You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > People's obsession with the academy
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

People's obsession with the academy


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Nov 23 10.57am

If we could produce the odd player even to sell for a couple of mil to the lower leagues, or abroad, with sell on fees we'd be doing well.

 


Red and Blue Army!

TheBigToePunt Flag 06 Nov 23 11.43am

This thread originally focused on how many players we have produced over the years. That seems a fair question, but I have some time for the response that we can't compare the past with the present, as we only recently got a top-class academy.

Perhaps instead of asking how many players we have produced in the past, we should ask whether there are any examples of clubs our size regularly producing players and/or a profit.

This is interesting:

[Link]

The article is focused on profit form transfers in youth-graduates, rather than number of graduates into the first team but, as you might guess, the most 'profitable' youth set ups seem to belong either to clubs from less-wealthy leagues that are geared up to sell players to bigger leagues, or the academies of mega-clubs. Chelsea and Liverpool in particular have been very good at obtaining a premium for their unwanted graduates, whilst Liverpool are masters at kidding the world that a player with their 'branding' must be better than he actually is (Jordan Ibe, Dominic Solanke etc).

What I can't see anywhere is an example of anyone our size building a successful top-ten club on the back of promoting and/or selling academy graduates. Southampton had a prolonged period of talent-production, but it didn't help their team to higher league placings, or stop the club falling into the Championship.

As others have said, we did once produce the team of the 80's, and are in a unique catchment area, so perhaps we could produce two players a year on average good enough to keep us in the top ten and/or sell at a profit.

I think we would be the exception to the rule if we can manage to do it though.

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 06 Nov 23 12.57pm

For many years we have had second or third dibs on the local guys but now that we have the academy and we will have first choice on the locals the new kids coming in will in theory be better than the youngsters who are coming through now. I believe (and it will take a little while) the recent trickle will become a steady stream, just be patient.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 06 Nov 23 1.06pm

With Connor, Guehi, Jonstone, Mitchel, Eze, we have arguably the strongest and most viable pathway in the UK.

So compared to any time before we should offer a serious alternative to the big teams. IF not in the early years, then at least around first pro contract time.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Nov 23 1.13pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

Our academy at the moment is not a production line of PL quality players.

It is often referred to in glowing terms by The Athletic, I wonder where they are getting these stories from?

The academy is not a substitute for adequate investment in the squad, quality of investment is a whole other discussion.

It’s been operational about 18 months at best, it’s a long term project.

You seem to miss the point that paying big transfer fees for the likes of Benteke and Sakho, it’s sustainable for a club of our finances. Producing some of you own youth players is more viable route.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Nov 23 1.14pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

I can't even think of any that are regulars in the lower leagues other than the two.

Sullay KaiKai has nearly 200 football league appearances and is an international for Sierra Leone.

Hiram Boateng also pushing 200 professional games across League One and League Two

Jason Lokilo is with Hull in the Championship.

Rob Street is in league one.

Ryan Innis has 100+ football league appearances and now with Forest Green in League Two.

There's also Keshi Andersen and Freddie Ladapo who are both Championship forwards - we signed both for our academy, as opposed to developed them from kids.

Again to hammer the point, we've had below average academy facilities for nearly all of the last 10 years, so I think it's a poor measuring stick as to what we'll be capable of moving forward.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Nov 23 1.17pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This thread originally focused on how many players we have produced over the years. That seems a fair question, but I have some time for the response that we can't compare the past with the present, as we only recently got a top-class academy.

Perhaps instead of asking how many players we have produced in the past, we should ask whether there are any examples of clubs our size regularly producing players and/or a profit.

This is interesting:

[Link]

The article is focused on profit form transfers in youth-graduates, rather than number of graduates into the first team but, as you might guess, the most 'profitable' youth set ups seem to belong either to clubs from less-wealthy leagues that are geared up to sell players to bigger leagues, or the academies of mega-clubs. Chelsea and Liverpool in particular have been very good at obtaining a premium for their unwanted graduates, whilst Liverpool are masters at kidding the world that a player with their 'branding' must be better than he actually is (Jordan Ibe, Dominic Solanke etc).

What I can't see anywhere is an example of anyone our size building a successful top-ten club on the back of promoting and/or selling academy graduates. Southampton had a prolonged period of talent-production, but it didn't help their team to higher league placings, or stop the club falling into the Championship.

As others have said, we did once produce the team of the 80's, and are in a unique catchment area, so perhaps we could produce two players a year on average good enough to keep us in the top ten and/or sell at a profit.

I think we would be the exception to the rule if we can manage to do it though.

I don't think anyone is suggesting that, but there's no reason we can't supplement our first team squad with academy graduates, with the odd gem coming along every few years.

