This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Rose tinted specs. In my view the Watkins Villa pen was 50:50. Was right to stick with the original decision as it wasn't a clear and obvious error. Equally, would have been right to stick with it if no pen was given. If we want VAR to work effectively it can't be used to challenge every decision made. No one wants that. Benefit of doubt has to go in favour of the referees original decision. Many fouls are subjective with pundits and fans often split. Offside's are more black and white and decisions based on clear rules. The Liverpool offside was a clear major cock up. I don't understand why they couldn't just stop the game immediately once they realised their mistake. Took him 5 minutes to justify his original decision though. Obviously VAR thought it was wrong, would love to hear the audio
|
|
|
Originally posted by Bexley Eagle
I cannot believe the bollox around they thought the goal was given on the pitch? Are they not watching the game? I reckon he was taking a leak or something. They’ve got one job basically, watch the game!! You would think that would be their main remit, to at the very least actually be watching the game. Now you get the impression it’s like Paul Merson in the Soccer Saturday studio
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Rose tinted specs. In my view the Watkins Villa pen was 50:50. Was right to stick with the original decision as it wasn't a clear and obvious error. Equally, would have been right to stick with it if no pen was given. If we want VAR to work effectively it can't be used to challenge every decision made. No one wants that. Benefit of doubt has to go in favour of the referees original decision. Many fouls are subjective with pundits and fans often split. Offside's are more black and white and decisions based on clear rules. The Liverpool offside was a clear major cock up. I don't understand why they couldn't just stop the game immediately once they realised their mistake. The PGMOL issued an apology. So they obviously thought the decision was wrong in hindsight. Also there was a directive, yes another one, at the beginning of this season (or last I can't remember) that said that referees were to stop giving soft penalties/fouls - there is no doubt that the penalty was soft even if it does come under the "seen them given" category.
The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore. |
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Rose tinted specs. In my view the Watkins Villa pen was 50:50. Was right to stick with the original decision as it wasn't a clear and obvious error. Equally, would have been right to stick with it if no pen was given. I respect your opinion and you may well have seen different footage of the incident to me. But the 3 or 4 angles of it and replays of it that I have seen, show Richards played the ball twice and won it cleanly. Presumably that is what VAR also saw and is why they sent Darren England to the monitor…and tried for 5 minutes to get him to see sense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Oh dear . . . Talk about "assassination" by social media & HOL. YES, he/they made a error(I'm being polite). How many of all of you could referee a game? C'mon, put up, OR shut up! I wouldn't advise the Liverpool forums.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Davepalace707
No a Liverpool supporting mate sent it. As you can imagine they have several similar bits of info circulating I can well imagine.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Oh dear . . . Talk about "assassination" by social media & HOL. YES, he/they made a error(I'm being polite). How many of all of you could referee a game? C'mon, put up, OR shut up! Fair comment. I reffed one game 'officially' and decided it wasn't for me. However, Darren England has put himself up to do this and is clearly incompetent, so he should do the honourable thing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sansbup
Darren England has put himself up to do this and is clearly incompetent, so he should do the honourable thing. Harakiri ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Oh dear . . . Talk about "assassination" by social media & HOL. YES, he/they made a error(I'm being polite). How many of all of you could referee a game? C'mon, put up, OR shut up! I think you are an eminently reasoned and sensible poster and I do think that a lot of the noise on this issue in this forum is based on perceived wrongs Mr England has inflicted on us in the past. But I think I need to take issue on this point,1) The error that Mr England made was nothing to do with his ability to referee a game. It was to do with his ability to focus and concentrate for a fairly short period time and to pay particular attention to decisions that happen even less frequently within that time period. I don’t know anyone who has been successful in any walk of life that can’t do that, especially when they have an assistant to help them get things right. The fact that someone who is purportedly