You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Favourite, most under/overrated, 'G.O.A.T' etc.
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Favourite, most under/overrated, 'G.O.A.T' etc.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Apr 22 9.45am

Saw this trending on twitter, although it was used for 'Rappers', 'NBA/NFL/MLB players' etc and thought it ridiculous not one yank had thought to do one for Palace Players!

Give it a go if you've got a spare few mins today, bit of fun and would of course be interested to see. Going to once more expose my relative youth here, but I'll give it a go for now and may come back with a revised version that I've given more than 5 mins to...


Favourite Palace Player of all time: Aki Riihilahti

Palace Player I dislike: Tom Soares, always thought he was 5H!T!!

Palace Player that grew on me: Neil Danns (Had never herd of him previously)

Most overrated Palace Player: I fear it may be AWB but will go with Tom Soares again or very possibly John Bostock (who?... exactly)

Most underrated Palace Player: Joonas Kolkka, thought he was superb! Wish he'd stayed longer

The G.O.A.T.: Has to be Wilf, surely? He's long dethroned AJ for me (in my lifetime).

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Teddy Eagle Flag 12 Apr 22 10.01am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Saw this trending on twitter, although it was used for 'Rappers', 'NBA/NFL/MLB players' etc and thought it ridiculous not one yank had thought to do one for Palace Players!

Give it a go if you've got a spare few mins today, bit of fun and would of course be interested to see. Going to once more expose my relative youth here, but I'll give it a go for now and may come back with a revised version that I've given more than 5 mins to...


Favourite Palace Player of all time: Aki Riihilahti

Palace Player I dislike: Tom Soares, always thought he was 5H!T!!

Palace Player that grew on me: Neil Danns (Had never herd of him previously)

Most overrated Palace Player: I fear it may be AWB but will go with Tom Soares again or very possibly John Bostock (who?... exactly)

Most underrated Palace Player: Joonas Kolkka, thought he was superb! Wish he'd stayed longer

The G.O.A.T.: Has to be Wilf, surely? He's long dethroned AJ for me (in my lifetime).

Favourite: Don Rogers
Dislike: I keep my dislike for the opposition
Grew on me: AJ. Wasn’t thrilled when we got him but…
Overrated: Probably AWB. He was very good though.
Underrated: Maybe Ambrose or Matt Jansen
G.O.A.T. Wilf but I’ll stick with Rogers.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Apr 22 10.05am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Favourite: Don Rogers
Dislike: I keep my dislike for the opposition
Grew on me: AJ. Wasn’t thrilled when we got him but…
Overrated: Probably AWB. He was very good though.
Underrated: Maybe Ambrose or Matt Jansen
G.O.A.T. Wilf but I’ll stick with Rogers.

OMG I didn't even think about Ambrose! I'll never waitress in Torquay again -.-' Genuinely ashamed! I'll blame it being early.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

sprites Flag Auckland 12 Apr 22 10.07am

Favourite: James McArthur.

Dislike: PVA. Arrogant tit.

Grew on me: Murray. Like a fine wine.

Overrated: Bolasie or Wilf (sorry). I'll go Bolasie though.

Underrated: Barry Bannan.

GOAT: Lombardo.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Apr 22 10.37am

Favourite: Jim Cannon - saw his debut and his last game for Palace ( and plenty in between )

Dislike: Kevin Miller !!

Grew on me: Andy Roberts. Awful to begin with but turned into a very good signing

Overrated: Not going to be popular I suspect, but Vince Hilaire. Didn't fulfill his early potential

Underrated: Phil Barber. Came out of non-league and was a regular in the promotion winning team in '89 and played in the 1990 Cup Final

GOAT: Wilf - he's been performing to a high standard at the top level for longer than any other Palace player

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Beastie Flag 12 Apr 22 11.07am

Favourite: Attilio Lombardo
Dislike: Kevin Miller
Grew on me: Mile Jedinak
Overrated: Max Meyer
Underrated: James McArthur
GOAT: Wilfried Zaha

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 12 Apr 22 2.51pm

Favourite: Don Rogers
Dislike: PVA (but mostly Terry Venables and Alan Mullery)
Grew on me: Julian Speroni (bad start but quite brilliant when established)
Overrated: Wilf overrates himself!! But I'll go for Mamadou Sakho
Underrated: Rachid Harkouk
GOAT: Wilfried Zaha reluctantly, cos it's been over a long time, but over the shorter time he was with us I think AJ had the greatest impact

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 12 Apr 22 3.20pm

Favorite Vince Hilair
Dislike Doggie
Grew on me Lombardo
Overated , Brolin
Under rated , Scot Dann
G.O.A.T THE JEDI

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 12 Apr 22 3.59pm

Favourite: Derry / Puncheon

Dislike: I used to get incredibly frustrated with Paddy McCarthy

Grew on me: Jedinak - the first game I watched him play at Selhurst he looked like he'd won a raffle to be there.

Overrated: Andre Moritz

Underrated: James McCarthur / Owen Garvan / Scott Dann

GOAT: Wilf, no question.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 12 Apr 22 4.22pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Julian Speroni

Palace Player I dislike: Stern John. Could have squared to Ambrose at Hillsborough for an easy tap-in in 2010. Might have cost us our existence. Selfish.

