You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Would relegation be such a bad idea?
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Would relegation be such a bad idea?


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
AERO Flag 10 Feb 24 1.35pm

Yes for sure rather stay in premiership But been in this league for how many years ? All i can see we have to show for it is an Academy? We haven't progressed as we should have through lack of investment. It could be a case of rip it up and start again .Get our youngsters in get a decent manager in and give him something to get his teeth into.No manager will touch us as moment and who could blame him ?

 

DenTyler Flag Sidcup 10 Feb 24 1.35pm

The only plus I could see is more 3pm saturday kick-offs.

I utterly hate early or worse still late kick off times for Palace. I used to love my Saturdays. Bit of work, bit of lunch and a pint then the football. Sundays should always be be one of the big boys playing, sit back, relax watch a good game (with zero stress as it’s not Palace).
Hate Monday night games too (for Palace).

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 10 Feb 24 2.45pm

Originally posted by DenTyler

The only plus I could see is more 3pm saturday kick-offs.

I utterly hate early or worse still late kick off times for Palace. I used to love my Saturdays. Bit of work, bit of lunch and a pint then the football. Sundays should always be be one of the big boys playing, sit back, relax watch a good game (with zero stress as it’s not Palace).
Hate Monday night games too (for Palace).

I couldn't agree more.

 

AERO Flag 10 Feb 24 3.41pm

Here Here

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 10 Feb 24 4.20pm

Relegation would be bad and I'll tell you why: Because we have consistently failed in the EPL. Championship football is all about dreaming of doing well in the premier league. How could we dream big after Crystal Parish? Barely tenth spot, no silverware, nothing, zero, zilch. It won't be the same as being in the Championship when we once believed we would realise top six status in the top tier like we once achieved before it was the premier league. No, after 12 years of Parish's same old same old we'd be in the championship trying to fight 23 other clubs to get back into the EPL, only this time only believing that if promoted we'd once again be fighting relegation every season. No, it won't be the same, and therefore a bad idea. We need to kick some butt in this league or _______ OFF!

Edited by Oddball2021 (10 Feb 2024 4.23pm)

 

stancummins Flag 10 Feb 24 5.26pm

With Luton (surprisingly)and Everton losing the buffer zone will remain

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 10 Feb 24 5.30pm

Relegation would be bad, but at the moment we’re playing championship football. The worst team in the prem. Offer nothing there. A couple of talented star, but no ambition, drive, endeavor, industry at player, team and club level. Even Burnley actually have a plan that’s starting to take shape.

 

AERO Flag 10 Feb 24 5.48pm

A point Monday may feel like 10 ?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Feb 24 6.56pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

I feel we are always a feeder club... produce talent that turns a profit... I don't mind us being a stepping stone.. for me, it's about enjoyment... I haven't enjoyed palace for a long, long time.

Feeder club, who have we sold on apart from AWB in the last 11 years? You stated, we have broken our transfer policy by not investing in youngsters, do you know the ages of Wharton and Franca.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Feb 24 7.07pm

Would relegation be such a bad idea? Yes probably. Who's to say when we would be promoted again? All that wasted effort.
Hopefully should it occur Parish has some contingency plan. I note that we are investing in youth, and with codger Hodgson gone next season we could see a revitalised side under a progressive manager that favours youth.
Results today were favourable for us, but we still have to do our bit and pick up crucial points when and where available.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (10 Feb 2024 8.39pm)

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 10 Feb 24 8.08pm

Very unlikely to be a 'quick return'. Look at the number of bigger and failed Premiership clubs who are log jammed in that league !!
Sheffield Wednesday, Southampton and Leicester have all gone even lower over recent years, so no, relegation not a positive at all.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 10 Feb 24 8.11pm

The daftest thread of the year.

Getting relegated is never, repeat, never a good thing.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 10 Feb 24 8.23pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The daftest thread of the year.

Getting relegated is never, repeat, never a good thing.

If that’s the case - why are you so adamant we should stick with Roy..??

Roy’s the problem..!!

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 11 Feb 24 12.34am

Originally posted by Painter

Feeder club, who have we sold on apart from AWB in the last 11 years? You stated, we have broken our transfer policy by not investing in youngsters, do you know the ages of Wharton and Franca.

Oh hello mate, been a while...

So, you'll see this thread is about would going down be bad!?

