You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson


Page 3 of 27 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
sprites Flag Auckland 21 Nov 23 7.39pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I think the jury is out on Franco, who is very young and may develop into a flop, a fair player, or even a bargain in time, and also out on Henderson insofar as we simply don't know if there are undisclosed reasons for the signing.

What is certainly true is that £40m could potentially have been spent on 'here and now' improvements to give Roy a better chance of winning games in the first half of this season. The fact that it wasn't, and that we have had injuries to key players (especially attacking ones) is hugely significant in assessing the manager's performance. Like most clubs outside of the big-boys, we simply cannot maintain our best performance levels without key players.

By the time he finally packs in it, Roy will have managed us for about half of what is by far the longest top-flight spell in our history. He has, in the main, done that with a level of spending not only lower (sometimes far lower) than two-thirds of the clubs we compete against, but also lower (again, sometimes far lower) than many of his predecessors.

I doubt that has anything to do with trusting Roy in the market (managers have very little to do with signings, especially at Palace), it's just the way the dice have rolled. He never seems to be in the hotseat on the rare occasions we are able to spend. This time around he does have the benefit of the good players we signed for Vieira, but has of course lost Wilf. Pounds-for-points he must be up there with the best of them. For me, that makes his impact on the fortunes of our club comparible with any former manager bar Coppell.

Years ago I took the football coaching badges. I never worked in the professional game, but I did spend time in some interesting places with some interesting people.

Once, I was invited to a coaching demonstration by Ray Lewington at Fulham, where he and Roy were having great success at the time. After the session, Ray took a few questions. The matter of Roy's preferred tactics and reported coaching methods came up, and Ray could not have been clearer: Roy coaches 11v11, methodically, in repetitive, almost robotic detail on each and every occasion it is possible to do so. And yes, it bores the life out of the players. And yes, they beg to do something with a bit more zip. And no, he never changes.

Whether he does things any differently now I don't know, but there are videos on line of him doing this type of work at West Brom, and he was pretty famous for it. Some of the videos of Palace training sessions show short, sharp stuff, so perhaps Roy has changed. I doubt it though. It's more likely that the stuff we see is taken from the one or two times a week they are not working on shape!

One of the things I found during the coaching courses was that almost everyone, from elite footballers to semi-pros hates tactical sessions where they work methodically on shape. It's not just boring, it is often frustrating and even demoralising, to have to stop and walk through the same little details again and again when football is usually such a dynamic, intuitive and fast-paced game. In fact, the general consensus was that too much of that type of work can risk a revolt.

So why does Roy seem genuinely popular with his players?

Obviously, as Ray pointed out at Fulham, the results justify the methods. He is not just keeping clubs save in mid-table, he is keeping players, and their careers and prospects, there too. That will smooth many a bump.

Mostly though I think he just seems like a decent bloke. He is renowned for being multi-lingual, well-read and articulate, but that doesn't seem to translate into aloofness or arrogance (although by all accounts he can be a bit of a spiky character if required).

I listen to a podcast called 'Undr the Cosh' in which former journeyman footballers interview other, former journeyman players. It is striking how often they cite nothing more than basic honesty, decent manners and personal consistency as the key ingredients of the best managers they ever had, and how many managers seem to lack those things. One of the hallmarks of our stay in the top-flight has been the relative absence of drama and intrigue. I think Roy calmly, fairly and politely going about his work has a lot to do with that stability, which in turn puts us a league place or two above any club that self-destructs (of which there are usually at least one or two most years).

All in all, he will be difficult to replace.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (21 Nov 2023 11.58am)

I don't suppose you could track them down for us could you mate? I can't find them...!

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 23 Nov 23 8.28pm

Originally posted by sprites

I don't suppose you could track them down for us could you mate? I can't find them...!

[Link]

[Link]

There you go.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 25 Nov 23 7.49pm

In a recent podcast Roy spoke at length about a solid defence being the number one priority in the Premier League. And about the need to make the most out of the players you have. Well where is that solidity Roy? Five goals shipped against two of the poorer teams in the league. What is going on?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Nov 23 11.34am

Talksport reckon Parish will hire Cooper if he's sacked by forest. I'll be surprised tbh.

 


COYP

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 28 Nov 23 11.49am

What we dont know is Roys Health, Winter coming, training pitch most days, not good for a man of 76 and with a net worth of $26, i would be in the Caribbean, or the Canaries

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 28 Nov 23 11.50am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

What we dont know is Roys Health, Winter coming, training pitch most days, not good for a man of 76 and with a net worth of , i would be in the Caribbean, or the Canaries

$26m that is

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Nov 23 12.01pm

The only way I see Roy going is if the fans turned toxic (which I don't see happening) or if we slip into the relegation zone. Given we are currently 10 points clear of the drop that seems unlikely to happen before Christmas even if we lost all of our games. Personally I think we'll cobble together 20 points by Christmas and by Easter we'll be all but safe after a few more ugly wins. Roy will take the stabilisers off for the last few games and everyone will ask, 'why didn't we play this well earlier in the season?'

