You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Leeds
November 16 2026 4.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team for Leeds


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 29 Nov 21 12.19pm

Guaita in goal, of course. Sorry!

Originally posted by KevW


This ^^^^

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 29 Nov 21 12.21pm

I really hope we see something different centrally.

If we want to play how we have been of late we cannot have a CM with Luka and CK. Neither are progressive enough. Surely its time to see what Hughes has to offer?

Olise might not be ready to start every game. The boy is unstoppable on the counter when he has space to run into. But might not quite know how to unpick defences that sit in.

Benteke is a bit of a conundrum for me. I think he is hard to drop as he is scoring, but his lack of movement causes us issues.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 29 Nov 21 12.49pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I really hope we see something different centrally.

If we want to play how we have been of late we cannot have a CM with Luka and CK. Neither are progressive enough. Surely its time to see what Hughes has to offer?

Olise might not be ready to start every game. The boy is unstoppable on the counter when he has space to run into. But might not quite know how to unpick defences that sit in.

Benteke is a bit of a conundrum for me. I think he is hard to drop as he is scoring, but his lack of movement causes us issues.

Agree with a lot of this. The problem with playing LM and CK is that it makes it very easy for teams to defend against us. They can cede possession and let us have the ball 70% of the time knowing that we're not a threat because we have no one in the middle of the park except Gallagher who can unlock them and they can pretty much assign two men to worry about him because there's no other threat. Yes, I think it's high time we saw what Hughes has to offer but even more, I think it's time we saw what Olise has to offer in his preferred (and correct) position in central midfield. Whether starting or off the bench, I'd like to see both given chances in that role over the next few games.

You raised another point that I think is important about Olise but it applies more generally: "The boy is unstoppable on the counter when he has space to run into." I noticed both at Burnley and on Saturday, and it's a small detail, but our playing of the simple pass is, more often than not, absolutely f***ing horrible. Even though in both games we've had an enormous amount of possession (which far too often we've used to crab the ball sideways across the back four rather than forwards into attack), our crab-passing is way below standard. Far too often we play the ball either to someone's feet or, worse, slightly behind them so they're either forced to take the ball facing our own goal or to control it, turn and then having to look up to see who's available. It's a mystery to me why these simple passes can't be played into space ahead of the player so he can run onto the ball and is moving in the right direction when gets it. There's no point playing possession football if you don't know what to do with the ball. It's a small but important detail.

I don't have a conundrum about Benteke. As with Ayew, I think he gets an unreasonable amount of stick here. He's playing well (by his own recent standards), scoring goals, and seems to have his confidence back. The biggest problem I have him with at the moment is at the other end of the pitch; his defending of set-pieces is absolutely f***ing terrible. He doesn't seem to realise that marking doesn't involve just standing next to someone when the ball is played; you actually have to track them and defend the ball when it comes in.

More importantly, I also think we still don't use Benteke properly. Even if he's a bit of a statue, in the air he's an extremely dangerous one and we seem not make it a priority to play whipped crosses into the six yard box when we've got one of the best headers of the ball in the PL waiting there. That mystifies me. If I see another floaty cross, I think I'm going to self-immolate and while I'm on the subject, what's with the short-corners? I've never understood why you'd f*** around with "clever" movement and short passes before you cross the ball (yes, I know the idea is to pull defenders out of position but the risk of doing so is that you never get the cross in at all) when you have a Benteke in the middle who's capable of getting onto anything. When we have a corner, just fizz the bloody ball towards the penalty spot and Benteke will get onto his fair share. And if he doesn't, at least it'll create some danger in the box. I'd rather lose the ball there than out by the corner flag where there's no chance of scoring.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Painter Flag Croydon 29 Nov 21 1.40pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Agree with a lot of this. The problem with playing LM and CK is that it makes it very easy for teams to defend against us. They can cede possession and let us have the ball 70% of the time knowing that we're not a threat because we have no one in the middle of the park except Gallagher who can unlock them and they can pretty much assign two men to worry about him because there's no other threat. Yes, I think it's high time we saw what Hughes has to offer but even more, I think it's time we saw what Olise has to offer in his preferred (and correct) position in central midfield. Whether starting or off the bench, I'd like to see both given chances in that role over the next few games.

