You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Kicking the can down the road...
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Kicking the can down the road...


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
est1905 Flag 05 Jul 23 1.07pm

Originally posted by Casual

Paddy ?? Really??
Would you have any interest in him if he wasn’t already at /played for Palace?
A year putting the cones out, doesn’t make a premier league manager I’m afraid.

Completely agree. If Paddy had never played for Palace everyone would be laughing their arses off at the prospect of Paddy taking charge of a Premiership club

 

est1905 Flag 05 Jul 23 1.13pm

Originally posted by doombear


Arsenal risked more than that when they signed Arteta!

Now I'm not saying that McCarthy should be in line to take over from Hodgson.

However, he did show he could manage the U21s and get the best out of them (performances of the U21s fell off after he stepped up when Vieira was sacked) so he has shown he has man-management skills - not to be sniffed at. I question whether the likes of Lampard, Gerrard and perhaps even Vieira have them.

I would like to see McCarthy go and earn his corn at a lower league club. He may well be a candidate for a PL job in the future and possibly with Palace if we're still in the PL, of course.

Completely different but the most obvious difference is Arsenal are wealthy enough to go a season without Champions League football whereas Palace cant really afford to lose their place in the division-which is what would likely happen should we make the wrong managerial choice!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jul 23 1.35pm

Originally posted by est1905

Completely different but the most obvious difference is Arsenal are wealthy enough to go a season without Champions League football whereas Palace cant really afford to lose their place in the division-which is what would likely happen should we make the wrong managerial choice!


At present yes, but after a year or possibly two working as Hodgson's assistant, it will become somewhat similar if he's deemed to be good enough, and unlike Arteta, he wouldn't be moving to a new club and having to get to know the players etc..

Given the rate at which PL managers are being sacked these days employing a manager from outside the club (other than one with proven PL successful experience - and they will probably want a bigger club) is equally risky.

Edited by doombear (05 Jul 2023 1.36pm)

 

est1905 Flag 05 Jul 23 5.50pm

Originally posted by doombear


At present yes, but after a year or possibly two working as Hodgson's assistant, it will become somewhat similar if he's deemed to be good enough, and unlike Arteta, he wouldn't be moving to a new club and having to get to know the players etc..

Given the rate at which PL managers are being sacked these days employing a manager from outside the club (other than one with proven PL successful experience - and they will probably want a bigger club) is equally risky.

Edited by doombear (05 Jul 2023 1.36pm)

If your auntie had bollox.....
In my opinion giving it to Macarthy in a years time is still ridiculous if he has had zero first team experience as the no.1. Arsenal can afford to take that kind of risk (and have the money to make a World class replacement. We dont.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Jul 23 6.09pm

Originally posted by est1905

If your auntie had bollox.....
In my opinion giving it to Macarthy in a years time is still ridiculous if he has had zero first team experience as the no.1. Arsenal can afford to take that kind of risk (and have the money to make a World class replacement. We dont.

But it’s all within context.

We are not big enough to attract a “ World Class replacement “ as you say. So we would look to replace at a different level should we give the job to Paddy and it doesn’t work out. In the same way we would if an external hire didn’t .

If in a years time Dougie and Roy think that Paddy is up to the task then he may get a chance

 


Old, Ungifted and White

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Jul 23 6.11pm

Originally posted by est1905

If your auntie had bollox.....
In my opinion giving it to Macarthy in a years time is still ridiculous if he has had zero first team experience as the no.1. Arsenal can afford to take that kind of risk (and have the money to make a World class replacement. We dont.

So, who in your experienced opinion, should we sign that's going to give us top half finishes & possibly Europe.

Paddy learning from probably the most experience manger in the Prem, is a risk far better than anyone else, UNLESS they happen to be a Prem winner & fit in with the Palace ethos . . .

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 05 Jul 23 7.34pm

Lots on here seem to assume this is all part of a master plan, Roy nurtures Paddy for a year and hey presto Paddy leads us to the promised land.

I don't see that level of planning by the board.

Roy however great he is/was is in the twilight years. We clearly looked at other managers but failed to appoint.

We have taken the easy way out. Will it work? Only time will tell

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Jul 23 7.50pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Lots on here seem to assume this is all part of a master plan, Roy nurtures Paddy for a year and hey presto Paddy leads us to the promised land.

I don't see that level of planning by the board.

Roy however great he is/was is in the twilight years. We clearly looked at other managers but failed to appoint.

We have taken the easy way out. Will it work? Only time will tell

Well, there are a lot of assumptions being made on here. You’ve just made one - how is it “ clear “ that we looked at other managers but failed to appoint ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

beak Flag croydon 06 Jul 23 9.07am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

A percentage of it anyway since his replacement will have to be paid.

I said kitty,not transfer kitty,wages have to come out of the pot obviously but no one will be paid the silly money offered to Zaha.

 

YT Flag Oxford 06 Jul 23 10.51am

There's a lot of pant-wetting on this topic. Roy is a good, proven manager, so why shouldn't he continue to lead us? All this stuff about not having a long-term plan; so what? Apart from Klopp and Pep, how many PL managers on a 3 or 4 year contract as part of yet another 'long-term plan' ever stay to the end before being sacked? Roy is our manager; end of. Let's get behind him and the team and have a rollickin' good season.

Edited by YT (06 Jul 2023 10.52am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 06 Jul 23 10.58am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Lots on here seem to assume this is all part of a master plan, Roy nurtures Paddy for a year and hey presto Paddy leads us to the promised land.

I don't see that level of planning by the board.

Roy however great he is/was is in the twilight years. We clearly looked at other managers but failed to appoint.

