You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from yesterday's game
November 16 2026 4.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Back from yesterday's game


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
DANGERCLOSE Flag London 22 Aug 21 5.23pm

Early day's but here goes

Partnership between Andersen and Guehi looks decent

Mitch needs to do better

Ward not quick enough

Gallaher and McArthur were both excellent

Kouyate poor performance

Schlupp looked lost at times

Zaha poor performance

Big Ben needs to make runs, a bit too static

Bench, no real options

My take on things so far

We need Eze and Olise back as we lack attacking options, if mitch gets injured we don't have a replacement. We played a lot better than last week and was a bit more exciting than last season. It will take time but I personally think we will be ok.

Transfer market.

We need ST,LB,Maybe a winger but I would like JRS given opportunities. We need better options on the bench for sure, I know Tompkins can do a job but do we need another?

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 22 Aug 21 8.09pm

Agree with the vast majority of your points but feel we missed a trick as better performances from Zaha (too much hiding when the pass was on) & Benteke was the difference between winning and only drawing.
However, it is a worry that we have a goalkeeper who now wants to keep punching catchable balls and the short passing across the six yard box at goal kicks I hope is not persisted with - it didn't work too well for Arsenal at times last season !

 

Kant Flag exeter 22 Aug 21 8.39pm

Can’t really agree with this assessment, even though I’m ready to accept that I’m probably in the minority.

If Wilf had been making his debut for us yesterday we’d be lauding him. Familiarity clearly breeding contempt.

I thought Mitchell was fine given his level of experience. Yes, he wasn’t faultless, but Jimmy Mac aside I can’t think of anyone who didn’t make a mistake or two; including the newbies. Shame his honeymoon period with the critics is over. The others should enjoy it while it lasts.

And Schlupp didn’t look ‘lost’ to me. He enjoyed some effective forays on the wings, interchanging with Wilf, and was his normal direct self. I didn’t think Ayew improved things.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 23 Aug 21 6.09am

Originally posted by Kant

Can’t really agree with this assessment, even though I’m ready to accept that I’m probably in the minority.

If Wilf had been making his debut for us yesterday we’d be lauding him. Familiarity clearly breeding contempt.

I thought Mitchell was fine given his level of experience. Yes, he wasn’t faultless, but Jimmy Mac aside I can’t think of anyone who didn’t make a mistake or two; including the newbies. Shame his honeymoon period with the critics is over. The others should enjoy it while it lasts.

And Schlupp didn’t look ‘lost’ to me. He enjoyed some effective forays on the wings, interchanging with Wilf, and was his normal direct self. I didn’t think Ayew improved things.

Wow, you're right so funny how differently people can see things. Disagree with most of your points and agree pretty much entirely with the OP.

Wilf was terrible. If he was on debut, I'd be saying get rid. Mitchell was woeful. He's not the answer at LB for us. Schlupp looked like no one knows what his best position is...which is probably true.

I'd also add that Gallagher was immense. Him and Macca/Luka sitting behind Eze whets the appetite.

 

leejaneagles Flag 23 Aug 21 9.22am

There was literally a point where the Defender fouled Wilf but slipped and fell on his backside, the ball at Wilf's feet about 35 yards from goal with a defender on the floor and 2 Team Mates around him.

Referee clearly indicated advantage and Wilf stood there waving and pointing crying like a little girl to get his free kick rather than just run forward. Sick of him. Even if he had a good game to that point that's more than enough to know his attitude stinks and he isn't mentally right.

Schlupp is a good impact player but if you're going to start him it definitely needs to be in midfield running at players and having an option left and right all times. He's clearly not a winger that can bomb down the wing and create on his own.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 23 Aug 21 11.09am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

There was literally a point where the Defender fouled Wilf but slipped and fell on his backside, the ball at Wilf's feet about 35 yards from goal with a defender on the floor and 2 Team Mates around him.

Referee clearly indicated advantage and Wilf stood there waving and pointing crying like a little girl to get his free kick rather than just run forward. Sick of him. Even if he had a good game to that point that's more than enough to know his attitude stinks and he isn't mentally right.

Schlupp is a good impact player but if you're going to start him it definitely needs to be in midfield running at players and having an option left and right all times. He's clearly not a winger that can bomb down the wing and create on his own.

Schlupp may be world football's one and only remaining 'inside left'.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 23 Aug 21 11.17am

Originally posted by sprites

Wow, you're right so funny how differently people can see things. Disagree with most of your points and agree pretty much entirely with the OP.

Wilf was terrible. If he was on debut, I'd be saying get rid. Mitchell was woeful. He's not the answer at LB for us. Schlupp looked like no one knows what his best position is...which is probably true.

