You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Andy Madley
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Andy Madley


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
The Dolphin Flag 04 Jan 23 7.34am

Apparently he had a shocker at the Emirates last night and that on top of a poor game when he refereed the Fulham game on Boxing Day at Selhurst Park.
How do these - sometimes - incompetent referees get away with this kind of performance?
One hopes that he will be dropped to the Championship for a few weeks.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 23 9.13am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Apparently he had a shocker at the Emirates last night and that on top of a poor game when he refereed the Fulham game on Boxing Day at Selhurst Park.
How do these - sometimes - incompetent referees get away with this kind of performance?
One hopes that he will be dropped to the Championship for a few weeks.

I witnessed the game and I don't recognise this description of his performance.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Jan 23 9.17am

Originally posted by Willo

I witnessed the game and I don't recognise this description of his performance.

No surprises there! Reading the reports you appear to be the only one ( oh and smug Eddie)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 23 9.26am

Originally posted by Spiderman

No surprises there! Reading the reports you appear to be the only one ( oh and smug Eddie)

To be honest I have not perused any reports, I watched the game on the television.

 

The Dolphin Flag 04 Jan 23 9.56am

I didn't watch the game which is why I said apparently.
9 yellow cards in a game that didn't seem to be that bad?
One penalty which obviously was a penalty - var backed him I might add - but he should be seeing this stuff.
Against Fulham he was as biased as can be and while Mitchell deserved to be sent off, he just couldn't wait to send Tomkpins off for what was not a yellow card offence.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 23 10.11am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I didn't watch the game which is why I said apparently.
9 yellow cards in a game that didn't seem to be that bad?
One penalty which obviously was a penalty - var backed him I might add - but he should be seeing this stuff.
Against Fulham he was as biased as can be and while Mitchell deserved to be sent off, he just couldn't wait to send Tomkpins off for what was not a yellow card offence.

I have heard the argument when a number of 'Yellows' are issued that "It wasn't a dirty game" etc etc.Suffice to say not every 'Yellow' is issued for a robust challenge etc etc !

I certainly do not accept the charge of "Biased" in the Fulham game, he made decisions based on his professional judgement.
I strongly suspect that if one of our players had been on the end of the Mitchell tackle and the opponent was not red-carded the referee would have faced animus.Similarly if one of our players was blocked off when running in the direction of the goal and the opponent was not issued with a Yellow, the referee would have been severely criticised by our supporters.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 04 Jan 23 10.19am

I watched the last half hour of the Arsenal game and thought he was fine. Newcastle were doing everything possible to waste time and it riled Arteta up who lost his rag - there was a lot of cynical play in the game - hence why most of the bookings were forwards. The handball is never a penalty, he got that right, and the shirt pull should have been a penalty but that falls onto the VAR official - it's always going to be difficult for a referee on the pitch to see every interaction between players in the box at a free kick. The first time I watched it I knew there was a decision to be made from the free kick and even still the first I saw of it was Gabriel on the floor.

On the Fulham game, the Mitchell one is a red card; the first Tomkins one is an unquestionable booking; and the second Tomkins one is naive - he's stepped into Mitrovic with no intention of playing the ball and raised his arm. He knows enough of Mitrovic to know he'll go down and make the most of it and whether it was a booking or not, it's a really silly thing to do on a yellow. Personally, as someone sat close to it, I thought he was going to get booked the second he did it. The frustration out of the Fulham game is that we were crap.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

taylors lovechild Flag 04 Jan 23 10.36am

Originally posted by ambrose7

I watched the last half hour of the Arsenal game and thought he was fine. Newcastle were doing everything possible to waste time and it riled Arteta up who lost his rag - there was a lot of cynical play in the game - hence why most of the bookings were forwards. The handball is never a penalty, he got that right, and the shirt pull should have been a penalty but that falls onto the VAR official - it's always going to be difficult for a referee on the pitch to see every interaction between players in the box at a free kick. The first time I watched it I knew there was a decision to be made from the free kick and even still the first I saw of it was Gabriel on the floor.

On the Fulham game, the Mitchell one is a red card; the first Tomkins one is an unquestionable booking; and the second Tomkins one is naive - he's stepped into Mitrovic with no intention of playing the ball and raised his arm. He knows enough of Mitrovic to know he'll go down and make the most of it and whether it was a booking or not, it's a really silly thing to do on a yellow. Personally, as someone sat close to it, I thought he was going to get booked the second he did it. The frustration out of the Fulham game is that we were crap.

I thought Madley was fine last night too. Newcastle did everything to make the game as ugly as their fans and Arsenal struggled to break them down. Arsenal should have had a penalty for Dan Burns' attempt to remove Gabriel's shirt, but for some reason VAR thought that was ok?! Last night was a good example of why a more accurate added time should be given though (like in the World Cup). Newcastle were so cynical in their time wasting from about the hour mark onwards.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 04 Jan 23 10.58am

Originally posted by Willo

I have heard the argument when a number of 'Yellows' are issued that "It wasn't a dirty game" etc etc.Suffice to say not every 'Yellow' is issued for a robust challenge etc etc !

