You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Release Academy Players
November 16 2026 3.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace Release Academy Players


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Jun 22 6.47am

Some well known names touted for a first team spot have been released.

[Link]

 


One more point

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 11 Jun 22 7.32am

Saw that and it got me thinking about the value and/or direction of the academy. I'm instinctively pro the academy, the idea of harvesting and nurturing the best talent in South London etc, but is it working?
Recently you would only point to AWB and Mitchell, the later with some input from Brentford. I thought Rak-Sakyi's debut was ok. Genuinely ok. Needs to beef up a bit to survive the rigors of Premier League football.
So if we're going the academy route lets do some things differently. We need to loan out smarter, even at the risk of the finishing position of the Academy teams. Say send a player to Sutton free of charge, where we can monitor easily. Yes try and follow the Chelsea model at a lower level, although I think we are a long way off that at the moment. Give the Academy one place on the bench, now there will be 5 substitutes.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 11 Jun 22 7.52am

Good luck to them all and hopefully they find new clubs.

I feel especially sorry for Luke Dreher who was on the verges of the first team at one stage but unfortunately injuries had ruined his chances to progress with us.

I know Sean Robertson was highly rated also at one point but again injuries curtailed his play time.

I’m sure Nya Kirby won’t be short of takers.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 11 Jun 22 12.43pm

Originally posted by cROYdonrogers

Saw that and it got me thinking about the value and/or direction of the academy. I'm instinctively pro the academy, the idea of harvesting and nurturing the best talent in South London etc, but is it working?
Recently you would only point to AWB and Mitchell, the later with some input from Brentford. I thought Rak-Sakyi's debut was ok. Genuinely ok. Needs to beef up a bit to survive the rigors of Premier League football.
So if we're going the academy route lets do some things differently. We need to loan out smarter, even at the risk of the finishing position of the Academy teams. Say send a player to Sutton free of charge, where we can monitor easily. Yes try and follow the Chelsea model at a lower level, although I think we are a long way off that at the moment. Give the Academy one place on the bench, now there will be 5 substitutes.

You're never really going to get more than a couple of first-team prospects in each batch of kids coming through - the fact we can point to AWB and Mitchell in the last few years is amazing... how many clubs have sold an academy graduate for £50m in recent years? And how many have another graduate as one of the first name's on the team sheet?

We're going well - Adaramola and JRS look to be the next up, and the current U18 squad seems to be particularly strong... I think there's 4 or 5 of them who've represented England at various youth levels.

The future is bright!

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 11 Jun 22 1.36pm

Also in the grand scheme of things the Academy is still a fledgling operation, for sure it will evolve as each season passes.

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You're never really going to get more than a couple of first-team prospects in each batch of kids coming through - the fact we can point to AWB and Mitchell in the last few years is amazing... how many clubs have sold an academy graduate for £50m in recent years? And how many have another graduate as one of the first name's on the team sheet?

We're going well - Adaramola and JRS look to be the next up, and the current U18 squad seems to be particularly strong... I think there's 4 or 5 of them who've represented England at various youth levels.

The future is bright!

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 11 Jun 22 5.47pm

Two names there which were highly rated at one time

Dreher who was seriously unlucky with injuries.

Kirby who had chances to shine whilst out on loan, but never seemed to to fulfill potential.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Jun 22 6.56pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Two names there which were highly rated at one time

Dreher who was seriously unlucky with injuries.

Kirby who had chances to shine whilst out on loan, but never seemed to to fulfill potential.


Was part of that England U17 World Cup winning squad along the likes of Sancho, Foden, Gallagher, Hudson-Odoi, Smith-Rowe, Guehi and a few others.

Just shows how quickly things can change for a youngster. I remember watching Kirby in one of last season's pre=season matches and thinking 'he hasn't got what it takes for the PL'. Clearly, the club have taken the same view.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 12 Jun 22 11.00am

I don't know how old those players being released are, but once you are getting close to being too old for the Under 23s then you are reaching a crossroads. Unless you are a genuine clear prospect for inclusion in the senior squad then there is no option but to move them on.

I wish them well.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 12 Jun 22 3.28pm

At the risk of boring people by repeating a point I've made before, there simply isn't an amount of money, a set of facilities, a standard of staff or an organisational strategy any club can use that overcomes the bald facts of the profession: Very, very few youth prospects make it. Look at how many international youth tournament winners end up not even being professional footballers.