You raised another point that I think is important about Olise but it applies more generally: "The boy is unstoppable on the counter when he has space to run into." I noticed both at Burnley and on Saturday, and it's a small detail, but our playing of the simple pass is, more often than not, absolutely f***ing horrible. Even though in both games we've had an enormous amount of possession (which far too often we've used to crab the ball sideways across the back four rather than forwards into attack), our crab-passing is way below standard. Far too often we play the ball either to someone's feet or, worse, slightly behind them so they're either forced to take the ball facing our own goal or to control it, turn and then having to look up to see who's available. It's a mystery to me why these simple passes can't be played into space ahead of the player so he can run onto the ball and is moving in the right direction when gets it. There's no point playing possession football if you don't know what to do with the ball. It's a small but important detail.

I don't have a conundrum about Benteke. As with Ayew, I think he gets an unreasonable amount of stick here. He's playing well (by his own recent standards), scoring goals, and seems to have his confidence back. The biggest problem I have him with at the moment is at the other end of the pitch; his defending of set-pieces is absolutely f***ing terrible. He doesn't seem to realise that marking doesn't involve just standing next to someone when the ball is played; you actually have to track them and defend the ball when it comes in.

More importantly, I also think we still don't use Benteke properly. Even if he's a bit of a statue, in the air he's an extremely dangerous one and we seem not make it a priority to play whipped crosses into the six yard box when we've got one of the best headers of the ball in the PL waiting there. That mystifies me. If I see another floaty cross, I think I'm going to self-immolate and while I'm on the subject, what's with the short-corners? I've never understood why you'd f*** around with "clever" movement and short passes before you cross the ball (yes, I know the idea is to pull defenders out of position but the risk of doing so is that you never get the cross in at all) when you have a Benteke in the middle who's capable of getting onto anything. When we have a corner, just fizz the bloody ball towards the penalty spot and Benteke will get onto his fair share. And if he doesn't, at least it'll create some danger in the box. I'd rather lose the ball there than out by the corner flag where there's no chance of scoring.

A considered post.

I think Benteke is told to defend an area rather than man mark someone, generally around the near post.

 

The Dolphin Flag 29 Nov 21 1.41pm

Guaita

Ward
Tomkins - Anderson is not fit still apparently
Guehi
Mitchell

Ayew
Gallagher
Kouyate
Schlupp

Zaha
Edouarde

Edited by The Dolphin (29 Nov 2021 1.41pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 29 Nov 21 2.01pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Agree with a lot of this. The problem with playing LM and CK is that it makes it very easy for teams to defend against us. They can cede possession and let us have the ball 70% of the time knowing that we're not a threat because we have no one in the middle of the park except Gallagher who can unlock them and they can pretty much assign two men to worry about him because there's no other threat. Yes, I think it's high time we saw what Hughes has to offer but even more, I think it's time we saw what Olise has to offer in his preferred (and correct) position in central midfield. Whether starting or off the bench, I'd like to see both given chances in that role over the next few games.

You raised another point that I think is important about Olise but it applies more generally: "The boy is unstoppable on the counter when he has space to run into." I noticed both at Burnley and on Saturday, and it's a small detail, but our playing of the simple pass is, more often than not, absolutely f***ing horrible. Even though in both games we've had an enormous amount of possession (which far too often we've used to crab the ball sideways across the back four rather than forwards into attack), our crab-passing is way below standard. Far too often we play the ball either to someone's feet or, worse, slightly behind them so they're either forced to take the ball facing our own goal or to control it, turn and then having to look up to see who's available. It's a mystery to me why these simple passes can't be played into space ahead of the player so he can run onto the ball and is moving in the right direction when gets it. There's no point playing possession football if you don't know what to do with the ball. It's a small but important detail.

