You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Worst 5 Palace Managers (listed on Holmesdale.net)
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Worst 5 Palace Managers (listed on Holmesdale.net)


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
aashman12 Flag 23 Oct 21 9.29pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Alan Smith and Ian Dowie, and before anyone says Dowie got us promotion no he didnt, Andy Johnson got us Promotion, who was bought by Trevor Francis

So Wright got us promoted not Coppell? Utter trash.

 

davidmyboy Flag 23 Oct 21 10.10pm

For me:-
ALAN MULLERY
STEVE BRUCE
IAN DOWIE
GEORGE BURLEY
FRANK DE BOER
and as a sub although saved us TONY PULIS, Don't know what went on behind the scenes but all let us down big time

 

OldFart Flag By the sea 24 Oct 21 1.58am

Going back a bit but Cyril Spiers can be added to list. Not only bad results but bad football to go with it. More modern ones I would say that Burley and De Boer

 

beak Flag croydon 24 Oct 21 8.44am

Originally posted by chris123

According to this, Sir Steve was far more successful than I ever remember and won 565 games for us.

If he had put his boots on probably more, a sensational winger,sadly for Man.U.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 24 Oct 21 9.59am

I was really excited when we got Peter Taylor, thinking we'd be signing loads of exciting U21 players.

Instead we got his son in law.

That was possibly the most under-whelming era in my time.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 24 Oct 21 10.03am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Dario Gradi, Alan Mullery, Ron Noades (2 games), Peter Taylor, Paul Hart, George Burley all awful

Harsh.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 24 Oct 21 10.28am

Originally posted by mars

Very harsh on Pards and Colin and Ollie to some extent

I agree. Pardew was there a long time, and the end was dragged out for so long that it clouded the good stuff he did. The FA Cup final remains our highest achievement. He wasn't great, but certainly not the worst ever.

Really not a fan of Warnock, but he almost did an incredible job in 2010, and it's not his fault that he didn't.

Ollie.... hmmm. Watching the documentary again just magnified how we were promoted in spite of him. The players all but admit they defied his orders to swing the momentum back to wining ways. If he's lost the dressing room while we're in the top 6, he's got no chance in a relegation fight. Everyone liked him, everyone wanted him to do well, but it was evident that he got some glaring points wrong. The shambolic recruitment probably wasn't his fault, but wanting to invert wingers when we were destroying the division was an unnecessary tweak that almost killed us. He should be admired for admitting he wasn't up to it. It takes some brutal, selfless honesty, and I can imagine must be pretty heart-breaking to say out loud. Most managers would hang in there till the bitter end, in denial of their ineptitude, waiting for the pay-off (for example, Steve Bruce).

I can only think of Holloway and Kevin Keegan who have admitted they just weren't up to a job.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 25 Oct 21 8.50am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Yes, I remember me and my brother watching them thump Reading 3-0 near Christmas, at their gaff. We watched it in the pub together.

After that, an incredible surge to get promotion.

I actually had £20 on us to get promoted that season matched on Betfair at 990/1. Unfortunately I thought I was being clever trying to lay off as much I could on the last day of the season when it looked like we wouldn’t make the play offs. Still won about a grand for 20 quid but certainly a case of what might have been.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 25 Oct 21 8.58am

Originally posted by Qwijibo

I was really excited when we got Peter Taylor, thinking we'd be signing loads of exciting U21 players.

Instead we got his son in law.

That was possibly the most under-whelming era in my time.

Peter Taylor has a better win percentage than Roy Hodgson. Someone has to say it...

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 25 Oct 21 9.53am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Peter Taylor has a better win percentage than Roy Hodgson. Someone has to say it...

Yeah, in the Championship...

Anyway for me, in no particular order

De Boer
Venebles (2nd stint - I wasn't old enough for his first)
Burley
Holloway (harsh, but i had zero confidence in him getting us a point in that season in the Premiership)
Smith (harsh, but we were so bad in the 2000/2001 season. We should have walked that league)

 


La la la your mum

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 27 Oct 21 11.42am

Strange choice (list) of names.

