You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish verses Textor?
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish verses Textor?


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
dreamwaverider Flag London 20 Jan 23 10.55pm

From what I’ve researched, Eagle football owns 40% of the club, Harris and Blitzer 36% Parish 20% and 4% Franco.
What is unclear is how much money went into share purchases versus loans / contributions to the transfer fund.
I read recently that Eagle have put £20m into the transfer fund this month but I don’t know for sure.
I don’t think the Homesdale is too far out with its banners but I’m not really clear nor is anyone.
An ongoing issue in football is how much info on the running of a club do owners share with fans ? In most cases I’d say not a lot. The outcome is banners like in the Homesdale.
Fans v Owners. Always an awkward topic. I don’t think it’s smooth at most clubs and we are no exception.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Jan 23 11.16pm

It sounds from Textor's interview and statement about transfer targets (and "talent" that his main interest is making money from moving players. So testing players from France, Brazil and Belgium in the moneybags Premier League and getting some money back from the ones that come good ? Maybe dangling Champions League football at OL ?

Despite all the talk about percentage of ownership it's clear that the choice for us (in our heads) as fans is Steve Parish, academy and a club with local identity with occasional promotion to the Premier League (for however long it exists). Or a sugar daddy and corporate presence in the Premier League for longer but our fans turning into an entitled group who expect to win.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (20 Jan 2023 11.16pm)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 20 Jan 23 11.41pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

That is not strictly correct. Eagle Football, of which John Textor is chairman and a shareholder paid £300 million for Lyon. Eagle Football is an investor group. The £300m is not John Textor's but the cumulative sum made up by the various parties in the group. It may well be that they had no interest in spending their money on CPFC and thought Lyon was an investment that would yield a better return. If that's the case, there's nothing Textor could do. He can recommend purchasing Palace, but that is all. It's not his money to spend as he wishes.

Edited by sydtheeagle (20 Jan 2023 7.44pm)

But Textor’ controls ‘ Eagle Holdings . My point is that he has the ability , should he wish to do so, to increase his share holding if Harris and Blitzer decide to sell. I don’t know if that is his intention any more than you know that it isn’t.

I speculated that if he felt that Parish was holding the club back then should he gain a controlling share of Palace, he may well feel the need to dispense with Parish’s services.

Ultimately it’s all guesswork on our part. Nobody knows what agreements are in place for certain

 


Old, Ungifted and White

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 21 Jan 23 12.40am

IMHO Parish is now milking the club as his main source of income.

He constantly seeks the lime light on TV and in the media.

He is not a football expert and should be hands off.

2010 is history now.

He has said many times words to the effect that he would only sell shares of the club to parties with the club's long term interests at heart. In reality has sold to parties who have let him keep control and income.

I am grateful to CPFC 2010 as a group , we are now in a different era.

Textor may be the answer we need

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 21 Jan 23 1.49am

Parish held out last minute to get a really sweet deal for the club... fair enough, he's a businessman... however, a fan wouldn't have let us struggle til last minute.

Parish doesn't have the funds to take us further, that's apparent.

Parish makes a very comfortable profit from palace, palace use his side companies and one being 'smoke and mirrors'.

Parish puts off investors as he feels he has the last say.. parish spins this as he is protecting the club... protecting it from what?

Please do not tell me administration...

Time for Parish to sell up and let someone else have a go.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 5.36am

Originally posted by HKOwen

IMHO Parish is now milking the club as his main source of income.

He constantly seeks the lime light on TV and in the media.

He is not a football expert and should be hands off.

I agree with your second and third points and have said so on many occasions but I'm not so sure about the first.

Whilst Parish does seem to take an enormous salary I'm sure that he puts most of it back into the company in the form of loans which I have always thought to be a silly idea.

Say he draws £1.5m. He will pay tax on that of £675,000 leaving £825,000 which is loaned to the club which to my mind is not very cost effective at all but is done to pretend to be injecting funds to match that of the wealthier shareholders.

