This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
I’m a (now retired) ref. The offside decision is completely baffling. Here is an FAQ section of Law 11 (offside law) from the IFAB website. [Link] If you read the questions the exact situation that happened yesterday is described and the answer is an indirect free kick is awarded. This situation is much worse than the penalty - that to a certain degree is a matter of opinion - the offside is a matter of fact. For top referees not to know the laws of the game shows a stunning level of incompetence. How can this possibly be allowed to happen?
Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC) |
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
No I didnt miss it in the replay and I didn't miss some other critical situations where wrong decisions of the refs went against us and influenced the game. The only thing I wanted to express that with just a few minutes to go it was not quite impossible that Liverpool would have won anyway. I wouldn`t have pointed that out in case the pen had led to an equalizer or one-goal lead for Liverpool. So as scandalous this decision was the related harm could be just a slightly worse goal difference and not the loss of points.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hannes
No I didnt miss it in the replay and I didn't miss some other critical situations where wrong decisions of the refs went against us and influenced the game. The only thing I wanted to express that with just a few minutes to go it was not quite impossible that Liverpool would have won anyway. I wouldn`t have pointed that out in case the pen had led to an equalizer or one-goal lead for Liverpool. So as scandalous this decision was the related harm could be just a slightly worse goal difference and not the loss of points. Your sentiment is so wrong. It was clear Palace were the team going forward, there would be ten minutes to play (with all the stoppage time) and to allow Liverpool a two-goal cushion at that point obviously punched the stuffing out of the team. It really is as simple as that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Friend's performance brought in mind the notorious Ecuadorian ref, Byron Moreno, and while we're here let's have an honourable mention for the lino, who happened not to notice the offisde and non interference of the Liverpool player for their second goal. Someone must have imagined Benteke offside from an onside position later in the game though. except they most probably werent 'errors', but something much more sinister !
|
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Does Crystal Palace - the club and the business - simply accept this clear travesty of a team of officials doing everything possible to ensure a victory by the visiting team? Or does it take action like some supporters have done? How difficult would it be to compile a file of all the wrong decisions, with appropriate video clips, in support of a complaint to the FA? Or does the club simply accept having its trousers pulled down and being shafted? I keep hearing that "football is now all about money". Well if that's the case, then surely CPFC has a right to defend its monetary interests. Fret ye not! Italy, knocked out by hosts South Korea in 2002 thanks in no small part to referee Byron Moreno, went on to lift the trophy in 2006. Karma works in mysterious ways. This season the FA Cup is ours!
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by IMpalace
Extract from the FA website rules on offside: You are offside if you are: - challenging an opponent for the ball (which he was) Insane that this wasn't given. I think I'm correct in stating: The lino made an error and VAR wasn't called for verification.
Edited by southnorwoodhill (25 Jan 2022 10.20am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
What sticks out for me is Klopp can forget all that bonhomie he delivers in abundance to his opponents. He supported this penalty decision, and still does apparently, so if he is the great guy he thinks he is he could say something like, 'yeah that was a bad decision but obviously it has helped our cause'. Or maybe he congratulated Jota in the dressing room for being 'smart/really clever'. It's becoming a grudge match for me. I didn't care before but have had enough. Even turn on the Tele and have to see some rubbish about Hillsborough.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
It's becoming a grudge match for me. I didn't care before but have had enough. Even turn on the Tele and have to see some rubbish about Hillsborough.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Firstly, let's be clear - the penalty decision robbed us of what very small chance remained of atoning for yet more s*** Palace defending against a set-piece and a cross in the air. Liverpool had us chasing shadows for the first half an hour, but that's exactly when we most need to hang on in the game and avoid poor defensive mistakes. We didn't. For the first goal, Schlupp is marking Fabinho but leaves him late to run with Van Dyke, thereby blocking what small chance Andersen had of tracking the Dutchman. For the second, our midfield shape is so bad that Andersen gets dragged over to meet Robertson, leaving Jota in oceans of space, and pulling both Guehi and Mitchell over into a fragile 2v3 behind him. Even if we somehow overlook the poor quality of our finishing we have to mull over the poor defending when analysing the defeat. I'm sure our manager will be looking at both issues far more than the officiating, whatever he says in public. Turning to the decisions nonetheless: VAR itself is neither good nor bad for the game really, it's all about how it is used. Also, remember that we have had our fair share of gifts from VAR, including unreal decisions away at United and Arsenal, so let's not tell ourselves a tale of bias against the little guy here. We are dealing with incredibly poor decisions and inconsistent processes, but not bias. The argument that offside should be given against Firmino is not conclusive, but what I am amazed by is that VAR didn't seem to look at it even once. Compare this to the twenty replays they poured over for the penalty decision. The on-field ref gave nothing both times, so why the vast difference in VAR approach? Regarding the penalty, it all comes down to a sensible understanding of what a foul is, and what cheating is. At the start of this season, the league said they would avoid giving soft free-kicks for minimal contacts, and would also stop being overly forensic with VAR replays. For the first few months that worked so well that Klopp and Solskjaer were moaning about their precious babies being roughed up, and the leagues forward players seemed to be spending a bit more time playing the game and bit less time falling over. The tempo and flow of games became noticeably better once it became more about actually playing, and less about 'winning' decisions. Now it's lapsed back towards last season: A soul-destroying clipboard full of technicalities rather than a football match. For me, if you can't see the offence with the naked eye and at normal speed then the margin for human error has not been breached. The normal speed aspect is critical - all pundits agree that slow-motion makes any contact look worse, but what they neglect to mention is that it's only when watching play at normal speed that one can fully appreciate the change of direction and momentum that the nations leading s***houses employ when jumping away from the path of the ball and into a nearby defender, thereby initiating the 'foul' they benefit from. Kane has done it for years, Jota did it on Sunday. Wilf and Ayew have their moments, albeit in a slightly different style. Many footballers will play as far beyond the letter and spirit of the laws of the game as they are allowed to. These are highly competitive animals under far greater pressure to win than to play honestly, and we are all to blame for that. What I find increasingly difficult to understand is how VAR officials (who referee live games too don't forget), somehow fail to consider the tricks that modern forwards call upon the moment a slow-motion replay switches on. Baffling, alienating nonsense that pushes me further away from professional football and further towards watching the non-league game instead. Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 Jan 2022 10.49am) Good post. However I must take issue regarding the 2nd goal, it is conclusive. Laws clearly state if play is interfering with play or distracts defender whilst in offside position it is offside. All pundits I have heard say it was offside as Firmino being there caused Mitchell to go towards him rather the Oxlade-Chamberlain. Friend was told immediately there was no reason to rule goal out, he touched his earpiece, so some communication was relayed.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.