You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team
November 16 2026 3.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
rikz Flag Croydon 09 Jan 23 10.31am

Originally posted by Willo

Regulars Guaita,Ward,Clyne,Schlupp, Ayew and Zaha are in their 30s.
Milivojevic who has mostly been on the bench is in his 30s.
Tomkins who played against Fulham is in his mid-30s.
Overall we don't have a youthful squad !

How many of them were bought in the last 2 years ? Do you expect us to transform the whole squad in 2 transfer windows ?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Jan 23 10.38am

Originally posted by rikz

How many of them were bought in the last 2 years ? Do you expect us to transform the whole squad in 2 transfer windows ?

I was merely highlighting the fact that a number of players are in the twilight of their careers in response to a comment about a "Young team".

 

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Jan 23 12.57pm

Originally posted by Willo

Regulars Guaita,Ward,Clyne,Schlupp, Ayew and Zaha are in their 30s.
Milivojevic who has mostly been on the bench is in his 30s.
Tomkins who played against Fulham is in his mid-30s.
Overall we don't have a youthful squad !

Zaha, Clyne, Sclupp, Ayew are 30-31
Ward 33
Guaita 35 not unknown for a keeper.

In their 30s paints a different picture than saying they’re 30 years. You need a balance of experience and youth.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Jan 23 1.05pm

Originally posted by Painter

Zaha, Clyne, Sclupp, Ayew are 30-31
Ward 33
Guaita 35 not unknown for a keeper.

In their 30s paints a different picture than saying they’re 30 years. You need a balance of experience and youth.

With the greatest of respect the players you highlighted are in their 30s.You omitted Milivojevic who is also in his 30s as is Tomkins.

I accept the argument of an amalgam between experience and youth.
My sentiments were merely in response to comments about a "Young team", my words were not laced with any criticism.

Edited by Willo (09 Jan 2023 1.06pm)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 09 Jan 23 1.08pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the greatest of respect the players you highlighted are in their 30s.You omitted Milivojevic who is also in his 30s as is Tomkins.

I accept the argument of an amalgam between experience and youth.
My sentiments were merely in response to comments about a "Young team", my words were not laced with any criticism.

Edited by Willo (09 Jan 2023 1.06pm)

I think the issue is that we have players in their 30's that are past their best.

A blend of youth and experience is no bad thing, but of our senior players only Zaha cuts it regularly at this level.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

rikz Flag Croydon 09 Jan 23 1.45pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the greatest of respect the players you highlighted are in their 30s.You omitted Milivojevic who is also in his 30s as is Tomkins.

I accept the argument of an amalgam between experience and youth.
My sentiments were merely in response to comments about a "Young team", my words were not laced with any criticism.

Edited by Willo (09 Jan 2023 1.06pm)

Then you mention players in the squad, we have a pretty young team. Eduoard, olise, eze, doucoure, Mitchell, guehi, andersen, 7 outfield players who would start most games even mateta is young.

If we are going to sack the manager every time we have a bad spell we will go through about 6 managers a season.

 

YT Flag Oxford 09 Jan 23 1.45pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think the issue is that we have players in their 30's that are past their best.

A blend of youth and experience is no bad thing, but of our senior players only Zaha cuts it regularly at this level.

The other issue is that we have players NOT in their 30s that are past their best.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Jan 23 1.55pm

Originally posted by rikz

Then you mention players in the squad, we have a pretty young team. Eduoard, olise, eze, doucoure, Mitchell, guehi, andersen, 7 outfield players who would start most games even mateta is young.

If we are going to sack the manager every time we have a bad spell we will go through about 6 managers a season.

Of course there are young players in the team but based on my interpretation of the comments made by a member, I highlighted the fact that we have quite a number of players in their 30s and in the twilight of their careers.

For avoidance of doubt I repeat that at this juncture I see no justification in calling time on PVs tenure at our club.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Jan 23 2.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

Of course there are young players in the team but based on my interpretation of the comments made by a member, I highlighted the fact that we have quite a number of players in their 30s and in the twilight of their careers.

For avoidance of doubt I repeat that at this juncture I see no justification in calling time on PVs tenure at our club.

The blend of experience with youth is often seen as:

Wise, mentally strong, well drilled players + pace, flair and enthusiasm

It could, however, also be articulated as:

Physically inferior, disinterested, over the hill + Naive, shying from responsibility and tactically immature.

Has felt a lot like the latter of late.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Jan 23 2.16pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the greatest of respect the players you highlighted are in their 30s.You omitted Milivojevic who is also in his 30s as is Tomkins.

I accept the argument of an amalgam between experience and youth.
My sentiments were merely in response to comments about a "Young team", my words were not laced with any criticism.

Edited by Willo (09 Jan 2023 1.06pm)

You omitted McArthur, who is also in his 30s. I mentioned players that are regulars in the team, not squad fillers.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Jan 23 4.04pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the greatest of respect the players you highlighted are in their 30s.You omitted Milivojevic who is also in his 30s as is Tomkins.

I accept the argument of an amalgam between experience and youth.
My sentiments were merely in response to comments about a "Young team", my words were not laced with any criticism.

Edited by Willo (09 Jan 2023 1.06pm)


Perhaps we should distinguish between squad and team.
Over half the regulars are relative youngsters:
- Mitchell 23
- Guehi 21
- Andersen 26
- Olise 21
- Eze 24
- Doucoure 23 (birthday yesterday)
- Mateta 25
- Edouard 24 (25 next week)

7 of those 8 would usually form part of the starting 11. With Mitchell having been banned and Mateta and Edouard injured/unwell since the restart, the team has featured more older squad members than usual. As both Edouard and Mateta are now fit again, I expect one of them will start against Chelsea with the other coming on a sub at some point. Likewise, I would expect Mitchell will be back after his ban, and we will back to a relatively young 1st XI.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 10 Jan 23 12.28am

Originally posted by rikz

We prioritised bringing the average age of the squad down, we've got a young team, we are a midtable team in the strongest and most competitive league in the world. We will have poor runs and poor performances. Do you think we are going to play like City every week ?

We don't have a young team, we never played like city nor anyone expected us too.. nice deflect. Our performances have been piss poor - not good enough at all.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 10 Jan 23 12.29am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

To be fair to Vaibow and other posters - it is not about playing like City every week.
We have our own standards and our performances of late have fallen well below those standards.
Losing I can accept - it is the way that we lose that worries me.
PV was a combative midfield player with fire in his belly - that does not seem to be a directive given to some of our players.

spot on.

 


This was once a quality forum....

rikz Flag Croydon 10 Jan 23 6.25am

Originally posted by Vaibow

We don't have a young team, we never played like city nor anyone expected us too.. nice deflect. Our performances have been piss poor - not good enough at all.

Apart from 7 out of 10 outfield players who would usually start are on the right side of their 20's.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team