This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Zaha - Stay or go?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Slimey Toad Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 24 May 22 6.50am |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
What a dilemma. We have missed our chance of big money for him. Why would anyone pay more than £20m now? He’s only got a one more season contract right now. Wait a season, offer him say £ 8m signing on and salary aged 30 and hope to get 2 seasons. Slightly different to Ronaldo on £30m for two seasons. His contract with us runs out at 30 eg one more year. After that he may be worth one more season at £6m (his current salary). I reckon he will sit on the fence now. He’s a very strong boy. Just hope he keeps going here till he is say 32 Right now he is still our best most consistent player. Anyone who was there on Sunday knows how valuable he is to us.
And a good job too. How many points has his goals given us this season alone, let alone his rejuvenated attacking play? We may have missed out on a big fee but then we could have been tempted to have done another Benteke and overpaid for a just-not-good-enough player.
Instead we have budgeted wisely and look who we've got - Guehi, Eze, Olise, Anderson, Mateta, Édouard (the last one is particularly worth persevering with. This boy has got skill). Most of these are worth quite a bit more than we paid.
|
Dubai Eagle 24 May 22 6.51am |
|
|
Given where we are now in our development as a PL club, PV stays & we have another good transfer window (perhaps bringing in 2 or 3 good players to strengthen the squad) to me, providing no one comes in for him with an exorbitant offer he would absolutely be better off signing another 2 year contract & staying.
|
Casual Orpington 24 May 22 10.37am |
|
|
Although I’ve never thought that he has been champions league level/worth £80 odd million, like some on here have suggested. But with Viera as manager and Gallagher going. We need to keep him and add a few. It’s a decent balanced squad, in my opinion , with no stars , so I’m not expecting anyone to go. Not like when AJ was at least twice as good as everyone else and eventually had to go.
|
Pierre Purley 24 May 22 11.30am |
|
|
Wilf is and has always been worth more a hell of a lot more to us than any club is willing to pay! He has just enjoyed a fabulous season and whose to say he won't have a better one next year? If we manage to strengthen the squad in the right areas over the summer there is absolutely no reason why Palace cannot mount a stronger campaign next season. He's a wise and canny operator now so if we can find a quality proven goal scorer to work alongside him in attack, together with a direct CW replacement there is no reason why I think he wouldn't want to stay at Palace. Certainly for the time that PV is around. I certainly enjoyed watching him this season!
|
Badger11 Beckenham 24 May 22 11.51am |
|
Originally posted by Pierre
Wilf is and has always been worth more a hell of a lot more to us than any club is willing to pay! He has just enjoyed a fabulous season and whose to say he won't have a better one next year? If we manage to strengthen the squad in the right areas over the summer there is absolutely no reason why Palace cannot mount a stronger campaign next season. He's a wise and canny operator now so if we can find a quality proven goal scorer to work alongside him in attack, together with a direct CW replacement there is no reason why I think he wouldn't want to stay at Palace. Certainly for the time that PV is around. I certainly enjoyed watching him this season!
One of the reason for Wilf's good season is the form of other creative players such as Olise and Eze. Instead of the opposition focusing on him and marking him out of the game they now have to contend with other match winners which gives Wilf more space.
Unfortunately this could be said of better teams and I am sure Wilf has noticed. Were he to go to Arsenal or City I am sure he would have a great season for that reason.
Just hope he stays.
Edited by Badger11 (24 May 2022 11.52am)
One more point
|
Eaglecoops CR3 24 May 22 12.00pm |
|
|
For the first time since Wilf rejoined us, we are a team on an upward and improving trajectory. In many ways and considering the benefits to him of being here you have to question why he’d want to leave.
1) he is paid fantastic money, more than anyone else in the team. 2) his family are settled in the area and he has his group of friends outside football on the doorstep too. 3) he never settled at Utd so what makes anyone think he could settle elsewhere. 4) he is guaranteed to start for Palace when fit. He is not going to get that anywhere else. 5) he knows he is the fan favourite and I’m pretty sure he likes that. Again it is unlikely he’d get that anywhere else. 6) he has a great opportunity to move forward as the teacher and role model to the up and coming players at Palace. You only get that sort of respect when you are the legend that he is within a club. He would be pretty much an impact player at a top club and probably wouldn’t be given that senior statesman acknowledgment or responsibility. 7) is playing European football really what it’s cracked up to be? ( Rangers got to a Euro final ffs). He is already playing in the most competitive league in the world and most European games are played against teams that would barely scrape into the PL. it’s only really the top couple of teams in Spain, Italy, Germany and France that are competitive against Liverpool, Man City, Chelsea. Why give up regular football for half a chance of half a game against Real Madrid once in your lifetime.
