You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer policy
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer policy


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
palace99 Flag New Mills 01 Nov 23 9.52am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt


Leaving aside that we did sign Ferguson, Clyne, and Richards in that time, neither of us know if we did try to sign Walker-Peters, or if we did, how hard we tried, or why we didn't get him. Very hard to be critical of Palace without that information, and that's my point really.

Maybe we did bid for Walker-Peters but were outbid by Southampton, or he wanted to leave London, or they offered more in wages, or he fancied his chances of being first choice for them more than for us.

Maybe the club didn't think much of him (I personally don't). Who knows? Either way, if we are looking for players that were seemingly feasible signings you can take Walker-Peters and times him by at least a hundred over the last few years I'd guess. Each will have a story of its own that we will never know.

he's a Southampton player, so not sure how they can outbid us. They've just been relegated so are hardly handing out improved terms, and in WPs case he has 2 years left of a 5 year contract.

It is probably as simple as, if we enquired, they asked for a higher transfer fee than we were prepared to pay so the conversation ended. They also sold another RB to Newcastle so didn't want to lose 2 in the same window.

Clyne was signed as a stop gap when AWB left - 4 years on he's still here, as a stop gap. That sums up our transfer policy

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Nov 23 10.03am

Originally posted by palace99

he's a Southampton player, so not sure how they can outbid us. They've just been relegated so are hardly handing out improved terms, and in WPs case he has 2 years left of a 5 year contract.

It is probably as simple as, if we enquired, they asked for a higher transfer fee than we were prepared to pay so the conversation ended. They also sold another RB to Newcastle so didn't want to lose 2 in the same window.

Clyne was signed as a stop gap when AWB left - 4 years on he's still here, as a stop gap. That sums up our transfer policy

Boom, nailed it. We have / have had a number of players who could / should have been released but Parish prefers to offer them new contracts rather than scour the market, Benteke springs immediately to mind, Schlupp is another. The players are happy to go through the motions and pick up a handy pay packet, they know they are not going to go upwards in their careers so accept what Parish offers.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 10.21am)

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 Nov 23 10.43am

Originally posted by palace99

he's a Southampton player, so not sure how they can outbid us. They've just been relegated so are hardly handing out improved terms, and in WPs case he has 2 years left of a 5 year contract.

It is probably as simple as, if we enquired, they asked for a higher transfer fee than we were prepared to pay so the conversation ended. They also sold another RB to Newcastle so didn't want to lose 2 in the same window.

Clyne was signed as a stop gap when AWB left - 4 years on he's still here, as a stop gap. That sums up our transfer policy

I was responding to the suggestion that we should have signed WP when he left Spurs.

Again, we did sign Ferguson (highly enough rated and sought after at the time) and Richards in that period, something a few people seem to gloss over.

Perhaps replacing Ward or Clyne with a younger, better player, within our budget and whilst also strengthening other positions isn't quite as easy as people think.

Listening to some people on here you'd think Clyne and Ward were members of the f***ing public.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 Nov 23 10.50am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Boom, nailed it. We have / have had a number of players who could / should have been released but Parish prefers to offer them new contracts rather than scour the market, Benteke springs immediately to mind, Schlupp is another. The players are happy to go through the motions and pick up a handy pay packet, they know they are not going to go upwards in their careers so accept what Parish offers.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 10.21am)

It's easy to say we should release X and Y, but you have to have a better player to replace them with first, or else you become weaker overall. Painful as it might be at the time, it is better to have Benetke than nobody, or (more realistically) better to renew Benteke's contract than to spend millions of pounds on a transfer fee for a player who will be no better.

As per my posts above, none of us know what attempts were made to buy a new forward before the decision was taken to renew Benteke for another year, so none of us can say that the club 'preferred' to keep the player they had.

What we do know is that footballers who are good enough to improve the (roughly) 12th or 13th best team in the best league in the world don't grow on trees. They cost the earth, will be highly sought-after, and we will not be their first choice option in most cases.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Nov 23 11.03am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

It's easy to say we should release X and Y, but you have to have a better player to replace them with first, or else you become weaker overall. Painful as it might be at the time, it is better to have Benetke than nobody, or (more realistically) better to renew Benteke's contract than to spend millions of pounds on a transfer fee for a player who will be no better.

As per my posts above, none of us know what attempts were made to buy a new forward before the decision was taken to renew Benteke for another year, so none of us can say that the club 'preferred' to keep the player they had.

