You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Don’t abuse the Manager !
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Don’t abuse the Manager !


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Jan 23 11.58pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

A la Lanzo:

GK: Guaita/Johnstone

RB: New
CB: Guehi
CB: Andersen
LB: New

CM: New
CM: Doucoure
CAM: Eze

LW: Zaha
CF: Mateta/Edouard/New
RW: Olise

Right on. Now just show us the money.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Jan 23 12.02am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

That’s back to back shockers at home, but I don't think Vieria is getting anything terribly wrong when it comes to team selection and tactics. If he was playing the goalie upfront and the striker at right-back then fair enough, but otherwise these things are (firstly) a matter of opinion -and opinions are a bit like arseholes, we've all got one- and (secondly) a far smaller part of any particular result than modern football likes to accept.

English football clubs have moved away from Managers whose work should be judged in the long term, to Coaches, who have a ‘Philosophy’. This may variously involve playing with a high line, or a deep block, or a false nine, or maybe even one of the players laying down behind the defensive wall at free kicks, but either way, tactics and team selections seem to have gone from being a method of trying to achieve medium-to-long term targets to being the decisive factor in specific results. Once, it was only ever players that were held responsible for their performances on a match-by-match basis, whilst the manager was assessed over the long term. Now Liverpool vs Man City is somehow Klopp's tactics played out against Guardiolas, the players simply chess pieces.

This seems to suit the clubs (who preach about stability but actually want a ‘panic’ button to press if relegation looms), the players (who take less and less responsibility for their clubs fortunes with every passing year), the ‘Coaches’ themselves (who get work on the basis that they can and will offer an instant fix), and of course the fans (who now need someone to blame, not for the medium to long term fate of their club, but for each and every bad result).

It wasn’t Vieria who gave the ball away for the second goal, and then stood there watching Kane in oceans of space. Clyne and Anderson getting turned inside out like a pair of socks for the third goal has nothing to do with tactics. Should it really be up to the coaching staff to tell Anderson and Guehi not to get lost under a high ball as they both managed to do for the fourth goal? In what set of tactics is that anything other than simply awful play from them?

As for criticisms that the club is unlikely to spend big this January, I can only advise typing the following into a search engine: ‘CPFC Published Accounts’, ‘FFP’, ‘Reality’.

That won’t show shareholders pockets, how deep they are and how keen they are to spend on CPFC.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 06 Jan 23 3.32am

The bournemouth win didn't fool me, sure we scored two... but it was not the performance I wanted after Fulham. We should have demolished them, how spurs demolished us, heck Bournemouth didn't even register a shot until 85th minute.

It's going to a long, cold, lonely January.

 


This was once a quality forum....

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 06 Jan 23 7.20am

Watch out sounds like some are suggesting that issues sit above PV and rest with the board.

It is forbidden to speak badly of the glorious leader Mr Parish and if you do you will be derided and informed that he is the saviour beyond reproach.

But we are now seeing results of years of underinvestment coming home to haunt us. Years of poor buys, players who have never and would never play for the club, years of keeping players well past their sell by date, years of chasing a costly vanity project in a new stand.

We now have overseas shareholders who rightly want value from their investments

I might dare to suggest things are looking a bit grim ATM.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 06 Jan 23 7.59am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Could you not just say I agree


Why use two words when you can use plenty?

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 06 Jan 23 8.12am

Originally posted by doombear


Why use two words when you can use plenty?

Cost of speaking crisis

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Jan 23 8.25am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Watch out sounds like some are suggesting that issues sit above PV and rest with the board.

It is forbidden to speak badly of the glorious leader Mr Parish and if you do you will be derided and informed that he is the saviour beyond reproach.

But we are now seeing results of years of underinvestment coming home to haunt us. Years of poor buys, players who have never and would never play for the club, years of keeping players well past their sell by date, years of chasing a costly vanity project in a new stand.

We now have overseas shareholders who rightly want value from their investments

I might dare to suggest things are looking a bit grim ATM.

How many other clubs, that have been in administration twice in the last 25 years and are in our position of 10 years in the Premier. There are plenty of ex big clubs that would love to be in our position.
It’s no point saying the board should invest more, it’s a business and just pouring in money isn’t viable, as clubs need to be sustainable and we have been down the route of pouring in money and ended up skint.
The issue lies in recruitment, we just don’t appear to be picking up players in Europe that can fit into the first team. Teams like Brentford, Fulham and Brighton seem to do it regularly

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Jan 23 8.31am

Originally posted by Painter

How many other clubs, that have been in administration twice in the last 25 years and are in our position of 10 years in the Premier. There are plenty of ex big clubs that would love to be in our position.
It’s no point saying the board should invest more, it’s a business and just pouring in money isn’t viable, as clubs need to be sustainable and we have been down the route of pouring in money and ended up skint.
The issue lies in recruitment, we just don’t appear to be picking up players in Europe that can fit into the first team. Teams like Brentford, Fulham and Brighton seem to do it regularly

[Link]

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 06 Jan 23 9.23am

Originally posted by Painter

How many other clubs, that have been in administration twice in the last 25 years and are in our position of 10 years in the Premier. There are plenty of ex big clubs that would love to be in our position.
It’s no point saying the board should invest more, it’s a business and just pouring in money isn’t viable, as clubs need to be sustainable and we have been down the route of pouring in money and ended up skint.
The issue lies in recruitment, we just don’t appear to be picking up players in Europe that can fit into the first team. Teams like Brentford, Fulham and Brighton seem to do it regularly

I knew someone would bite! Didn't take long...&#128516;

I agree it's how you do things but as a counter to what you say the model upon which the club is run now is light years away from the model of one rich but often flawed owner/supporter which led twice to hearts ruling heads and administrators being appointed.

