You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team v Charlton
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team v Charlton


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Pete53 Flag Hassocks 28 Jul 21 10.11am

Okay it was only a friendly but good players should have good habits.

Whatever the context of a match you expect players to be able to display the fundamentals of the game - ball control, holding possession, accurate passing, intelligent positioning etc.

I did miss the first 30 minutes (thinking it started at 7:30) but from what I did witness, I didn't see a great deal of those qualities last night.

Okay there were a lot of youngsters playing, but, these games are a great chance for them to demonstrate if they genuinely have the potential to make the breakthrough into the senior side. Likewise, our established players should be putting down a marker and showing PV they deserve a place in the starting line-up.

It was interesting to listen to Mark Bright's comments during the game on Palace TV. At times he seemed less than impressed with what he was seeing.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 28 Jul 21 10.16am

Was that Alfie Matthew’s on the bench as I was under the impression he’d been released and where was Omiliabu?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Jul 21 10.26am

Originally posted by Helmet46

Was that Alfie Matthew’s on the bench as I was under the impression he’d been released and where was Omiliabu?


No, it was the new 3rd keeper Matthews. No idea where Omilabu was.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 28 Jul 21 11.07am

Originally posted by doombear


No, it was the new 3rd keeper Matthews. No idea where Omilabu was.

The U23's are playing Bromley away on Sat, same time we play Reading, think Omilabu will be involved at Bromley

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Den1923 Flag 28 Jul 21 11.49am

I think the worrying thing is here we are just 17 days away from our first PL fixture and we do not have a first team squad that can survive in the PL. I know friendly games do not matter in terms of results but it is worrying that we are still making mistakes at the back and we still do not have a midfield dynamo or a proven striker who can score on a regular basis at PL standard. Whilst I want to be optimistic on our future, however, at the current point in time it does look so good and is of
great concern!

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 28 Jul 21 11.57am

It’s not all that bad surely.

Benteke and Zaha were our most important forwards last season and they remain at the club.

We’ve potentially replaced a 35 and 34 year old centre back pair with two young talented players while allowing one that has been a sponge on the finances for far too long to leave.

Mitchell has replaced PVA and Jairo seems capable of providing cover as well as Schlupp.

In centre mid we have lost just one fringe player. If we replace him with a better younger player we will be stronger than last season.

Probs need Clyne to sign a 12 month deal. Sign a centre mid and a forward…on top of this Andersen signing.

 

glaziermart Flag 28 Jul 21 12.01pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I think the worrying thing is here we are just 17 days away from our first PL fixture and we do not have a first team squad that can survive in the PL. I know friendly games do not matter in terms of results but it is worrying that we are still making mistakes at the back and we still do not have a midfield dynamo or a proven striker who can score on a regular basis at PL standard. Whilst I want to be optimistic on our future, however, at the current point in time it does look so good and is of
great concern!


What a load of garbage! How many regulars were missing last night??? Benteke, Zaha, Olise, Eze, Ward, Cahill (resigned contract soon), McArthur (only played last 30 mins), Schlupp (only played last 30 mins), Anderson (soon to be signed) Gallagher (likely loan) etc. We are easily good enough when we have a full team out

 

Buckspalace Flag Thornborough 28 Jul 21 12.06pm

Do you think Cahill is going to sign then?

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 28 Jul 21 12.07pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I think the worrying thing is here we are just 17 days away from our first PL fixture and we do not have a first team squad that can survive in the PL. I know friendly games do not matter in terms of results but it is worrying that we are still making mistakes at the back and we still do not have a midfield dynamo or a proven striker who can score on a regular basis at PL standard. Whilst I want to be optimistic on our future, however, at the current point in time it does look so good and is of
great concern!

Don't worry I'm sure there's quite a few sets of fans of different clubs who are thinking the same.

Still more than a month of the transfer window left and I feel we've made a decent start in what has been a slow start for many. We could have a couple more in by next week.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 28 Jul 21 12.13pm

Fine to disagree with someone but not necessary to call their comments "garbage". Is a bit of courtesy too much to ask for?

Originally posted by glaziermart

What a load of garbage! How many regulars were missing last night??? Benteke, Zaha, Olise, Eze, Ward, Cahill (resigned contract soon), McArthur (only played last 30 mins), Schlupp (only played last 30 mins), Anderson (soon to be signed) Gallagher (likely loan) etc. We are easily good enough when we have a full team out

Edited by Pete53 (28 Jul 2021 12.14pm)

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 28 Jul 21 12.22pm

Originally posted by Buckspalace

Do you think Cahill is going to sign then?

This currently seems doubtful to me so I’m judging the squad as if he wasn’t going to stay.

Far from being concerned about the squad…I’d be more concerned about the manager.

