This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by doombear
Well, if this extract from an Athletic article is anything to go by, França may well start tonight or at least get some decent minutes: “He’s very bright,” added Hodgson. “He came in injured with a stress fracture, so he was in the hands of the medical department and sports science people for the first two months of the time he was here, and was released to us in small batches to do small things. It’s maybe the last two months where we’ve had him every day and he’s been fit to play. “That’s two months I have had to work with him, see him and realise what a talented player (sporting director) Doug Freedman has found. “We’re going to see plenty of him. The fans and the club will like him and appreciate his play. Doug told me about this signing and his decision to bring him to the club was made before they asked me to come back — (Freedman) said he’d need a bit of time to adjust, acclimatise and that’s been the case. But he has adjusted and acclimatised.
The other thing I do not like is why do we keep doing this signing people who have injuries. Roy can praise him all he wants it's BS actions speak louder he has only had 45 minutes game time so far. We paid over 20m for him you would expect for that money the guy to start every week (I do wonder if he will be loaned out if work permit allows it)
|
|
|
First start tonight, lets see what he can do.
|
|
|
According to the BBC weather page, it was 27 degrees with thundery showers in Rio today, and next week it will be in the 30s and sunny.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
It’s in the same hamstring just a different part of it according to the medical report I read, so it’s totally related as your body compensates when you are returning from injury. If Roy had of protected him as advised by his medical staff and taken him off once we had a 2 goal lead, he wouldn’t have picked up the injury at all, simple as that. Roy trying to deflect and refusing to take any blame yet again for his deficiencies in managing a tired and not totally fit squad and you backing him as normal. You’re not related are you? I can only comment on what I know. The medical team ‘ release ‘ players to the manager when they are deemed to be ready to return to training and therefore selection. Hodgson was advised to rest Olise soon after his return from the injury he picked up playing for France. Which he did . I have not read anything from the medical team in which they advised Hodgson to sub Olise . If you can be bothered, please feel free to post in on here. And maybe you could also prove that Hodgson is “ deflecting “ by sharing the medical report that you read. I’m sure we would all like to understand more. I don’t always back Roy. If you are capable of reading my posts without the prejudice you always display towards him, that might sink in although I’m far from confident it will.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I don't want to be pessimistic, and of course it is very early days, but I didn't see any sort of quality in Franca whatsoever last night, or in his previous sub appearances. He is obviously very keen, which might be affecting his decision-making, but he seemed to have almost no judgement or awareness at all. In terms of distribution, he was trying passes which were never, ever there to be played, ignoring ones that were, but most of all making a below-average job of even those passes he did identify. At one point just before he came off, he tried a left foot pass through to Eze in the box (when Eze had clearly been tracked by covering defenders) and sort of blundered it in there at knee height. It went flying out for a goal kick. Eze gave him an encouraging clap, but must have thought 'WTF?'. A couple of minutes later Franca had the ball wide right during a period where we had Everton pinned back. Andersen stepped forward into the right-back position to offer Franca support. Our players could see what was happening and started getting ready for a cross into the box from Andersen, who was clearly setting himself to whip a first-time ball into the area. Franca held it too long, giving Everton players a chance to get close and then, instead of setting the ball in front of Andersen's right foot to allow a first-time cross, he played it too heavily just outside Andersen's left foot. Andersen had to take three touches just to prevent the counter. These are very small details, but they smack of poor quality, and Franca did it all night. Finally, his judgement when running with the ball was poor. His best moment came in the first half when he got away from the left-back on the halfway line and ran at the centre of the Everton defence. He got a free kick in a good position, but it was a needless foul - Franca had already played his pass, to nobody, despite having two well-placed players to pick from. The moment in front of the Holmesdale, when he got the ball in a 1v1 with Mykolenko out by the corner flag, summed up my concerns. Franca faced his defender, touched the ball to the right and advanced as if he expected the defender to just disappear into thin air. Mykolenko, who is a young and average player himself, just casually stepped in front of the ball, leaving Franca helpless as it rolled out of play for a goal kick. No forward beats his man every time, but it was a really weird attempt to begin with, as if Franca had never played against an adult before. It would be unlike Palace to spend north of £15m on a player without careful research, so I presume he looked the part before arriving here. Based on what I have seen though, I am not sure what type of player he is supposed to be. He is not slow, but certainly not rapid. He seems to do everything too frantically to be a passer. I wonder what position and style he thinks he plays best in? The lad is very young, a long way from home, and trying to play in a very different and much higher standard of football. He will need many more games to have any chance, but so does every young player. Most don't get them, because you have to be useful (to some extent) pretty quickly just to get those first 20-30 games. Based on last night, I'm not sure why Franca is going to get them apart from the price tag. I would, or course, love him to do well. I actually thought Franca showed promise. One I don't think has the potential or skill set is Ahamada. Franca had flashes of driving forward and seemed stronger than I thought he would be. Ahamada has had one half decent run out in the last two seasons. If we could, I'd like to see him on loan somewhere.