Perhaps if I am wrong one of HOL's accountants could correct me

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 21 Jan 23 6.56am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I agree with your second and third points and have said so on many occasions but I'm not so sure about the first.

Whilst Parish does seem to take an enormous salary I'm sure that he puts most of it back into the company in the form of loans which I have always thought to be a silly idea.

Say he draws £1.5m. He will pay tax on that of £675,000 leaving £825,000 which is loaned to the club which to my mind is not very cost effective at all but is done to pretend to be injecting funds to match that of the wealthier shareholders.

Perhaps if I am wrong one of HOL's accountants could correct me

Fair enough and I may be wrong on first point, it's an opinion .

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 7.03am

SP said at the time that the 2010 consortium was formed & took on the club, they didnt want to own the club, they were fans, they left it to the last minute in the hope that someone else would step in, only when it became apparent that no one else was waiting in the wings to save the club did they come forward -

SP Salary seems to upset people, for how many years after the takeover didn't he draw any salary ? (I think it was 4 years but I am ready to stand corrected) at least his salary is published in the accounts -

CEO for life, I have heard SP say several times that he is currently the custodian of the position, if the right investment comes along & that new investment can take the club forward he will step aside -

Financially astute - whilst it would be nice to see new players etc, as Syd points out its not easy to know whats going on in the boardroom, but I think SP is doing his best to keep the club on an even keel whilst walking that tightrope to keep us in the PL, at the moment we dont have surplus money to go forward at full steam & what happens when super league comes along & we are not included, Palace will be in the second tier, no one knows how that money tree will shake down, how many multi million pound transfers can we take on the books without being vulnerable to any new league payment structure (with TV money being negotiated to new levels because they want to show Super League as a premium product) or some other as yet unrecognised disruptive element (Covid style or) ?

SP has been cautious & IMHO quite rightly so, it would be easy to over reach in the hope of jam tomorrow -

The football pyramid is a difficult path to navigate, many clubs are envious of our financial position & place in the league - how it pans out with the current shareholders remains to be seen but to those that are spouting about SP stepping aside & letting someone else run the ship, who exactly are they talking about instilling in his place ?


 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 8.06am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

SP Salary seems to upset people, for how many years after the takeover didn't he draw any salary ? (I think it was 4 years but I am ready to stand corrected)

I don't know if that comment was aimed at me but leaving aside the fact that £1.5m is an obscene salary for the chairman of a small loss making company my objection is based on the fact that he draws a salary, pays a large amount of tax on it and invests the balance back into the company.

It would be much more cost effective for the company if he didn't pay himself anything thus saving the huge payment of income tax which would be an enormous benefit to the club's finances

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 9.14am

Hi ME -
Trust all remains good with you -
No wasn't aimed at you particularly - Although I am interested to know where the figure of 1.5 million comes from for SP salary -

I am not an accountant - but when I look at CPFC 2021 submissions -
(for an 11 month period , so not the whole year + during Covid)
As a layman I think I can see that the club employed nearly 300 people, with a turnover of £134,383 Million - Players wages represented £108,965 (81% of turnover) the club lost £40,209 million before tax & SP took a salary of £810,645 with no pension rights - (So £884,340 if its for a full year)

For a CEO with what is now 10 years experience + in comparison to what Managers & players earn, IDK to me it doesn't seem to be so far out of whack, now whether its the most tax efficient way of doing it is another matter but at least its transparent -

Maybe I am not reading it correctly or missing something ?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Jan 23 9.22am

Does anyone know if the club pays dividends to the shareholders?

 


One more point

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 9.29am

No dividends were distributed to Shareholder's for the financial period 1/08/2020 up until 30/06/2021 -

Originally posted by Badger11

Does anyone know if the club pays dividends to the shareholders?

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 9.36am

There are 2 other disclosures -

VMM £45,000 for "services" - VMM are a project management company so my guess would be that they are being used for the new stand project -

Smoke & Mirrors £156,000 for a tenancy agreement (IDK , maybe the Soho offices?)

