You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should We Field More Youngsters?
November 16 2026 4.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should We Field More Youngsters?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 30 Jan 22 7.04pm

There's a very good feature in today's Sunday Times written by Jonathan Northcroft about the large number of young English footballers playing in Europe.

It's titled The Sancho Effect and describes how he decided to join Dortmund because he believed it would fast track his career. Their philosophy, he said, was, age didn't matter, if you're good enough they'll play you.

Apparently 7% of minutes in Bundesliga were played by Under 21 year olds in 2020/21, but even this low number is almost double the figure in the PL which has the lowest % of minutes played by Under 21s in any of the world's top 15 leagues, except China and Mexico.

For whatever reason it seems that English clubs consider that young players with experience in Foreign clubs have better potential than those from, say, the Championship.

Although we are making progress in developing our Academy players and bringing them into the first team, I can't help thinking we could give more game time to the likes of Omilabu, Rak-Sakyi and Kirby. Why even consider the likes of Nketiah when we have our own, home grown talent available?

Am I alone in this or are others of you keen to see us 'play our youngsters if they're good enough'?

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

mars Flag Folkestone 30 Jan 22 7.11pm

Good post.. spot on.. we clearly have youth talent so let’s use it!

 

glaziermart Flag 30 Jan 22 7.12pm

I agree. We have a top talent as well called Daniel Quick a defender who can play full back and centre back, and is wanted by Dortmund, Liverpool and Southampton. I am a bit disappointed that Vieira has not integrated some more into the team. We did have Wells-Morrison and Rak-Sakyi on the bench against Millwall, but I feel they could have been on the bench more instead of Jairo and Kelly

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Jan 22 7.35pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Am I alone in this or are others of you keen to see us 'play our youngsters if they're good enough'?

I would guess that every supporter would like to see home grown talent in the first team but you did say "if they're good enough" and obviously our manager doesn't feel that they are good enough but I'm sure that loads of supporters will think that they know better

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 Jan 22 7.49pm

Hartlepool is an obvious game if any are good enough. Maybe not starting but to come on at least.

 


Red and Blue Army!

rikz Flag Croydon 30 Jan 22 8.13pm

And how good has sancho been in the prem ? Would rather play players because they're good enough not because they're young. Like someone else has said, how many players have we released from our academy, have gone onto better things ? None. Zaha, wan bissaka, moses, Clyne, Mitchell, Watson, routledge have all broken into the first team so it shows when it comes to identifying young players who are good enough, as a club we have a pretty good track record.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 30 Jan 22 9.40pm

The Premier League is probably the toughest league to play in. Every opponent tends to be a tough team to beat. In our previous eight seasons we have failed to reach 50 points. In other words most of each season has been spent trying to ensure we survive. Bringing through youngsters, therefore, has been and continues to be difficult for clubs like Palace whose primary aim has been and remains to stay in the league. Yes, we could give a promising youngster a few minutes off the bench in a game that is comfortably being won by us (a rare event) or where a game is already a lost cause (as happened for Rak-Sakyi first up against Chelsea), but most of the time we're trying to either hold on to what we've got in a game or pushing for an equalizer/winner.

What PV has done well this season is give the better Academy players regular opportunities to train with the first team, thereby enabling:
1) him and his coaching team to see where those youngsters are at and what they need to work on and
2) the youngsters to experience first hand what it's like to come up against and play alongside first team players.

The last Academy player to come through, of course, is Mitchell. He got his chance because of injuries BUT he was clearly still very raw and struggled for quite a few games before fans started thinking that he might be up to scratch. How many chances would he have had, had PvA not been out for as long as he was?

I would hope to see several youngsters on the bench on Saturday and, assuming we score several goals and are well in control, hope one or two of them will get some minutes.

I also hope that we'll reach the 40 point mark soonest so as to enable PV to consider giving one or two youngsters opportunities in the final games of the season.

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 30 Jan 22 10.54pm

Should we be in touching point of safety after 28 games - ten left to go - there would be the option to put out an Under 23 and under 18 mixture against a team against whom the first team would usually lose.