I don't have a conundrum about Benteke. As with Ayew, I think he gets an unreasonable amount of stick here. He's playing well (by his own recent standards), scoring goals, and seems to have his confidence back. The biggest problem I have him with at the moment is at the other end of the pitch; his defending of set-pieces is absolutely f***ing terrible. He doesn't seem to realise that marking doesn't involve just standing next to someone when the ball is played; you actually have to track them and defend the ball when it comes in.

More importantly, I also think we still don't use Benteke properly. Even if he's a bit of a statue, in the air he's an extremely dangerous one and we seem not make it a priority to play whipped crosses into the six yard box when we've got one of the best headers of the ball in the PL waiting there. That mystifies me. If I see another floaty cross, I think I'm going to self-immolate and while I'm on the subject, what's with the short-corners? I've never understood why you'd f*** around with "clever" movement and short passes before you cross the ball (yes, I know the idea is to pull defenders out of position but the risk of doing so is that you never get the cross in at all) when you have a Benteke in the middle who's capable of getting onto anything. When we have a corner, just fizz the bloody ball towards the penalty spot and Benteke will get onto his fair share. And if he doesn't, at least it'll create some danger in the box. I'd rather lose the ball there than out by the corner flag where there's no chance of scoring.

I'd agree on the short passing being sloppy. It sounds trivial but it puts the receiver on the back foot.

My guess is that as Benteke is arguably the best in the air, we give him a free role and tell him to just attack the ball. I'm fine with that in the first phase, but he then needs to work harder after that initial cross.

The corner/set piece conundrum is getting more ridiculous by the week. My recollection is that broadly they are all individual errors but so many are basic. And its now spreading to players like Tompkins coming in for his first game. How such an experience defender misreads the flight of the ball that badly is baffling.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 29 Nov 21 2.36pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

My guess is that as Benteke is arguably the best in the air, we give him a free role and tell him to just attack the ball. I'm fine with that in the first phase, but he then needs to work harder after that initial cross.

Agreed. However, for that to be a useful approach, the quality of our crossing has to improve considerably. The "slow, high ball wafted into the penalty area" is completely ineffective and we do it far too often. In my view, our crosses have to a). come in much harder and faster (whipped in), and b). they need to arrive far earlier. All too often we have Wilf, Olise, Ward, or Mitchell get to the byline and then, rather than whipping a cross in for Benteke to attacke, they play it back to the next man to put in the cross by which time the defense has had those vital extra thirty seconds to organise themselves and the advantage of momentum has been lost. We need to create more chances, rather than always looking for the perfect pass.


Originally posted by MrRobbo

The corner/set piece conundrum is getting more ridiculous by the week. My recollection is that broadly they are all individual errors but so many are basic. And its now spreading to players like Tompkins coming in for his first game. How such an experience defender misreads the flight of the ball that badly is baffling.

Not excusing Tomkins but I suspect the wind on the pitch was far more difficult to deal with than those of us in the stands realised. That said, what I thought gave the lack of organisation away was there was a play towards the end of the first half on Saturday, from memory, where Villa played a ball to the far post and literally everyone stood there watching it, Guita, Tomkins, Ward, and Guehi all waiting for each other to make a move until Ward, I think it was, booted it out for a corner more out of desperation than judgment. It was a bit reminiscent of Burnley's second goal the week before where everyone seemed rooted and Woods (I think it was) pretty much headed in unchallenged. Had their been a Villa player in the neighbourhood on Saturday, that would been 2-0 but thankfully, there wasn't.