at the very top of their vocation was unable to do that seems to me extraordinary – Especially as the task they were performing wasn't exactly mentally tricky. The VAR technician seemed to have a reasonable understanding as to what was going on and he probably couldn’t referee a game. 2) If we were to overlook that shortcoming and say that it was an excusable error that anyone could make (it wasn’t), it is the reaction to that error that was the most telling. Effectively he just froze, didn’t listen to his colleague the VAR guy, and then said nothing could be done, while seeming to me that he was hoping that no one would notice. That should not be the reaction of someone in such a high level job, they should be able to think fast, be decisive and command the situation. All attributes that a good Referee at that level should possess. Edited by tshepp897 (04 Oct 2023 7.23pm)
The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore. |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Oh dear . . . Talk about "assassination" by social media & HOL. YES, he/they made a error(I'm being polite). How many of all of you could referee a game? C'mon, put up, OR shut up! It isn’t my profession so why should I? However if I made a string of errors in my line of work I would be at the very least disciplined. There would be consequences.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Oh dear . . . Talk about "assassination" by social media & HOL. YES, he/they made a error(I'm being polite). How many of all of you could referee a game? C'mon, put up, OR shut up! God forbid we should discuss a huge footballing incident, probably the biggest VAR mistake yet, on a football forum
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace 1979
Sad to say it, but looks like England is back at the weekend. His decisions could cost clubs a lot of money if they miss Europe etc, yet he gets a 1 game ban. Madness... They are, after officiating in the Gulf, as part of the FA's link up with the respective associations. Chairman/Managers/Players also cost money, missing out on Europe & Relegation, Ok? Can i please say, it is every fans 'duty' to slag the ref off fter every game, its expected, regardless the result. Ive done it myself. Ive also had it done to me(not nice) ive been shouted at, pushed. spat at, assaulted, hospitalised & i even had to run for my life after doing a game in Greece & the police/stewards were laughing. Slag refs off if you want(fans privilege), try reffing a game yourself & understand what it means. Darren England/Dan Cook messed up BIG time, no doubt, the grief they are going to get, well, gotta love fans. I always said, if BOTH teams/fans hated me, i was consistent Edited by eagleman13 (17 Oct 2023 5.59pm)
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
They are, after officiating in the Gulf, as part of the FA's link up with the respective associations. Chairman/Managers/Players also cost money, missing out on Europe & Relegation, Ok? Can i please say, it is every fans 'duty' to slag the ref off fter every game, its expected, regardless the result. Ive done it myself. Ive also had it done to me(not nice) ive been shouted at, pushed. spat at, assaulted, hospitalised & i even had to run for my life after doing a game in Greece & the police/stewards were laughing. Slag refs off if you want(fans privilege), try reffing a game yourself & understand what it means. Darren England/Dan Cook messed up BIG time, no doubt, the grief they are going to get, well, gotta love fans. I always said, if BOTH teams/fans hated me, i was consistent Edited by eagleman13 (17 Oct 2023 5.59pm) You are Gussie Gates and I claim my £5!
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Palace 1979
I understand your points and many are valid. I have reffed some matches myself after a serious injury when playing at a good level, and yes it is tough and very unrewarding and I walked away quite quickly. However, when you are at the very top of your profession and are setting an example to other upcoming refs, it's the impression they give that worries me. Rumours of favourites and untouchable refs was quite clear when we are able to listen to the commentary. There has been lots of this before this incident, but being able to listen to the commentary and the way the VAR operator was totally ignored proved this point. Darren England stating there was "nothing they could do" was pathetic and only thinking of his reputation and not the good of the game. He clearly has an inflated ego which was also apparent just a few weeks before with the way he would not over turn the penalty at Villa. There is too much money at stake now for these mistakes just to continue and go unpunished properly. A 1 match ban gives no incentive to improve. Maybe a card/point system similar to players would be an option. The more mistakes the longer the ban ! Agree with this, totally wrong to relegate incompetence to the Championship for a game or two Edited by HKOwen (18 Oct 2023 11.10am)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.