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I don't want to be pessimistic, and of course it is very early days, but I didn't see any sort of quality in Franca whatsoever last night, or in his previous sub appearances. He is obviously very keen, which might be affecting his decision-making, but he seemed to have almost no judgement or awareness at all. In terms of distribution, he was trying passes which were never, ever there to be played, ignoring ones that were, but most of all making a below-average job of even those passes he did identify. At one point just before he came off, he tried a left foot pass through to Eze in the box (when Eze had clearly been tracked by covering defenders) and sort of blundered it in there at knee height. It went flying out for a goal kick. Eze gave him an encouraging clap, but must have thought 'WTF?'. A couple of minutes later Franca had the ball wide right during a period where we had Everton pinned back. Andersen stepped forward into the right-back position to offer Franca support. Our players could see what was happening and started getting ready for a cross into the box from Andersen, who was clearly setting himself to whip a first-time ball into the area. Franca held it too long, giving Everton players a chance to get close and then, instead of setting the ball in front of Andersen's right foot to allow a first-time cross, he played it too heavily just outside Andersen's left foot. Andersen had to take three touches just to prevent the counter. These are very small details, but they smack of poor quality, and Franca did it all night. Finally, his judgement when running with the ball was poor. His best moment came in the first half when he got away from the left-back on the halfway line and ran at the centre of the Everton defence. He got a free kick in a good position, but it was a needless foul - Franca had already played his pass, to nobody, despite having two well-placed players to pick from. The moment in front of the Holmesdale, when he got the ball in a 1v1 with Mykolenko out by the corner flag, summed up my concerns. Franca faced his defender, touched the ball to the right and advanced as if he expected the defender to just disappear into thin air. Mykolenko, who is a young and average player himself, just casually stepped in front of the ball, leaving Franca helpless as it rolled out of play for a goal kick. No forward beats his man every time, but it was a really weird attempt to begin with, as if Franca had never played against an adult before. It would be unlike Palace to spend north of £15m on a player without careful research, so I presume he looked the part before arriving here. Based on what I have seen though, I am not sure what type of player he is supposed to be. He is not slow, but certainly not rapid. He seems to do everything too frantically to be a passer. I wonder what position and style he thinks he plays best in? The lad is very young, a long way from home, and trying to play in a very different and much higher standard of football. He will need many more games to have any chance, but so does every young player. Most don't get them, because you have to be useful (to some extent) pretty quickly just to get those first 20-30 games. Based on last night, I'm not sure why Franca is going to get them apart from the price tag. I would, or course, love him to do well. I got slated for questioning his price tag after his second cameo appearance. I appreciate it was early days, but even so £20m for an unproven kid with average skills seemed excessive. Nothing has changed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
I got slated for questioning his price tag after his second cameo appearance. I appreciate it was early days, but even so £20m for an unproven kid with average skills seemed excessive. Nothing has changed. The Guardian reported this at the time: Crystal Palace are set to sign the 19-year-old Brazilian forward Matheus França from Flamengo in a deal worth up to £26m. França has emerged as Palace’s main attacking target after WilfriedZaha turned down a deal worth £200,000 a week to join Galatasaray last week. França, who has represented Brazil at various youth levels and can play in a variety of forward roles, was also tracked by Chelsea and Newcastle after starring for Flamengo last season. Palace’s sporting director, Dougie Freedman, is believed to have played an instrumental role in the signing, having scouted França for some time. França is expected to complete a medical on Monday before travelling to London to sign. It is understood the deal includes various bonuses, including €5m (£4.3m) if Franca is nominated for the Ballon d’Or and a 20% sell-on clause for any fee that exceeds the £17m Palace will pay up front.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I don't want to be pessimistic, and of course it is very early days, but I didn't see any sort of quality in Franca whatsoever last night, or in his previous sub appearances. He is obviously very keen, which might be affecting his decision-making, but he seemed to have almost no judgement or awareness at all. In terms of distribution, he was trying passes which were never, ever there to be played, ignoring ones that were, but most of all making a below-average job of even those passes he did identify. At one point just before he came off, he tried a left foot pass through to Eze in the box (when Eze had clearly been tracked by covering defenders) and sort of blundered it in there at knee height. It went flying out for a goal kick. Eze gave him an encouraging clap, but must have thought 'WTF?'