 

aashman12 Flag 28 Jul 21 12.22pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I think the worrying thing is here we are just 17 days away from our first PL fixture and we do not have a first team squad that can survive in the PL. I know friendly games do not matter in terms of results but it is worrying that we are still making mistakes at the back and we still do not have a midfield dynamo or a proven striker who can score on a regular basis at PL standard. Whilst I want to be optimistic on our future, however, at the current point in time it does look so good and is of
great concern!

It's the close of the window that we need to look at more,

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 28 Jul 21 12.24pm

Originally posted by glaziermart


What a load of garbage! How many regulars were missing last night??? Benteke, Zaha, Olise, Eze, Ward, Cahill (resigned contract soon), McArthur (only played last 30 mins), Schlupp (only played last 30 mins), Anderson (soon to be signed) Gallagher (likely loan) etc. We are easily good enough when we have a full team out

While I agree the bed-wetters are overreacting based on a pre-season, I am not sure we will ever see Cahill in our colours again (unless he signs for Barcelona).

Also, while not based on last night, I am not sure they are wholly wrong. An inexperienced coach and un-gelled team will take a while to adjust and the early games will prove difficult for the low of patience.

But we should be fine by next May.

 

Den1923 Flag 28 Jul 21 12.35pm

Originally posted by glaziermart


What a load of garbage! How many regulars were missing last night??? Benteke, Zaha, Olise, Eze, Ward, Cahill (resigned contract soon), McArthur (only played last 30 mins), Schlupp (only played last 30 mins), Anderson (soon to be signed) Gallagher (likely loan) etc. We are easily good enough when we have a full team out

Let's wait and see, Eze will not be back this side of Christmas, Zaha heart is elsewhere and he was certainly not performing at his best last season, Cahill, like it or not is past his best and has not signed as yet, Gallagher and Anderson have not been signed at time of writing therefore its all just speculation at present and Benteke is not a modern day striker and is not capable of scoring enough goals in the PL to make us a threat and of course there is Ferguson who I have yet to see in a Palace shirt and on top of that we have an unproven Manager in PL and a new squad, It all points to very high risk as far as I can see!

 

Chubskip Flag 28 Jul 21 12.42pm

We still require at least one if not two pacey defensive midfielders. We still get caught by the ball over the top and current midfielders seem to lack the pace to cover this
No matter who we have to come in or currently play. Need a Southgate style player to sit on front of the defence.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Jul 21 12.49pm

Originally posted by silvertop

While I agree the bed-wetters are overreacting based on a pre-season, I am not sure we will ever see Cahill in our colours again (unless he signs for Barcelona).

Also, while not based on last night, I am not sure they are wholly wrong. An inexperienced coach and un-gelled team will take a while to adjust and the early games will prove difficult for the low of patience.

But we should be fine by next May.


Agreed and I'm Doombear! Much will depend on what happens in the rest of this transfer window. Assuming Andersen is a 'done deal' bar the actual signing and photo then our minimum need IMO is:
- a CM
- one wide player
- a striker

and ideally another CB and a LB
We have 2 PL loans we could go for and other foreign loans as well and at least one more purchase after Andersen (we weren't chasing Lookman or Madueke as loans as far as I am aware so presumably there is some money for a wide player).

All doable IMO and we have the time. Also we don't know who else Dougie may have lined up when planning this window.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 28 Jul 21 1.00pm

Originally posted by glaziermart


What a load of garbage! How many regulars were missing last night??? Benteke, Zaha, Olise, Eze, Ward, Cahill (resigned contract soon), McArthur (only played last 30 mins), Schlupp (only played last 30 mins), Anderson (soon to be signed) Gallagher (likely loan) etc. We are easily good enough when we have a full team out

lots of ifs and buts in your above list.

Eze will be out until the New Year i believe so pretty pointless listing him at the moment.

Clearly it was a friendly but the squad is looking a bit thread bare and that's a reasonable comment to make

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 28 Jul 21 1.27pm

With our very tough early run of fixtures, I wonder if it might be better to have a team that is a bit of work in progress, than if we went into the season with our number one all transfers completed squad - then got turned over anyway by Chelsea Man City & Co

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 28 Jul 21 2.38pm

Originally posted by doombear


Agreed and I'm Doombear! Much will depend on what happens in the rest of this transfer window. Assuming Andersen is a 'done deal' bar the actual signing and photo then our minimum need IMO is:
- a CM
- one wide player
- a striker

and ideally another CB and a LB
We have 2 PL loans we could go for and other foreign loans as well and at least one more purchase after Andersen (we weren't chasing Lookman or Madueke as loans as far as I am aware so presumably there is some money for a wide player).

All doable IMO and we have the time. Also we don't know who else Dougie may have lined up when planning this window.

RB too?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Jul 21 2.51pm

Originally posted by silvertop

RB too?


I suppose I'm assuming Clyne will sign and that the club will want to wait to see if Fergusson will be ready in the Autumn. If Clyne doesn't sign then yes another RB will be needed.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team v Charlton