What we do know is that footballers who are good enough to improve the (roughly) 12th or 13th best team in the best league in the world don't grow on trees. They cost the earth, will be highly sought-after, and we will not be their first choice option in most cases.

Agree, some posters seem to believe running a club is the same as playing Football Manager online. Buy him , cancel his contract etc it’s not reality. It was widely reported Hall was coming on loan from Chelsea, we extend Olises contract, then Chelsea block Halls loan as a result. Zaha kept us hanging on for weeks, then decides to go to Turkey, leaving very little time to get a replacement.

It’s not as easy as people think, there are so many variables.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Nov 23 11.12am

There is without doubt an imbalance ,that is hard to understand let alone explain. Tomkins ,didn’t have another season in him, Furguson say no more, Clyde, nothing lasts for ever, but all kept, in an area of the team that some of the outward loans ,could have covered with a better chance than some of those we try in forward areas. Then we say good bye to three experienced mid fielders, including a loan, and only replace one spot, Lerma. Add to that Wilf, goes ,absolutely no surprise surely.
Surely at this point, it’s going to need at least four ready to use players just to get par.
We know what we got , cover for Tomkins, and it would seem, a £20 million huge maybe. And this is without addressing fullbacks, or something more up front.
The goalkeeping thing crept up on them, had to be sorted , but how it was sorted what it cost, is highly debatable. So we are just left with thinking our club conveyor belt will keep us safe, that remains much more wishful thinking than fact.
Some here mention McCarthy, It would seem some one puts a lot of faith in him, and the conveyor belt players for forward areas. Don’t think it’s Hodgson, or Ray.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Nov 23 11.49am

Originally posted by Painter

Agree, some posters seem to believe running a club is the same as playing Football Manager online. Buy him , cancel his contract etc it’s not reality. It was widely reported Hall was coming on loan from Chelsea, we extend Olises contract, then Chelsea block Halls loan as a result. Zaha kept us hanging on for weeks, then decides to go to Turkey, leaving very little time to get a replacement.

It’s not as easy as people think, there are so many variables.

What an utter load of rubbish. No-one on here thinks this is football manager. The reality is we failed to fill gaping holes in our squad, in some cases for 4 years and yet if you consider the business done in the last 6 or so windows they are still not considered a priority by our management. Roy sees the problem, most of the fans see the problem, but clearly you and a couple of others don’t and obviously agree with the continual Parish line of, “it’s very difficult “. That is a line that is wearing very thin now.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Nov 23 11.55am

Originally posted by Painter

Agree, some posters seem to believe running a club is the same as playing Football Manager online. Buy him , cancel his contract etc it’s not reality. It was widely reported Hall was coming on loan from Chelsea, we extend Olises contract, then Chelsea block Halls loan as a result. Zaha kept us hanging on for weeks, then decides to go to Turkey, leaving very little time to get a replacement.

It’s not as easy as people think, there are so many variables.

No one is saying it is easy, but we have / have had a number of players well past their sell by date. For whatever reason Parish prefers to offer them another contract rather than clear the decks. It doesn't say much about the quality of the Academy if the academy players can't break into the first team squad. My understanding is that this what Parish is ultimately hoping for. Then again it has to be wondered about the level of scouting expertise when the likes of Edouard and Mateta are brought in, plus a few sick notes here and there. Doesn't due diligence exist in the scouting department?

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 12.39pm)

 

rikz Flag Croydon 01 Nov 23 12.22pm

Originally posted by Painter

Agree, some posters seem to believe running a club is the same as playing Football Manager online. Buy him , cancel his contract etc it’s not reality. It was widely reported Hall was coming on loan from Chelsea, we extend Olises contract, then Chelsea block Halls loan as a result. Zaha kept us hanging on for weeks, then decides to go to Turkey, leaving very little time to get a replacement.

It’s not as easy as people think, there are so many variables.

Its definitely easy enough to have more than one LB in your squad and whoever finds that difficult shouldn't hold a position at a premier league club.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 01 Nov 23 12.37pm

Originally posted by Painter

Agree, some posters seem to believe running a club is the same as playing Football Manager online. Buy him , cancel his contract etc it’s not reality. It was widely reported Hall was coming on loan from Chelsea, we extend Olises contract, then Chelsea block Halls loan as a result. Zaha kept us hanging on for weeks, then decides to go to Turkey, leaving very little time to get a replacement.

