You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Don't blame Roy!
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Don't blame Roy!


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 25 Jan 24 9.08am

Originally posted by Den1923

Roy was called back from retirement by Parish because no ambitious manager wants to put his name on the line with the weak squad we have, plus the dysfunctional board all of whom seem to be in disagreement with Parish and want out. This results in no team investment, poor quality or aged players in key position, all of which Roy has made clear on multiple occasions telling Parish et.al what he wants, they seem to ignore him, they cannot walk the talk and whilst he remains in place little will change and Parish will happily go on picking up his pocket money bonus from the club,for as long as can get away with it!

100% - Its cab time for Parish, Freedman and the Board...one slight issue though is that they don't seem to be able to sell us to anyone, so we're a bit screwed really.

Roy though is responsible for the team and I'm sure they're as bored playing it as we are watching it, but he doesn't seem to ever have a plan B so its jog on time for him as well tbh.


 

Skip Flag 25 Jan 24 10.55am

It seems everywhere I look there's blame with no accountability.

Yes I Roy for quite a bit of why we are where we are. I think he should have left after the Arsenal game, but that's purely because I don't want to see a 76 year old man who is struggling to keep up with things eventually get abused. He's reverted back to "Version Roy 2021". He oversees the coaching, picks the team and sets us up so needs to find another way to get the team winning and expressing themselves.

Parish has also got to take some responsibility but I don't agree he should walk away, or that he's lining his pockets as some have suggested. He's recently spent £11M on 3 pitches at the Academy training ground. He's made mistakes and needs to rectify them.

Why we spent £50M+ in the summer on 3 players who, when everybody is fit do not make Roy's starting eleven suggests to me that our Director of Football is signing players without the manager's approval. Stubborn old Roy looks like he's more interested in proving Dougie wrong by not playing Franca unless we are getting tonked, rather than slowly introduce him. We are nearly into February and we still don't know if he's good enough. Signing Henderson to replace Jack Butland for £20M was a curious decision. I don't think he's as good as Sam Johnstone, but I don't think there's an awful lot of difference between him and Jack Butland.

I don't think we move players on quick enough. It seems we'd rather keep the likes Tompkins, Ward, Rieldewald, Hughes and Schlupp. I know that replacing them would cost millions in transfer fees. Rewarding them all with contract extensions just smacks of laziness in recruitment, and a reluctance to see what our youngsters can do.

There has to be a plan that we stick to rather than settle for survival one season at a time. That has to come from the top. Investment in the Academy and spending all that money on pitches is great, but if the door into the first team squad is shut then there is very little point. If I was SP I would want Dougie and whoever the manager is going to be to work much closer on our transfer targets, and who we release from the deadwood pile.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 25 Jan 24 11.06am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Yep I agree. And as a result, their squad is 100% better than ours.

I think the bold bit is key, especially understanding how it fits into the 3 year cycle. Trying get players in early, bed them in and make sure they are ready to cover departures.

e.g. Buy Ronnie Edwards now for 10m , loan him back for the rest of the season. Sell Anderson in the summer for 30m.

It would also mean we can end our love with extending contracts of 'end of life players'. Luka, Jairo, Tomkins. How much money has been thrown after bad.

I don’t know how any planned spend on the new stand would affect the three year cycle - I know the capital element is excluded not sure whether any interest payable on any borrowed funds would be a cost we have to take as a hit. And assuming reports are true that SP is still trying to raise the last chunk of investment for the stand, can’t see there would be any appetite for spending anything on new players atm, we’d have to make a sale first to generate the cash flow.

 

PatrickA Flag London 25 Jan 24 1.28pm

There’s a saying along the lines that ‘second marriages are a triumph of hope over experience.’
I wonder if there’s an element of this in relation to Roy and the club.
The first marriage ended by mutual consent with both parties wanting to move on.
The club entered into a new relationship (with Vieira) that at first was exciting and showed potential , but it eventually ended in failure.
At this point the club felt nostalgic about the good old steady days with Roy and said why don’t we try again?
Roy agreed, and there was a brief honeymoon period at the end of last season which led to us formalising a new relationship with him, full of optimism about the future.
However, it wasn’t long before flaws in the relationship became evident again reminiscent of those that led to the initial break up.
Another case of the triumph of hope over experience?
Perhaps I’m overthinking it!