 

PatrickA Flag London 28 Nov 23 12.02pm

Excellent and thought provoking analysis.I guess Roy's methods work well with clubs of our stature, but are less likely to succeed at elite clubs with exceptional players and the expectation of having to win all the time and also entertain. Never too low with Roy, but also never too high.

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I think the jury is out on Franco, who is very young and may develop into a flop, a fair player, or even a bargain in time, and also out on Henderson insofar as we simply don't know if there are undisclosed reasons for the signing.

What is certainly true is that £40m could potentially have been spent on 'here and now' improvements to give Roy a better chance of winning games in the first half of this season. The fact that it wasn't, and that we have had injuries to key players (especially attacking ones) is hugely significant in assessing the manager's performance. Like most clubs outside of the big-boys, we simply cannot maintain our best performance levels without key players.

By the time he finally packs in it, Roy will have managed us for about half of what is by far the longest top-flight spell in our history. He has, in the main, done that with a level of spending not only lower (sometimes far lower) than two-thirds of the clubs we compete against, but also lower (again, sometimes far lower) than many of his predecessors.

I doubt that has anything to do with trusting Roy in the market (managers have very little to do with signings, especially at Palace), it's just the way the dice have rolled. He never seems to be in the hotseat on the rare occasions we are able to spend. This time around he does have the benefit of the good players we signed for Vieira, but has of course lost Wilf. Pounds-for-points he must be up there with the best of them. For me, that makes his impact on the fortunes of our club comparible with any former manager bar Coppell.

Years ago I took the football coaching badges. I never worked in the professional game, but I did spend time in some interesting places with some interesting people.

Once, I was invited to a coaching demonstration by Ray Lewington at Fulham, where he and Roy were having great success at the time. After the session, Ray took a few questions. The matter of Roy's preferred tactics and reported coaching methods came up, and Ray could not have been clearer: Roy coaches 11v11, methodically, in repetitive, almost robotic detail on each and every occasion it is possible to do so. And yes, it bores the life out of the players. And yes, they beg to do something with a bit more zip. And no, he never changes.

Whether he does things any differently now I don't know, but there are videos on line of him doing this type of work at West Brom, and he was pretty famous for it. Some of the videos of Palace training sessions show short, sharp stuff, so perhaps Roy has changed. I doubt it though. It's more likely that the stuff we see is taken from the one or two times a week they are not working on shape!

One of the things I found during the coaching courses was that almost everyone, from elite footballers to semi-pros hates tactical sessions where they work methodically on shape. It's not just boring, it is often frustrating and even demoralising, to have to stop and walk through the same little details again and again when football is usually such a dynamic, intuitive and fast-paced game. In fact, the general consensus was that too much of that type of work can risk a revolt.

So why does Roy seem genuinely popular with his players?

Obviously, as Ray pointed out at Fulham, the results justify the methods. He is not just keeping clubs save in mid-table, he is keeping players, and their careers and prospects, there too. That will smooth many a bump.

Mostly though I think he just seems like a decent bloke. He is renowned for being multi-lingual, well-read and articulate, but that doesn't seem to translate into aloofness or arrogance (although by all accounts he can be a bit of a spiky character if required).

I listen to a podcast called 'Undr the Cosh' in which former journeyman footballers interview other, former journeyman players. It is striking how often they cite nothing more than basic honesty, decent manners and personal consistency as the key ingredients of the best managers they ever had, and how many managers seem to lack those things. One of the hallmarks of our stay in the top-flight has been the relative absence of drama and intrigue. I think Roy calmly, fairly and politely going about his work has a lot to do with that stability, which in turn puts us a league place or two above any club that self-destructs (of which there are usually at least one or two most years).

All in all, he will be difficult to replace.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (21 Nov 2023 11.58am)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 28 Nov 23 12.04pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Talksport reckon Parish will hire Cooper if he's sacked by forest. I'll be surprised tbh.

That's been rumbling for a while...if we were to get less than 4 points from the next two games and Cooper gets the boot then it wouldn't surprise me at all.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 28 Nov 23 12.22pm

I’m a big fan of Roy’s and I’m glad, as a team that spends next to nothing most years, that we have him in charge.

But, I wanted him to leave at the end of last season. After some of the stick he got at end of his last tenure and then calling it a day in front of 5,000 fans in a Covid restricted stadium it would’ve been nice for him to have had a proper send off in a packed Selhurst and whilst his stock was high again after sorting the mess PV had left us in.

