You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rate the transfer window
November 16 2026 4.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rate the transfer window


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Feb 22 9.16am

I noticed Sky were doing hit or miss on team's transfer windows. Personally think ours is a miss - Mateta was already here, so nothing added. Hopefully was cheap as reported.
Plane - for the future, may work out, may not.

I believe other teams have strengthened, those around us in particular.

I didn't expect us to buy anyone. That pretty much happened. A bland window at best.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Feb 22 9.38am

I wasn't expecting much this window so I would say Par.

As long as we have plans for the summer I am fine with that.

As for others I think we all expected Newcastle to spend (5 signing) and Everton. What did surprise me was nothing for Watford.

 


One more point

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Feb 22 9.54am

Others around us have spent a fortune; and they had to.

History shows that clubs do not always prosper by chucking expensive "name" players into a team... often a high cost for no real progress. Everton are past masters at that.

And the teams that spent were largely basket cases where players will go into an unsettled environment. Only direct success may cause that to change.

We, on the other hand, started our transition much earlier, have done OK given the circumstances, and will likely float into about 12th place by May with the bank barely bruised.

And ready for the summer window.

Thus, always disappointed to not add more quality and would have loved VdB, but heh ho, we did not have a problem that needed desperate fixing.

 

The Heath Eagle Flag Thornton Heath 01 Feb 22 9.58am

Newcastle quietly spent £81,000,000 on transfers. They are going to make Man City and Chelsea's spending look like small potatoes.

The Premier League has been occupied by oil rich nations, an oligarch and investment firms.

In 5 years the top 3 will be Chelsea, City and Newcastle in no particular order. Liverpool and Man U will try their best to make up the other slot.

The death of top division football.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 01 Feb 22 10.34am

Everton manage to get around FFP with some ridiculous creative accounting. Newcastle buy a new defence. Watford go lucky dip with some cheap foreign players. Burnley appear to have signed a quality replacement for Wood but seem short on numbers still. Smith must be a bit fed up that no one came in at Norwich, especially as Cantwell left.

As for us, Mateta at a reduced fee seems good business. Derby fans seem to really rate Plange, so for £1m a good punt. If he doesn't work out we can probably get more selling him back to a Championship club. Would have been nice to get some real quality in, but our squad looks good enough already with Zaha and Kouyate returning this month and possibly McArthur.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 01 Feb 22 11.05am

I didn't expect us to buy which is okay. We have a squad that should keep us up. It would only have been worth splurging out if there had been a real must buy player out there. I wouldn't have put the likes of, for example, Ramsey and Nketiah in that bracket.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 Feb 22 11.13am

Along with many on here I wasn't expecting us to be doing any significant business, so I can't be disappointed. Yes, other clubs around and below us have spent money but how long will it take for the new line-ups at Newcastle and Everton, for example, to gel? We have a settled squad and that shouldn't be underestimated.

Making the Mateta move permanent at an apparently reduced price of less than £10m seems good business and the youngster, Plange, is the kind of cheap (in PL terms) punt that is worth taking.

Presumably next summer's window will focus on midfield and defence strengthening and I would expect DF & Co. to have potential targets in view.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 01 Feb 22 11.36am

When you consider we spent £1.8 million on Marco Gabbiadini over 30 years ago it makes the Plange deal look pretty good. Coincidentally, we sold Gabbiadini to Derby for £1m, so they did owe us almost a million quid.

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 01 Feb 22 12.21pm

Jeff Bourne was the best player we ever had from Derby. £30,000. Anyone remember him?

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 01 Feb 22 1.08pm

I reckon this window was a hit . We have a fairly good 1st team and not a bad bench . Im glad we didnt get held to randsom over Ramsey or Deli or any of the other over hyped and over priced prima donnas. The summer is the time to get the best deals . We need a few players in and a few out but all in all im happy .

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 01 Feb 22 1.26pm

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

Jeff Bourne was the best player we ever had from Derby. £30,000. Anyone remember him?

Yes, He was playing with Dave Swindlehurst on that little pitch and putt at the Sparrows den one day, i was with my dad we got both autographs. must have been mid 70s

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Mine's A Harveys Flag Sussex 01 Feb 22 1.31pm

It's been a very sensible window for January.

Watching Palace play this season has been a real joy, and it's still a work in progress. As relegation is unlikely (fingers crossed!) the rest of the season can be used to develop the current squad.