We have taken the easy way out. Will it work? Only time will tell

No big deal, especially if we’d ended up with someone sacked by Leeds, Watford, Norwich, Leicester, Wolves or Southampton. There’s a long list of managers now on the merry go round that we could’ve ended up with, so on reflection im quite happy we’ve stuck with Roy

 

SurbsEagle Flag 06 Jul 23 11.44am

Originally posted by YT

There's a lot of pant-wetting on this topic. Roy is a good, proven manager, so why shouldn't he continue to lead us? All this stuff about not having a long-term plan; so what? Apart from Klopp and Pep, how many PL managers on a 3 or 4 year contract as part of yet another 'long-term plan' ever stay to the end before being sacked? Roy is our manager; end of. Let's get behind him and the team and have a rollickin' good season.

Edited by YT (06 Jul 2023 10.52am)

Well said.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Jul 23 11.44am

Originally posted by YT

There's a lot of pant-wetting on this topic. Roy is a good, proven manager, so why shouldn't he continue to lead us? All this stuff about not having a long-term plan; so what? Apart from Klopp and Pep, how many PL managers on a 3 or 4 year contract as part of yet another 'long-term plan' ever stay to the end before being sacked? Roy is our manager; end of. Let's get behind him and the team and have a rollickin' good season.

Edited by YT (06 Jul 2023 10.52am)

Yes !!

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 06 Jul 23 11.48am

Originally posted by YT

There's a lot of pant-wetting on this topic. Roy is a good, proven manager, so why shouldn't he continue to lead us? All this stuff about not having a long-term plan; so what? Apart from Klopp and Pep, how many PL managers on a 3 or 4 year contract as part of yet another 'long-term plan' ever stay to the end before being sacked? Roy is our manager; end of. Let's get behind him and the team and have a rollickin' good season.

Edited by YT (06 Jul 2023 10.52am)

Exactly that.

Could be far, far worse. Let's hypothetically say we still spend no money but bring in somebody completely untired and untested.

Without the funds to invest in team, to be quite frank, Roy is probably best we can hope for next season. Ended last term strongly, has the experience and track record to avoid catastrophe etc. etc.

Ideal? No. Far from catastrophe? Yes.

COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

YT Flag Oxford 06 Jul 23 4.02pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Exactly that.

Could be far, far worse. Let's hypothetically say we still spend no money but bring in somebody completely untired and untested.

Without the funds to invest in team, to be quite frank, Roy is probably best we can hope for next season. Ended last term strongly, has the experience and track record to avoid catastrophe etc. etc.

Ideal? No. Far from catastrophe? Yes.

COYP

Because Roy can get a bit weary at his advanced age?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 06 Jul 23 4.08pm

Originally posted by YT

Because Roy can get a bit weary at his advanced age?

Could actually be a good descriptor for him. I'm in my 30's yet 90 mins of football Tuesday looks to have put me out for a month!

Still raring at his grand old age though!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

est1905 Flag 06 Jul 23 5.23pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

So, who in your experienced opinion, should we sign that's going to give us top half finishes & possibly Europe.

Paddy learning from probably the most experience manger in the Prem, is a risk far better than anyone else, UNLESS they happen to be a Prem winner & fit in with the Palace ethos . . .

Who said anything about top half finishes? If Paddy Macarthy got the Palace job in a years time based on working as Roy's number 2 I'd be happy if we were still in touch of safety once they sacked him. Working as a number 2 no matter how much the players respect him means absolutely nothing when we are talking about his ability to take the top job.
Plus, thanks for describing my opinion as 'experienced' but you are wrong there (not for the first time it seems) I have only the experience of what I have witnessed down the years in all my time supporting Palace and watching football in general. Same as you I imagine. Only difference I can see is that I dont look at the clubs business decisions romantically. I look at things that make sensible business and footballing sense. For me? gambling £100m+ annual income an ex player whose done well with the reserves because, lets face it, he's an ex player is pretty pathetic.

 

SarfNorwoodAl Flag South Norwood 06 Jul 23 5.27pm

The players will be bored of Grandad by the New Year. The Greek pavaroti nutter at Forest would have sacked Cooper by then so Parish with his fake sun tan will put him in charge and start our long term plan. Sorted.

 

est1905 Flag 06 Jul 23 5.30pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

But it’s all within context.

We are not big enough to attract a “ World Class replacement “ as you say. So we would look to replace at a different level should we give the job to Paddy and it doesn’t work out. In the same way we would if an external hire didn’t .

If in a years time Dougie and Roy think that Paddy is up to the task then he may get a chance

I cant see how Dougie and Roy are going 'think Paddy is up to the task' based upon him doing a year in a number 2 role. You might as well give the job to Freedman. At least we know he has been a no.1 and can do the job. And before anyone says anything, I absolutely do NOT want Freedman anywhere near Palace's dug out either!
What is Palace fans obsession with ex players? It makes no sense. There are loads of promising young managers out there with more experience than Paddy that would on paper at least do a better job if 'young upcoming coach' is the route Parish wants to go down. I'd suspect as a businessman that doesn't like risk then NOT.

 

est1905 Flag 06 Jul 23 5.32pm

Originally posted by YT

There's a lot of pant-wetting on this topic. Roy is a good, proven manager, so why shouldn't he continue to lead us? All this stuff about not having a long-term plan; so what? Apart from Klopp and Pep, how many PL managers on a 3 or 4 year contract as part of yet another 'long-term plan' ever stay to the end before being sacked? Roy is our manager; end of. Let's get behind him and the team and have a rollickin' good season.

Edited by YT (06 Jul 2023 10.52am)

Well said.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Kicking the can down the road...