This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Sam Johnstone no.1?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Apr 23 10.59pm |
|
|
I’ve been very impressed by him have to say. Not only looks a very good keeper but has an assured, sincere presence about him that for me inspires confidence and a belief in a quiet leader at the back.
Not without his faults but I do/have loved Vinnie however age alone might usher in a successor. Unsure on Sam’s longer term likelihood of staying fit etc but very encouraged by the prospect of him being our no.1 goalie.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
EddieMac 15 Apr 23 11.05pm |
|
|
100% should be our number 1. Much better all round keeper and so much better with his feet. I can’t see him losing the jersey now.
|
CT Charlie 15 Apr 23 11.13pm |
|
|
I've long been a Vincente fan because of his quick reactions, cool demeanor, and genuine humility. His lack of confidence re coming off the line for high balls, commanding his defenders, or playing the ball with his feet were shortcomings I've been willing to overlook because he made so many reaction-saves that would have been goals against other keepers.
Sam has been superior regarding "long" saves with strong hands, commanding his defenders (it appears), and of course playing with his feet. Today he made several kicks that were better than any I've seen by a Palace keeper in the past 5-6 seasons. I'm glad he's ours going forward, and I'd be surprised if his game declines at all in the next 3-5 seasons. Great signing.
|
Far away fan On the border of jungle 16 Apr 23 3.23am |
|
|
I agree Sam needs to keep number one shirt
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 16 Apr 23 3.39am |
|
|
Think VG must wait for Sam J. to be injured to get back...
|
Elpis In a pub 16 Apr 23 7.18am |
|
|
Which given his recent record wont be too long . As Nicholas alludes in the OP Johnston needs to prove his long term fitness rather than his goalkeeping abilities which have never really been in question .
A fit Johnstone will be a worry for Vicente
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 16 Apr 23 12.59pm |
|
|
I think the club have a good situation but that will need to be managed carefully.
VG has been absolutely top drawer over four years IMO but at thirty six there has to be an eye on the future whereas Johnstone at thirty will consider himself in his prime years and want game time.
Johnstone looked very assured and solid against Leeds and made good decisions.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 16 Apr 23 1.10pm |
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
I think the club have a good situation but that will need to be managed carefully.
VG has been absolutely top drawer over four years IMO but at thirty six there has to be an eye on the future whereas Johnstone at thirty will consider himself in his prime years and want game time.
Johnstone looked very assured and solid against Leeds and made good decisions.
Agree, nice position to be in. Have to say first impressions are that Johnston has the edge.
|
monkey Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 16 Apr 23 2.09pm |
|
|
I would prefer him to VG, he seems to have a bit more presence as well as his agility. Although his appearances have tied in with our upturn in form, so maybe comparing him to VG would be fairer after he’s played a lot more games.
|
Palace Old Geezer Midhurst 23 Apr 23 6.27pm |
|
|
He had another good game yesterday and I'd like to see him keep his place. For me, he has more presence than Guaita and looks to be more authorative in the box.
Both good keepers so no worries in that department.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 23 Apr 23 7.56pm |
|
|
Sam til the end of the season.
If Sam is fit for august, t hen long may he continue and his to lose.
This was once a quality forum....
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 24 Apr 23 9.29am |
|
|
Vincente is still no1 for me.
But great to know that we have a natural successor and/or don't need to worry about injuries.
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Apr 23 9.47am |
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Vincente is still no1 for me.
But great to know that we have a natural successor and/or don't need to worry about injuries.
Each to their own. I've been itching for Sam to get his chance and have been delighted with how he has performed in the last 3 games. I hope and expect him to retain the jersey for the rest of the season.
Of course, what the new manager decides for next season is anybody's guess.
Edited by doombear (24 Apr 2023 9.48am)
Edited by doombear (24 Apr 2023 9.48am)
Edited by doombear (24 Apr 2023 9.49am)
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Apr 23 5.38pm |
|
|
I note that in today's press conference, Roy confirmed that Johnstone will be the starter tomorrow and made it clear that Guaita will have await his opportunity.
|
Uphill Bedford 25 Apr 23 4.22pm |
|
|
We must be the best endowed team for keepers in the Premier League
1. Sam Johnstone 2. Vicente Guaita 3. Jack Butland (on loan at United)
Three of the best. I bet Leeds would like one of them, possibly Spurs as well.
But keeping them all happy ? Well that's the rub ...
|
Eaglecoops CR3 25 Apr 23 6.13pm |
|
Originally posted by Uphill
We must be the best endowed team for keepers in the Premier League
1. Sam Johnstone 2. Vicente Guaita 3. Jack Butland (on loan at United)
Three of the best. I bet Leeds would like one of them, possibly Spurs as well.
But keeping them all happy ? Well that's the rub ...
Virtually guaranteed that Butland will go at the end of the season. Apparently Rangers want him which would be an ok move for him. The young lad who filled in this season will probably be our third choice.
|
Palace 1979 Surrey 25 Apr 23 10.19pm |
|
|
I hope Roy keeps him as number 1 after his first mistake late in the game.
I think he has to be our number one going into next season, and to drop him after one mistake would be the wrong decision. he was solid again tonight, commands his area, talks to the back 4 and is much better with his feet(normally).
I love that we have 2 great keepers but Johnstone is a slightly better all round option.
Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 26 Apr 23 6.08am |
|
|
Was it really a penalty? Sam J. hit the ball cleanly and never touched the diving Wolves player. Guess if it had been the other way round, Olise tackled in the opposite area that pr...ck of a ref would have waved it on.
|
southnorwoodhill 26 Apr 23 6.14am |
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
Was it really a penalty? Sam J. hit the ball cleanly and never touched the diving Wolves player. Guess if it had been the other way round, Olise tackled in the opposite area that pr...ck of a ref would have waved it on.
He flew in studs showing. An outfield player could have been shown a red, so he got lucky.
|
Elpis In a pub 26 Apr 23 6.33am |
|
|
As no contact was made a Yellow was the correct decision . The referee would have deemed it as reckless play (yellow) rather than dangerous play or using excessive force (red).He could have seen it as careless play and not given any card at all
It was actually for me borderline if it was even a penalty ,Ive no complaints that it was but was one of those that had it not been given would not have been overturned
|