going as far as telling her he watches her do the daily school run to validify his threats. The police weren't interested. If there is a reporting process for abuse on social media, there should be a way for proper and appropriate punishment depending on the situation. No, no, no. Anonymity protects people from those that wish to damage them for their opinions. A handful of morons is not an excuse for controlling thought, which is what it would surely become.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
No, no, no. Anonymity protects people from those that wish to damage them for their opinions. A handful of morons is not an excuse for controlling thought, which is what it would surely become. Agree, I think there are lots of valid reasons to want to be anonymous online - hell, isn’t that half the fun for a lot of people. I think the solution has to be in algorithms and programming to flag abuse - they managed it with all the fake news around Covid and it’s almost unbelievable the speed they take down videos posted without consent - they have the capacity to monitor abuse far better than they do.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by madcap_v2
I have no issue with linking my ID to my social media accounts, I had to do so to verify my twitter account. Saw something this morning where a female football fan was repeatedly targeted by someone on instagram, who when blocked, would just set up another account. Even going as far as telling her he watches her do the daily school run to validify his threats. The police weren't interested. If there is a reporting process for abuse on social media, there should be a way for proper and appropriate punishment depending on the situation.
Edited by BlueJay (15 Jul 2021 4.39pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
I don't use social media and sorry if what I am about to say is a repeat of another post. I'm glad you aren't in charge.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
I don't use social media and sorry if what I am about to say is a repeat of another post. What of whistleblowers and other people who put themselves at significant risk by speaking publicly. Do you not think that in certain situations or societies being able to anonymously shine a light on abuses from government or military holds value for instance, and has to be weighed up against this? Some abuse these platforms, but there are already are laws in place to deal with this. The irony is that in the bigger worldwide picture it is likely persecuted minorities and the downtrodden that benefit from anonymity. Entertaining the idea of wiping that out due to a few loudmouth d!ickheads is unfortunate. People are falling into a trap just because it relates to something that they agree with in the moment. Governments change over time, and the more you readily hand over to them in terms of your liberties the quicker you're eventually going to find yourself in a 'social credits' type situation like China where you're rated and graded as a human being based on how much you adhere to whatever criteria is set in the moment. And we know what abuses occur in China, and how terrified people are of publicly speaking out. What may start with something apparently well intentioned rarely ends there. I assume people require a telephone number and the like to sign up to Twitter anyway, so the vast majority aren't anonymous in any significant sense as it is. Hence why action has already been taken against several already. I would wager that few blurting out racist nonsense are tech savy cerebral types masking their every step along the way. They're idiots with keyboards. Edited by BlueJay (15 Jul 2021 4.42pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
No, no, no. Anonymity protects people from those that wish to damage them for their opinions. A handful of morons is not an excuse for controlling thought, which is what it would surely become. One no would suffice. Anonymity when it comes to expressing opinions, sure, I don't think anyone would need an ID trail for opinions, abuse and threats, yes, there should be a trail to the authorities and some accountability there.
La la la your mum |
|
|
Originally posted by madcap_v2
One no would suffice. Anonymity when it comes to expressing opinions, sure, I don't think anyone would need an ID trail for opinions, abuse and threats, yes, there should be a trail to the authorities and some accountability there. How would you differentiate? To paraphrase a cliche: One man's opinion is another's abuse.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'm with Bluejay on this. While there is an issue with anonymity on the net in terms of abuse, if you think about it giving away your identity in all circumstances leads to huge centralised power and while you and I might agree with it in some aspects....no anonymity on the Internet will and can be hugely abused by the state and corporations. We have been moving towards a social credit system for sometime now and people should know what they are sleep walking into. Once you give the state more power it's a lot harder to remove it. There are many instances where anonymity is a good thing: - You live in a police state and want to express your dissatisfaction with the regime. Etc.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
How would you differentiate? To paraphrase a cliche: One man's opinion is another's abuse. "You're not very good at football" - opinion I think it's pretty easy to differentiate?
La la la your mum |
|
|
Originally posted by madcap_v2
"You're not very good at football" - opinion I think it's pretty easy to differentiate? Sure but I saw a media article the other the police are investigating a post which said "why don't you go back to your own country". * Not exact words but close enough. From what I could see it was abusive but no swearing or skin colour mentioned, how is that a crime?
One more point |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.