It’s not as easy as people think, there are so many variables.

Of course are a lot of variables, but lets be honest we seam to be one of the worst at it. We brought in the joint lowest amount of players this window (4).

And that's on top of a thin squad.

We also havent utilised the loan market, which is insane.

And on Wilf, as soon as he didnt renew his contract we knew he was leaving. We've had years to plan for his departure.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 01 Nov 23 12.50pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

No one is saying it is easy, but we have / have had a number of players well past their sell by date. For whatever reason Parish prefers to offer them another contract rather than clear the decks. It doesn't say much about the quality of the Academy if the academy players can't break into the first team squad. My understanding is that this what Parish is ultimately hoping for. Then again it has to be wondered about the level of scouting expertise when the likes of Edouard and Mateta are brought in, plus a few sick notes here and there. Doesn't due diligence exist in the scouting department?

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 12.39pm)

Agreed. We haven’t had a decent striker since Murray. Brentford Fulham Brighton etc etc etc have all managed it.

 

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 01 Nov 23 12.59pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

No one is saying it is easy, but we have / have had a number of players well past their sell by date. For whatever reason Parish prefers to offer them another contract rather than clear the decks. It doesn't say much about the quality of the Academy if the academy players can't break into the first team squad. My understanding is that this what Parish is ultimately hoping for. Then again it has to be wondered about the level of scouting expertise when the likes of Edouard and Mateta are brought in, plus a few sick notes here and there. Doesn't due diligence exist in the scouting department?

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 12.39pm)

You're right about Edouard and Mateta (and I'd add Riedewald to this list), but we have had some hits as well with the likes of Eze, Olise, Guehi, Anderson, Doucoure, etc. and with a bit of luck Franca. I think the academy might start bringing people through like Rak-Sakyi and Ozoh now starting to appear, but could be a while before we see a regular stream of players coming through as a result of the recent upgrading.

However, that being said, no idea why we've not strengthed the fullbacks. I think Ward turned 34 this week, Clyne is 32 and Ferguson, feel sorry for the lad, but with all these injuries he needs to start looking to get his coaching badges if he wants to stay in football, as I don't ever see him appearing on the pitch for us.

With a striker, we've been crying out for someone for years and a first-team-ready striker costs an arm and a leg, so I can see why they tried cheaper alternatives. However, think the time has come to push the boat out as much as we can and get someone decent in. There's been talk of Hugo Ekitike since the last transfer window, but who knows?

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Nov 23 1.24pm

Originally posted by SnapperKain

You're right about Edouard and Mateta (and I'd add Riedewald to this list), but we have had some hits as well with the likes of Eze, Olise, Guehi, Anderson, Doucoure, etc. and with a bit of luck Franca. I think the academy might start bringing people through like Rak-Sakyi and Ozoh now starting to appear, but could be a while before we see a regular stream of players coming through as a result of the recent upgrading.

However, that being said, no idea why we've not strengthed the fullbacks. I think Ward turned 34 this week, Clyne is 32 and Ferguson, feel sorry for the lad, but with all these injuries he needs to start looking to get his coaching badges if he wants to stay in football, as I don't ever see him appearing on the pitch for us.

With a striker, we've been crying out for someone for years and a first-team-ready striker costs an arm and a leg, so I can see why they tried cheaper alternatives. However, think the time has come to push the boat out as much as we can and get someone decent in. There's been talk of Hugo Ekitike since the last transfer window, but who knows?

Yes there's no denying that.

Agree totally.

In another thread I mention Hwang at Wolves, starting to come good for them - energetic and determined, qualities that our pair of lazy duffers lack. £13m. Decent forwards are out there, our scouting hasn't identified them. I do wonder what the decision making process was for Mateta, did Dougie look at "best of" 90 second Youtube clip and think "yeah, he fits the budget"?

 

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 01 Nov 23 2.34pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Yes there's no denying that.

Agree totally.

In another thread I mention Hwang at Wolves, starting to come good for them - energetic and determined, qualities that our pair of lazy duffers lack. £13m. Decent forwards are out there, our scouting hasn't identified them. I do wonder what the decision making process was for Mateta, did Dougie look at "best of" 90 second Youtube clip and think "yeah, he fits the budget"?

I can't defend the signing of Mateta, that's definitely one we've got wrong as he's just not good enough for the prem and unfortunately, a bit lazy as well IMHO. Frustrated the hell out of me against Spurs when he just came on so presumably full of energy and just didn't shift his arse, especially to get out of offside positions.

