This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by PJEagle
If we have ambitions to improve as a club, we can't sell our best players. These players have bonded very well, and we need to keep them together, especially as Wolf's future is so uncertain We'll have to disagree there. We cannot compete with most of the clubs in this league financially in a straight fight. Granted we've not really sold many players of late, but we were ok with out AJ, Bolasie, AWB etc. Players leaving is a fact of life, no point trying to chain them up. We've effectively done that with Wilf and there is a good chance he'll leave for zero. If brilliant bids come in, way above their market value we'd be mad not to consider them, and weight up their worth to the team vs what you could do with the money.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
If Guehi did go I wonder if the club might make a move for Bella-Kotchap from Southampton. He looked really good whenever I saw him and we were rumoured to be scouting him for a while before he ended up there. As it is I wouldn't want us to lose either Guehi or Andersen. The former is quick and intelligent, while the latter is big and has that fantastic passing range. Richards looked really good when he's filled in, but obviously his injuries are a concern. I also wonder what O'Brien's future is after a seemingly successful loan in Belgium. He's a ball-playing centre-back, is big and scores quite a few. Always looked composed when I saw him for the U23s. Good shout about the Southampton player. We certainly need a tighter defence, especially height as our two centre backs are stronger on the ground than they are in the air. It may be losing Guehi and replacing him will strengthen us in the air on set pieces and give us some extra cash? We will of course miss his other attributes as he is a quality premiership player :-(
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
If Geuhi gets sold for a large amount of money to a top six team this will speak volumes about Chelsea and the mess of a club it is. Rather than nurture a young, promising talent they sell him off to a London rival so they can carry on buying expensive foreign imports - and look what that has done. Marc and us will quite likely end up above them at the end of the season! Except as I understand it they have a 20% share of any sell on fee!
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I really like Guehi, but I wonder if he would actually start regularly for any of the teams rumoured to be interested. He is quite short for a centre-back at 6' and lacks the aggression of someone like Martinez to make up for it. Great player for us, but I think he needs a couple more years with us where he will be forced to defend more before he moves to a bigger club. Also if Chelsea do get 20% of any fee I imagine Parish would want 60m+ otherwise the return on investment might not be considered enough. Is he a 60m+ defender right now? I'm not so sure, but then Maguire went for 80m so what do I know. Before Man Utd signed Maguire he had played around 250 games, covering the Championship and PL, and he had at least 16 England caps. Man Utd purchased a player who was strong in the air, a threat at set-pieces, was more than capable of bringing the ball out of defence, distributed the ball well with a good a long diagonal pass in his locker and was physically imposing. I would suggest that Man Utd signed a more capable player than Guehi is at this present time but I recognise his qualities and he will improve with experience. Edited by Willo (23 May 2023 9.24am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Except as I understand it they have a 20% share of any sell on fee! So that's 10 million plus? Pocket change to a clueless, spendthrift club like them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PJEagle
This is outdated thinking in my eyes and if Brighton had dug in over selling Cucarella, Bissouma, Trossard, White etc they wouldn't have been able to build a team that have done so well this season. The horrible reality is that they have leapfrogged us by being shrewd at transfers and if we have any chance of moving up that table we have to do the same. In the last few years we've roughly bought Eze for 15m, Guehi for 20m, Andersen for 15m, Olise for 7m and Doucoure for 20m. That's 75-80m for 5 outstanding players. If we can sell Guehi for £50-60m and use the money to invest in the team, we're going to be stronger overall even if he will be a big individual loss. The sad reality is that it's the only way we'll be able to spend.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