I certainly do not accept the charge of "Biased" in the Fulham game, he made decisions based on his professional judgement.
I strongly suspect that if one of our players had been on the end of the Mitchell tackle and the opponent was not red-carded the referee would have faced animus.Similarly if one of our players was blocked off when running in the direction of the goal and the opponent was not issued with a Yellow, the referee would have been severely criticised by our supporters.

I thought he had a pretty bad game for us against Fulham. Not for the Mitchell sending off but for his general demeanour. If you watch the game back you’ll see a lot of inconsistency in decisions which is what happened last night.

I don’t think he is bias in the same way the the idiot Clattenburg appeared to be, in my opinion. I’m just not convinced he’s good enough. Still at least he also doesn’t kiss arse like MC used to.

 

Robk Flag 04 Jan 23 11.57am

He is one of the worst Referee’s.... terrible against Fulham and again last night...

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 23 11.57am

Originally posted by Helmet46

I thought he had a pretty bad game for us against Fulham. Not for the Mitchell sending off but for his general demeanour. If you watch the game back you’ll see a lot of inconsistency in decisions which is what happened last night.

I don’t think he is bias in the same way the the idiot Clattenburg appeared to be, in my opinion. I’m just not convinced he’s good enough. Still at least he also doesn’t kiss arse like MC used to.

Mark was not biased towards any team he made decisions based on his professional judgement.

I have no more comment to make on any sentiments raised on here apropos Mark as the discussion will only disintegrate into a dastardly Willo thread.Forgive me if do not respond.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 04 Jan 23 12.26pm

He is an awful referee, thought that long before Fulham.

Fact is, most are. There are two huge problems in my very, very humble opinion:

1. Supply and demand I guess - just how prolific is the refereeing profession in this country? It's got to be a million miles off of that for footballers. It's not as if everyone dreams of becoming a referee when young and therefore the competition for becoming a qualified referee is high and only the creme de la creme make it through.

2. The 'rules' as they now are. They've been analysed, further convoluted, distorted and become somewhat bonkers. I do feel sorry for referees these days as were I in that seat, I wouldn't have a clue as to what was supposed to be done in various situations. We all know what the rules should be and, despite subjectivity, what would constitute common sense in the game but it's all over the shop now and quite often deviates from common sense/ubiquitous understanding of the game.

I always like to think there's a really formal, professional system for PL referees however my suspicion is a lot of them are still that kid at school, who couldn't even play on the playground, probably supported United and therefore the only way they could be involved was reffing. A slight delusion of grandeur, little understanding of football from a playing/attending perspective and probably quite thick too - Madeley brothers.

Edited by Nicholas91 (04 Jan 2023 12.27pm)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

YT Flag Oxford 04 Jan 23 12.31pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Apparently he had a shocker at the Emirates last night and that on top of a poor game when he refereed the Fulham game on Boxing Day at Selhurst Park.
How do these - sometimes - incompetent referees get away with this kind of performance?
One hopes that he will be dropped to the Championship for a few weeks.

Truly; Madley - Deeply worrying.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 04 Jan 23 12.34pm

Originally posted by YT

Truly; Madley - Deeply worrying.

Rather savage, from your garden

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

crystal-purley Flag Purley 04 Jan 23 12.36pm

Originally posted by Willo

Mark was not biased towards any team he made decisions based on his professional judgement.

I have no more comment to make on any sentiments raised on here apropos Mark as the discussion will only disintegrate into a dastardly Willo thread.Forgive me if do not respond.

"Mark" has since admitted he was wrong

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 04 Jan 23 12.49pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

He is an awful referee, thought that long before Fulham.

Fact is, most are. There are two huge problems in my very, very humble opinion:

1. Supply and demand I guess - just how prolific is the refereeing profession in this country? It's got to be a million miles off of that for footballers. It's not as if everyone dreams of becoming a referee when young and therefore the competition for becoming a qualified referee is high and only the creme de la creme make it through.

2. The 'rules' as they now are. They've been analysed, further convoluted, distorted and become somewhat bonkers. I do feel sorry for referees these days as were I in that seat, I wouldn't have a clue as to what was supposed to be done in various situations. We all know what the rules should be and, despite subjectivity, what would constitute common sense in the game but it's all over the shop now and quite often deviates from common sense/ubiquitous understanding of the game.

I always like to think there's a really formal, professional system for PL referees however my suspicion is a lot of them are still that kid at school, who couldn't even play on the playground, probably supported United and therefore the only way they could be involved was reffing. A slight delusion of grandeur, little understanding of football from a playing/attending perspective and probably quite thick too - Madeley brothers.