I'd also add that Gallagher was immense. Him and Macca/Luka sitting behind Eze whets the appetite.

Absolutely agree Sprites. Zaha needs to get his head on right, but as our GOAT he gets a little extra latitude.

The 2 CBs look immense, and other than the players reading the memo about football going back to being properly a contact sport and to start beasting other players (I'm looking at you especially Benteke, and Wilf mate, just get on with it!!) and the fact that it's very much a burgeoning project, I think it looks alright.

Imagine Eze back, Olise stepping up well, maybe one more signing, Luka back... that seems alright to me.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Chubskip Flag 23 Aug 21 11.22am

I don't understand why Ayew escapes criticism? Cannot fault his effort but I really don't think he's good enough for prem league. Please prove me wrong.... I still think we need a holding midfielder, maybe Hughes could be that man and a forward coming in off the RHS. I too think we will be fine but may struggle to get points in next 4 or 5 games.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 23 Aug 21 11.24am

Originally posted by FinchleyEagle

Absolutely agree Sprites. Zaha needs to get his head on right, but as our GOAT he gets a little extra latitude.

The 2 CBs look immense, and other than the players reading the memo about football going back to being properly a contact sport and to start beasting other players (I'm looking at you especially Benteke, and Wilf mate, just get on with it!!) and the fact that it's very much a burgeoning project, I think it looks alright.

Imagine Eze back, Olise stepping up well, maybe one more signing, Luka back... that seems alright to me.

Should Luka get back into the side he might, with the greater leniency being shown by refs, complete a game without getting a yellow card!!

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 23 Aug 21 11.49am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Early day's but here goes

Partnership between Andersen and Guehi looks decent

Mitch needs to do better

Ward not quick enough

Gallaher and McArthur were both excellent

Kouyate poor performance

Schlupp looked lost at times

Zaha poor performance

Big Ben needs to make runs, a bit too static

Bench, no real options

My take on things so far

We need Eze and Olise back as we lack attacking options, if mitch gets injured we don't have a replacement. We played a lot better than last week and was a bit more exciting than last season. It will take time but I personally think we will be ok.

Transfer market.

We need ST,LB,Maybe a winger but I would like JRS given opportunities. We need better options on the bench for sure, I know Tompkins can do a job but do we need another?

Overall no more than a 6 out of 10. 1st half poor, got better in the 2nd half and could have nicked it.

I thought both full backs were ok but neither are great going forward - slows the attack down and unable or unwilling to put over an early cross.

Andersen and Guehi good although Andersen looked a little slow when dragged out to the wing.

Gallagher great 1st half but lost his way in the 2nd. Jimmy Mac solid, but disappoint in Jeff S. I still don't know his best position.

Tekkers won little in the air, looked a little disinterested (stupid offisdes etc) and missed with the one clear heading opportunity he had.

Wilf is Wilf - personally he has had performances like that for a few years now and definitely has lost a yard of pace. He needs to grow up regarding fouls, especially as the rules have been tweaked. Atkinson is a poor ref so he knew what to expect before the game (he was the ref who 'booked' Wild for a stonewall pen v Arse a couple of years ago before VAR corrected it).

One observation re defending. We still look poor at set pieces and will continue conceding too many from corners/free kicks and the 2 yard pass out from the keeper will definitely result in a goal being conceded soon (remember Sakho at Leicester)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Aug 21 2.09pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

There was literally a point where the Defender fouled Wilf but slipped and fell on his backside, the ball at Wilf's feet about 35 yards from goal with a defender on the floor and 2 Team Mates around him.

Referee clearly indicated advantage and Wilf stood there waving and pointing crying like a little girl to get his free kick rather than just run forward. Sick of him. Even if he had a good game to that point that's more than enough to know his attitude stinks and he isn't mentally right.

Schlupp is a good impact player but if you're going to start him it definitely needs to be in midfield running at players and having an option left and right all times. He's clearly not a winger that can bomb down the wing and create on his own.


This Wilf incident stuck clearly in my mind as well and confirmed to me at least that these days Wilf only cares about Wilf on the field of play and as for his team mates, they have to work for him and round him even when they are in better positions to score or assist than he is.

He desperately needs to sort his head out or get out.

Edited by doombear (23 Aug 2021 2.10pm)

 

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 23 Aug 21 4.00pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

There was literally a point where the Defender fouled Wilf but slipped and fell on his backside, the ball at Wilf's feet about 35 yards from goal with a defender on the floor and 2 Team Mates around him.