Like you have pointed out, our time in the prem, we haven't produced or progressed anyone of noteworthy talent to then sell on for a profit, where as the 90's and 00's I was impressed at players such as Wright, Martyn, Hopkin, Jansen, going off to bigger, better things, seeing players like Cole come and get experience - the prem always seemed like the prize to be in. Producing local lads that featured, then the likes of Zaha, then him getting the utd deal, Moses off to Wigan - you see where I'm going? I enjoyed that, we haven't done that in 11 years, besides AWB.

Then, we up the wages, bring in loan signings like Sakho, Adebayo... other signings like Cabaye, once you do those kind of signings, you raise the bar - I feel we lost our way and ended up doubling down on Zaha when in reality we didn't need too.. had we invested in quality youth players from the start, players with the right mentality, that fit us, with something to prove... but trouble is, with so many managers we had so many visions.

So yeah, you can see why 11 years of the prem hasn't been as enjoyable, for me, when we have nothing to show for it, just debt... rather than be a club looking up, using youngsters, getting some quality in and enjoying the journey.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 11 Feb 24 7.12am

I have to concur with H the G that this is the stupidest thread going.

The OP has even suggested that there has never been a better time for the drop, as it's going to happen one day anyway.

That's like wanting to die because there's a Black Friday deal at the local funeral directors.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 11 Feb 24 8.15am

With four of our super star players out, there are little hope against Chelsea. But if the manager sets up the same "parking bus" team as he has for most of the season, the crowd will react. Losing is acceptable if we give it all, but the way we have surrendered lately make us the laughing stock of PL. At least have a go, place round pegs in round holes and for God's sake, avoid those stupid goals from corners.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Feb 24 8.27am

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

I have to concur with H the G that this is the stupidest thread going.

The OP has even suggested that there has never been a better time for the drop, as it's going to happen one day anyway.

That's like wanting to die because there's a Black Friday deal at the local funeral directors.

Exactly. There is no upside to relegation, we will lose our best players and find ourselves in debt whilst trying to re-build.

I don't see the point in supporting a team if you don't have a dream that maybe someday your club will get promoted or win something.

It's the hope that keeps us going even when the reality is somewhat different.

How many times have fans come away from a game saying "that's the last time, never again" only to pop up the next week.

 


One more point

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Feb 24 8.49am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Oh hello mate, been a while...

So, you'll see this thread is about would going down be bad!?

Like you have pointed out, our time in the prem, we haven't produced or progressed anyone of noteworthy talent to then sell on for a profit, where as the 90's and 00's I was impressed at players such as Wright, Martyn, Hopkin, Jansen, going off to bigger, better things, seeing players like Cole come and get experience - the prem always seemed like the prize to be in. Producing local lads that featured, then the likes of Zaha, then him getting the utd deal, Moses off to Wigan - you see where I'm going? I enjoyed that, we haven't done that in 11 years, besides AWB.

Then, we up the wages, bring in loan signings like Sakho, Adebayo... other signings like Cabaye, once you do those kind of signings, you raise the bar - I feel we lost our way and ended up doubling down on Zaha when in reality we didn't need too.. had we invested in quality youth players from the start, players with the right mentality, that fit us, with something to prove... but trouble is, with so many managers we had so many visions.

So yeah, you can see why 11 years of the prem hasn't been as enjoyable, for me, when we have nothing to show for it, just debt... rather than be a club looking up, using youngsters, getting some quality in and enjoying the journey.

So, you now agree, we are no longer a feeder club. You say being in the Premier isnt enjoyable, but you liked it when we sold our best players in the past, strange.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 11 Feb 24 9.26am

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

I have to concur with H the G that this is the stupidest thread going.

The OP has even suggested that there has never been a better time for the drop, as it's going to happen one day anyway.

That's like wanting to die because there's a Black Friday deal at the local funeral directors.


Ahhh, but what about the Immaculate Conception?

 

pssguy Flag 11 Feb 24 9.46am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The daftest thread of the year.

Getting relegated is never, repeat, never a good thing.

And yet here you are contributing

Bournemouth, Fulham, Wolves, Newcastle and Aston Villa are all teams above us and playing much more attractive football. They have also all been relegated and promoted since Palace's current stint in the EPL started

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Would relegation be such a bad idea?