I think one problem is that we appear to be marking zonally rather than man-to-man and it's simply not working for two reasons. First, players appear not to know their zones (I mean, you have to assume someone is covering a zone on the edge of a six yard box so if no one is there, there has to be a breakdown somewhere) and second, if you're going to play zonally, given that by definition it means opposing players will need to be handed off to another marker when they move between zones, you really need to have players who really know each other and have been playing that way for a long time to ensure everyone is picked up which is not the case with us at present. A third issue is that a zonal system as opposed to man-to-man marking also requires a really vocal goalkeeper to be effective, as the keeper will really need to "quarterback" the zones and shout to make sure everyone is aware of what's happening. And for all his pluses, Guiata is NOT that sort of keeper.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Nov 21 4.11pm

Originally posted by Painter

Kouyate crossed the ball for the goal against Villa, something Olise couldn’t do all game.
Benteke is the most successful Premier striker, we have ever had, one goal away from 100 Premier goals. Bad players don’t score that many goals in the Premier and you want to sell him.

He has scored 37 goals in 160 matches for us, not exactly a glut is it, and its only cost us 65m, he isn't a goal scorer, Edouard might be if he gets the CF position. out him, get some money back and buy another CF

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

palace99 Flag New Mills 29 Nov 21 5.39pm

Originally posted by OneWayTicketToMars

This:

We will make one change Ayew for Olise.

Lets go on another unbeaten run

COYP

i suspect you are correct. Certainly won't be wholesale changes

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 29 Nov 21 7.22pm

In an ideal world, Butland, Hughes, Riedewald or Schlupp & Eze for Guaita, Kouyate, Luka & Olise, but as a previous contributor said, wholesale changes unlikely.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 29 Nov 21 8.54pm

Originally posted by Swindy

In an ideal world, Butland, Hughes, Riedewald or Schlupp & Eze for Guaita, Kouyate, Luka & Olise, but as a previous contributor said, wholesale changes unlikely.

I think you're probably right, but I wonder. This is a big test for Vieira; arguably his biggest test as a manager so far this season. The two games we'd lost previously, Chelsea and Liverpool away, were not realistically games we expected to get anything from so no reaction to the results was mandated. We've had a few draws where might have expected wins but those have not been overtly poor results; we've picked up points consistently.

Saturday, on the other hand, was probably the first match this season that yielded an outright disappointing performance AND negative result so it's the first time we'll get to see how Vieira reacts to failure. And he was pretty blunt in his post-match analysis on Saturday about our shortcomings.

With all that in mind, there's an argument that if he was ever going to shake things up a bit (and in a way, he did that already by hooking Wilf on Saturday which if nothing else made the point that he's not afraid to act when we're playing sub-par), tomorrow is the game where he might just make some wholesale changes. It's away, Leeds are a decent team out-of-form, so it's about as low-risk a time to do it as you're going to get.

By and large, he's stuck with the same 14/15 players throughout the season so I just wonder if some of those on the fringes won't get an opportunity tomorrow night. Of course, he could go in the opposite direction and give the regulars the opportunity to redeem themselves tomorrow night but I have a sneaking feeling, nothing more, that he might just lay down a marker and change things more than we expect. One things for sure; to me this will be his most interesting team selection of the season so far and possibly his first real "moment" to make a point to the squad about what sort of manager he is in terms of his expectations from them.

If he does go down the "wholesale changes" route, I'd expect: Eze will not start because he's still some way from full fitness. Hughes and Schlupp are the two I'd expect to get opportunities and possibly Olise coming into the middle with Schlupp out wide. That would give us Wilf-Hughes or Olise-Gallagher-Schlupp across the middle. Up front, I think Edouard will get a start. 50/50 whether he's partnered with Benteke or Ayew but I suspect Ayew as Leeds are a demanding team physically and little needs to be said about Ayew's willingness to run with them versus Benteke's plus Benteke is a useful option off the bench if needed later in the game where Ayew really isn't. So my guess would be Edouard and Ayew up front.

I also think it's not beyond the bounds of possibility that Wilf finds himself starting this game on the bench although I wouldn't bet on that happening.

