You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Widow review
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Widow review


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 02 Sep 23 10.02am

We’ve done well to bring in Henderson and offload Guaita and we have additional cover at centre back. I’m assuming O’Brien wanted to leave for game time. I think we had already decided to stick with Wardie and Clyne at RB presumably giving Ferguson a bit more time to see if he can make it back.
Lerma was a good addition in an area that needed strengthening and we kept the rest of a decent midfield. Up front we have a new young player once his back is better and we’ve clearly decide to give Jesrun a chance which I applaud. We have to start showing our academy leads somewhere other than to sales to the lower leagues or abroad. It also makes financial sense especially given the ridiculous transfer fees recently.
The only negative as I see it is that we didn’t get another striker but that’s never going ti be easy or cheap and a loan was out best hope with the possible exception of Balogun who might have been worth the money Monaco paid out.

All in all the squad is stronger than it was. 8/10

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 02 Sep 23 10.08am

A decent window for me

Positives

As mentioned we kept all the players we wanted to keep (along with some we didn't ,lol )

Strengthened the midfield with Lerma , the double DM should mean less goals conceeded

Enough weaknesses in the squad that give the youngsters opportunity to step up

No Loans ,I hate other teams players in our side , Its Palace not a rescue center for other clubs bloated squads

Negatives

No cover at Left back
We still need a striker .

Overall

Not too deflated , our strikers have got to be better and find their shooting boots
We all hope the Brazilian kid is the dogs b.


It could very well be a season to remember COYP!


 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 02 Sep 23 10.10am

Very poor window for me, we have holes all over the squad and only the centre-mid hole was filled by an excellent free.

Those FIVE players that people are banging on about will be one year closer to the end of their contracts and we have no replacements. If we are trying to adopt the Brighton model then we have to sell these players for a profit with reserves ready to fit in. We are so short of quality in the squad that losing just one of those players would push us towards a relegation battle.

From the outside it looks like there is no plan at all.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Sep 23 10.17am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Very poor window for me, we have holes all over the squad and only the centre-mid hole was filled by an excellent free.

Those FIVE players that people are banging on about will be one year closer to the end of their contracts and we have no replacements. If we are trying to adopt the Brighton model then we have to sell these players for a profit with reserves ready to fit in. We are so short of quality in the squad that losing just one of those players would push us towards a relegation battle.

From the outside it looks like there is no plan at all.


The plan is to tread water for as long as possible, ending up in 12th to 14th place. Parish has found a niche and is happy to fill it.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 02 Sep 23 10.28am

Originally posted by dg1937


Next summer will be a massive test as we are bound to lose one or two of our big names. Let’s hope we are better prepared than we were for the loss of Wilf.

Agree with that, it could even be January that we lose one. If we're comfortably mid-table, Holding looks okay and a £70m bid comes in for Guehi.... it could happen.

A theoretical £70m for Guehi, compared to our recent spending, would unlock the total money we spent on the other 4 (Eze, Olise, Doucoure, Andersen).

Forest and West Ham serve as examples this summer of what selling a single player for big money can unlock, provided that the players coming in perform. Kudus + JWP + Alvarez feels like a big upgrade vs Rice.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 02 Sep 23 10.29am

Rubbish

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Sep 23 10.44am

I cannot fathom why with such wealthy shareholders (Harris and Blitzer) we dont have a raise of say £50m and dilute existing holders accordingly.
Say we value the club at £200m and raise £50m, that would dilute existing holders by 20%. (Newcastle was bought for £300m)
So if H&B put the money in it will give them 20% increase and the remaining shareholders will decrease (or participate).
If no other holders participate that would give them control eg 36% existing plus 20% = 56%
The others would reduce by 20% which would suit Eagle football who anyway want to invest in Chelsea and therefore need to reduce their stake by 10% down to sub 30%.
Bringing in £50m would have given us sufficient funds to have brought in two decent wing backs and a striker.
Add them to the players we have and with a fair wind that would have given us a squad equipped for european competition.
This would massively add value to the club and fulfil what so many on here are stating as the needed requirement to push on.
To hell with the stadium. That is a massive overhead and turbulence which at this stage we can really do without. The ROI on the new stand is minimal compared to its inevitable cost (min. £150m).
Any of you accountants got a view on this?