In short I think he would be foolish to leave. He should become the Le Tiss of Palace and wallow in that.
|
Teddy Eagle 24 May 22 12.15pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
For the first time since Wilf rejoined us, we are a team on an upward and improving trajectory. In many ways and considering the benefits to him of being here you have to question why he’d want to leave.
1) he is paid fantastic money, more than anyone else in the team. 2) his family are settled in the area and he has his group of friends outside football on the doorstep too. 3) he never settled at Utd so what makes anyone think he could settle elsewhere. 4) he is guaranteed to start for Palace when fit. He is not going to get that anywhere else. 5) he knows he is the fan favourite and I’m pretty sure he likes that. Again it is unlikely he’d get that anywhere else. 6) he has a great opportunity to move forward as the teacher and role model to the up and coming players at Palace. You only get that sort of respect when you are the legend that he is within a club. He would be pretty much an impact player at a top club and probably wouldn’t be given that senior statesman acknowledgment or responsibility. 7) is playing European football really what it’s cracked up to be? ( Rangers got to a Euro final ffs). He is already playing in the most competitive league in the world and most European games are played against teams that would barely scrape into the PL. it’s only really the top couple of teams in Spain, Italy, Germany and France that are competitive against Liverpool, Man City, Chelsea. Why give up regular football for half a chance of half a game against Real Madrid once in your lifetime.
In short I think he would be foolish to leave. He should become the Le Tiss of Palace and wallow in that.
I hope Wilf reads that, prints it out and puts it on his wall.
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 24 May 22 1.21pm |
|
|
Problem with Zaha is that he has always been far more valuable to us than he has to any other team.
We could have got £100million for him at one time or another and still not spent all of that and adequately replaced him/his impact.
That stock is not as high as it used to be but for Wilf and us the situation is very much the same. Firstly, if he goes, he's not going cheap and ultimately no team will pay above the odds for him. United tried that and it didn't work, at least he trailblazed there.
For all the reasons many have mentioned including that excellent post from Eaglecoops the best choice is for him to stay, for now anyways.
Edited by Nicholas91 (24 May 2022 1.25pm)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
Henry of Peckham Eton Mess 24 May 22 1.31pm |
|
|
Would hate to see Wilf go ... I believe Veira recently said "he's a leader in the dressing room" in one of his post match interviews. Tell me if I'm wrong but I think he’s shown more maturity this season.
Denial is not just a river in Egypt
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 24 May 22 1.34pm |
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
Would hate to see Wilf go ... I believe Veira recently said "he's a leader in the dressing room" in one of his post match interviews. Tell me if I'm wrong but I think he’s shown more maturity this season.
You are not wrong at all HoP.
I would also add to your post Wilf is Palace and he has been Palace for so long. Very selfish but him staying would just be the icing on the cake for me in terms of his place in Palace folklore.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
Pierre Purley 25 May 22 2.43pm |
|
Originally posted by sprites
Disagree - consistent is one thing he's not.
Guehi, he's been consistent. McArthur, consistent. Even players like Schlupp and Kouyate...even if it's consistently 'okay' at least it's consistent. Wilf can be magical one moment, then completely invisible and petulant the other.
In terms of the OP, I can't see anyone taking him for decent money now. He's probably worth more to us over the next couple of seasons than we'd recoup....I'd say he's finishing his top flight career with us now.
Wilf as you say may be accused of being a touch inconsistent at being magical, invisible and petulant. However he is never 'inconsistent' in being the biggest headache every opposition team has to worry about week in and week out. Wilf also hardly ever misses a match despite the regular punishment he receives during each game due to constant rotational fouling. I for one think he should by now have outgrown his tantrums, however a little bit of me thinks it's that's it's part of his DNA and without the odd flare up it just wouldn't be the passionate, trickster, explosive Wilf!! He had a go at that young Man Utd kid on Sunday after their altercation but when the teams came back out in the second half Wilf went and spoke to him before the match restarted.
|
Glazier#1 25 May 22 9.11pm |
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
You are not wrong at all HoP.
