You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy accepts Everton replay not an ideal scenario
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy accepts Everton replay not an ideal scenario


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
South London Weekly Flag London 04 Jan 24 11.17pm

[Link]

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 04 Jan 24 11.21pm

Shame he didn't show some intent to win the first game - it ain't rocket science !!!

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 05 Jan 24 7.05am

We could have played the replay last night & barring a serious glaring error from either side & it would still have been 0;0 this morning.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 05 Jan 24 9.39am

to be fair to Roy, once they went down to 10 men, he put of a raft of attacking Players.
that's about as ambitious as it gets from him.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Jan 24 3.16pm

Roy's spoiling us so much that we get another match in the cup too.

 


Red and Blue Army!

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 05 Jan 24 3.37pm

The sooner he goes the better, I'm fed up with negative football

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Jan 24 3.41pm

Wed's 17th 19.45 ko. Confirmed

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Jacey Flag 06 Jan 24 10.23am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

The sooner he goes the better, I'm fed up with negative football

Agreed.
Should have played for a win rather than a Royball,bore draw.Even a defeat would have b a better outcome rather than risking any further injuries to our depleted squad.
As it is,an unnecessary replay away,just days before the vital Arsenal game.

Edited by Jacey (06 Jan 2024 11.06am)

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 07 Jan 24 12.26am

Originally posted by Jacey

Agreed.
Should have played for a win rather than a Royball,bore draw.Even a defeat would have b a better outcome rather than risking any further injuries to our depleted squad.
As it is,an unnecessary replay away,just days before the vital Arsenal game.

Edited by Jacey (06 Jan 2024 11.06am)

20240107_002544.jpg Attachment: 20240107_002544.jpg (102.45Kb)

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 07 Jan 24 8.28am

I was hopeful when we did not put the reserves out, but then soon realised this was going to be a Roy special tight defence but no bite.

He seems to have yet to realise in the cup you actually have to win.....

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Jan 24 8.39am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

I was hopeful when we did not put the reserves out, but then soon realised this was going to be a Roy special tight defence but no bite.

He seems to have yet to realise in the cup you actually have to win.....

I know I’ll be continued to be labelled as a Roy Apologist by asking this question, but what would you have done differently on Thursday then ?

People clamouring for Franca to start got their wish, what else could Hodgson have done to win the game ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 07 Jan 24 8.52am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I know I’ll be continued to be labelled as a Roy Apologist by asking this question, but what would you have done differently on Thursday then ?

People clamouring for Franca to start got their wish, what else could Hodgson have done to win the game ?

Well yes, you are.
As for the question, how about giving attack an equal footing with defence in a holistic view of the game overall? But as we know, coaching forward play is completely alien to Roy's football philosophy as he has demonstrated throughout his career.
In Royworld 0-0 is the ideal result.

 

PatrickA Flag London 07 Jan 24 8.59am

He could have instructed his players to make forward runs, get closer to Mateta who was often isolated with no Palace player within 30 yards of him.
He could have instructed his players to make late runs into the penalty area occasionally rather than keeping to a rigid shape which is so easy to defend against.
Schlupp was ostensibly playing left wing but played like a left half and often occupied a similar area of the pitch to Lerma.
As other pointed out , so many players were out of their natural position and didn’t it show.
I was sitting near the directors box and rarely have seen the fans around me so frustrated.
Not angry, or calling for Roy’s head , but just wanting a coherent strategy showing some attacking intent.


Originally posted by NEILLO

I know I’ll be continued to be labelled as a Roy Apologist by asking this question, but what would you have done differently on Thursday then ?

People clamouring for Franca to start got their wish, what else could Hodgson have done to win the game ?

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Jan 24 9.42am

Originally posted by PatrickA

He could have instructed his players to make forward runs, get closer to Mateta who was often isolated with no Palace player within 30 yards of him.
He could have instructed his players to make late runs into the penalty area occasionally rather than keeping to a rigid shape which is so easy to defend against.
Schlupp was ostensibly playing left wing but played like a left half and often occupied a similar area of the pitch to Lerma.
As other pointed out , so many players were out of their natural position and didn’t it show.
I was sitting near the directors box and rarely have seen the fans around me so frustrated.
Not angry, or calling for Roy’s head , but just wanting a coherent strategy showing some attacking intent.


Well hopefully that frustration wasn’t wasted on Steve Parish.

I don’t disagree with the points you are making, but I didn’t see much on Thursday that’s been radically different from most home games this season. So we are really only re-hashing the same issues over again.

I think Hodgson has had bad luck with injuries to an already thin squad. And the result has been to revert to the dull, safety first football to which we have become accustomed. This should not have come as a surprise to anyone.

Personally I think it’s been a wasted season. But that was on the cards from the day that Roy was re-appointed.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 07 Jan 24 9.53am

Originally posted by PatrickA

He could have instructed his players to make forward runs, get closer to Mateta who was often isolated with no Palace player within 30 yards of him.
He could have instructed his players to make late runs into the penalty area occasionally rather than keeping to a rigid shape which is so easy to defend against.
Schlupp was ostensibly playing left wing but played like a left half and often occupied a similar area of the pitch to Lerma.
As other pointed out , so many players were out of their natural position and didn’t it show.
I was sitting near the directors box and rarely have seen the fans around me so frustrated.
Not angry, or calling for Roy’s head , but just wanting a coherent strategy showing some attacking intent.
Love it I was a left half and inside left before it all changed to attacking/holding /defensive midfielder the good old days

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 24 10.19am

I overheard a Brighton supporter utter to a supporter of our club apropos Mr Hodgson "We had Chris Hughton you have the same with Roy Hodgson". I suspect he was referring to the style of play - Chris Hughton has admitted he is not the most expansive of coaches.

 

Jacey Flag 07 Jan 24 10.25am

In Roy's defence,he is extremely elderly and forgetful at times.
Believe he forgot he was in a Cup game and was playing for the point!!

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 07 Jan 24 10.32am

In Jan & Feb, 60 days, we’re playing 8 games including the replay. Hardly a heavy workload. And many of our players have missed so many games you’d think they’d be grateful for more match time. Get on with it.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 07 Jan 24 11.07am

We can't afford any more injuries to our best players and with the replay coming three days before we play Arsenal I would rest Guehi, Andersen, Mitchell, Eze and Lerma. The home game was the time to go strong, the replay is the time to play the reserves and come what may, especially as Everton are a very physical team. Everton play three days before the replay and then have almost two weeks off so they may field a stronger team.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 08 Jan 24 9.03am

I think the draw is this evening and will be telling for me.

At least we're in there for now so my tune will change in response to the opponent.

If we get a home draw vs lower league opposition, I'll be fully supporting the fielding of the strongest team possible Weds.

If we're drawn away at the Etihad or similar, I'd be happy to see the U21's get a run out.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy accepts Everton replay not an ideal scenario