This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Painter
He was found out at Chelsea, we don’t need a manager, that can’t manage at a big club.
Potter is a complex manager who requires time to implement a playing style and his players to completely buy into his methods. He had neither of those at Chelsea, only joining in September which meant he had to hit the ground running without a pre-season, plus he had to contend with Boehly spunking hundreds of millions on players that he clearly didn't want and who didn't fit his ethos. He had 22 league games in charge at Chelsea, winning 7, drawing 7 and losing 8 which is average for them. However, after he left they played a further 10 games and won 1, drew 3 and lost 6, so they actually got significantly worse. As manager of Ostersund he got promoted twice and then in the top flight finished 8th (1.40 points per game), 5th (1.67), 7th (1.55). At Brighton in the Premier League he finished 15th (1.08 ), 16th (1.08 ), 9th (1.35) and then had them 4th (2.17) after six games when he left. De Zerbi is getting all the credit but I say there's a convincing argument that clubs get better and better under Potter and that he deserves much of the credit for their season. If we appoint him and give him time, he will take us forward without any doubt in my mind. Edited by Canterbury Palace (31 May 2023 5.25pm)
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
| waddy |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
By not getting to grips with 1 billion worth of players and not getting them organised, motivated or playing a cohesive style that brings out the talent that is without doubt in the squad. i close my case for the prosecution. I think most top managers would have struggled with the names the egos the pay checks in that changing room. I doubt he had a say in the £600mill that was outlaid- more a case of :
Forever Palace Proud |
|
|
He was the right fit at Chelsea,every Potter needs a shed.
|
|
| waddy |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
A few snow flake “wokers” on here I see ! Or should I say “w******s”. yet “Woy” does sound ignorant/ abusive ?
Forever Palace Proud |
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
You need to factor in that he took over a semi sinking ship when he started at Brighton. They were on the brink of relegation at that point in time. He's clearly progressed them as a club and a lot of credit for this seasons 6th place finish must be attributed to him for their great start. We're more advanced now than what Brighton were when he took over. If we can get gradual progress and work our way up the league a few positions, that would be a fantastic outcome. He's had a solid CV and has done the hard graft overseas to get to where he is today. He's not a Frank Lampard/Steven Gerrard who are clearly out of their depth and landing jobs based on their names. For a big club like Chelsea to sack Tuchel in favour of Potter shows how highly he's regarded. He won't get a 'Big 6' job any time soon, so a club like Palace could be a good fit for all parties. I would imagine Spurs, Everton and West Ham would all be interested too. He'd be my first choice out of those who realistically available. I also would be happy with Roy, but think if someone of Potter's calibre is available and interested, it's a too good a opportunity to turn down. Yeah. I'd go along with that.
|
|
|
Although I'd say its time for Mr Hodgson to go now. What a manager. A true Palace legend imo.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Glazier#1
Although I'd say its time for Mr Hodgson to go now. What a manager. A true Palace legend imo. At some time we've got to get the succession right. I'd prefer Cooper, but he hasn't resigned, and Forest are still in the PL. of those available, he looks like he ticks quite a few boxes. Good PL experience and laid the foundations for a good Brighton team. The other option would be Roy mentoring Paddy to take over after a season....but I think Pqddy would be plunged in to the deep end far too soon. Difficult choices. It didn't work out with de Boer or Patrick. Let's hope Parish gets the choices right 🤞
|
|
|
Originally posted by waddy
A few snow flake “wokers” on here I see ! Or should I say “w******s”. yet “Woy” does sound ignorant/ abusive ?
