You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Time for PV too keep his word
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Time for PV too keep his word


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 31 Mar 22 11.33am

Originally posted by Omph


Another way of looking at this he has the least first team football of any of the mids in that squad. His experience is less than or on a par with the players from City or Liverpool. The vast majority of the mids in the squad have reasonably extensive experience at Champo level - even if on loan.

The England U21 manager is on record as saying how highly he rates him but finds it hard to place him simply because he has only U23 experience. A couple of mins week 1 off the bench is frankly irrelevant.

Edit: this is the relevant article

[Link]

The most relevant bit is

“What I’ve noticed is trying to compare a player who is playing in the U23s with a player that’s playing in the Championship is very difficult,” explained Carsley. “I expect one to do really well and I expect one to struggle and it’s having the eye to see how [these players] would fit in there.

“The quicker these players can get out on loan or play senior football it helps them [as] part of their development. It’s an important part of making that next step.”

I wouldn't be drawing any conclusions from his England U20 record at all on the basis of this.

Edited by Omph (31 Mar 2022 11.23am)

Edited by Omph (31 Mar 2022 11.24am)

Very true, with the rubbish we have on the bench, and safely in mid table surely there is space for a couple of U23 players on the bench

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 31 Mar 22 11.33am

Originally posted by Omph


Another way of looking at this he has the least first team football of any of the mids in that squad. His experience is less than or on a par with the players from City or Liverpool. The vast majority of the mids in the squad have reasonably extensive experience at Champo level - even if on loan.

The England U21 manager is on record as saying how highly he rates him but finds it hard to place him simply because he has only U23 experience. A couple of mins week 1 off the bench is frankly irrelevant.

Edit: this is the relevant article

[Link]

The most relevant bit is

“What I’ve noticed is trying to compare a player who is playing in the U23s with a player that’s playing in the Championship is very difficult,” explained Carsley. “I expect one to do really well and I expect one to struggle and it’s having the eye to see how [these players] would fit in there.

“The quicker these players can get out on loan or play senior football it helps them [as] part of their development. It’s an important part of making that next step.”

I wouldn't be drawing any conclusions from his England U20 record at all on the basis of this.

Edited by Omph (31 Mar 2022 11.23am)

Edited by Omph (31 Mar 2022 11.24am)

I hadn't read that interview before - interesting; thanks for sharing

I think you're misinterpreting my point, which is not to suggest that a loan is a bad idea, just that minutes in the Premier League are exceptionally hard to come by at that age.

I think in hindsight we should have loaned him to the Championship this season - maybe they thought he'd get more opportunities or didn't expect Olise to be quite as impactful straight away etc.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 31 Mar 22 11.37am

I stand ready to be corrected here but didn't both our U18 & U23 teams get promoted at the end of last season ?

If so we may well have felt that as we were going to be playing at a higher level that it would be best to keep our promoted squad together, at least until we have established what life would look like in the new respective divisions.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 31 Mar 22 11.52am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I hadn't read that interview before - interesting; thanks for sharing

I think you're misinterpreting my point, which is not to suggest that a loan is a bad idea, just that minutes in the Premier League are exceptionally hard to come by at that age.

I think in hindsight we should have loaned him to the Championship this season - maybe they thought he'd get more opportunities or didn't expect Olise to be quite as impactful straight away etc.

An interesting angle on this is that when PV came he brought with him someone from the PSG youth system whose remit was specifically iirc to manage the transition from youth set up to first team football. It's something obvs on PV's agenda.

My 2+2 = 5 logic here is that JRS is on course for some first team football this term. The limitations of U23 football is not a particular secret and the loan system is by now a well-acknowledged route to progression. JRS is clearly rated internally and presumably a principled decision has been made to not farm him out.

2+2 doesn't always equal 5 of course so perhaps restricting his man's football exposure has another explanation.

Edited by Omph (31 Mar 2022 11.53am)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 31 Mar 22 12.09pm

Originally posted by Omph

An interesting angle on this is that when PV came he brought with him someone from the PSG youth system whose remit was specifically iirc to manage the transition from youth set up to first team football. It's something obvs on PV's agenda.

My 2+2 = 5 logic here is that JRS is on course for some first team football this term. The limitations of U23 football is not a particular secret and the loan system is by now a well-acknowledged route to progression. JRS is clearly rated internally and presumably a principled decision has been made to not farm him out.