The game against Liverpool would have been an opportunity (with the referee having no knowledge of who to warn against playing positively.

I am certain that PV would be able to prepare his selection for any loss, and they would be likely to play without fear.

 

aashman12 Flag 31 Jan 22 7.56am

What ones do you suggest we play and instead of who? None are bossing it at u23 level to suggest they deserve a jump up to Premier league football and that is a massive jump.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 31 Jan 22 8.19am

I would just add to Doombears comment - There is more money in the PL than any other league so its attracts significant amounts of talent from far & wide (Players & agents wanting to follow the money) this only increases the competition for places in those clubs lucky enough to make up the PL.

Originally posted by doombear

The Premier League is probably the toughest league to play in. Every opponent tends to be a tough team to beat. In our previous eight seasons we have failed to reach 50 points. In other words most of each season has been spent trying to ensure we survive. Bringing through youngsters, therefore, has been and continues to be difficult for clubs like Palace whose primary aim has been and remains to stay in the league. Yes, we could give a promising youngster a few minutes off the bench in a game that is comfortably being won by us (a rare event) or where a game is already a lost cause (as happened for Rak-Sakyi first up against Chelsea), but most of the time we're trying to either hold on to what we've got in a game or pushing for an equalizer/winner.

What PV has done well this season is give the better Academy players regular opportunities to train with the first team, thereby enabling:
1) him and his coaching team to see where those youngsters are at and what they need to work on and
2) the youngsters to experience first hand what it's like to come up against and play alongside first team players.

The last Academy player to come through, of course, is Mitchell. He got his chance because of injuries BUT he was clearly still very raw and struggled for quite a few games before fans started thinking that he might be up to scratch. How many chances would he have had, had PvA not been out for as long as he was?

I would hope to see several youngsters on the bench on Saturday and, assuming we score several goals and are well in control, hope one or two of them will get some minutes.

I also hope that we'll reach the 40 point mark soonest so as to enable PV to consider giving one or two youngsters opportunities in the final games of the season.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 31 Jan 22 9.03am

Originally posted by aashman12

What ones do you suggest we play and instead of who? None are bossing it at u23 level to suggest they deserve a jump up to Premier league football and that is a massive jump.

I think Wells-Morrison and Rak-Sakyi are the obvious two for a few minutes

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 31 Jan 22 9.14am

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

There's a very good feature in today's Sunday Times written by Jonathan Northcroft about the large number of young English footballers playing in Europe.

It's titled The Sancho Effect and describes how he decided to join Dortmund because he believed it would fast track his career. Their philosophy, he said, was, age didn't matter, if you're good enough they'll play you.

Apparently 7% of minutes in Bundesliga were played by Under 21 year olds in 2020/21, but even this low number is almost double the figure in the PL which has the lowest % of minutes played by Under 21s in any of the world's top 15 leagues, except China and Mexico.

For whatever reason it seems that English clubs consider that young players with experience in Foreign clubs have better potential than those from, say, the Championship.

Although we are making progress in developing our Academy players and bringing them into the first team, I can't help thinking we could give more game time to the likes of Omilabu, Rak-Sakyi and Kirby. Why even consider the likes of Nketiah when we have our own, home grown talent available?

Am I alone in this or are others of you keen to see us 'play our youngsters if they're good enough'?

In response to your question, yes.

However we likely don't have any good enough.

I suspect its easier to make the break into top level football in other leagues as the general standard is a bit lower than the prem. Naturally driven my money.

Hence a lot of the youngsters we get from abroad have top flight experience under their belt.


 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 31 Jan 22 10.00am

I get why people say this, but money is the issue here.

May as well re title the thread 'Do you want to get relegated?'

No one in the Prem will ever promote young talent unless they either have to (as we did when AWB emerged,) or they are told to. The risk of relegation and financial loss is too great.

This leads to clubs like Chelsea stockpiling talent and loaning out huge numbers each year. Some then make it and some don't.

Rule changes are the only way to do this. Restrict the number of players a club can loan out at any one time and make it that every club has to field 2 under 23's on the pitch at all times.