The numbers alone dictate constant rejection of youth players. You give your senior left back a five year deal. Meanwhile, you have a left back in each of your youth teams from u14 up to u18. At the end of each of the next five years you have to decide if the oldest youth team left back is likely to be better than the senior man. People talk about creating a 'pathway' but even if the club sell the senior left back and give the u18 player a chance, you'd end up either replacing that same player a year later with the next upcoming youth player, or releasing that next upcoming youth player. One way or another, there can never be enough job opportunities for the number of youth products, even if only because the lifespan of a professional contract covers the same period in which four or five youth players reach the end of the development process.

The vast majority of players on the list will have known for a long time that they weren't going to be professional footballers. They are kept on because the one or two that might have a chance need another twelve or thirteen blokes around them in order to play matches.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 12 Jun 22 7.50pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

At the risk of boring people by repeating a point I've made before, there simply isn't an amount of money, a set of facilities, a standard of staff or an organisational strategy any club can use that overcomes the bald facts of the profession: Very, very few youth prospects make it. Look at how many international youth tournament winners end up not even being professional footballers.

The numbers alone dictate constant rejection of youth players. You give your senior left back a five year deal. Meanwhile, you have a left back in each of your youth teams from u14 up to u18. At the end of each of the next five years you have to decide if the oldest youth team left back is likely to be better than the senior man. People talk about creating a 'pathway' but even if the club sell the senior left back and give the u18 player a chance, you'd end up either replacing that same player a year later with the next upcoming youth player, or releasing that next upcoming youth player. One way or another, there can never be enough job opportunities for the number of youth products, even if only because the lifespan of a professional contract covers the same period in which four or five youth players reach the end of the development process.

The vast majority of players on the list will have known for a long time that they weren't going to be professional footballers. They are kept on because the one or two that might have a chance need another twelve or thirteen blokes around them in order to play matches.


This is key. If our policy was to let every player go at 18 who wasn't going to make it we wouldn't be able to field a team. It sounds harsh, but many of the players will be going through the motions, at the minute to keep JRS and TA playing and progressing.

 

Norway Flag Sandnes,Norway 13 Jun 22 11.33am

Today Manchester City signed a young Norwegian - his father Alfi Haaland signed for City 22 years ago. Alfie was part of an excellent youth team (the same for his son a few decades later) I remember one of Alfies trainers told me: When I looked at the group as 16 years old I would never have thought Alfie Haaland would make it - many in the team had much more talent than him. But he was the one who trained hardest and worked hardest - making him a pro in England for a decade. Nobody thought that was possible when he played for the youth teams.

My point is - too much talent who shines early often lack the hard work which make the really good players. And the Haalands are definitly among them.
So let us encourage the young Palace players to keep working hard!

 


Norway

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Jun 22 12.01pm

I remember a story from harry rednap when at Tottenham about frank lampard kicking balls at goal in all weather at all hours. I can’t remember what player wasn’t signed instead but harry said there and then that frank would get to the top.
Too right he did. Much as he’s now a bit of a dinlow frank certainly was a great player.
Point being it’s not the most skilful who actually make it as the poster said.

Oops I think it was West Ham

Edited by cryrst (13 Jun 2022 8.16pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 13 Jun 22 12.40pm

Originally posted by Norway

Today Manchester City signed a young Norwegian - his father Alfi Haaland signed for City 22 years ago. Alfie was part of an excellent youth team (the same for his son a few decades later) I remember one of Alfies trainers told me: When I looked at the group as 16 years old I would never have thought Alfie Haaland would make it - many in the team had much more talent than him. But he was the one who trained hardest and worked hardest - making him a pro in England for a decade. Nobody thought that was possible when he played for the youth teams.

My point is - too much talent who shines early often lack the hard work which make the really good players. And the Haalands are definitly among them.
So let us encourage the young Palace players to keep working hard!

Good point, many of my friends from school went to Torquay along with Lee Sharpe. They were much better footballers - we beat his school team 19-0 and 0-11. That's what we were like. However, Sharpe worked hard, washed the kits, cleaned the boots. My mates wasted their talent. They play non league and Sunday league - even to this day. But look at where working hard got Sharpe. He wasn't that highly rated. (I still don't like him).

 


Red and Blue Army!

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 13 Jun 22 7.42pm

theres so many kids to reach a level then go backwards , alot to do with attitude and willing to work hard , let anyone of them drop and you are out , the wake up call is being rejected some come back in lower lges others end up working for a living ,

I played against many good players who just enjoyed playing drinking and women , these was good enough to play a very high standard , then you get the martin Robinsons good but nothing special and played for spurs back in the 70s , i marked him out the 3 games i played against him I was 15 he was 16 , so goes to show if you work hard you get there

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jun 22 7.56pm

You will meet very bright people on building sites and some dumb ones at universities.

