dominic calvert-lewin ban rescinded

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

dominic calvert-lewin ban rescinded

Visit the current forum | Forum Rules

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

dreamwaverider London 09 Jan 24 4.30pm
We all need to be taking a long hard look at VAR. It is destroying the game..... and also making many of us late for other appointments.

dreamwaverider

London 09 Jan 24 4.30pm

We all need to be taking a long hard look at VAR.

It is destroying the game..... and also making many of us late for other appointments.

monkey Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 09 Jan 24 6.07pm
And there was a few chaps on here who thought it WAS a red, it’s a funny old game how we can see things so different at times. It proves not all high feet or studs up are dangerous and need to be a red card

monkey

Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 09 Jan 24 6.07pm

And there was a few chaps on here who thought it WAS a red, it’s a funny old game how we can see things so different at times. It proves not all high feet or studs up are dangerous and need to be a red card

steeleye20 Croydon 09 Jan 24 6.13pm
Now they have rescinded the red card, I think it was actually a red!

steeleye20

Croydon 09 Jan 24 6.13pm

Now they have rescinded the red card, I think it was actually a red!

Runningman Keston 09 Jan 24 8.24pm
So what is the point of VAR ?

Runningman

Keston 09 Jan 24 8.24pm

So what is the point of VAR ?

Goal Machine The Cronx 09 Jan 24 8.39pm
VAR. Turning correct decisions into clear and obvious errors. Couldn’t write it. The sooner it goes, the better. Football is 20% worse because of it.

Goal Machine

The Cronx 09 Jan 24 8.39pm

VAR. Turning correct decisions into clear and obvious errors. Couldn’t write it.

The sooner it goes, the better.

Football is 20% worse because of it.

Runningman Keston 09 Jan 24 8.41pm
Originally posted by Goal Machine VAR. Turning correct decisions into clear and obvious errors. Couldn’t write it. The sooner it goes, the better. Football is 20% worse because of it. VAR check It’s actually 22%

Runningman

Keston 09 Jan 24 8.41pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

VAR. Turning correct decisions into clear and obvious errors. Couldn’t write it.

The sooner it goes, the better.

Football is 20% worse because of it.

VAR check
It’s actually 22%

Goal Machine The Cronx 09 Jan 24 9.00pm
Originally posted by Runningman VAR check It’s actually 22% Rescinded

Goal Machine

The Cronx 09 Jan 24 9.00pm

Originally posted by Runningman

VAR check
It’s actually 22%

Rescinded

palace chick South Croydon 09 Jan 24 9.24pm
There is was thinking it was a reckless challenge with his studs raised. How silly am I :-) Attachment: 1A93F899-C178-4759-BB9A-6406FBBB1D44.jpeg (478.55Kb)

palace chick

South Croydon 09 Jan 24 9.24pm

There is was thinking it was a reckless challenge with his studs raised. How silly am I :-)

Attachment: 1A93F899-C178-4759-BB9A-6406FBBB1D44.jpeg (478.55Kb)

eaglesdare 09 Jan 24 9.38pm
I actually thought it was the most blatant red card I have seen all season. It was high It was dangerous Studs were showing Caught clyne Typical scousers moan about it and it gets rescinded. If it was the other way no one bats an eye lid.

eaglesdare

09 Jan 24 9.38pm

I actually thought it was the most blatant red card I have seen all season.

It was high
It was dangerous
Studs were showing
Caught clyne

Typical scousers moan about it and it gets rescinded. If it was the other way no one bats an eye lid.

dreamwaverider London 10 Jan 24 7.20am
Typical. Now the red card has been rescinded, Keith Hackett comes out agreeing it was the wrong decision. All these ex referees being paid to comment are a waste of space. They always agree with their paymaster or their historic paymaster. They sit on Sky like rabbits caught in headlights denying the obvious which is is frustrating to watch. Get shot of the lot of them and bring in people like ex players who may just help improve things for football. Modern technology can help the game, it just needs to be designed and used to much better effect than VAR.

dreamwaverider

London 10 Jan 24 7.20am

Typical. Now the red card has been rescinded, Keith Hackett comes out agreeing it was the wrong decision.
All these ex referees being paid to comment are a waste of space. They always agree with their paymaster or their historic paymaster. They sit on Sky like rabbits caught in headlights denying the obvious which is is frustrating to watch.
Get shot of the lot of them and bring in people like ex players who may just help improve things for football. Modern technology can help the game, it just needs to be designed and used to much better effect than VAR.

joe_cpfc Basingstoke 10 Jan 24 8.19am
I thought it was a red and still do. Ive seen absolutely loads of lesser challenges get reds and nobody has said a word afterwards. Maybe its because he's a poster boy for the weird and wonderful and ticks too many boxes to be punished. Wouldn't surprise me. Attachment: jjqk5xZ.png (289.71Kb)

joe_cpfc

Basingstoke 10 Jan 24 8.19am

I thought it was a red and still do. Ive seen absolutely loads of lesser challenges get reds and nobody has said a word afterwards. Maybe its because he's a poster boy for the weird and wonderful and ticks too many boxes to be punished. Wouldn't surprise me.