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 02 Sep 23 10.51am

Originally posted by kevlee

Some might say Forrest are a ‘bigger’ team

Well they were back in the late 70’s and early 80’s but have literally have been in the doldrums for 40 years.Not sure how they can spend so much in such a short time after only being in the Premiership for 2 seasons.

We should ask ourselves how have teams like Forest, Brentford and Bournemouth managed to get where they are in such a short space of time?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 02 Sep 23 11.03am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Well they were back in the late 70’s and early 80’s but have literally have been in the doldrums for 40 years.Not sure how they can spend so much in such a short time after only being in the Premiership for 2 seasons.

We should ask ourselves how have teams like Forest, Brentford and Bournemouth managed to get where they are in such a short space of time?

Their recruitment is better than ours, currently - although I could find flaws with any of them. Brentford closed their academy believing they were better off just to scout for the first team. They've been forced to reopen it. Forest, obviously, have signed too many - they should have thought about developing some of what they had like Brennan Johnson. Bournemouth have not performed that well considering their spend - on paper they made some really good signings. But Bournemouth's ground is still crap. It exists to make Selhurst look good. Not much improvement in infrastructure at Brentford currently either - although they may have plans I'm unaware of. Forest have always been a big side. They dominate their city and have always been a name in football. I suppose what's more annoying is to be in the Premier League this long but still feel like imposters. We still seem to have, or even want/crave, a small club mentality.
As for the transfer window; name our current decent wide players. The list consists of Olise - injured, next best is Ayew - ok, next is between Mitchell and Schlupp. Need I go on?

 


Red and Blue Army!

lagoseagle Flag Rotterdam 02 Sep 23 11.05am

I think all the players brought in look like good signings.

The only problem being what we really needed were (at least one, if not two) better quality full backs, and a striker who can actually put the ball in the net. Which we seem to have ignored again.

But I don't doubt that inflated prices, caused by Saudi, and the top of the EPL, have made it almost impossible to find good quality for a reasonable price.

We should finish comfortably mid-table this year. The question already is what to do post Roy.

 

Aray Flag South London 02 Sep 23 11.13am

Originally posted by YT

Oi! I haven't complained about his signing or any other signings or non-signings

You must be feeling guilty! &#128517;

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 02 Sep 23 11.26am

Originally posted by Jefroc

At the end of the season Palace had FIVE players who could easily have been bought by Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool Spurs and who knows who else. Olise, Ebs, Decoure Guehi and Anderssen have all stayed even though up to yesterday there was talk of Ebs going to Spurs. That they didn't is all praise to Parish and Freedman. They kept a really good squad together. Plus Palace have another top class goalkeeper, a proven EPL defender, a potentially excellent attacking striker/midfielder and another really fine midfielder. Further Palace have three players in the England squad.

Running a football club is not the same as playing a video game - it's real RESPONSIBLE life! Yet all I read on these pages are pitiful bleatings from the same NEGATIVE MOANERS!!!


Yawns

We received an offer for 1 player only Olise the rest of the names was all media speculation.

Nothing to do with SP or Freedman.

If a club comes in for people now clubs don't really have any power at all it's all about the players really and we have seen this already.

Your post is a joke right

Holding proven EPL defender WHAT.

Top class goalkeeper yet he has been dumped by United. (has 1 England cap back in 2020)

Palace already had England capped players Eze, Johnstone, Mitchell, Guehi, Clyne (3 of those had been called up for this current squad)

When people like yourself do not have proper arguments you come out with the silly comments about the likes of Football Manager (I would like to point out all the data in that game is from scouts with over 90% of it being the same data clubs pay for some managers in the past even mentioned using it as a tool)

How can you be really happy every one else is doing something yet we a club who has been in this league for over a decade go for rejects or do nothing happy to keep resigning 30+ year olds.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Sep 23 11.50am

I have to report that I have been in conversations with a plethora of supporters and the consensus can be filed under "Underwhelmed" or "Disappointed".