It's not an either/or - the correct model is obviously a combination of recruitment and development, but the upsides to a productive academy are obvious and absolutely worth trying.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Nov 23 1.18pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Sullay KaiKai has nearly 200 football league appearances and is an international for Sierra Leone.

Hiram Boateng also pushing 200 professional games across League One and League Two

Jason Lokilo is with Hull in the Championship.

Rob Street is in league one.

Ryan Innis has 100+ football league appearances and now with Forest Green in League Two.

There's also Keshi Andersen and Freddie Ladapo who are both Championship forwards - we signed both for our academy, as opposed to developed them from kids.

Again to hammer the point, we've had below average academy facilities for nearly all of the last 10 years, so I think it's a poor measuring stick as to what we'll be capable of moving forward.

A sign of how far Charlton have fallen last transfer window their fans were wistfully hoping they would sign him whilst acknowledging he was out of their league.

Edited by Badger11 (06 Nov 2023 1.18pm)

 


One more point

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Nov 23 1.23pm

Originally posted by Badger11

A sign of how far Charlton have fallen last transfer window their fans were wistfully hoping they would sign him whilst acknowledging he was out of their league.

Edited by Badger11 (06 Nov 2023 1.18pm)

He would be a real coup for them, which does say a lot! The kid Leaburn they have upfront currently looks a good prospect though.

Ladapo has been prolific over a few spells in League One - a decent goalscorer in the Championship, but he seems to really up the run rate in League One.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 06 Nov 23 1.28pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I don't think anyone is suggesting that, but there's no reason we can't supplement our first team squad with academy graduates, with the odd gem coming along every few years.

It's not an either/or - the correct model is obviously a combination of recruitment and development, but the upsides to a productive academy are obvious and absolutely worth trying.

Yes, that's how I should have put it, thanks.

To rephrase - I can't see any examples of clubs our size consistently supplementing their first team with at least one player a year from their academy and/or making a notable profit from selling youth team graduates, whilst still maintaining a top-ten side. I certainly can't see any examples of clubs doing that whilst developing a consistently better side.

Basically, I can't see anyone comparable to us who is able to do what we seem to hope to do.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (06 Nov 2023 1.31pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Nov 23 1.29pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

He would be a real coup for them, which does say a lot! The kid Leaburn they have upfront currently looks a good prospect though.

Ladapo has been prolific over a few spells in League One - a decent goalscorer in the Championship, but he seems to really up the run rate in League One.

I thought so to, but my Charlton mate says he is decent but being overhyped so he would be happy to sell him as long as the funds were spent on the team.

I think at the moment he is just potential but he is a lump with some skill so you can see why the bigger clubs are showing an interest.

 


One more point

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Nov 23 1.33pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Yes, that's how I should have put it, thanks.

To rephrase - I can't see any examples of clubs our size consistently supplementing their first team with at least one player a year from their academy and/or making a notable profit whilst maintaining a top-ten side.

Basically, I can't see anyone comparable to us who is able to do what we seem to hope to do.

Sure, that's quite specific parameters though.

The big 6 are not comparable in size to us, so you're left with 4 top half spaces - Newcastle and Villa now both splash out lots on transfer fees, and then it's basically us, West Ham, Brighton and Brentford competing for the last two top half spots. Could arguably include Wolves in that.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Nov 23 1.34pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I thought so to, but my Charlton mate says he is decent but being overhyped so he would be happy to sell him as long as the funds were spent on the team.

I think at the moment he is just potential but he is a lump with some skill so you can see why the bigger clubs are showing an interest.

Yeah I think a lot of the potential is in his athleticism, but plenty of players have made good careers out of that!

 

rikz Flag Croydon 06 Nov 23 1.56pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I don't think anyone is suggesting that, but there's no reason we can't supplement our first team squad with academy graduates, with the odd gem coming along every few years.

It's not an either/or - the correct model is obviously a combination of recruitment and development, but the upsides to a productive academy are obvious and absolutely worth trying.

The Premier league is full of the best players in the world not the best players in England, when people moan about mateta and Edouard and scream for the manager to give a youngster a chance, its just not a realistic option. I can almost guarantee not one player in the academy has half the ability of either player.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 06 Nov 23 2.01pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Sure, that's quite specific parameters though.

The big 6 are not comparable in size to us, so you're left with 4 top half spaces - Newcastle and Villa now both splash out lots on transfer fees, and then it's basically us, West Ham, Brighton and Brentford competing for the last two top half spots. Could arguably include Wolves in that.

They are specific parameters, yeah, but those are our circumstances.

What I am interested in is whether it is possible for us to invest so much in our academy, utilizing a unique metropolitan catchment area that produces so much talent, that we can be (as far as I can see) the first team of our size in the modern era to get into the top ten as a result of that strategy.