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 25 Jan 24 1.32pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

There’s a saying along the lines that ‘second marriages are a triumph of hope over experience.’
I wonder if there’s an element of this in relation to Roy and the club.
The first marriage ended by mutual consent with both parties wanting to move on.
The club entered into a new relationship (with Vieira) that at first was exciting and showed potential , but it eventually ended in failure.
At this point the club felt nostalgic about the good old steady days with Roy and said why don’t we try again?
Roy agreed, and there was a brief honeymoon period at the end of last season which led to us formalising a new relationship with him, full of optimism about the future.
However, it wasn’t long before flaws in the relationship became evident again reminiscent of those that led to the initial break up.
Another case of the triumph of hope over experience?
Perhaps I’m overthinking it!

I agree. But stand by for alternative views….

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 25 Jan 24 5.30pm

More grist to the mill. Have to say, IMO the Standard aren't wrong with this article

[Link]

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 25 Jan 24 8.45pm

Originally posted by doombear

More grist to the mill. Have to say, IMO the Standard aren't wrong with this article

[Link]

Sounds like he could be a fan. Nice to read something not full of errors.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 25 Jan 24 8.50pm

Originally posted by doombear

More grist to the mill. Have to say, IMO the Standard aren't wrong with this article

[Link]

good.
thanks for link.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 25 Jan 24 9.12pm

Originally posted by doombear

More grist to the mill. Have to say, IMO the Standard aren't wrong with this article

[Link]

Says it all really

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Jan 24 9.31pm

I shall refrain from apportioning culpability in relation to the Board or Mr Hodgson.
I will not gallivant down that well trodden path !

I just want a return to those halcyon days where I actually looked forward to attending matches at Selhurst Park.At present I feel rather deflated akin to a pouffe without its wadding.
My dial rests on 'Negative' like a fallen elm.

Edited by Willo (25 Jan 2024 9.45pm)

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 25 Jan 24 11.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

I shall refrain from apportioning culpability in relation to the Board or Mr Hodgson.
I will not gallivant down that well trodden path !

I just want a return to those halcyon days where I actually looked forward to attending matches at Selhurst Park.At present I feel rather deflated akin to a pouffe without its wadding.
My dial rests on 'Negative' like a fallen elm.

Edited by Willo (25 Jan 2024 9.45pm)

I think Willo is saying he’s pissed off.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Jan 24 11.37pm

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

I think Willo is saying he’s pissed off.

It is better to be pis..d OFF, than pis..d ON.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 26 Jan 24 3.23am

Originally posted by Willo

I shall refrain from apportioning culpability in relation to the Board or Mr Hodgson.
I will not gallivant down that well trodden path !

I just want a return to those halcyon days where I actually looked forward to attending matches at Selhurst Park.At present I feel rather deflated akin to a pouffe without its wadding.
My dial rests on 'Negative' like a fallen elm.

Edited by Willo (25 Jan 2024 9.45pm)

You've still got Elm? Surely not.
But if you have then surely they are longer in the tooth than Hodgson.

Edited by dreamwaverider (26 Jan 2024 3.25am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 26 Jan 24 3.33am

Poor old Roy is looking awful in that picture above. Tired, old and very stressed.

Is it all worth it?

Apart from greed and money, then I would very much doubt it.

His health and wellbeing are something both he and Palace should be keeping a very close eye on. Especially after that turn before Villa away.

 

PatrickA Flag London 26 Jan 24 9.11am

[Link]

A Jonathan Llew piece in the Guardian worth a view.
One line sticks out, ‘A Hodgson team without thrust and energy is basically indistinguishable from a square dance.’