Palace Player that grew on me: Jordan Ayew

Most overrated Palace Player: Meyer. Can't think of many alternatives in my twenty years supporting the club.

Most underrated Palace Player: Jeffrey Schlupp. When he plays well, we rarely lose! Gets stick for nothing.

The G.O.A.T.: Wilf. The main reason why we have stayed in this elite league for nine seasons. The points without him statistic was worrying a season or two ago.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Apr 22 5.10pm

No votes for Jordon Mutch. I am surprised

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 12 Apr 22 8.15pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Dave Swindlehurst

Palace Player I dislike: None!

Palace Player that grew on me: Nicky Chatterton

Most overrated Palace Player: James McArthur

Most underrated Palace Player: Jerry Murphy

The G.O.A.T.: Kenny Sansom/ Jim Cannon

 

sprites Flag Auckland 12 Apr 22 8.50pm

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Dave Swindlehurst

Palace Player I dislike: None!

Palace Player that grew on me: Nicky Chatterton

Most overrated Palace Player: James McArthur

Most underrated Palace Player: Jerry Murphy

The G.O.A.T.: Kenny Sansom/ Jim Cannon

You should be banned from the site!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Apr 22 9.12pm

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Dave Swindlehurst

Palace Player I dislike: None!

Palace Player that grew on me: Nicky Chatterton

Most overrated Palace Player: James McArthur

Most underrated Palace Player: Jerry Murphy

The G.O.A.T.: Kenny Sansom/ Jim Cannon

I'm devastated

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 12 Apr 22 10.12pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Andy Johnson

Palace player I dislike: PVA (Tyrick is vastly superior)

Palace player that grew on me: Glenn Murray. I didn’t think much of him at first when we signed him, but when he started scoring for fun in the 12/13 season, he quickly proved me wrong. Why did we ever sell him?!

Most overrated Palace player: Max Meyer.

Most underrated Palace player: James McArthur (AKA the unsung hero)

The G.O.A.T.: Wilf. Without him, we’d be struggling to get out of the Championship. And he’s seemingly matured since he’s come back from the AFCON.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 12 Apr 22 10.26pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Billy Gilbert

Palace Player I dislike: Neil Ruddock

Palace Player that grew on me: Julian Speroni

Most overrated Palace Player: Yohan Cabaye

Most underrated Palace Player: Dave Swindlehurst

The G.O.A.T. Kenny Sansom or Ian Wright

 

mileend Flag East London 12 Apr 22 11.47pm

Favourite Palace Player of all time: Kenny Sansom - you can never surpass that childhood hero worship. Except Ian Wright did but then fell from grace in the manner of his exit. Perhaps Eddie McGoldrick and Wayne Routeledge should get a look in.

Palace Player I dislike: I don't like any kind of boo boy mentality against any Palace players - but there is one and only one who makes me absolutely furious that he wore the red and blue - Andy Dorman

Palace Player that grew on me: Richard Shaw - I thought he was literally the most abysmal footballer in history as a left back and seemed only about one in ten of his passes up the line stayed in play. But once he moved inside the defence became a thing of wonder.

Most overrated Palace Player: I see Max Meyer has been mentioned and sadly I agree though the name Michele Padovano also springs to mind. Had the question been Most Disappointing Palace Player there would have been a cast of hundreds

Most underrated Palace Player: Due to a character fault I seem to try and rate all Palace Players while no one outside the club think hardly any are any good. In the current crop I think Jeffrey Schlupp gets undue negativity (Benteke too but it's understandable) - I liked Dave Madden and Owen Garvan which shows an undue liking for good passers with low mobility so perhaps it was the rarity at Palace over the years of those who loved possession of the ball rather than their ability that I was drawn to? Also Marouane Chamakh - we would have never made it through season 1 of this Premier league run without him.

The G.O.A.T. Wilf. Obviously. It's fun to say other names but simply no one else is close.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 13 Apr 22 6.48am

Favourite Player: Nigel Martyn

Player I dislike: Marouanne Chamahk

Player that grew on me: David Hopkin

Most overrated player: Neil Ruddock

Most underrated player: Fan Zhiyi

GOAT: Wilf

 

JohnB Flag 13 Apr 22 8.09am

Favourite Player: Simon Rodger

Player I dislike: Kevin Muscat/Patrick Bamford

Player that grew on me: Peter Ramage

Most overrated player: Dwight Gayle

Most underrated player: Craig Moore

GOAT: Wilf Zaha/Yaya Sanogo

 

Noz Flag North Hampshire 13 Apr 22 9.01am

Favourite Player: Mark Bright

Player I dislike: Jordan Mutch (originally had Itzak Zohar, but decided to go with JM).

Player that grew on me: Michael Hughes - couldn't see the what the fuss was about at first then realized what a monster he was.

Most overrated player: Steve Mandanda. French national keeper?!

Most underrated player: Johnny Williams, had it all, thwarted by injury. Unlike Connor Whickham who didn't have anything but was still thwarted by injury.

GOAT: AJ

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Favourite, most under/overrated, 'G.O.A.T' etc.