Or, as I suspect, will we be spending all that money just to maintain the current average success rate (one first-team player every three or four years)?

It would be great if we produced one or two players a year, sold some, played others, then better utilize our limited budget on key signings, and make noticeable progress as a result.

My point really is that we would be the first if we did. It's not an established model that we are imitating. That doesn't mean we shouldn't do it, of course.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Nov 23 2.12pm

The chances of academy players making it are pretty bleak. Less than 1% according to this.

[Link]

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Nov 23 2.13pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

They are specific parameters, yeah, but those are our circumstances.

What I am interested in is whether it is possible for us to invest so much in our academy, utilizing a unique metropolitan catchment area that produces so much talent, that we can be (as far as I can see) the first team of our size in the modern era to get into the top ten as a result of that strategy.

Or, as I suspect, will we be spending all that money just to maintain the current average success rate (one first-team player every three or four years)?

It would be great if we produced one or two players a year, sold some, played others, then better utilize our limited budget on key signings, and make noticeable progress as a result.

My point really is that we would be the first if we did. It's not an established model that we are imitating. That doesn't mean we shouldn't do it, of course.

What are we actually investing in the academy? You keep using language like 'all that money' - what does that actually look like?

If we consider producing our best ever player, an England international and a £50m right back, all in a 10-year spell as average, then certainly it's got no chance - those expectations aren't realistic.

I don't really follow that this isn't an established model - supplementing a first team with academy players is one of the most established models there is - I don't think it's necessary to distinguish between the size of the club when it comes to comparing things like that - at pretty much every level, you'll find squads topped up with academy players.

Arsenal have Saka, Nelson, Nketiah and Smith-Rose - arguably only Saka is a top level player of those four, but the other 3 form an important part of their squad.

United do the same with Hannibal, Pellestri, Garnacho.

Liverpool have Trent as the star, but also use Jones, Quansah, Bajcetic.

Chelsea have Chalobah, Colwill, James, Maatsen, Gallagher, Broja all in the squad, haven't sold a number of other graduates for big fees in the last few years (Mount, Abraham, Guehi, Tomori)

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (06 Nov 2023 2.15pm)

 

Goalpost1 Flag Worcester Park 06 Nov 23 2.28pm

I don't know how much the academy costs to run per annum but as long as the expectations are not too high to start then it is potentially a great investment. Take into account selling AWB for £50m and Wilf who has help keep us in the Prem for years, which is worth huge millions then that alone is worth it.

The next step surely though has to be a la Arsenal rather than Chelsea and bring through more first team squad players from the academy.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 06 Nov 23 2.28pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

What are we actually investing in the academy? You keep using language like 'all that money' - what does that actually look like?

If we consider producing our best ever player, an England international and a £50m right back, all in a 10-year spell as average, then certainly it's got no chance - those expectations aren't realistic.

I don't really follow that this isn't an established model - supplementing a first team with academy players is one of the most established models there is - I don't think it's necessary to distinguish between the size of the club when it comes to comparing things like that - at pretty much every level, you'll find squads topped up with academy players.

Arsenal have Saka, Nelson, Nketiah and Smith-Rose - arguably only Saka is a top level player of those four, but the other 3 form an important part of their squad.

United do the same with Hannibal, Pellestri, Garnacho.

Liverpool have Trent as the star, but also use Jones, Quansah, Bajcetic.

Chelsea have Chalobah, Colwill, James, Maatsen, Gallagher, Broja all in the squad, haven't sold a number of other graduates for big fees in the last few years (Mount, Abraham, Guehi, Tomori)

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (06 Nov 2023 2.15pm)

Not sure about the others but Garnacho was definitely signed, the same as martinelli at arsenal. The big clubs don't even want to develop youngsters anymore they want to sign the best ones from other academies just so they qualify as an English developed player.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Nov 23 2.44pm

Originally posted by rikz

Not sure about the others but Garnacho was definitely signed, the same as martinelli at arsenal. The big clubs don't even want to develop youngsters anymore they want to sign the best ones from other academies just so they qualify as an English developed player.

I think signing a 16 year old and bringing them through is still relevant - we 'signed' Phillips, Banks, O'Brien, Reid, Balmer from Irish and Scottish clubs, but they're very much part of our academy, and if any make it to the first team would be considered graduates of the academy.

Brighton 'signed' Evan Ferguson and West Ham 'signed' Declan Rice' - I don't think anyone argues they are not products of the clubs though.

We also 'signed' Mitchell from Brentford when they decided to close the academy, and JRS from Chelsea when he was released - still very much our products.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > People's obsession with the academy