Some of this issue does lie at the feet of the owners as they run the place.

 

NE14T Flag 06 Jan 23 9.28am

I think we all feel sorry for Doucoure not being given any support in centre of park. Schlupp, PV’s favourite just seems to run up and down with little composure or reading of the game. It beggars belief that Hughes is not given a chance to start next to Doucoure but I’m sick of saying it.

We also need an owner who will invest some money in the team. I could be wrong but Parish doesn’t seem to have much non club related money and our US friends seem distracted with buying other clubs rather than making one good/great.

Edited by NE14T (06 Jan 2023 9.38am)

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 06 Jan 23 9.36am

Have always liked Hughes and don't see why he has not beed given more of a shout. Can't remember him letting us down when he has come on.

We miss Jimmy Mac more than I think some people see as he was a leader and reads a game far better than most at the club.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Jan 23 9.39am

Originally posted by NE14T

I think we all feel sorry for Doucoure not being given any support in centre of park. Schlupp, PV’s favourite just seems to run up and down with little composure or reading of the game. It beggars belief that Hughes is not given a chance to start next to Doucoure but I’m sick of saying it.

I understand the clamour for the inclusion of Hughes but when I look at the player I see someone who doesn't have that burst of pace, is a tad one-paced and his overall mobility is called into question. I do however recognise his technical and passing abilities.
I have a 'Feeling in my water' that Hughes will start tomorrow.
Hughes was Marco Silva's first signing at Watford.

Edited by Willo (06 Jan 2023 9.45am)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 06 Jan 23 10.07am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

No. But it makes you wonder why he left.

Chance to play in PL? Playing fir French icon PV? More money?

 

eaglesdare Flag 06 Jan 23 10.17am

Tomorrow Hughes will play and everyone will see why he doesn't play as often as people think he should!

 

NE14T Flag 06 Jan 23 10.43am

Ok but if Hughes does start let’s be fair and judge him on any improved cohesion and structure he brings to the team hopefully giving us better solidity in midfield and also allowing our flair players like Olise, Zaha and Eze to get more attacking opportunities.

I also think he’d provide a better outlet or bridge for our defenders to find which has been shaky in the last few games leading to lost possession or Anderson hoofing it long as the only viable option.

Let’s see.

Edited by NE14T (06 Jan 2023 10.44am)

Edited by NE14T (06 Jan 2023 10.49am)

Edited by NE14T (06 Jan 2023 11.04am)

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Jan 23 10.56am

PV is only half way through his second season as a Premier League manager.

In the time he has been at Palace he has ;

Overseen a radical change in playing style
Integrated new signings in the summer of 2021
Lost three midfield players in Gallagher, MacArthur and Kouyate
Not had the backing in the transfer market to improve a very average squad

Yes, he’s made mistakes. And of course his team selections and tactics are challenged by supporters who think they know better. That’s the same at every club.

I’ve been disappointed with some of his decisions of late, but overall I think he’s doing a good job given the constraints under which he works.

He needs our support now more than ever because we have a tough few weeks ahead.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 06 Jan 23 11.44am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

I have always liked Hughes and don't see why he has not beed given more of a shout. Can't remember him letting us down when he has come on.

We miss Jimmy Mac more than I think some people see as he was a leader and reads a game far better than most at the club.


Did watch 2nd half Chelsea vs Man City last night. If Vieira sticks with Schlupp and Eze in midfield at Stamford Bridge, we will endure 90 hurtful minutes.
I would like to see Hughes and Luka (yes, the captain) together with Doucoure. On top Zaha, Maeta and Olise.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Jan 23 12.37pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

I knew someone would bite! Didn't take long...&#128516;

I agree it's how you do things but as a counter to what you say the model upon which the club is run now is light years away from the model of one rich but often flawed owner/supporter which led twice to hearts ruling heads and administrators being appointed.

Some of this issue does lie at the feet of the owners as they run the place.

The issue of our most sustained run in the Premier is down to the owners.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 06 Jan 23 12.41pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle


Did watch 2nd half Chelsea vs Man City last night. If Vieira sticks with Schlupp and Eze in midfield at Stamford Bridge, we will endure 90 hurtful minutes.
I would like to see Hughes and Luka (yes, the captain) together with Doucoure. On top Zaha, Maeta and Olise.

AS much as I hate to agree to any plan that contain Luka, I'm tempted to agree.

Chelsea are poor up top, but strong in CM. The key with them is not getting over run.

 

The Dolphin Flag 06 Jan 23 1.08pm

Luka playing will not be a disaster at all.
Put Doucoure and others in front of him and he will be fine.
Drop Eze though.
To be fair we could not be any worse in midfield than we are currently so it has got to be worth a try!

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Don’t abuse the Manager !