You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Another astonishing VAR decision.
November 22 2026 7.23pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another astonishing VAR decision.


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
dreamwaverider Flag London 28 Feb 22 7.55am

Originally posted by JRW2

You've lost me. Easily done.

!!
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I sent in a comment to BBC which was not published TL:

"Don't particularly like Everton, Lampard even more so, plus it suits my team for City to win here. However, had that penalty, and it was a penalty, been given, the question would not have been 'Why has the referee made that decision?', it would have been 'Why did Rodri do that?'. Inconsistent, bizarre and baffling decision making once again. Does make you wonder how much the officials are being paid for these decisions?"

All fine until you got to the last sentence. BBC???? Really? No way those PC wokes would ever consider it. Even though 99% of football fans must be asking the same question tonight.
In my book that decision has completely destroyed the point of having VAR. That was so blatant a penalty. It begs your question, yet our national public sector tv won’t go there. Shocking.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 28 Feb 22 8.00am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

If the system is that subjective then what’s the point of it? VAR costs nearly £3,000,000 a season - has it improved football or not?

In my opinion, VAR is sucking the life out of the game.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

dreamwaverider Flag London 28 Feb 22 8.12am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

If the system is that subjective then what’s the point of it? VAR costs nearly £3,000,000 a season - has it improved football or not?

I would subjectively suggest that a lot more than £3m is being spent each season on VAR, only it is hidden and the amounts are unknown. However it is those possible payments that are killing football.
Nobody with the benefit of action replays and all the angles could possibly question the Everton right to a penalty. It was totally clear cut if you watch them. So two extra points to Man City. What’s that worth? A lot more than £3m.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 28 Feb 22 8.26am

In tennis there is a computer system that conclusively and immediately shows the world if a ball is in or out. No explanatory lines or angles taking ages to reach a decision by some guy behind the scenes.
A comparative system could easily be produced for soccer which would eliminate all this nonsense.
For some reason, football seems to want to keep all the pressure on human beings to make the call. Either the ref, and/or the person watching the playbacks on VAR.
Absoute nonsense.
Move it into the 21st century. Bot it and the problem is solved.
All a hangover from the Herr Blatter era that we need to progress from and improve the image of football. That was the idea of VAR. Now go all the way with technology.

 

The Dolphin Flag 28 Feb 22 8.41am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'var' by becky

Lukaku's goal should have been allowed - his arm/shoulder was ahead but his feet were way behind the opposition line.
I really feel that if they are going to use millimetre's to deal with it then it should about where your feet are planted and leave it at that.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Feb 22 8.44am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

In tennis there is a computer system that conclusively and immediately shows the world if a ball is in or out. No explanatory lines or angles taking ages to reach a decision by some guy behind the scenes.
A comparative system could easily be produced for soccer which would eliminate all this nonsense.

For some reason, football seems to want to keep all the pressure on human beings to make the call. Either the ref, and/or the person watching the playbacks on VAR.
Absoute nonsense.
Move it into the 21st century. Bot it and the problem is solved.
All a hangover from the Herr Blatter era that we need to progress from and improve the image of football. That was the idea of VAR. Now go all the way with technology.

VAR system currently adjudicates on 'Offside' using technology and it is being enhanced as the following link illustrates.

[Link]

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Feb 22 8.52am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

In tennis there is a computer system that conclusively and immediately shows the world if a ball is in or out. No explanatory lines or angles taking ages to reach a decision by some guy behind the scenes.
A comparative system could easily be produced for soccer which would eliminate all this nonsense.
For some reason, football seems to want to keep all the pressure on human beings to make the call. Either the ref, and/or the person watching the playbacks on VAR.
Absoute nonsense.
Move it into the 21st century. Bot it and the problem is solved.
All a hangover from the Herr Blatter era that we need to progress from and improve the image of football. That was the idea of VAR. Now go all the way with technology.

It works better in cricket and rugby too - one of the problems with football is that goals are rarer than wickets or tries so VAR decisions are more likely to affect the result and so cause controversy.
Also as pointed out the potential financial implication for clubs is far higher in football.
It seems daft for VAR to spend 3 minutes forensically analysing a minuscule offside possibility then ignore the wrestling which happens at corners.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 28 Feb 22 8.54am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

In tennis there is a computer system that conclusively and immediately shows the world if a ball is in or out. No explanatory lines or angles taking ages to reach a decision by some guy behind the scenes.
A comparative system could easily be produced for soccer which would eliminate all this nonsense.
For some reason, football seems to want to keep all the pressure on human beings to make the call. Either the ref, and/or the person watching the playbacks on VAR.
Absoute nonsense.
Move it into the 21st century. Bot it and the problem is solved.
All a hangover from the Herr Blatter era that we need to progress from and improve the image of football. That was the idea of VAR. Now go all the way with technology.

In fairness, it is a bit easier in sports like tennis, that are more binary. The ball is either in or out.

A lot of footballing decisions are obviously a lot more subjective, which I get. Its ones like this weekend that are unexplainable


 

The Dolphin Flag 28 Feb 22 8.59am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I'm clinging on to my belief that they are incompetent, not corrupt.