Attachment: jjqk5xZ.png (289.71Kb)

roman eagle South London 10 Jan 24 9.41am
So the first ref thought it wasn’t but the second thought it might be so the first had another look and thought it was, then a third ref had a look and thought it wasn’t and the first two refs were wrong. The refs decision is final-ish, long live VAR 🤣 Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC)

roman eagle

South London 10 Jan 24 9.41am

So the first ref thought it wasn’t but the second thought it might be so the first had another look and thought it was, then a third ref had a look and thought it wasn’t and the first two refs were wrong. The refs decision is final-ish, long live VAR 🤣

Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC)

dreamwaverider London 10 Jan 24 10.35am
I thought at the time Calvert Lewin was very calm while waiting an age for the decision. His departure was exceptionally graceful, which is rare. Probably because he was in a state of shock at such a poor decision. Edited by dreamwaverider (10 Jan 2024 10.35am)

dreamwaverider

London 10 Jan 24 10.35am

I thought at the time Calvert Lewin was very calm while waiting an age for the decision. His departure was exceptionally graceful, which is rare. Probably because he was in a state of shock at such a poor decision.

Edited by dreamwaverider (10 Jan 2024 10.35am)

EverybodyDannsNow SE19 10 Jan 24 10.39am
I thought it was a red - no intent in it, but just a terrible tackling technique which is undoubtedly dangerous - he only made slight contact with Clyne and still managed to injure him, if he'd made any sort of proper contact it would have done real damage. Typically 'strikers challenge', but still dangerous.

EverybodyDannsNow

SE19 10 Jan 24 10.39am

I thought it was a red - no intent in it, but just a terrible tackling technique which is undoubtedly dangerous - he only made slight contact with Clyne and still managed to injure him, if he'd made any sort of proper contact it would have done real damage.

Typically 'strikers challenge', but still dangerous.

eaglerik1 10 Jan 24 10.43am
just for a change, I actually felt a bit sorry for the ref here. I think it was a foul and maybe worthy of a yellow but once he has been told to take another look he has no other choice but to give a red or stay with no foul. I believe he cant say yes foul and a yellow in this situation.

eaglerik1

10 Jan 24 10.43am

just for a change, I actually felt a bit sorry for the ref here.
I think it was a foul and maybe worthy of a yellow but once he has been told to take another look he has no other choice but to give a red or stay with no foul. I believe he cant say yes foul and a yellow in this situation.

CrazyBadger Ware 10 Jan 24 11.17am
can we appeal the appeal? "It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

CrazyBadger

Ware 10 Jan 24 11.17am

can we appeal the appeal?

"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

eaglesdare 10 Jan 24 11.36am
Amazing how we all seen the same thing and we all have different thoughts on it. I still think VAR and the ref made correct decisions.

eaglesdare

10 Jan 24 11.36am

Amazing how we all seen the same thing and we all have different thoughts on it.

I still think VAR and the ref made correct decisions.

monkey Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 10 Jan 24 11.36am
Originally posted by palace chick There is was thinking it was a reckless challenge with his studs raised. How silly am I :-) Indeed very silly if they showed a still of every tackle in football you could make it look bad at some point

monkey

Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 10 Jan 24 11.36am

Originally posted by palace chick

There is was thinking it was a reckless challenge with his studs raised. How silly am I :-)

Indeed very silly if they showed a still of every tackle in football you could make it look bad at some point

EverybodyDannsNow SE19 10 Jan 24 11.47am
Originally posted by monkey Indeed very silly if they showed a still of every tackle in football you could make it look bad at some point They can’t magically make your studs point outwards at shin height though - whether you think it’s a red card or not, it’s an awful technique to be making a tackle.

EverybodyDannsNow

SE19 10 Jan 24 11.47am

Originally posted by monkey

Indeed very silly if they showed a still of every tackle in football you could make it look bad at some point

They can’t magically make your studs point outwards at shin height though - whether you think it’s a red card or not, it’s an awful technique to be making a tackle.

Elpis In a pub 10 Jan 24 2.38pm
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow They can’t magically make your studs point outwards at shin height though - whether you think it’s a red card or not, it’s an awful technique to be making a tackle. I think (I may be wrong) the reason the appeal was upheld was because it wasn't actually a tackle but the player (CL) attempting to bring the loose ball under control .Clyne just arrived on the scene as he was wrapping his boot around the ball ,though granted he made a clumsy mess of it . Take Clyne out of the picture and Calvert -Lewin would be making exactly the same movement in getting the ball . Had Clyne been in possession and CL had done what he did as a tackle then no question its a red . You have to look at the whole incident not just one picture .

Elpis

In a pub 10 Jan 24 2.38pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

They can’t magically make your studs point outwards at shin height though - whether you think it’s a red card or not, it’s an awful technique to be making a tackle.

I think (I may be wrong) the reason the appeal was upheld was because it wasn't actually a tackle but the player (CL) attempting to bring the loose ball under control .Clyne just arrived on the scene as he was wrapping his boot around the ball ,though granted he made a clumsy mess of it . Take Clyne out of the picture and Calvert -Lewin would be making exactly the same movement in getting the ball .
Had Clyne been in possession and CL had done what he did as a tackle then no question its a red . You have to look at the whole incident not just one picture .

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

dominic calvert-lewin ban rescinded

Site Map