. A couple of minutes later Franca had the ball wide right during a period where we had Everton pinned back. Andersen stepped forward into the right-back position to offer Franca support. Our players could see what was happening and started getting ready for a cross into the box from Andersen, who was clearly setting himself to whip a first-time ball into the area. Franca held it too long, giving Everton players a chance to get close and then, instead of setting the ball in front of Andersen's right foot to allow a first-time cross, he played it too heavily just outside Andersen's left foot. Andersen had to take three touches just to prevent the counter. These are very small details, but they smack of poor quality, and Franca did it all night. Finally, his judgement when running with the ball was poor. His best moment came in the first half when he got away from the left-back on the halfway line and ran at the centre of the Everton defence. He got a free kick in a good position, but it was a needless foul - Franca had already played his pass, to nobody, despite having two well-placed players to pick from. The moment in front of the Holmesdale, when he got the ball in a 1v1 with Mykolenko out by the corner flag, summed up my concerns. Franca faced his defender, touched the ball to the right and advanced as if he expected the defender to just disappear into thin air. Mykolenko, who is a young and average player himself, just casually stepped in front of the ball, leaving Franca helpless as it rolled out of play for a goal kick. No forward beats his man every time, but it was a really weird attempt to begin with, as if Franca had never played against an adult before. It would be unlike Palace to spend north of £15m on a player without careful research, so I presume he looked the part before arriving here. Based on what I have seen though, I am not sure what type of player he is supposed to be. He is not slow, but certainly not rapid. He seems to do everything too frantically to be a passer. I wonder what position and style he thinks he plays best in? The lad is very young, a long way from home, and trying to play in a very different and much higher standard of football. He will need many more games to have any chance, but so does every young player. Most don't get them, because you have to be useful (to some extent) pretty quickly just to get those first 20-30 games. Based on last night, I'm not sure why Franca is going to get them apart from the price tag. I would, or course, love him to do well. I respectfully disagree with the pessimism TBTP. Franca is almost certainly what we need or what I and apparently others, desire. I would also suggest your comments are representative of the gripes many have with the game these days and with our current identity. Apologies ASCPFC but Ahamada is another case for me where I would like to see more of him. The flip side of this was our constant and predictable passing it around at the back yesterday, apparent desire or design to play at walking pace and our inability to capitalise on them being down to 10, and at one stage 9, men. I'd suggest 11 Franca/Ahamdas would be entertaining but equally disastrous for any team however the other end of the spectrum is the boring, predictable and often ineffective football we displayed yesterday. Even Zaha at the end, when in advanced positions, would repeatedly turn around and pass the ball back toward defence, slowing down and effectively nullifying our own attacks. Pep is the best example, for my money, at balancing the rigid, structural and possession based approach to the game however doing this with players who are both willing and capable to show some flair and take some profitable risks, most notably up top. Having an unlimited chequebook is of course pivotal to his enormous success. I had started another thread with regards to maintaining our current status. Footballers who play the statistics game and conservatively play, with extreme risk aversion, may well preserve but will never progress us, broing many to death in the process. Something a bit different and able to unnerve/rattle opposition defences is therefore required or every football match will be identical with only 2/3 highlights ever defining them. Franca featured yesterday in a very tired, laboured, rigid football match between two ideologically similar managers. I actually put a comment up on BBC saying Roy and Sean may well have had a staring match to determine the outcome. He is of course very young, coming to a very different social and footballing culture and will take time to find his feet. The discipline and patterns are surely easier to coach into him than the mentality and instinct he showed yesterday, albeit without much success at the end of it. The FK he won that Eze lackadaisically skied over the bar was a glimpse of this. It is repeatedly speculated or stated, I wouldn't know, that Roy does not coach attacking play, only ever focussing upon structure/shape. This would be evident in our performances and was so last night. If so, coach and mould Franca into that and like Eze/Olise, and Wilf before them, Franca may well provide a key to unlock defences up the other end in lieu of us having a tactical and practiced strategy for doing so.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I respectfully disagree with the pessimism TBTP. Franca is almost certainly what we need or what I and apparently others, desire. I would also suggest your comments are representative of the gripes many have with the game these days and with our current identity. Apologies ASCPFC but Ahamada is another case for me where I would like to see more of him. The flip side of this was our constant and predictable passing it around at the back yesterday, apparent desire or design to play at walking pace and our inability to capitalise on them being down to 10, and at one stage 9, men. I'd suggest 11 Franca/Ahamdas would be entertaining but equally disastrous for any team however the other end of the spectrum is the boring, predictable and often ineffective football we displayed yesterday. Even Zaha at the end, when in advanced positions, would repeatedly turn around and pass the ball back toward defence, slowing down and effectively nullifying our own attacks. Pep is the best example, for my money, at balancing the rigid, structural and possession based approach to the game however doing this with players who are both willing and capable to show some flair and take some profitable risks, most notably up top. Having an unlimited chequebook is of course pivotal to his enormous success. I had started another thread with regards to maintaining our current status. Footballers who play the statistics game and conservatively play, with extreme risk aversion, may well