But that will never happen

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Jan 22 10.42am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle


No one in the Prem will ever promote young talent unless they either have to or they are told to. The risk of relegation and financial loss is too great.

This leads to clubs like Chelsea stockpiling talent and loaning out huge numbers each year. Some then make it and some don't.

I disagree with both of the above statements. There are many superb young talents who make it in the Premier League at a very young age because they have the talent to do so.

Chelsea stockpile talent as it's part of their income generating business model as they can cherry pick the best youngsters for their own side and earn a good income or profit on the rest - Marc Guéhi being a good case in point

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 31 Jan 22 11.16am

Does anyone know how the FIFA proposal last year has developed . I guess it was shelved due to corona but the proposal was to reduce the amount of loans any club could do restricted to 6 per club both in and out .

That would obviously impact the way clubs like Chelsea operate with 30 odd players out and I think 1 (Niguez) in . Something would obviously have to give there with a pool of talent returning to Stamford bridge without a team to play in
(A cheeky bid for CG anyone ?)

The proposal would also encourage sides to use more of their own junior ranks without the the availability or option of a loan . It make our academy status even more important than first thought .

Or does SP know something we dont ?

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 31 Jan 22 11.33am

Looking at our own Academy, the infrastructure is almost complete in terms of facilities. Palace will now have a better chance of attracting young talent than they ever did before.

But we are playing catch up here. Other clubs have had a head start on us. So this will only just start to bear fruit in the next couple of years.

In terms of fielding more youngsters, I think everyone would like to see home grown players come through. But they have to be good enough to deserve that opportunity. Of our current crop at U23, Rak-Sakyi looks a good bet and I understand PV wants him to stay rather than go out on loan this season. Just my opinion, but I haven't seen anyone else in our youth set up that looks like they are ready for the step up at the moment.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

taylors lovechild Flag 31 Jan 22 12.23pm

The fact we don't seem to have Championship clubs knocking on our door for players suggests our current crop are not quite at the right level yet. Scouts could easily watch U23 PL2 games and so the fact we're only sending players to L1 and L2 (or lower) perhaps tells us what we need to know.

Rak-Sakyi does seem the closest but he does drift in and out of games even at U23 level. Also, is he really better or even as good as Zaha, Olise or Ayew? Not yet he isn't in my view. I think he needs to get a loan to the Championship to try and strengthen and really test himself.

I'm really glad that the club have supported Mitchell when they could easily have replaced him. I and others have questioned in the past whether he really is PL standard, but fair play to the lad he's stepped up this season defensively (if perhaps not quite so much offensively). Can we really afford to do the same with another young player though without weakening? Vieira has already talked about naivety among the younger players, so I can't see anyone else getting a significant first-team role this season unless there is a glut of injuries/COVID cases. Given how most of our games seem to go down to the wire we don't even really have the luxury of throwing on a youngster for the last 10 minutes.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 31 Jan 22 3.49pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Does anyone know how the FIFA proposal last year has developed . I guess it was shelved due to corona but the proposal was to reduce the amount of loans any club could do restricted to 6 per club both in and out .

That would obviously impact the way clubs like Chelsea operate with 30 odd players out and I think 1 (Niguez) in . Something would obviously have to give there with a pool of talent returning to Stamford bridge without a team to play in
(A cheeky bid for CG anyone ?)

The proposal would also encourage sides to use more of their own junior ranks without the the availability or option of a loan . It make our academy status even more important than first thought .

Or does SP know something we dont ?

[Link]

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

aashman12 Flag 01 Feb 22 2.05pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think Wells-Morrison and Rak-Sakyi are the obvious two for a few minutes

Wells Morrison is OK at 23s level but nowhere near knocking on the door,

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 03 Feb 22 10.19am

We're only 9 points clear of the relegation zone at the moment with all those sides having games in hand. Whilst I don't think we'll go close to going down, I don't think you can afford to mess around until we're nearer the 40 points mark. After that, definitely start handing out some minutes to the young players.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should We Field More Youngsters?