Taking the p out of someone with a speech impediment is ignorant and rude
|
|
|
Originally posted by PJEagle
At some time we've got to get the succession right. I'd prefer Cooper, but he hasn't resigned, and Forest are still in the PL. of those available, he looks like he ticks quite a few boxes. Good PL experience and laid the foundations for a good Brighton team. The other option would be Roy mentoring Paddy to take over after a season....but I think Pqddy would be plunged in to the deep end far too soon. Difficult choices. It didn't work out with de Boer or Patrick. Let's hope Parish gets the choices right 🤞 I think Roy has already indicated that the “mentoring” role is a complete non starter. Who makes the decisions? As Roy said Paddy for example takes training and Roy overseas…Roy thinks I could do this better myself….why wouldn’t he.
|
|
|
Let’s just get this done quickly and get ahead of the game with new signings and pre-season.
|
|
|
Potter would be a cracking appointment in my opinion,we should get this done. Played some great stuff at Brighton.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Zaha127
I think what Jordan said was right. De Zerbi did benefit a lot from Potter (his style of play and players) that helped him do so well with Brighton. Potter at Chelsea was always going to be a disaster due to expectations and him not dealing with huge superstars. Palace's next aim is probably to become an established top 10 side i.e. finish top 10 every season which is something that is more than do able if Palace buy a new RB, midfielder, winger to replace Zaha and striker who gets over 13 goals a season minimum. Potter can achieve top 10 every season if the right players are bought in. So is that a minimum of 14 goals then? This would be a rare event for this club. As far as I'm aware, it's only happened 5 times in the 'top flight'. Wright (Div 1), Bright (Div 1), Armstrong (PL), Johnson (PL), Benteke (PL).
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
So is that a minimum of 14 goals then? This would be a rare event for this club. As far as I'm aware, it's only happened 5 times in the 'top flight'. Wright (Div 1), Bright (Div 1), Armstrong (PL), Johnson (PL), Benteke (PL). I would settle for 2 players who get 10 goals a season each.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Let’s just get this done quickly and get ahead of the game with new signings and pre-season. As if But then they’ve surprised us all getting the new kit out early for a change, so you never know!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eagle Black.
Potter would be a cracking appointment in my opinion,we should get this done. Played some great stuff at Brighton. Heart and head reply here. In complete agreement although I would like to see some transitional managerial overplay work with Hodgson as well following Potter's bruising experience at Chelsea. Potter built a team ethic at Brighton that at the time was precisely the club to align ourselves to in terms of realistic progressive steps to adopt. Potter has that blueprint model of delivery to take Palace forward. As for Hodgson in the long run? Is Honorary President Of CPFC really that far flung a working suggestion? We need to keep him close to the club (as Palace is to his heart and how he has rescued our Prem.survival) as rebuild continues. What do others think?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sportyteacher
Heart and head reply here. In complete agreement although I would like to see some transitional managerial overplay work with Hodgson as well following Potter's bruising experience at Chelsea. Potter built a team ethic at Brighton that at the time was precisely the club to align ourselves to in terms of realistic progressive steps to adopt. Potter has that blueprint model of delivery to take Palace forward. As for Hodgson in the long run? Is Honorary President Of CPFC really that far flung a working suggestion? We need to keep him close to the club (as Palace is to his heart and how he has rescued our Prem.survival) as rebuild continues. What do others think? With all due respect ST, and acknowledging you are only the latest of many to propose this idea, has this actually happened anywhere, ever? It’s continually discussed as though it’s commonplace let alone viable. Hodgson and Potter two very different managers so at the very least I’d expect that to be a problem let alone the fact that one may not take or be impressed coming into a job where they are overseen by their predecessor. Genuine questions as I am intrigued so if ‘Y’ I’m surprised I’ve missed it and if ‘no’ why on earth is it continually put forward?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
With all due respect ST, and acknowledging you are only the latest of many to propose this idea, has this actually happened anywhere, ever? It’s continually discussed as though it’s commonplace let alone viable. Hodgson and Potter two very different managers so at the very least I’d expect that to be a problem let alone the fact that one may not take or be impressed coming into a job where they are overseen by their predecessor. Genuine questions as I am intrigued so if ‘Y’ I’m surprised I’ve missed it and if ‘no’ why on earth is it continually put forward? Didn't SAF do that when Moyes was appointed manager of manure, or did it just seem that way?
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
So is that a minimum of 14 goals then? This would be a rare event for this club. As far as I'm aware, it's only happened 5 times in the 'top flight'. Wright (Div 1), Bright (Div 1), Armstrong (PL), Johnson (PL), Benteke (PL).
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.