Some of the negatives concerned Holding with those asserting that he only got a handful of starts in the PL last season and has been criticised for his performances. "No pace", "Gets too close to opponents and gets done on the turn" were just some of the negatives.Not impressed at all. Someone commented "A cheap option" etc etc.

Whilst some welcomed Franca some did say that most of his appearances for Flamengo have been from the substitutes bench so he is not some "Wonderkid" ready to be thrust into the PL.

No strengthening in the forwards department so we are left with Eduoard and Mateta !! No cover at left-back and we still have two right-backs in their 30s and in the twilight of their careers.

Henderson also came in for criticism but there was universal praise for Lerma.

Overall - "Excreta" !!!! These chaps are not 'Rays of sunshine' and negativity does have a proclivity to ooze from their pores !!!

Edited by Willo (02 Sep 2023 12.10pm)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 02 Sep 23 11.56am

For me a decent window, 36m on 4 players, Lerma excellent, Henderson good, two decent Keepers, i expect Guaitas contract to be ended, Holding for 4m ok, and i suppose Franca must be decent, if he is ever fit, keeping all our best players, the one disappointment for me is Burnley getting Mike Tresor on loan, he is going to be one hell of a player, and wouldnt have been expensive from Genk.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Sep 23 12.10pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have to report that I have been in conversations with a plethora of supporters and the consensus can be filed under "Underwhelmed" or "Disappointed".

Some of the negatives concerned Holding with those asserting that he only got a handful of starts in the PL last season and has been criticised for his performances. "No pace", "Gets too close to opponents and gets done on the turn" were just some of the negatives.Not impressed at all. Someone commented "A cheap option" etc etc.

Whilst some welcomed Franca some did say that most of his appearances for Flamengo have been from the substitutes bench so he is not some "Wonderkid" ready to be thrust into the PL.

No strengthening in the forwards department so we are left with Eduoard and Mateta !! No cover at left-back and we still have two right-backs in their 30s and in the twilight of their careers.

Henderson also came in for criticism but there was universal praise for Lerma.

Overall - "Excreta" !!!!

Well, it's all about opinions.

My mate, who has an Arsenal season ticket, reckons Holding is good business for us.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 02 Sep 23 12.12pm

Don't you just hate transfer windows? Well, I certainly do - all those rumours and counter rumours, stupid clickbait gossip making no sense at all, agents pushing their clapped out stars for ridiculous money.

Oh yes, the money. Billions have been spent. Change for the sake of change. The Saudis still in the hunt for Salah with a possible offer of £200 million.

If we must go along with this meat market approach to buying and selling players, then I reckon we did OK. So, we lost Wilf, but we kept the rest of our star players who, according to the gossip, were highly rated by other clubs. Keeping Olise felt like a big coup, the same goes for Eze - wonderful business.

I'm delighted with the way Mr Parish managed the whole process, except for the fact we still don't have a first rate striker

Edited by Palace Old Geezer (02 Sep 2023 12.13pm)

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 Sep 23 12.13pm

My heart says Oh no we didn't replace Wilf or sign a striker.

My head says we kept Olise and the other key players.

 


One more point

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 02 Sep 23 12.15pm

Originally posted by Badger11

My heart says Oh no we didn't replace Wilf or sign a striker.

My head says we kept Olise and the other key players.

Exactemont Monsieur!

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Sep 23 12.21pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well, it's all about opinions.

My mate, who has an Arsenal season ticket, reckons Holding is good business for us.

One could argue that he has not cost a great deal,provides cover both in central defence and at right-back and he has made nearly 100 appearances in the PL.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 02 Sep 23 12.22pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

For me a decent window, 36m on 4 players, Lerma excellent, Henderson good, two decent Keepers, i expect Guaitas contract to be ended, Holding for 4m ok, and i suppose Franca must be decent, if he is ever fit, keeping all our best players, the one disappointment for me is Burnley getting Mike Tresor on loan, he is going to be one hell of a player, and wouldnt have been expensive from Genk.

Are people not aware Guaita has left?

[Link] - Celta have announced he's joined.

Hilariously, Palace just don't fancy giving him the air time to announce it.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Widow review