The issue with Butland for Guaita is that I don't think you really do that unless you think Butland is simply ready to take over the shirt full-time because there's no mileage in putting him in there, pissing Guaita off, and finding out he's not good enough for the role. However, if Vieira rates Butland highly and with Guaita out of contract and possibly off in the summer (or even getting some money for him in January rather than letting him go for free in May), if we do rate Butland highly then there's an argument that now would be time to put him in. Again, there are aspects of this decision that we as fans will never see. If the club are aware (and they would be aware of it) that there's real interest from Spain in Guaita and they know the player's interested in going home after this season then that may well encourage us to cash in on him in January and put Butland in the side now. That is just speculation but it's probably in part how these decisions are made.

Edited by sydtheeagle (29 Nov 2021 9.07pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 29 Nov 21 8.55pm

I'm happy to go with whoever PV selects......as long as he leaves Luka at home.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Mathers Flag 30 Nov 21 12.22am

Delighted that people have now acknowledged how s***e Luka is. Fingers crossed PV sees the same and he never pulls on the shirt again.

100% time for Hughes and Edouard to start. Would love to see Banks get a chance off the bench ahead of someone like Ayew.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 30 Nov 21 1.23am

Originally posted by Mathers

Delighted that people have now acknowledged how s***e Luka is. Fingers crossed PV sees the same and he never pulls on the shirt again.

100% time for Hughes and Edouard to start. Would love to see Banks get a chance off the bench ahead of someone like Ayew.

Banks, when his time comes, won't be at the cost of Ayew. Not his role at all, and as I've said repeatedly the lack of respect shown to Ayew borders on criminal. Banks, a bit like Olise, is presently almost certainly a little lightweight for the PL. That said, I have no doubt at all that as he fills out physically over the next year or two, he'll become an extremely important player. But not yet. Hughes and Edouard, I couldn't agree more. Unless Hughes is (still) injured I struggle to see why he's not even had any time off the bench given the limitations of Luka and even Kouyate.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Wilbraham413 Flag 30 Nov 21 2.29am

I don't want to see the Luka/Kouyate pairing again this season. The problem is, Schlupp and Reidewald are not quality enough to be starters. Schlupp has one good run per game, then is invisible the rest of the time. Riedewald runs around a lot, but can't pass or maintain possession.

I'd honestly like to see Hughes in midfield, or Eze, but I have a feeling that Eze isn't going to start yet.

PV seems to like Benteke, so I think he will still start over Edouard for now.

I'll take Olise over Ayew any day. If we are leading late, then I like Ayew as a late sub, but the guy hasn't contributed anything to the offense in over a year, and we can't afford that.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

viveasheagle Flag perth 30 Nov 21 2.34am

Some good posts on this thread and i like syd the eagles input. I definitely think there is a strong case to move Olise to the middle and play either Schlupp or Ayew on the right. Edouard down the middle also looks good to me.

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 30 Nov 21 3.46am

Guaita

Ward Tomkins Guehi Mitchell

Kouyate

Olise Gallagher

Zaha Benteke Edouard

 

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Nov 21 8.07am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I think you're probably right, but I wonder. This is a big test for Vieira; arguably his biggest test as a manager so far this season. The two games we'd lost previously, Chelsea and Liverpool away, were not realistically games we expected to get anything from so no reaction to the results was mandated. We've had a few draws where might have expected wins but those have not been overtly poor results; we've picked up points consistently.

Saturday, on the other hand, was probably the first match this season that yielded an outright disappointing performance AND negative result so it's the first time we'll get to see how Vieira reacts to failure. And he was pretty blunt in his post-match analysis on Saturday about our shortcomings.

With all that in mind, there's an argument that if he was ever going to shake things up a bit (and in a way, he did that already by hooking Wilf on Saturday which if nothing else made the point that he's not afraid to act when we're playing sub-par), tomorrow is the game where he might just make some wholesale changes. It's away, Leeds are a decent team out-of-form, so it's about as low-risk a time to do it as you're going to get.