preserve but will never progress us, broing many to death in the process. Something a bit different and able to unnerve/rattle opposition defences is therefore required or every football match will be identical with only 2/3 highlights ever defining them. Franca featured yesterday in a very tired, laboured, rigid football match between two ideologically similar managers. I actually put a comment up on BBC saying Roy and Sean may well have had a staring match to determine the outcome. He is of course very young, coming to a very different social and footballing culture and will take time to find his feet. The discipline and patterns are surely easier to coach into him than the mentality and instinct he showed yesterday, albeit without much success at the end of it. The FK he won that Eze lackadaisically skied over the bar was a glimpse of this. It is repeatedly speculated or stated, I wouldn't know, that Roy does not coach attacking play, only ever focussing upon structure/shape. This would be evident in our performances and was so last night. If so, coach and mould Franca into that and like Eze/Olise, and Wilf before them, Franca may well provide a key to unlock defences up the other end in lieu of us having a tactical and practiced strategy for doing so. I would certainly agree that a player with a positive mindset (i.e. one who wants to attack the opposing defender) is a rare and valuable commodity. The younger Zaha was blessed with it - he never, ever passed the ball backwards when he got it. Thing is, you have to produce something or you are just running up dead ends and blind alleys. The ability has to match the mindset.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I would certainly agree that a player with a positive mindset (i.e. one who wants to attack the opposing defender) is a rare and valuable commodity. The younger Zaha was blessed with it - he never, ever passed the ball backwards when he got it. Thing is, you have to produce something or you are just running up dead ends and blind alleys. The ability has to match the mindset. Yes, I absolutely agree. One argument would be that this was a criticism of a young Zaha, again for my money, our greatest modern player. My shortened statement on Franca would be this: He is yet to be in a position where any definitive statement could be made of him. His shortfalls are obvious but not unexpected in the circumstances. I am hopeful that he can be brought up to pace and his natural ability, atop that coached into him, will be a highly valuable commodity for us. May yet work out, may not. I am retaining optimism for the time being however and fall within the bracket of those desperate to see something beyond the sleep inducing performances of this season. COYP
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I don't want to be pessimistic, and of course it is very early days, but I didn't see any sort of quality in Franca whatsoever last night, or in his previous sub appearances. He is obviously very keen, which might be affecting his decision-making, but he seemed to have almost no judgement or awareness at all. In terms of distribution, he was trying passes which were never, ever there to be played, ignoring ones that were, but most of all making a below-average job of even those passes he did identify. At one point just before he came off, he tried a left foot pass through to Eze in the box (when Eze had clearly been tracked by covering defenders) and sort of blundered it in there at knee height. It went flying out for a goal kick. Eze gave him an encouraging clap, but must have thought 'WTF?'. A couple of minutes later Franca had the ball wide right during a period where we had Everton pinned back. Andersen stepped forward into the right-back position to offer Franca support. Our players could see what was happening and started getting ready for a cross into the box from Andersen, who was clearly setting himself to whip a first-time ball into the area. Franca held it too long, giving Everton players a chance to get close and then, instead of setting the ball in front of Andersen's right foot to allow a first-time cross, he played it too heavily just outside Andersen's left foot. Andersen had to take three touches just to prevent the counter. These are very small details, but they smack of poor quality, and Franca did it all night. Finally, his judgement when running with the ball was poor. His best moment came in the first half when he got away from the left-back on the halfway line and ran at the centre of the Everton defence. He got a free kick in a good position, but it was a needless foul - Franca had already played his pass, to nobody, despite having two well-placed players to pick from. The moment in front of the Holmesdale, when he got the ball in a 1v1 with Mykolenko out by the corner flag, summed up my concerns. Franca faced his defender, touched the ball to the right and advanced as if he expected the defender to just disappear into thin air. Mykolenko, who is a young and average player himself, just casually stepped in front of the ball, leaving Franca helpless as it rolled out of play for a goal kick. No forward beats his man every time, but it was a really weird attempt to begin with, as if Franca had never played against an adult before. It would be unlike Palace to spend north of £15m on a player without careful research, so I presume he looked the part before arriving here. Based on what I have seen though, I am not sure what type of player he is supposed to be. He is not slow, but certainly not rapid. He seems to do everything too frantically to be a passer. I wonder what position and style he thinks he plays best in? The lad is very young, a long way from home, and trying to play in a very different and much higher standard of football. He will need many more games to have any chance, but so does every young player. Most don't get them, because you have to be useful (to some extent) pretty quickly just to get those first 20-30 games. Based on last night, I'm not sure why Franca is going to get them apart from the price tag. I would, or course, love him to do well. A fair summary. The highlighted comment was my concern, lost the ball so easily. A suspect a few cameo sub appearances will be his impact this season.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.