2+2 doesn't always equal 5 of course so perhaps restricting his man's football exposure has another explanation.

Edited by Omph (31 Mar 2022 11.53am)

Yes, that was Said Aigoun who came with quite a big reputation.

Wasn't PV's role at City also to help identify talent and manage the transition from youth to men's football?


I also think it would've been part of Parish's pitch to any potential manager last summer that we've got these two youth squads coming through, new academy opening etc. and made clear that the expectation would be for some of those to make it into the first team, so potentially JRS was kept here as the best hope of achieving that.

Definitely agree it was a decision not to loan him out - it won't have been a lack of interest given what he's done in the development league.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 31 Mar 22 12.53pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Yes, that was Said Aigoun who came with quite a big reputation.

Wasn't PV's role at City also to help identify talent and manage the transition from youth to men's football?


I also think it would've been part of Parish's pitch to any potential manager last summer that we've got these two youth squads coming through, new academy opening etc. and made clear that the expectation would be for some of those to make it into the first team, so potentially JRS was kept here as the best hope of achieving that.

Definitely agree it was a decision not to loan him out - it won't have been a lack of interest given what he's done in the development league.

A different angle on this is that JRS plays in a position that is particularly demanding under the PV system and it takes time to come to terms with it. Olise after all took quite a time to establish himself despite a completely starring season in the Champo.

It could well be that Vieira has decided that JRS would benefit from a full season's tuition in his way before going out on loan and putting it all into practice. Train JRS up first and then allow him to have a more dominant season in the champo than might otherwise be the case? This would put his development back a year at first sight but might produce a stronger player at the end.

Looked at in one way it is putting skills before experience, which does add up.


Edited by Omph (31 Mar 2022 12.53pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Mar 22 2.14pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I stand ready to be corrected here but didn't both our U18 & U23 teams get promoted at the end of last season ?

If so we may well have felt that as we were going to be playing at a higher level that it would be best to keep our promoted squad together, at least until we have established what life would look like in the new respective divisions.


They are two different systems. The U18 leagues are regional in that there is a north and a south. the winners of the two leagues play to decide who is the overall U18 champions. I think last season Citeh beat Fulham (the latter having pipped us on goal difference despite us doing the double over them).

The U23s did get promoted to the top league through the play-offs (Leeds won the 2nd division). We are now playing against the top teams although some of them (Chelsea being the prime example) are struggling because their best U23 players are out on loan (think Gallagher, Broja, Gilmour etc.) Indeed Chelsea U23s are in danger of relegation (currently 13th out of 14 teams). We are doing well in 5th place, whereas Leeds who romped to the 2nd division title last year are down in 11th. We've been playing our strongest team most of the season. Leeds on the other hand have had to shore up their first team squad with youngsters. Some of our more experienced youngsters did go out on loan in January (by which point our U23s weren't in any relegation danger). Both O'Brien ()at Swindon and Street (at Newport) seem to be getting regular men's football albeit in League 2 (both teams fighting for a play-off place so good experience for our lads).

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 31 Mar 22 2.38pm

Originally posted by doombear


They are two different systems. The U18 leagues are regional in that there is a north and a south. the winners of the two leagues play to decide who is the overall U18 champions. I think last season Citeh beat Fulham (the latter having pipped us on goal difference despite us doing the double over them).

The U23s did get promoted to the top league through the play-offs (Leeds won the 2nd division). We are now playing against the top teams although some of them (Chelsea being the prime example) are struggling because their best U23 players are out on loan (think Gallagher, Broja, Gilmour etc.) Indeed Chelsea U23s are in danger of relegation (currently 13th out of 14 teams). We are doing well in 5th place, whereas Leeds who romped to the 2nd division title last year are down in 11th. We've been playing our strongest team most of the season. Leeds on the other hand have had to shore up their first team squad with youngsters. Some of our more experienced youngsters did go out on loan in January (by which point our U23s weren't in any relegation danger). Both O'Brien ()at Swindon and Street (at Newport) seem to be getting regular men's football albeit in League 2 (both teams fighting for a play-off place so good experience for our lads).

Interesting detail - thanks for sharing.

I was always impressed with O'Brien when he played with the development squad, and he seems a big hit with the Swindon fans so far - also highly rated amongst the Irish national set-up and he started for their U21s in an impressive win and clean sheet over Sweden

Seems a good prospect.