Edited by Nicholas91 (04 Jan 2023 12.27pm)

Phew, where to start . . .

So, without making an 'eagleman' thread i agree with your 2 points although 'common sense' for refs went out the window years ago, FIFA barred it. As for your last paragragh, you are so off the mark, some of us could & have played, i turned to reffing as injury scuppered any chance i had of making it as a footballer. I worked hard to get to the level i attained, you wouldn't believe how the 'County' biased system works it takes a lot of who you know, not what.

When i retired from reffing in the EFL i was invited to become an assessor, which opened my eyes up to what was then being asked & required by refs to 'make it' further up the ladder. Back then we were ALL amateurs only getting paid match fees & expensives. One of my guilty secrets, is now i can scream & hurl abuse at a refs decision knowing ive been there, done that & had the black eyes & cut lips from players & fans alike

Until FIFA change & it is FIFA not the FA/EPL/EFL nothing will satisfy the average fan who goes week in week out, then down the pub etc & along with their mates say how crap their team was/is, the ref was a biased cnut & as for the 'lino' . . . Well.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 04 Jan 23 1.54pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Phew, where to start . . .

So, without making an 'eagleman' thread i agree with your 2 points although 'common sense' for refs went out the window years ago, FIFA barred it. As for your last paragragh, you are so off the mark, some of us could & have played, i turned to reffing as injury scuppered any chance i had of making it as a footballer. I worked hard to get to the level i attained, you wouldn't believe how the 'County' biased system works it takes a lot of who you know, not what.

When i retired from reffing in the EFL i was invited to become an assessor, which opened my eyes up to what was then being asked & required by refs to 'make it' further up the ladder. Back then we were ALL amateurs only getting paid match fees & expensives. One of my guilty secrets, is now i can scream & hurl abuse at a refs decision knowing ive been there, done that & had the black eyes & cut lips from players & fans alike

Until FIFA change & it is FIFA not the FA/EPL/EFL nothing will satisfy the average fan who goes week in week out, then down the pub etc & along with their mates say how crap their team was/is, the ref was a biased cnut & as for the 'lino' . . . Well.

In all fairness Eagleman, I don't think I am 'off the mark'.

The number of 'I could have...' people in this country is staggering. For an anecdote, I was actually scouted by WHU and on the books/played a number of games but broke my arm quite badly whilst playing for Lewisham district, that ended all hope. I would never consider myself as coming that close, quite frankly my PE teacher at school also doubled up as a WHU scout and therefore I was quite fortunate in the first instance. I was the greatest footballer of all time of course however, life, you know.

As for your point apropos bias, I believe this backs up my poorly articulated point and have no problem accepting your commentary as truth. Same with footballers actually. Jamie Redknapp, Frank Lampard etc. etc. The list of footballing dynasties is quite long and I fail to believe that is a genetics and merit over connections 'thing' in fact quite the opposite.

I did say 'I am suspicious' so as not to put forth my little world view as an assertion of fact, it's just how it looks for me. I was sort of alluding to a quasi-cabal of referees, hence both the Madleys being one. That can't just be coincidence/free of other contributors separate from ability. That was sort of my point really, on top of the pool being a lot smaller, I fail to believe it is a pure meritocracy that resultantly produces PL referees.

Combined with poor leadership from governing bodies and a now impractical lawbook, I have very little faith in most PL referees. I therefore reject your attempt to nullify my highly subjective, ill-informed, immature, impetuous digs and belittlement of them! That is my right as a football fan

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

silvertop Flag Portishead 04 Jan 23 2.25pm

Originally posted by Willo

I witnessed the game and I don't recognise this description of his performance.

I do. As does everyone else who are not predisposed to deference to any authority figure.

I don't think either sending off was technically bad in the Fulham game but many refs would have given Tomkins a final warning and nod to the dugout to take him off.

He is very card happy and last night appeared to be in little control

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 04 Jan 23 2.30pm

Originally posted by crystal-purley

"Mark" has since admitted he was wrong

The Cheif Ref said he was wrong at the time. Said he was overwhelmed by the event or similar. Didn't seem to bother him when he refed the Euro and ECL finals weeks later.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 23 2.42pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I do. As does everyone else who are not predisposed to deference to any authority figure.

I don't think either sending off was technically bad in the Fulham game but many refs would have given Tomkins a final warning and nod to the dugout to take him off.

He is very card happy and last night appeared to be in little control

My comments are not borne out of any deference but merely an honest evaluation which of course others are free to challenge.

Apropos Tomkins, I do not share the view that many referees would have given him a warning - In my opinion a yellow was the correct decision.
Given his performance perhaps he was relieved to be given his marching orders !

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Andy Madley