Not on scale but it happens.

Talent alone isn't going to guarantee success in any area, and the larger the pool and competition the harder it gets.

Luck, opportunity and hard work make up more of a percentage of success in life than most aren't that keen to ponder on. Putting in the hours and neglecting your leisure time to better yourself is no joke and most aren't willing to be hardcore on that.

However those realities can't make up for talent....if you aren't good enough no amount of striving is going to get you there.

For me Kevin Keegan is a good example.....he had the talent but his drive to be as good as he could be made him the player he became.

There would have been many 'Keegans' who turned out to be also rans.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Jun 22 11.43pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You will meet very bright people on building sites and some dumb ones at universities.

Not on scale but it happens.

Talent alone isn't going to guarantee success in any area, and the larger the pool and competition the harder it gets.

Luck, opportunity and hard work make up more of a percentage of success in life than most aren't that keen to ponder on. Putting in the hours and neglecting your leisure time to better yourself is no joke and most aren't willing to be hardcore on that.

However those realities can't make up for talent....if you aren't good enough no amount of striving is going to get you there.

For me Kevin Keegan is a good example.....he had the talent but his drive to be as good as he could be made him the player he became.

There would have been many 'Keegans' who turned out to be also rans.

A good example of your talent line are snooker or darts.
You either can or can’t. Practice will get you so far but if you have the knack then it’s just there. This could broaden out to education and learning. We all did times tables and writing skills but inevitably if you can do maths or have writing ability then you just have it. I find this could be the problem with schools and kids as getting bored by being forced to do something you just can’t do will only go one way. That’s for another thread though so apologies for deviating but my examples.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 14 Jun 22 10.47am

I've no doubt that Within the fraction of human beings capable of being top-class professional footballers, hard work and dedication can make the difference between success and failure. At Palace alone we've seen plenty who had the ability, the opportunity, but not the attitude and ended up out of football altogether at 25, having played a handful of premier league/championship games as a teenager.

At the same time, almost every case of a once very good schoolboy footballer who swears he could have made it if not for women/beer/smoking/attitude problems is probably to be treated with scepticism, even if the guy propping up the bar and telling his story was actually really good once.

There are hundreds of thousands of really, very, seriously good young players up and down the land, but very few end up good enough no matter how hard they try. I watched Michael Antonio playing for Tooting and Mitcham in the Ryman League once. Antonio was still a kid really (albeit a big one) playing against tough, experienced men, but he instantly made all 21 other plays look like they were moving in slow motion. And I mean that literally; it was like an optical illusion.

Being talented enough to be a top-class pro isn't a super-power, but usually, they stand out amongst the general population, and even amongst the better players in the general population like a sore thumb.

The idea that X made it because he wanted it more, or his face fitted, or whatever is not likely to be true, in my experience.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Jun 22 2.05pm

Originally posted by cryrst

A good example of your talent line are snooker or darts.
You either can or can’t. Practice will get you so far but if you have the knack then it’s just there. This could broaden out to education and learning. We all did times tables and writing skills but inevitably if you can do maths or have writing ability then you just have it. I find this could be the problem with schools and kids as getting bored by being forced to do something you just can’t do will only go one way. That’s for another thread though so apologies for deviating but my examples.

I once had some sixth formers tell me that if someone dedicated themselves enough they could reach Einstein standard in maths.

I tried to nicely tell them that dedication at the top was a given but that it doesn't quite work like that.....but I think some teacher or other had convinced them.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Jun 22 2.10pm

Originally posted by cryrst

A good example of your talent line are snooker or darts.
You either can or can’t. Practice will get you so far but if you have the knack then it’s just there. This could broaden out to education and learning. We all did times tables and writing skills but inevitably if you can do maths or have writing ability then you just have it. I find this could be the problem with schools and kids as getting bored by being forced to do something you just can’t do will only go one way. That’s for another thread though so apologies for deviating but my examples.

I loved that World Championship where Ronnie didn't play for a year then rocked up and won it. Unbelievable, only he could have done that.

 


Red and Blue Army!

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Jun 22 4.33pm

Talent, hard work and luck and sometimes just having the right physique are all important, but still the chances of making it as top-flight player are almost zero. What is becoming common is for players to have a career playing in lesser leagues across Europe (like here in Malta) where they can still earn a wage playing football, it's just more in line with us mortals.

Listening to Mark Bright in the commentary for U23 games is often quite insightful about where our youth players are at. Hopefully one or two get their chance in preseason to impress as I think most of us love it when a youth player does make the grade.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Release Academy Players