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 01 Nov 23 3.25pm

Originally posted by SnapperKain

I can't defend the signing of Mateta, that's definitely one we've got wrong as he's just not good enough for the prem and unfortunately, a bit lazy as well IMHO. Frustrated the hell out of me against Spurs when he just came on so presumably full of energy and just didn't shift his arse, especially to get out of offside positions.

To be fair he looked pretty good against Plymouth reserves, maybe we can do some sort of swap with them, it’s certainly his level.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 01 Nov 23 6.46pm

I think one of the major frustrations on the striker front is that we seem to keep signing players in the same mould, i.e. big and lacking energy. Why haven't we tried going down a different route? Even just on loan. A quick striker who will put pressure on defenders and try and force mistakes. Eze and Olise are both more than capable of slide-rule passes to get a quick striker in behind a defence.

 

PatrickA Flag London 02 Nov 23 8.09am

I'm not particularly a fan of Mateta or Edouard, who both contribute so little in terms of running the channels, closing down defenders or generally making a nuisance of themselves.
However, I will defend them in terms of the lack of service they receive.
It's notable at Villa, for example, Digne and Cash play a string of crosses every game.
Not aimless crosses, but crosses that defenders find difficult to defend and that are inviting for forwards.
Ward and Mitchell provide perhaps a couple of crosses per game and usually in no particular direction.
The difference is marked.
I suspect Watkins would struggle for goals in our side, although he would work a good deal harder than Mateta and Edouard.
The lack of service from out wide should be less of an issue when Olise and Eze return because they find other ways to create.
However, without those two any striker will struggle to score in our present team unless they create the chances themselves out of nothing.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Nov 23 8.53am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I'm not particularly a fan of Mateta or Edouard, who both contribute so little in terms of running the channels, closing down defenders or generally making a nuisance of themselves.
However, I will defend them in terms of the lack of service they receive.
It's notable at Villa, for example, Digne and Cash play a string of crosses every game.
Not aimless crosses, but crosses that defenders find difficult to defend and that are inviting for forwards.
Ward and Mitchell provide perhaps a couple of crosses per game and usually in no particular direction.
The difference is marked.
I suspect Watkins would struggle for goals in our side, although he would work a good deal harder than Mateta and Edouard.
The lack of service from out wide should be less of an issue when Olise and Eze return because they find other ways to create.
However, without those two any striker will struggle to score in our present team unless they create the chances themselves out of nothing.

In modern football the two full back positions are very important and an overlapping fullback should be your major source of crosses if you are not playing with out and out wingers. They are areas we should be looking to improve if we want to increase chances for our forwards in my opinion.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Nov 23 9.04am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I'm not particularly a fan of Mateta or Edouard, who both contribute so little in terms of running the channels, closing down defenders or generally making a nuisance of themselves.
However, I will defend them in terms of the lack of service they receive.
It's notable at Villa, for example, Digne and Cash play a string of crosses every game.
Not aimless crosses, but crosses that defenders find difficult to defend and that are inviting for forwards.
Ward and Mitchell provide perhaps a couple of crosses per game and usually in no particular direction.
The difference is marked.
I suspect Watkins would struggle for goals in our side, although he would work a good deal harder than Mateta and Edouard.
The lack of service from out wide should be less of an issue when Olise and Eze return because they find other ways to create.
However, without those two any striker will struggle to score in our present team unless they create the chances themselves out of nothing.

Excellent post. Currently we have no natural width, injuries noted. No natural wingers, and no overlapping fullbacks. The fullbacks dare not cross the half way line in support lest they get caught out. A fullback needs pace and stamina to get up and down throughout a game. It's not the current manager's style to press too many players forward at any one time. I've noticed that when the ball is put into the box sharpish Edouard does know where to position himself and stick out a leg to try and get on the end of things.
Our build up is too predictable, and we don't get behind the opposition fullbacks to turn their defence.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (02 Nov 2023 9.39am)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 02 Nov 23 12.46pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

In modern football the two full back positions are very important and an overlapping fullback should be your major source of crosses if you are not playing with out and out wingers. They are areas we should be looking to improve if we want to increase chances for our forwards in my opinion.

100% agree. With inverted wingers its a vitally important position . I genuinely think we'd kick on hugely with a couple of decent full backs

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer policy