Referee clearly indicated advantage and Wilf stood there waving and pointing crying like a little girl to get his free kick rather than just run forward. Sick of him. Even if he had a good game to that point that's more than enough to know his attitude stinks and he isn't mentally right.

Schlupp is a good impact player but if you're going to start him it definitely needs to be in midfield running at players and having an option left and right all times. He's clearly not a winger that can bomb down the wing and create on his own.

Surely the reason he didn’t run forward is that the defender had wrapped both arms round his ankle to stop him doing just that. I think I might have complained at that too

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 23 Aug 21 4.18pm

Agreed, watch it again. He wanted to play, then the defender wrapped his arms around him, so our "advantage" was gone. Then saw the ref wasn't calling it and made a move to play again, only for the defender to wrap his arm around him again.

Harsh to call this as bad. Let's face it, under last year's rules, he would have gotten 4-5 fouls that weren't called this year.

Rugby vs. Basketball

Originally posted by trapperjohn

Surely the reason he didn’t run forward is that the defender had wrapped both arms round his ankle to stop him doing just that. I think I might have complained at that too

 

Aray Flag South London 23 Aug 21 4.49pm

Defence:
CBs are excellent.

Guita is a problem. I've always thought his distribution was terrible and now its a real issue. As for the constant punching...And while I'm at it - I think he had a poor game last week at Chelski.

I didn't see much wrong with Mitchell or Ward but we could do with LB cover, for sure. Reckon Clyne plays when fit.

Midfield:
Thought Kouyate's first half performance was one of the worst I've seen from him. He did get better. Gallagher put him self about - not used to seeing that from our midfield - notwithstanding Jimmy Mac's tireless work. He was my MoM. But the midfield didn't really create much.

Upfront:
Wilf has had better games but the ref had a shocker. the rugby tackle in front of the Holmesdale towards the end of the match was terrible, as was the non-advantage decision.

He's moaning too much though. Losing sympathy with the fans - alot of folk where I sit weren't impressed.

I've seen Benteke and Schlupp play better and worse. Ayew was ok for the short passage he was on the pitch. Made stuff happen.

I personally feel that for a new approach we played in places. On the train after the game I got talking to some fellow Palace fans. They were far more downbeat on the performance than I.

One made an interesting point, that we dont have the players for this new system - we're a counter attack team with players who run with the ball. Maybe he's right - we need Olise and Eze back soon either way.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Aug 21 6.22pm

Originally posted by trapperjohn

Surely the reason he didn’t run forward is that the defender had wrapped both arms round his ankle to stop him doing just that. I think I might have complained at that too


Initially, yes, but Wilf quickly broke free and had good space ahead of him to run into with players waiting for a pass and he just stood still and waited for the ref to give the foul, allowing the defender to wrap arms around him again (because as I've said several times since the game, with Wilf now, it's all about him and not the team).

Edited by doombear (23 Aug 2021 6.24pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 23 Aug 21 6.37pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

Agreed, watch it again. He wanted to play, then the defender wrapped his arms around him, so our "advantage" was gone. Then saw the ref wasn't calling it and made a move to play again, only for the defender to wrap his arm around him again.

Harsh to call this as bad. Let's face it, under last year's rules, he would have gotten 4-5 fouls that weren't called this year.

Rugby vs. Basketball

Don’t forget that the Brentford player involved had already been booked. Definitely a yellow card but Atkinson just doesn’t like Wilf

 

NE14T Flag 23 Aug 21 9.27pm

Mitch was very poor and looked like a little boy caught in the headlights with passing a particular issue.
Benteke was again slow in the leg and not making the right run.
Ward was average at best.
With the way Veira wants to play it out from the back, I think we have real problems this year with Ward and Mitch.
One of the reasons Guita looked like he might make a howler with his clearance indecision was because he didn’t want to pass it to either wide backs particularly Mitch who never asked/showed for a the ball.

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

NE14T Flag 23 Aug 21 9.41pm

Ps Zaha had an off game but we can’t expect him to be a our saviour every game.
Gallagher looks class thanks god.

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

sprites Flag Auckland 23 Aug 21 9.55pm

Originally posted by NE14T

Ps Zaha had an off game but we can’t expect him to be a our saviour every game.
Gallagher looks class thanks god.

Zaha's has an off couple of years.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Aug 21 10.06pm

Originally posted by sprites

Zaha's has an off couple of years.


I think you're being somewhat unfair to Wilf re the last 2 years. I've said my piece about his mediocre performance on Saturday (and his selfish moaning attitude).

I agree his performances two seasons ago were not anywhere near his earlier standard BUT in the first half of last season he performed well for us in most games. I accept the second half of the season was less impressive but he was injured and may have carried that injury into some of his performances.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from yesterday's game