 

pssguy Flag 31 Mar 22 2.52pm

I'm not sure you can have a cookie-cutter approach to this. Players we have sent out on loan haven't set the world on fire whilst Wan Bissaka and Mitchell, for example, were always at the club

Hopefully, we can progress as a team next year so that we are not worried about relegation; can concentrate more on the cups; and get into Europe. That will offer more opportunities for young, fringe players

 

OldFella Flag London 31 Mar 22 5.18pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

No, its a factual book about the freemasons particularly about Florence, the home of the freemasons, its about a satanic Grande lodge. just google "monster of Florence" on Wiki, or there is a fantastic documentary on Scottish (STV) player

What colour crayons are you using?

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 31 Mar 22 8.59pm

Originally posted by OldFella

What colour crayons are you using?

i presume your literary standard is the Beano,

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

sprites Flag Auckland 31 Mar 22 9.22pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I think we'll see a forward line of;

Ayew Mateta Edouard

Hopefully JRS does make the bench.

Good lord...doesn't exactly fill you with confidence does it.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 01 Apr 22 11.00am

Originally posted by sprites

Good lord...doesn't exactly fill you with confidence does it.

The 2-2 at Highbury which didn't exactly flatter us featured Ayew Tekkers Edouard! I know he's been in and out of the side but personally think Edouard has been a great signing.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 01 Apr 22 12.06pm

Originally posted by Omph

The 2-2 at Highbury which didn't exactly flatter us featured Ayew Tekkers Edouard! I know he's been in and out of the side but personally think Edouard has been a great signing.

Eduoard Mateta Rak-Sakyi, give him a chance, they wont know what to expect, we are safe, he has done his apprenticeship and deserves a go

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Apr 22 1.00pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Eduoard Mateta Rak-Sakyi, give him a chance, they wont know what to expect, we are safe, he has done his apprenticeship and deserves a go

I'll give you your dues Lanzo, you are like a dog with a bone, whether it be Tekkers or JRS you just won't let go.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 01 Apr 22 1.12pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Eduoard Mateta Rak-Sakyi, give him a chance, they wont know what to expect, we are safe, he has done his apprenticeship and deserves a go

JRS wont/cant play for the 1st team as the U23's are playing away to (dirty)Leeds same night @ 19.00. Tho tbf, if PV includes him in the 1st team squad, thats a different matter, but somehow i doubt it atm.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Apr 22 6.26pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Eduoard Mateta Rak-Sakyi, give him a chance, they wont know what to expect, we are safe, he has done his apprenticeship and deserves a go

It doesnt work like that, you need to be good enough, JRS obviously isnt good enough yet. There are hundreds of apprentices that show much promise, but cant develop enough to be Premiership ready and fall away into the lower leagues.
PV has a wealth of experience and has worked with M Citys youth teams. He sees the player in training and has his own opinion, with respect more informed, than yours.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 01 Apr 22 9.46pm

Originally posted by Painter

It doesnt work like that, you need to be good enough, JRS obviously isnt good enough yet. There are hundreds of apprentices that show much promise, but cant develop enough to be Premiership ready and fall away into the lower leagues.
PV has a wealth of experience and has worked with M Citys youth teams. He sees the player in training and has his own opinion, with respect more informed, than yours.

AWB wasn't good enough and played against Spurs and never looked back, some rise to the challenge, some don't, until you try you never know

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

sprites Flag Auckland 02 Apr 22 5.41am

Originally posted by Omph

The 2-2 at Highbury which didn't exactly flatter us featured Ayew Tekkers Edouard! I know he's been in and out of the side but personally think Edouard has been a great signing.

Yeah the difference there is Tekkers vs Mateta. Instantly more threatening. But let's not go there...Lanzo's blood pressure will go through the roof.

 

OldFella Flag London 02 Apr 22 1.07pm

Originally posted by Painter

It doesnt work like that, you need to be good enough, JRS obviously isnt good enough yet. There are hundreds of apprentices that show much promise, but cant develop enough to be Premiership ready and fall away into the lower leagues.
PV has a wealth of experience and has worked with M Citys youth teams. He sees the player in training and has his own opinion, with respect more informed, than yours.

Not difficult in the case of Lanzo-Ad, tbf

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Time for PV too keep his word