This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Cronyism at it's worst from all parties Partisan political honours should be banned The honours system should be scrapped completely. Tony Blair reformed it, how's that working out. Edited by Badger11 (29 Mar 2024 7.19am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The honours system should be scrapped completely. Tony Blair reformed it, how's that working out. Edited by Badger11 (29 Mar 2024 7.19am) Political honours perhaps, but if retained certainly taken away from the politicians themselves. For others, those individuals who often give selflessly to make lives better, or serve us well in other ways, it is a way to recognise that. I have a friend who was awarded the British Empire Medal for her charity work a few years back. It was completely unexpected and overwhelmed her. It was though well deserved as she has worked tirelessly for many years helping others for no reward but the smiles she gets.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Political honours perhaps, but if retained certainly taken away from the politicians themselves. For others, those individuals who often give selflessly to make lives better, or serve us well in other ways, it is a way to recognise that. I have a friend who was awarded the British Empire Medal for her charity work a few years back. It was completely unexpected and overwhelmed her. It was though well deserved as she has worked tirelessly for many years helping others for no reward but the smiles she gets. Does Joe Biden give out honours?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Political honours perhaps, but if retained certainly taken away from the politicians themselves. For others, those individuals who often give selflessly to make lives better, or serve us well in other ways, it is a way to recognise that. I have a friend who was awarded the British Empire Medal for her charity work a few years back. It was completely unexpected and overwhelmed her. It was though well deserved as she has worked tirelessly for many years helping others for no reward but the smiles she gets. The whole system is corrupt. Celebs often get awards for dubious reasons. Sean Connery got a knighthood for services to the British Film Industry, this was a man who had not paid tax in the UK since the 1960's and made most of his films in Hollywood. Other celebs get theirs for dubious charity work. Anyway it should be abolished as the great and the good will always find a way through any reformed system.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The whole system is corrupt. Celebs often get awards for dubious reasons. Sean Connery got a knighthood for services to the British Film Industry, this was a man who had not paid tax in the UK since the 1960's and made most of his films in Hollywood. Other celebs get theirs for dubious charity work. Anyway it should be abolished as the great and the good will always find a way through any reformed system. If you were given an honour for “services to banking” or, let’s speculate, “defending Trump on a football website”, would you refuse because either was undeserved? It’s not rewarding celebs that’s important. It’s recognising the invisible that do good that is.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
If you were given an honour for “services to banking” or, let’s speculate, “defending Trump on a football website”, would you refuse because either was undeserved? It’s not rewarding celebs that’s important. It’s recognising the invisible that do good that is. Well done you!
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The honours system should be scrapped completely. Tony Blair reformed it, how's that working out. Edited by Badger11 (29 Mar 2024 7.19am) Don't you mean Sir Anthony Charles Lynton Blair KG?
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
If you were given an honour for “services to banking” or, let’s speculate, “defending Trump on a football website”, would you refuse because either was undeserved? It’s not rewarding celebs that’s important. It’s recognising the invisible that do good that is. No I wouldn't but I'm sure you would for services rendered to the Establishment. And isn't that the point, millions of us have spent our lives doing a job which we are paid for so why should politicians, celebs and the Civil Service get rewarded with honours. They are just doing their jobs. As for the invisible yeah they throw a bone to the people ooh look one school cleaner gets an MBE whilst the great and the good are trousering the big gongs.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
No I wouldn't but I'm sure you would for services rendered to the Establishment. And isn't that the point, millions of us have spent our lives doing a job which we are paid for so why should politicians, celebs and the Civil Service get rewarded with honours. They are just doing their jobs. As for the invisible yeah they throw a bone to the people ooh look one school cleaner gets an MBE whilst the great and the good are trousering the big gongs.