People are "more" successful on that list

Pardew - took us to Fa Cup Final

Ollie - Took us to the Premiership and had the "balls" to say he was out of his depth at that level

DeBoar - who knows the real truth

Roy?? For many despite keeping us Bored!!!! and keeping us up for 4 season, many may consider him the worse manager.. for one no player development and wasted talent.. Sorloth for example, gone on to play and score, at Top Turkish, German and now top of the league Spanish team. Because he didnt want to spend most of the match defending, Roy rarely used him.. Many ex players have voiced.....

BUT we are have our own opinions lol

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 27 Oct 21 11.43am

Well done Peter!!!!


Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Peter Taylor has a better win percentage than Roy Hodgson. Someone has to say it...

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 27 Oct 21 11.44am

Must have been Paneful to say that, rather than Glaze over

Originally posted by Glazier#1

This is true but he was responsible for signing Terry Venables and nurturing him into a managerial role.

Than, in itself, saves him for me.

Mind you, I'll never forgive the re-branding.

I'm afraid I'm a claret and blue, Glaziers kind of a man.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 27 Oct 21 12.04pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Strange choice (list) of names.

People are "more" successful on that list

Pardew - took us to Fa Cup Final

Ollie - Took us to the Premiership and had the "balls" to say he was out of his depth at that level

DeBoar - who knows the real truth

Roy?? For many despite keeping us Bored!!!! and keeping us up for 4 season, many may consider him the worse manager.. for one no player development and wasted talent.. Sorloth for example, gone on to play and score, at Top Turkish, German and now top of the league Spanish team. Because he didnt want to spend most of the match defending, Roy rarely used him.. Many ex players have voiced.....

BUT we are have our own opinions lol

Plays for Real Sociedad on loan from RB Leipzig.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

palace99 Flag New Mills 27 Oct 21 6.31pm

Pardew is only 1 of 2 managers to get us to a FA cup final so clearly is not one of the worst.

Both Francis and Taylor were given money yet played awful football and got average results. They will be up there for me.

Poor Burley took over a depleted squad after administration, so whilst not great there were mitigations.

Mulley got rid of the youth team and played a load of ageing free transfers. He must be up there too.

At the top - Stevie Coppell??

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 27 Oct 21 6.32pm

Originally posted by palace99

Pardew is only 1 of 2 managers to get us to a FA cup final so clearly is not one of the worst.

Both Francis and Taylor were given money yet played awful football and got average results. They will be up there for me.

Poor Burley took over a depleted squad after administration, so whilst not great there were mitigations.

Mulley got rid of the youth team and played a load of ageing free transfers. He must be up there too.

At the top (as in the best!!) - Stevie Coppell??

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 27 Oct 21 7.13pm

Now we're getting somewhere Palace 99. Win percentages are meaningless without context. It's basically a question of which Palace teams punched above their weight taking all things into consideration such as resources (both human and financial), strength of the opposition in the relevant league, length of time the manager was in charge etc.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 28 Oct 21 8.00pm

Aye

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Must have been Paneful to say that, rather than Glaze over

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 29 Oct 21 1.04pm

In my lifetime;

Allison - great cup run and rebranding but two consecutive relegations and blew the third divison. Also the John Jackson episode slightly before my time sounds like lunacy.

Gradi - no explanation needed

Mullery - ditto

De Boer - despite the terrible results and shambolic performances the things that still stick in my head are a vid of him doing one armed press ups in front of the players and freezing out Joel Ward. What a tit.

Burley - no explanation needed.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (29 Oct 2021 1.10pm)

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 29 Oct 21 6.26pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

In my lifetime;

Allison - great cup run and rebranding but two consecutive relegations and blew the third divison. Also the John Jackson episode slightly before my time sounds like lunacy.

Gradi - no explanation needed

Mullery - ditto

De Boer - despite the terrible results and shambolic performances the things that still stick in my head are a vid of him doing one armed press ups in front of the players and freezing out Joel Ward. What a tit.

Burley - no explanation needed.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (29 Oct 2021 1.10pm)

Despite the star signing of Andy Dorman, Burley had a terrible squad.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Worst 5 Palace Managers (listed on Holmesdale.net)