We've signed Mateta - hopefully giving him stability and confidence.

Aaron Ramsey is a great player but prone to injury, and has been on a ridiculously huge salary. Even if Palace only had to pay 25% of his wages that would be excessive. A bullet dodged.

Van de Beek - what's the point in a short-term loan? There is no option to buy and we have plenty of midfield options.

Nketiah - showed no enthusiasm for Palace. He will be available in the summer on a free if we're still interested.

Plange - an inexpensive acquisition and worth a punt.

Hopefully, there will be some money saved for a decent summer window when certain players leave.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 01 Feb 22 1.38pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I noticed Sky were doing hit or miss on team's transfer windows. Personally think ours is a miss - Mateta was already here, so nothing added. Hopefully was cheap as reported.
Plane - for the future, may work out, may not.

I believe other teams have strengthened, those around us in particular.

I didn't expect us to buy anyone. That pretty much happened. A bland window at best.

Hopefully his career at Palace takes off.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 01 Feb 22 2.04pm

[quote=Mine's A Harveys;3695031]

It's been a very sensible window for January.

Watching Palace play this season has been a real joy, and it's still a work in progress. As relegation is unlikely (fingers crossed!) the rest of the season can be used to develop the current squad.

We've signed Mateta - hopefully giving him stability and confidence.

Aaron Ramsey is a great player but prone to injury, and has been on a ridiculously huge salary. Even if Palace only had to pay 25% of his wages that would be excessive. A bullet dodged.

Van de Beek - what's the point in a short-term loan? There is no option to buy and we have plenty of midfield options.

Nketiah - showed no enthusiasm for Palace. He will be available in the summer on a free if we're still interested.

Plange - an inexpensive acquisition and worth a punt.

Hopefully, there will be some money saved for a decent summer window when certain players leave.

Yep, I'd go along with these comments. Oh, and mine's a Young's thanks.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 01 Feb 22 2.24pm

It's an ok window mainly as we weren't in desperate need of anyone although certainly need a new DMF in the summer. I have my doubts about Mateta but willing to be proved wrong. Plange is someone I had never heard of, hopefully had a good rest of season at Derby and is one for the future.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Mathers Flag 01 Feb 22 3.35pm

Positives
-We didn’t waste money on overpriced cast offs in positions we didn’t need (VDB, Nketiah,Dele)
-Saved £5m on the Mateta deal
-No risk transfer for Plange. Also good to help out a struggling team by agreeing a fair deal instead of being vultures like some clubs.

Negatives
-Left ourselves very short of cover defensively. Any injuries to the back 4 and we are scrapping

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 01 Feb 22 3.41pm

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

Jeff Bourne was the best player we ever had from Derby. £30,000. Anyone remember him?

I do remember him. I'm not sure if we have got many other players from Derby. He score goal number 4 in our win in at Wrexham that secured promotion to Div.2 in 1977 ( or did after the results on the last Saturday went our way).

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Feb 22 4.01pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Hopefully his career at Palace takes off.

Bloody auto correct

 


Red and Blue Army!

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 01 Feb 22 5.22pm

Would have been reasonable to sell one and gain one which we didn't do. So a poor window for me.

Who'll be in the mix for relegation even harder to guess now.

 

tonypeers5 Flag Wallington 01 Feb 22 5.42pm

I agree with others that I wasn’t expecting many transfers either, if any at all. We spent over £65m in the summer and that’s without CGs loan fee (all of which was needed). The squad seems very settled at the moment so I think there’s little risk of relegation with the current team and nothing to disrupt it in terms of new players - think Asprilla for Newcastle back in the 90s.

We have a good first team and strong bench too. Mateta feels like a new signing as he hasn’t featured much before and Eze is still to get back to fitness. Mateta also seems to be building a good playing relationship with Edouard so let’s hope that continues to grow. I expect that we need to make signings in the summer, mainly to replace CG (if not try to buy him) and, imo, we need more defensive cover who are better at playing to Vieira’s style (as our backups can’t - Kelly/Tomkins/Ward)

If not spending this window means more money for the summer when fees aren’t too overinflated, then I actually think it’s been an ok window. We didn’t lose anyone.

Edited by tonypeers5 (01 Feb 2022 5.43pm)

 


It's Red and Blue that unites us

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rate the transfer window