Both companies are controlled by SP -

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 9.49am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I am interested to know where the figure of 1.5 million comes from for SP salary -

It seems that I misremembered. It was the year ended 30th June 2019 that Parish's salary was an obscene £2.6m which was re-invested into the academy but after income tax was paid

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 9.50am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle


Smoke & Mirrors £156,000 for a tenancy agreement (IDK , maybe the Soho offices?)


That is correct and probably not unreasonable if one wants a fairly prestigious London office

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Jan 23 9.52am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

There are 2 other disclosures -

VMM £45,000 for "services" - VMM are a project management company so my guess would be that they are being used for the new stand project -

Smoke & Mirrors £156,000 for a tenancy agreement (IDK , maybe the Soho offices?)

Both companies are controlled by SP -

Thanks

 


One more point

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 9.59am

Then yes that does seem a strange way of doing things -
Maybe there was a simple explanation that dosent show up in the numbers ? ( Perhaps we needed to throw money at the academy project & paying SP with him paying the contractors / material supply companies seemed to be the best way of doing it at the time)

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

It seems that I misremembered. It was the year ended 30th June 2019 that Parish's salary was an obscene £2.6m which was re-invested into the academy but after income tax was paid

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 21 Jan 23 10.38am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Parish held out last minute to get a really sweet deal for the club... fair enough, he's a businessman... however, a fan wouldn't have let us struggle til last minute.

Parish doesn't have the funds to take us further, that's apparent.

Parish makes a very comfortable profit from palace, palace use his side companies and one being 'smoke and mirrors'.

Parish puts off investors as he feels he has the last say.. parish spins this as he is protecting the club... protecting it from what?

Please do not tell me administration...

Time for Parish to sell up and let someone else have a go.

Good post. Agree with most of it.

I've never warmed to Parish. He's always struck me as an egotistical wide-boy who's as concerned with his own money and image (in no particular order) as he is with anything else but over time I've also tried to be fair and see the best in him. On the whole, he's done a pretty good job for the club. It's hard to argue that he hasn't taken us to a much better place than the one in which he found us, and it's also hard to argue that he hasn't been a pretty good general for Blitzer and Harris' investment strategy.

What I think now is that, like managers, CEOs have a shelf life. Parish's job, which was essentially to secure our future in the wake of the chaotic takeover, is done. He's served his purpose and, at present, entering a different era where pushing on should be the priority rather than laying the foundations, it's time for a new leader. If Parish wasn't so ego-led, even he might see that it'd be better to step aside. Unfortunately, I don't think there's any chance of that happening. He's in love with himself before anything else, and he'll never believe he's not the best man for the job.

Whether he's done a good job or not (and he has, for the most part), Parish uses the club as a personal platform. He basks in the limelight, he endlessly self-promotes, and I think if he walked away, he'd be giving up a significant part of his personal identity, not just his job. He's not going to do that, at least voluntarily.

He reminds me a little of Kenwright at Everton, another chairman with a huge ego who uses his football club as a prop for his personal image, albeit with a far greater negative effect on the club. If Palace is ever to really fulfill its potential, either Harris and Blitzer need to find a road to Damascus and totally change their appetite for and approach to running CPFC, or the present owners need to cash in their investment in a calm and orderly way by putting the club up for sale and waiting until the right new owner (not just any new owner) is found.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

stancummins Flag 21 Jan 23 11.05am

Sorry i disagree i feel much more comfortable with Parish who is a supporter than some outside investor who sees us as a plaything and drops us when the poo hits the fan. I was always one of the very very few who preferred having Noades as he was a safe pair of hands, built the Holmesdale and led us to our highest ever league position , no other chairman has achieved that

 

becky Flag over the moon 21 Jan 23 11.30am

Originally posted by samprior

Maybe already posted but a bit more from Textor on his 'vision'. Seems a fairly reasonable set of statements.

Well at least that video interview explains our loss of form over the last few games (ManU excepted) - PV, OR and the team were probably all too busy worrying, along with the Brazilian lot, about that left back in Belgium in the name of co-operation and took their eyes off the Palace ball for a bit...

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish verses Textor?