 

BelfastEagle Flag 26 Jan 24 9.24am

The lazy decision to take the simplest option with the least resistance and give him another contract at the end of last season is coming back to bite the board. Don’t blame Roy he does what he thinks is best for the club he loves. It’s the board that are to blame who lack any coherent vision for the future. They continue to waste the talent that they have.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 Jan 24 9.28am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Poor old Roy is looking awful in that picture above. Tired, old and very stressed.

Is it all worth it?

Apart from greed and money, then I would very much doubt it.

His health and wellbeing are something both he and Palace should be keeping a very close eye on. Especially after that turn before Villa away.

Yes. I wonder about the Roy apologists. Roy didn't have to take the job. When Parish and the board decided that Vieira had to go, apparently Parish approached Roy and they worked out a deal for the rest of the season. A bit like Watford for Roy, except this time happy endings all round. Roy didn't have to take that on, and he certainly didn't have to take this season on either.
Don't feel sorry for him now it gone tits up, the hubris, the arrogance, and the lure of the £££ meant he couldn't resist.
In the end it's Parish's weakness and inability to find a new manager that brought Roy back. Between the two of them they've done enough damage already.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 26 Jan 24 9.46am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Yes. I wonder about the Roy apologists. Roy didn't have to take the job. When Parish and the board decided that Vieira had to go, apparently Parish approached Roy and they worked out a deal for the rest of the season. A bit like Watford for Roy, except this time happy endings all round. Roy didn't have to take that on, and he certainly didn't have to take this season on either.
Don't feel sorry for him now it gone tits up, the hubris, the arrogance, and the lure of the £££ meant he couldn't resist.
In the end it's Parish's weakness and inability to find a new manager that brought Roy back. Between the two of them they've done enough damage already.

I don't want to be labelled as an '' apologist '', I prefer to think of myself as someone that tries, not always successfully, to see the bigger picture.

In this instance, given that things went so well at the end of last season was, I think , a big factor in both Parish giving Hodgson the job and him accepting it.

Of course Roy didn't have to accept the job. But for you to accuse him of greed and arrogance is typical of your inability to do anything other than critisise him. I know of ' driven ' people that carry on working when they don't need to. It's not for me but I respect their desire even if it doesn't suit me.

It's regrettable that Zaha didn't stay or was replaced. That the transfer budget was used the way it was. That the season has been disrupted by injuries. Because those issues are not directly under Hodgson's control. Things may have been very different.

And just to re-iterate, I didn't want Roy appointed this season either.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

palace chick Flag South Croydon 26 Jan 24 9.48am

Originally posted by BelfastEagle

The lazy decision to take the simplest option with the least resistance and give him another contract at the end of last season is coming back to bite the board. Don’t blame Roy he does what he thinks is best for the club he loves. It’s the board that are to blame who lack any coherent vision for the future. They continue to waste the talent that they have.

In truth after a good turn around after taking over from PV a lot of us fans were happy that he was given another year. Main problem has been the injuries to Olise, Eze and Doucoure. And no strengthening of the squad by the board, especially after losing Zaha. We required a right back, central midfielder in case of that spine losing a key player (it happened) and perhaps a forward and left back to challenge Mitchell. Don’t think much of that is down to Hodgson, but he does need to go now as those injuries has meant our rigid formation he plays means players coming in have been playing out of position and making us weaker. You would hope a new manager would have a plan B unlike Hodgson? Im fairly sure we would be much higher up the table even with Hodgson in charge if it hadn’t been for injuries to major players?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 Jan 24 9.52am

"I really am stepping away from football for a while, but who knows what the future will be? It is a never-say-never moment. I've seen so many people retire with all the fanfare blazing, only to surface again somewhere in a fairly short period of time. I'd prefer not to do that."

Roy then turns up at Watford, Palace, and Palace again.

You've got to admire the board and some well thought out strategy:

Parish: It's agreed that Vieira has to go?
Others: Definitely. But who is available to take over at such short notice?
Parish: Don't worry, I know what motivates Roy.
Others: Roy? We all breathed a sigh of relief when he finally left last time!
Parish: Yes I know but beggars can't be choosers. Leave it to me.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (26 Jan 2024 10.01am)

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Don't blame Roy!