Don’t think anyone’s likely to recommend me for an award! I might get a “Certificate of Merit” for longevity as a bowler if I make 90! “Services to the Establishment”? You’re having a laugh! Countering cynicism perhaps but there would be objections. I have no problem in trying to ensure only the truly meritorious receive awards. Surely that can be done by completely removing the responsibility from politicians and civil servants and putting it solely in the hands of an independent commission directly under the control of, and appointed by, the monarchy.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
How the hell did Jimmy Savile slip through the net. Its fairly certain Downing Street & other top influencers had all heard the rumours. It seems not. He was quite cosy with Thatcher and had several photo opportunities with her. He was regarded as an untouchable national treasure. For me he was always just weird.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Identical conspiracy for a) Savile never getting convicted and b) him getting a knighthood. I refuse to believe the people around Thatcher didn't know. Every bloody vulnerable girl in every orphanage & care institution knew. Even the tea lady at the bbc knew. Sir jimmy savile ....only slightly less shocking than sir Gerry Adams or Sir anjem Choudery. Edited by PalazioVecchio (29 Mar 2024 9.56pm)
“I want to kill Jimmy Savile – he’s a hypocrite. I bet he’s into all kinds of seediness that we all know about but aren’t allowed to talk about. I know some rumours,”
|
|
|
Whilst I was working overseas one of our guys wives was something big in the scouts, she had been heavily involved with them in various capacities all over the world for about 50 years & was awarded a gong ( cant remember which one) & got to travel to London to meet the Queen / have it bestowed on her - to me thats the kind of person that deserves one. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Political honours perhaps, but if retained certainly taken away from the politicians themselves. For others, those individuals who often give selflessly to make lives better, or serve us well in other ways, it is a way to recognise that. I have a friend who was awarded the British Empire Medal for her charity work a few years back. It was completely unexpected and overwhelmed her. It was though well deserved as she has worked tirelessly for many years helping others for no reward but the smiles she gets.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Identical conspiracy for a) Savile never getting convicted and b) him getting a knighthood. I refuse to believe the people around Thatcher didn't know. Every bloody vulnerable girl in every orphanage & care institution knew. Even the tea lady at the bbc knew. Sir jimmy savile ....only slightly less shocking than sir Gerry Adams or Sir anjem Choudery. Edited by PalazioVecchio (29 Mar 2024 9.56pm) You have to remember that the overwhelming public face of Savile was a humble man who did things for other people - he made so many children's dreams come true on Jim'll Fix It; ran marathon after marathon for various charities, bringing in millions for them;he worked tirelessly in his 'free' time as an unpaid porter in Leeds hospital, and he even got himself involved in the fund raising for Royal charities - the ultimate stamp of approval. Yes, he was a bit of an oddball, but don't we British love our eccentric National Treasures? Now here's the rub, the public at large had no idea of his vile behaviour, so therefore, to not give him some sort of public recognition for charitable endeavours way above what others were being rewarded for every year would almost certainly have started questions being asked as to why he was being overlooked. Which would certainly have either made a lot of people 'in the know, but silent' very, very uncomfortable, or it would have blown the lid off the whole evil mess that was the truth behind the facade and a lot of heads would have had to roll. As for Sir Jerry Adams...... just give it time.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
You have to remember that the overwhelming public face of Savile was a humble man who did things for other people - he made so many children's dreams come true on Jim'll Fix It; ran marathon after marathon for various charities, bringing in millions for them;he worked tirelessly in his 'free' time as an unpaid porter in Leeds hospital, and he even got himself involved in the fund raising for Royal charities - the ultimate stamp of approval. Yes, he was a bit of an oddball, but don't we British love our eccentric National Treasures? Now here's the rub, the public at large had no idea of his vile behaviour, so therefore, to not give him some sort of public recognition for charitable endeavours way above what others were being rewarded for every year would almost certainly have started questions being asked as to why he was being overlooked. Which would certainly have either made a lot of people 'in the know, but silent' very, very uncomfortable, or it would have blown the lid off the whole evil mess that was the truth behind the facade and a lot of heads would have had to roll. As for Sir Jerry Adams...... just give it time. Well said, totally agree.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
You have to remember that the overwhelming public face of Savile was a humble man who did things for other people - he made so many children's dreams come true on Jim'll Fix It; ran marathon after marathon for various charities, bringing in millions for them;he worked tirelessly in his 'free' time as an unpaid porter in Leeds hospital, and he even got himself involved in the fund raising for Royal charities - the ultimate stamp of approval. Yes, he was a bit of an oddball, but don't we British love our eccentric National Treasures? Now here's the rub, the public at large had no idea of his vile behaviour, so therefore, to not give him some sort of public recognition for charitable endeavours way above what others were being rewarded for every year would almost certainly have started questions being asked as to why he was being overlooked. Which would certainly have either made a lot of people 'in the know, but silent' very, very uncomfortable, or it would have blown the lid off the whole evil mess that was the truth behind the facade and a lot of heads would have had to roll. As for Sir Jerry Adams...... just give it time. Excellent post. Much has been made about Thatcher but there is a committee that vets these things. I'm sure Maggie had plenty to do back then running the country rather then delving into every nomination. So the question is did the committee warn against him if not why not. If yes then why did Thatcher over rule them? And before people start saying these were rumours he wasn't charged with anything therefore.... Plenty of people have been turned down for gongs because there was the whiff of impropriety against them, plenty also have got them because the PM has been keen, which also stinks.
One more point |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.