I would also add to your post Wilf is Palace and he has been Palace for so long. Very selfish but him staying would just be the icing on the cake for me in terms of his place in Palace folklore.
Absolutely.
For me there is just no question.
Palace legend (over-used epithet but true here) and great player.
Stay, stay, stay until you can't and then take on the role of mentor, as has been suggested. Palace through and through.
|
Glazier#1 25 May 22 9.28pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
For the first time since Wilf rejoined us, we are a team on an upward and improving trajectory. In many ways and considering the benefits to him of being here you have to question why he’d want to leave.
1) he is paid fantastic money, more than anyone else in the team. 2) his family are settled in the area and he has his group of friends outside football on the doorstep too. 3) he never settled at Utd so what makes anyone think he could settle elsewhere. 4) he is guaranteed to start for Palace when fit. He is not going to get that anywhere else. 5) he knows he is the fan favourite and I’m pretty sure he likes that. Again it is unlikely he’d get that anywhere else. 6) he has a great opportunity to move forward as the teacher and role model to the up and coming players at Palace. You only get that sort of respect when you are the legend that he is within a club. He would be pretty much an impact player at a top club and probably wouldn’t be given that senior statesman acknowledgment or responsibility. 7) is playing European football really what it’s cracked up to be? ( Rangers got to a Euro final ffs). He is already playing in the most competitive league in the world and most European games are played against teams that would barely scrape into the PL. it’s only really the top couple of teams in Spain, Italy, Germany and France that are competitive against Liverpool, Man City, Chelsea. Why give up regular football for half a chance of half a game against Real Madrid once in your lifetime.
In short I think he would be foolish to leave. He should become the Le Tiss of Palace and wallow in that.
Yup
|
babylonjohn St Leonards-on-Sea 25 May 22 11.48pm |
|
|
Every summer we have this. Will he stay will he go. Cant see him going myself. We are no longer a one trick pony club where the tactics have been to park the bus and try and hoof it up to Wilf. There are other quality players around WZ in the team and we are playing a more attractive possession based style. Whats not to like ? Also the guy has a young family and I cant see him wanting to uproot them.
|
ambrose7 Croydon 08 Jul 22 3.52pm |
|
|
Bit of chat popping up today about Roma considering a bid for Wilf
There's a part of me that can that transfer happening. European football, a big name club in the world of football, Mourinho, realistic chance to win something, 2 years left on the contract, Tammy Abraham making a success of it plus Chris Smalling and Matic out there too...
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration 2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough 1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds 7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 08 Jul 22 4.25pm |
|
|
Wouldn't be surprised, Abrahams to keep him company, we know Jose likes him, but no champions league, Europa league. and probably 15/20m
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
Wilesy01 Bristol 08 Jul 22 5.03pm |
|
|
As much as I hate to say it I think Mourinho would really know how to get the absolute best out of Wilf, and could utilise him to push Roma towards the top of Serie A.
The money would have to be right but I wouldn't begrudge him leaving at this point in his career.
Can only imagine getting paid a bucket load of money and living in some mansion in Rome!!!
|
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 08 Jul 22 5.25pm |
|
|
If the money is right then it's the perfect time IMO.
We have Olise, Eze, Ebiowei and Rak-Sakyi who are all young and talented plus Ayew and Schlupp to cover out wide.
Would be a terrific move for him and a chance to land some silverware under Jose.
Get £20m and put it towards trying to land Gallagher.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
EaglesEaglesEagles 08 Jul 22 6.07pm |
|
|
First time in a while a move has been mooted for Wilf where I wouldn't begrudge him going.
Not because I wouldn't miss him! Far from it! He's just had his best season with us.
BUT Roma is not an English club and would be exciting for him and we would get some sort of fee for him later on in his career.
AND, as others have mentioned, we have quite a few good wide options (though Wilf is the best of them). Even Eduoard.
BUT Loss of a leader and our leading goalscorer. He has spearheaded every Palace team he has played for from the promotion season onwards. Can Eze or Olise fill in? Realistically? I suppose Wilf can't play forever.
I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.
|
daven Hailsham 08 Jul 22 6.17pm |
|
|
If this is true, then I wish him all the best.He deserves a chance at another club and right now with the young talent that we have I couldn't think of a better time to cah in on him.
|