By and large, he's stuck with the same 14/15 players throughout the season so I just wonder if some of those on the fringes won't get an opportunity tomorrow night. Of course, he could go in the opposite direction and give the regulars the opportunity to redeem themselves tomorrow night but I have a sneaking feeling, nothing more, that he might just lay down a marker and change things more than we expect. One things for sure; to me this will be his most interesting team selection of the season so far and possibly his first real "moment" to make a point to the squad about what sort of manager he is in terms of his expectations from them.

If he does go down the "wholesale changes" route, I'd expect: Eze will not start because he's still some way from full fitness. Hughes and Schlupp are the two I'd expect to get opportunities and possibly Olise coming into the middle with Schlupp out wide. That would give us Wilf-Hughes or Olise-Gallagher-Schlupp across the middle. Up front, I think Edouard will get a start. 50/50 whether he's partnered with Benteke or Ayew but I suspect Ayew as Leeds are a demanding team physically and little needs to be said about Ayew's willingness to run with them versus Benteke's plus Benteke is a useful option off the bench if needed later in the game where Ayew really isn't. So my guess would be Edouard and Ayew up front.

I also think it's not beyond the bounds of possibility that Wilf finds himself starting this game on the bench although I wouldn't bet on that happening.

The issue with Butland for Guaita is that I don't think you really do that unless you think Butland is simply ready to take over the shirt full-time because there's no mileage in putting him in there, pissing Guaita off, and finding out he's not good enough for the role. However, if Vieira rates Butland highly and with Guaita out of contract and possibly off in the summer (or even getting some money for him in January rather than letting him go for free in May), if we do rate Butland highly then there's an argument that now would be time to put him in. Again, there are aspects of this decision that we as fans will never see. If the club are aware (and they would be aware of it) that there's real interest from Spain in Guaita and they know the player's interested in going home after this season then that may well encourage us to cash in on him in January and put Butland in the side now. That is just speculation but it's probably in part how these decisions are made.

Edited by sydtheeagle (29 Nov 2021 9.07pm)

It's interesting in that we really don't know how he'll respond. He has shown he's willing to drop players when they don't perform to the standard he expects. My major concern is central midfield as aside from Gallagher no one has stood out since McArthur's injury. The way Vieira wants to play that has to be addressed.

Vicente signed a new contract ending speculation of him wanting to return to Spain. The old Butland was great, but do we have him or the one so shorn of confidence that he was warming the bench at Stoke when we bought him? Personally I think Guaita has earned his place unless Jack is demonstrating something special in training.

Bentenke is in form so I wouldn't drop him, but I do think Edouard should also start as he hasn't had a bad game yet.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 30 Nov 21 9.07am

In his pre-match Vieira stated more than once that squad members who haven't had game time can expect to get some over the next month. Let's hope that will start tonight with Hughes in midfield instead of Luka, although if that does happen I would expect Kouyate to drop deep with Hughes in the Jimmy Mac role.

Whilst I see Olise as a great prospect he doesn't seem ready to start games. In the two he has started he didn't do much whereas he's been more effective off the bench. Should he start in central midfield as suggested by Syd. Yes BUT that's surely Eze's spot once he's fully up and running.

My front 3 would be Zaha, Benteke and Edouard with Edouard on the left and Wilf told to play on the right and provide a few decent crosses for Tekkers (and Edouard).

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 30 Nov 21 9.12am

Originally posted by antipodeagle

Guaita

Ward Tomkins Guehi Mitchell

Kouyate

Olise Gallagher

Zaha Benteke Edouard

Your suggestion is very close to the team shown in today's Daily Mail antipodeagle. The only difference is that they're showing Eze instead of Olise. Not bad eh? At least Luka doesn't get a mention.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Leeds