And in hindsight any manager we got in during the summer would’ve had a free hit this season as no chance of going down!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Nov 23 12.24pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

I’m a big fan of Roy’s and I’m glad, as a team that spends next to nothing most years, that we have him in charge.

But, I wanted him to leave at the end of last season. After some of the stick he got at end of his last tenure and then calling it a day in front of 5,000 fans in a Covid restricted stadium it would’ve been nice for him to have had a proper send off in a packed Selhurst and whilst his stock was high again after sorting the mess PV had left us in.

And in hindsight any manager we got in during the summer would’ve had a free hit this season as no chance of going down!

Yes, and agree with rest of post, however when he came back, and stayed, in I saw it as indication we'd be getting next to nothing for the first team. Turned out to be the case.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 28 Nov 23 12.46pm

Originally posted by samprior

That's been rumbling for a while...if we were to get less than 4 points from the next two games and Cooper gets the boot then it wouldn't surprise me at all.

I'd be very happy with this. Cooper or Potter for me

 

Eagle Black. Flag South Croydon 28 Nov 23 12.56pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I'd be very happy with this. Cooper or Potter for me

Definitly Potter for me.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 28 Nov 23 1.04pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I'd be very happy with this. Cooper or Potter for me

Whoever eventually takes over I want someone who can better utilise the players we have. We do have some very good players but they are not giving of their best and I'd like to know if it is Hodgson's tactics that is holding them back.

I think his team selection against West Ham will be indicative of his current thinking - a team with Ward and Schlupp will underline his negativity whereas a newcomer would address our weaknesses and at least try Richards at right back and bring in Ahamada - and also be more imaginative with substitutions instead of the now established ritual of bringing on Mateta to illustrate his lack of ability and the manager's lack of ambition.

I await his line-up on Sunday in the hope it will not be the same old ...

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 28 Nov 23 2.47pm

Rob Edwards?

 

Zaha127 Flag 28 Nov 23 3.53pm

Potter for me. He is not a top 4 manager. But he is a manager who can get a team into Europe.

Palace's last 5 EPL finishes: 11th, 12th, 14th, 14th and 12th.

If Palace can become a side that comes in the top 10 consistently then Potter is a good choice. Palace fans would also bite your hand if you told them that they would get a manager that would get you in the top 10.

First it is not impossible. Last year Palace came 11th. Give Potter time. Not necessarily a lot of money. We know Palace do not spend much compared to other sides. A new RB, ST and retaining the current squad.

Additionally, promoting some players from our academy to the first team squad e.g. Ozoh, Adaramola, Wells Morrison, Ola Adebomi. We keep hearing of how good the academy is but since Mitchell who has really broke through? I think most of our fans would also love to see academy players coming through. Of course we do not expect them to play 90 mins every game but being part of the squad, getting minutes etc..


If we cannot get a new RB and ST why not play Imray and Ola Adebomi? If given the chance, they can be good players to the squad.


Edited by Zaha127 (28 Nov 2023 3.55pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Nov 23 5.30pm

The pot of speculation is simmering, the narrative appears to imply that Mr Hodgson is on the brink, his hat is on a shaky peg etc etc.There is a some 'Noise' on this matter but as far as I am concerned it is a load of old phooey.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 28 Nov 23 5.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

The pot of speculation is simmering, the narrative appears to imply that Mr Hodgson is on the brink, his hat is on a shaky peg etc etc.There is a some 'Noise' on this matter but as far as I am concerned it is a load of old phooey.

Would you go as far as to say it’s Hogswash ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Nov 23 5.44pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Would you go as far as to say it’s Hogswash ?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Nov 23 6.38pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Whoever eventually takes over I want someone who can better utilise the players we have. We do have some very good players but they are not giving of their best and I'd like to know if it is Hodgson's tactics that is holding them back.

I think his team selection against West Ham will be indicative of his current thinking - a team with Ward and Schlupp will underline his negativity whereas a newcomer would address our weaknesses and at least try Richards at right back and bring in Ahamada - and also be more imaginative with substitutions instead of the now established ritual of bringing on Mateta to illustrate his lack of ability and the manager's lack of ambition.

I await his line-up on Sunday in the hope it will not be the same old ...

I think we've got the worst centre forward options in the Premier League together with possibly the most limited full back pairing.

Our midfield are bereft of dynamism or a regular goalscorer (unless you include Eze) and we regularly start Schlupp, Ayew and Hughes who can best be described as average when they were in their prime.

I'd say that's a pretty big handicap and the talk of top ten has almost been laughable IMO.

As has been said many times on this forum it's a results business and any manager is only half a dozen bad ones away from being under pressure.

However, I find it ironic that a story like the Telegraph one has come out this early when the Board should be taking a hard look in the mirror at their work over the last few months.

It also worries me that the last decent window was reportedly funded by Textor.

 

Page 3 of 27 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson