You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > It is wrong to boo our own manager.
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

It is wrong to boo our own manager.


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Jan 24 10.24am

Originally posted by beak

Of course it was personal,directly targeted at our manager!

It’s strange that no one complains when the exact same words are shouted at a ref or linesman. It’s almost as if personal attacks are only important when it’s directed at someone you are backing.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 19 Jan 24 11.00am

Originally posted by beak

Of course it was personal,directly targeted at our manager!


Personal criticism is part and parcel of taking a job in the public arena. Let's face it, referees get personal insults week-in, week-out. They're always the baddies (which is why they are dressed in black, of course .

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 19 Jan 24 11.05am

I think the question will answer itself if we fail to beat the worst team in the division at Selhurst on Tuesday week.

The genius that is Roy Hodgson has masterfully engineered the weekend off for the boys, by not trying to score in 2 cup games vs Everton. They should be refreshed and ready to try to score a goal, which is very difficult to do in the Premier league. Particularly so with Hodgson's approach to the game.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Jan 24 11.13am

It might wake the boring Roy Hodgson out of his comfort zone and make him understand that the same dull routines week in week out don't cut it. Nothing easier than to put everyone behind the ball. Try coaching attacking play Roy, with some novel ideas to get behind the opposition and offer fans of the game a little excitement. Problem is you can't change the habits of a lifetime, that why you've been booed.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 19 Jan 24 11.53am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think Roy is blameless, he is doing the same as he always has, defensive tactics, experienced players, no change, i wouldn't have started Eze, Andersen, Guehi, Lerma or Mitchell, But as for the board a complete and utter shambles 75% of the voting shareholders don't give a s**t and the other one is businessly impotent.

To be fair it's not obvious who else he could have started; the supply of promising youngsters was pretty much dried up by the PL International Cup game against Feyenoord earlier in the day. It was probably frustrating for that squad not to have Franca or Ozoh available for a competition where as last year's losing finalists, we probably have a better chance. Since a 1-1 draw saw us through to the quarter finals, the right call was probably made.

Edited by Charles (19 Jan 2024 12.07pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 19 Jan 24 4.04pm

Have we forgotten how Charlton got bored with mid table and slit their own throats?

However dull Roy ball might be, it cannot compare to watching us playing in the league below under Peter Taylor or Trevor Francis.

The quality of football we are watching now is 10 times better than the crap of that era. We are also playing sides who are often made up of top class internationals and which cost multi millions.

Sure, I'd like to see more progression, but an FA Cup game is insignificant in the grand scheme. This club is attempting to better itself under Steve Parish and unless the League scraps fair play, all the Oil money in the world cannot improve our squad in the short term.
Show me someone who can sweep aside planning issues and build a new 60k stadium and increase our merchandise revenue x 20, and I will be interested.
Meanwhile, Roy is doing what his experience tells him to keep us up once again.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Jan 2024 4.06pm)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 19 Jan 24 4.23pm

Originally posted by Charles

To be fair it's not obvious who else he could have started; the supply of promising youngsters was pretty much dried up by the PL International Cup game against Feyenoord earlier in the day. It was probably frustrating for that squad not to have Franca or Ozoh available for a competition where as last year's losing finalists, we probably have a better chance. Since a 1-1 draw saw us through to the quarter finals, the right call was probably made.

Edited by Charles (19 Jan 2024 12.07pm)

Johnstone
Clyne Tomkins Richards Tayo
Franca Hughes Jairo Schlupp
Edouard Mateta

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

est1905 Flag 19 Jan 24 4.28pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Yep , they need to give their heads a wobble .Most have been moaning that Roy doesn't make subs and when he does he gets booed . Bloke can't win ,well we know that but booing Roy ?

He's Palace royalty

I agree he cant win. When Olise was left on till almost the end the other week (because he needed minutes) they were moaning Roy should have taken him off earliert so that Franca could come on. Even though when Olise came off Franca was already on and doing nothing!
Now Roy (mindful that Olise is out for Saturday and Eze is probably our only other creative influence) takes Eze off and the same Roy haters are moaning that he has taken him off! For doing the exact thing they were accusing him of NOT doing in the Brentford game.
Some idiot rang into Talksport the other day saying 'we're not going to beat Arsenal on Saturday, no chance so why save him for that game?' In the next breath he's moaning we might get relegated. So wouldn't it be more sensible to sacrifice the cup game and put your best possible available team out in the game where there are points at stake?
It might escape peoples notice but despite being favourites Arsenal are by no means Man City (who we got a draw with) and have plenty of weaknesses. For me, it makes total sense to put the Premiership game as a priority

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 19 Jan 24 5.08pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I agree. I'm not a fan of Roy's tactical approach but he has done what he does and what he knows best. I think the brief is to remain in the PL and thus far he has delivered.


This is fine in the league but to continue to do it in cup games which are knock out games is unacceptable.

Roy showed he doesn't care about cup it's the same every season with him.

Even PV did better job in cup.

Why did he even bother to start the likes of Eze.

He has been around a long time but what has he really achieved in top flight football nothing he hasn't won anything.

He has been hard done by this season you could tell by his tone at the start of the season he was not happy with the lack of recruitment.

People going on about Charlton not the same and you could use Stoke who like Palace are happy to just sit with no proper investment look what happened to them.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Jan 24 7.05pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


This is fine in the league but to continue to do it in cup games which are knock out games is unacceptable.

Roy showed he doesn't care about cup it's the same every season with him.

Even PV did better job in cup.

Why did he even bother to start the likes of Eze.

He has been around a long time but what has he really achieved in top flight football nothing he hasn't won anything.

He has been hard done by this season you could tell by his tone at the start of the season he was not happy with the lack of recruitment.

People going on about Charlton not the same and you could use Stoke who like Palace are happy to just sit with no proper investment look what happened to them.

Oh I agree. My comment is based on my perception of Hodgson's role and Parish's endorsement of it.
Stoke went as far as they could and no further. We are in that same boat without an influx of real investment.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 19 Jan 24 7.14pm

As one of the poor sods who were there, it was fu-king freezing, a s*** game and he took off our one player with flair, so the fans are entitled to sing WTF they like, and come on, I’m sure he has heard worse!!
He is paid a LOT of money. A bit of reaction comes with the job, no doubt the millions he is earning will ease the pain.
There was a lot of gallows humour in our end actually, so in terms of disappointment, well I thought we would lose and we did. At least Ladbrokes came to the rescue.
I did think their boy Brainthwaite looked good . Maybe one for us?

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 19 Jan 24 7.34pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Oh I agree. My comment is based on my perception of Hodgson's role and Parish's endorsement of it.
Stoke went as far as they could and no further. We are in that same boat without an influx of real investment.


Stoke had money but didn't want to spend. (They was like us getting away with it but it will catch up with you or you could say you stay still while others improve)

Pullis I remember speaking about it and I expect this is another reason why he walked from Palace.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Hannes Flag Vienna 19 Jan 24 7.37pm

Originally posted by kevlee

As one of the poor sods who were there, it was fu-king freezing, a s*** game and he took off our one player with flair, so the fans are entitled to sing WTF they like, and come on, I’m sure he has heard worse!!
He is paid a LOT of money. A bit of reaction comes with the job, no doubt the millions he is earning will ease the pain.

There was a lot of gallows humour in our end actually, so in terms of disappointment, well I thought we would lose and we did. At least Ladbrokes came to the rescue.
I did think their boy Brainthwaite looked good . Maybe one for us?

Exactly. We once met an elderly couple while travelling. The man had played as a keeper in the league many years ago. In one of our conversations, she told us that she was always completely furious when her husband was criticised, ridiculed or insulted by fans during a game. He just interrupted her with a smile and said that it was all right and that the fans were entitled to express their displeasure. After all, they had paid for the match, while he had been paid to play. He went on to explain that nobody had been particularly affected because everyone had been the target of ridicule at some point. And anyone who couldn't take it wouldn't have been suited for sport at this level and would have had to look for another job.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Jan 24 8.39pm

Originally posted by Hannes

Exactly. We once met an elderly couple while travelling. The man had played as a keeper in the league many years ago. In one of our conversations, she told us that she was always completely furious when her husband was criticised, ridiculed or insulted by fans during a game. He just interrupted her with a smile and said that it was all right and that the fans were entitled to express their displeasure. After all, they had paid for the match, while he had been paid to play. He went on to explain that nobody had been particularly affected because everyone had been the target of ridicule at some point. And anyone who couldn't take it wouldn't have been suited for sport at this level and would have had to look for another job.

Which was the correct response. Those involved with professional sport expect to take the rough with the smooth.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 19 Jan 24 8.44pm

Lets not forget, Roy has done it to himself, given the impact he made and the goodwill he created at the end of last season. All gone, by playing plyers out of position, criticizing the younger members of the squad, having a go at the fans, and choosing not to set out to play attacking football in games we can win.

No excuse with Sheff U. If we don't get 3 points, he needs to move on.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 19 Jan 24 10.07pm

Pay your money do as you please but bear in mind what that does psychologically to the players particularly the younger ones.

They don't think to themselves "oh they're booing Roy" they'll be thinking they're going to get murdered if they fvck up. Completely counter productive.

On a broader not I think our "best fans in the league" are in danger of making ourselves look muggy particularly some of the social media stuff.

I was in the bar after a recent game and some bloke shouted at Parish that he was a w***er as he walked through. He obviously aired him but it was really cringy and pathetic.

The response to Parish's tweet about the death of Franz Beckenbauer was little better nor the bottle throwing at Roy.

Don't get me wrong I'm not feeling the love at all and haven't for a while but some of the whining and bollocks being spouted is unbearable.

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 19 Jan 24 10.26pm

What good does it do. Nothing more laughable than seeing people boo.

They do not care. Roy, Moyes, big Sam etc…. Do you think the give the slightest about the criticism they get. Water off a ducks back and comes with the job, Hodgson got knocked out to Iceland when England manager and was the laughing stick of the country, I’m sure this compares to that.

His employer is satisfied with the job he is doing (rightly or wrongly) and that’s the only person he answers too.

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 20 Jan 24 12.54am

Originally posted by beak

[Link] This makes us look like a grubby small time club,how can these idiots call themselves supporters.I am really disgusted.

we are a grubby small time club. But I wouldn't be booing RH as much as I would SP. Last season you'd have to be blind not to see just three positions to fill to make us a top six side. But oh no, the usual three are kept, one made captain, and predictably the better players have to 'carry' the gaping holes and get injured and things go pear-shaped and I have to read posts on here blaming Hodgson, who, for all his flaws can only do what he can with the tools provided by SP. I agree with all the criticism of RH and I also hate his methods, but I'm not being distracted by SP as to whom is the culprit. HE IS. With a good squad RH will do exactly what he did end of last season. He will let the players play. But he's not one to sub a better player for a worse one or to take risks. Why should he? Why should take risks and end up copping all the blame?

 

mart.denman Flag In a cave 20 Jan 24 8.22am

Reading all these posts has been having a negative effect for my love of the beautiful game
So I've been watching indoor bowls Instead.
It's fascinating watching both competitors trying to win & not bowling sideways or backwards....
Oh BTW I'm convinced I saw Roy asleep in the audience.....
Also their fans can turn their hearing aids off so don't have to listen to thier droning "ultras"

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 20 Jan 24 8.42am

Originally posted by mart.denman

Reading all these posts has been having a negative effect for my love of the beautiful game
So I've been watching indoor bowls Instead.
It's fascinating watching both competitors trying to win & not bowling sideways or backwards....
Oh BTW I'm convinced I saw Roy asleep in the audience.....
Also their fans can turn their hearing aids off so don't have to listen to thier droning "ultras"

I watched the Sunderland Hull game last night. I have to say that despite only one goal and some questionable passing it was quite enjoyable to watch (albeit in the background at the pub whilst I was drinking). In fact I am finding Championship football better to watch all round than the PL which has become a bit boring and predictable.

Whilst acknowledging your parody I’m with you on the bowls. The World Indoors championship is good viewing.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > It is wrong to boo our own manager.