This is outdated thinking in my eyes and if Brighton had dug in over selling Cucarella, Bissouma, Trossard, White etc they wouldn't have been able to build a team that have done so well this season. The horrible reality is that they have leapfrogged us by being shrewd at transfers and if we have any chance of moving up that table we have to do the same. In the last few years we've roughly bought Eze for 15m, Guehi for 20m, Andersen for 15m, Olise for 7m and Doucoure for 20m. That's 75-80m for 5 outstanding players. If we can sell Guehi for £50-60m and use the money to invest in the team, we're going to be stronger overall even if he will be a big individual loss. The sad reality is that it's the only way we'll be able to spend. I concur with the general thrust of these sentiments. In the final analysis we are not capable of retaining our star assets if more prestigious clubs come calling.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Before Man Utd signed Maguire he had played around 250 games, covering the Championship and PL, and he had at least 16 England caps. Man Utd purchased a player who was strong in the air, a threat at set-pieces, was more than capable of bringing the ball out of defence, distributed the ball well with a good a long diagonal pass in his locker and was physically imposing. I would suggest that Man Utd signed a more capable player than Guehi is at this present time but I recognise his qualities and he will improve with experience. Edited by Willo (23 May 2023 9.24am) I never rated Maguire and always complained when he got picked for England. He's just a big thug. I get what you're saying though, but that's also my point, Guehi has not yet proved himself to be a 50/60m+ defender. Like with AWB it may come down to whether Parish is under any pressure to sell; if he's not then he'll likely demand a premium.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I concur with the general thrust of these sentiments. In the final analysis we are not capable of retaining our star assets if more prestigious clubs come calling. Indeed its a fine balancing act . Young players wont sign for us if they think they will not be allowed to move to more prestigious clubs if they are wanted by them . I suppose we need to get as close as we can to them so other things become a consideration .
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I concur with the general thrust of these sentiments. In the final analysis we are not capable of retaining our star assets if more prestigious clubs come calling. Exactly, we are now in a position to sell one player a year without it damaging the squad to much, obviously, some of the money needs to be reinvested in a couple of players whose value will also rise.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Exactly, we are now in a position to sell one player a year without it damaging the squad to much, obviously, some of the money needs to be reinvested in a couple of players whose value will also rise. Agree, other than Bolasie and AWB i don't think we've sold anyone for decent money (£5m plus) since we gained promotion so if Guehi was to be sold (or an.other) it wouldn't be the end of the world. Couple of other points to make. FFP rules might have some impact on whether we do sell. Finally, don't under-estimate the will of the player. If a player has his head turned it is difficult to keep an unhappy player. Edited by palace99 (23 May 2023 3.08pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Agree, other than Bolasie and AWB i don't think we've sold anyone for decent money (£5m plus) since we gained promotion so if Guehi was to be sold (or an.other) it wouldn't be the end of the world.
Well Wilf went for 12 million, I believe, and Gayle for a similar amount . But only Bolasie was anything like the model of buying young and selling for a profit and he probably only went because Everton came in with a ludicrous offer
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by pssguy
Well Wilf went for 12 million, I believe, and Gayle for a similar amount . But only Bolasie was anything like the model of buying young and selling for a profit and he probably only went because Everton came in with a ludicrous offer Wilf went before we were promoted (and for £10m). Forgot about Gayle, however, we did pay a massive amount for him and so the profit wasn't excessive. My point remains FFP rules may require us to sell the odd player for a big profit every now and again. Something we haven't done since AWB, 3 years ago.
|
|
|
Originally posted by pssguy
Well Wilf went for 12 million, I believe, and Gayle for a similar amount . But only Bolasie was anything like the model of buying young and selling for a profit and he probably only went because Everton came in with a ludicrous offer Bolasie was a wonderful player for Palace but never recovered form and fitness at Everton
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I really think we have to take advantage of the position with Guehi, although everyone would like him to stay, if a bidding war starts between 3/4 rich clubs we could really push the price up to silly money, particularly if Richards looks like he is going to be a very good CD, and reinvest the 60/70/80m in the squad, particularly as luka, McArthur, Guehi and Wilf (if he goes) is 300k a week saving on salaries I don’t think many will disagree with this. Guehi is a great asset, but everyone has their price. If selling him allows us to reinvest in a couple of other players…then that’s the way cookie crumbles (or should I say, that’s the Brighton philosophy).
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.