But it does make you wonder....

Neillo - I understand your hopeful thoughts but how could a qualified referee not give that decision in favour of Everton - the var ref was cheating and if that had been an Everton player it would have been a penalty.
There are dark forces at work in trying to assist the fight at the top of the table in my opinion.

 

The Dolphin Flag 28 Feb 22 9.03am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

But this isn’t really about the match referee - it’s about the VAR ref who didn’t have to make a decision in real time, had the benefit of slow motion and several angles and still got it wrong.

Spot on - the on field Ref didn't see it and fair enough on that but with VAR calling it they should have given a penalty.
Our one with the Liverpool penalty was even more of a joke but there again I am naturally biased both as a Palace fan and my dislike of the ever irritating Klopp!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Feb 22 9.10am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Neillo - I understand your hopeful thoughts but how could a qualified referee not give that decision in favour of Everton - the var ref was cheating and if that had been an Everton player it would have been a penalty.
There are dark forces at work in trying to assist the fight at the top of the table in my opinion.

I don't accept this at all.
If the ball had hit Rodri near his elbow or on the lower arm or hand a penalty would certainly have been awarded.
The 'Sleeve line', 'Bottom of the armpit' has been introduced and where the ball hit Rodri resulted in the VAR concluding that it was inconclusive as to whether the adjudication should be 'Handball'.
I recall a similar incident this season when Craig Dawson netted and the goal was allowed to stand.
Fine margins.

Edited by Willo (28 Feb 2022 9.43am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Feb 22 9.25am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Spot on - the on field Ref didn't see it and fair enough on that but with VAR calling it they should have given a penalty.
Our one with the Liverpool penalty was even more of a joke but there again I am naturally biased both as a Palace fan and my dislike of the ever irritating Klopp!

I believe I have already opined on HOL that when Jota and Guaita collided in my opinion the VAR adjudged that our goalkeeper then hauled Jota to the ground and accordingly awarded the penalty.
If Guaita had just fallen backwards the VAR might have concluded that it was Jota who fouled the keeper.

Edited by Willo (28 Feb 2022 9.27am)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Feb 22 9.28am

Originally posted by Willo

I don't accept this at all.
If the ball had hit Rodri near his elbow or on the lower arm or hand a penalty would certainly have been awarded.
The 'Sleeve line' has been introduced and where the ball hit Rodri resulted in the VAR concluding that it was inconclusive as to whether the adjudication should be 'Handball'.
I recall a similar incident this season when Craig Dawson netted and the goal was allowed to stand.
Fine margins.

The picture Spiderman posted clearly shows a space between the sleeve and where the ball hit his arm. In the case of West Ham’s goal against Leicester game there was some debate over the actual length of Craig Dawson’s sleeve as opposed to other players’ which is carrying subjectivity too far.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Feb 22 9.58am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

The picture Spiderman posted clearly shows a space between the sleeve and where the ball hit his arm. In the case of West Ham’s goal against Leicester game there was some debate over the actual length of Craig Dawson’s sleeve as opposed to other players’ which is carrying subjectivity too far.

Never had this notion of 'Sleeve line' 'T-Shirt line','Bottom of the armpit' in bygone days !
One heard words such as "Ball to hand or hand to ball?"

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 28 Feb 22 9.58am

So each year sides order shirts with a sleeve 2" longer than the year before, enough of a difference to be helpful in situations like this but not enough to be noticeable.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Feb 22 10.08am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

So each year sides order shirts with a sleeve 2" longer than the year before, enough of a difference to be helpful in situations like this but not enough to be noticeable.

The actual wording regarding handball mentions that the upper boundary of the arm is in line with the bottom of the armpit.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Feb 22 10.13am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

So each year sides order shirts with a sleeve 2" longer than the year before, enough of a difference to be helpful in situations like this but not enough to be noticeable.

Or for extra insurance wear a long sleeved shirt and “Denis Law” it by pulling the sleeves down over the hand.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 28 Feb 22 10.20am

I have to laugh at this Willo -
If they cant see ( inconclusive evidence) that the ball hit his arm, how are they supposed to recognise the upper boundary of the arm.

(OK I am being a bit flippant) or is it facetious ?

Originally posted by Willo

The actual wording regarding handball mentions that the upper boundary of the arm is in line with the bottom of the armpit.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Feb 22 10.54am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I have to laugh at this Willo -
If they cant see ( inconclusive evidence) that the ball hit his arm, how are they supposed to recognise the upper boundary of the arm.

(OK I am being a bit flippant) or is it facetious ?

My view for what it is worth (Probably not a lot !) is that the VAR has seen contact with the arm but adjudged that the actual position of contact is inconclusive based on 'Sleeve line', 'Bottom of the armpit' etc etc.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 28 Feb 22 11.27am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Or for extra insurance wear a long sleeved shirt and “Denis Law” it by pulling the sleeves down over the hand.

A lad in my school team used to do that. Thought it made him look cool. It did, but he scored plenty of goals so I guess it was justified.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Another astonishing VAR decision.