You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC 2010's best and worst signings
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

CPFC 2010's best and worst signings


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
PJEagle Flag London 30 May 24 7.16pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

The best 5 are probably about right. I'd argue you could chuck Cabaye in. It was the first time of this era the club bought a Champions League level player, a real coup at the time, and he made us a lot better to watch - particularly around that era where we beat Arsenal 3-0. Andersen probably isn't far behind either.

Not so sure about the worst 5.

Sakho wasn't great in hindsight but the fans signed him as much as the club did. Everyone was baying for that to take place after how good the loan spell was. I'd argue the loan spell could be in our top 5 transfers as it kept us in the league.

Wickham was just unfortunate. He was doing alright until the injury and probably would have had a good career with us. Sometimes injuries happen.

The club's got a good record on signings. You can point back to some horrors during the first promotion summer including Kebe, Marange, Fryers, Hunt etc. but none were particularly expensive. Of the current crop Ahamada and Franca are possible risks to enter that list purely because their fee was fairly high but time is on their side.

Ahamada looks like a great signing, but too early to know if he's really as good as his expensive signing suggests

Franca that is

Edited by PJEagle (30 May 2024 7.17pm)

 

Joseph Paxton Flag Lancing 30 May 24 11.47pm

Benteke...Jonathan. (2016-17)
1 App 0 Goals, then injured.

Just to keep his big brother on the books? Who will know?

Before Gegenpressing came the Belgian tactic of nepotism

 


Be where you are; otherwise you will miss your life.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 May 24 7.59am

Originally posted by Joseph Paxton

Benteke...Jonathan. (2016-17)
1 App 0 Goals, then injured.

Just to keep his big brother on the books? Who will know?

Before Gegenpressing came the Belgian tactic of nepotism

Over the years there have been many stories at clubs like this or the player's father gets a "no show" job at the club. It's the price of doing business I'm afraid.

 


One more point

esox lucius Flag Deal 31 May 24 9.29am

Worst has to be Yaya Sonogo, god he was truly awful.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 31 May 24 9.37am

Originally posted by esox lucius

Worst has to be Yaya Sonogo, god he was truly awful.

He's currently playing in China after a season in Armenia.
Maybe he's found his level.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 31 May 24 3.21pm

Originally posted by doombear


Perhaps, but to what extent did his goals in that first season (15 in the league) keep us in the Prem? We finished 14th with our lowest points total (41) 7 points clear of Hull in 18th (who we beat in a 6 pointer in our last home game) but only ONE point above Watford in 17th. I'm not convinced we would have survived without his goals that season. Agree he was a waste of money, thereafter, although he wasn't helped by Royball.

Good points, we would’ve been buggered without his goals that first season and any striker would have struggled with Roy’s tactics, even though he did miss a lot of chances as well. But I think it was the arrogance and the laziness after that first season when things weren’t going his way that did him no favours and what are my main issues with him.
It summed him up perfectly when he pushed Luka aside to take that last minute penalty against Bournemouth. Anyone can miss a penalty but the arrogance to push Luka away for his own personal bit of glory ahead of the team when every man, woman and their dog knew at that time Luka would’ve buried it was unbelievable

 

IMMER PALACE Flag BIELEFELD 31 May 24 9.38pm

I think the fact people can't even remember Loic (go sick) Remy is a good combat indicator of his uselessness.

Pardew's transfer business nearly ruined us. There is a school of thought to say we are only just recovered from it.

I would like to see the managers we have had since promo rated on their transfer business.

For me, bottom would be Olly - but it is arguable Pardew was much worse. Big Sam was terrific in transfers. Pulis too.

 

thetopgeezer Flag Streatham Hill 03 Jun 24 7.36am

Can't have this thread without mentioning Wright and Bright.

Bright:
Paid 75k, sold for 1.3m, 91 goals

Wright:
Paid 1 set of weight lifting equipment, sold for 2.5m, 117 goals

There is so much to say about each of them but perhaps the most interesting is comparing what we witnessed with our exciting forward line just recently to what Wrighty and Brighty did for us back in the late eighties.

 

thetopgeezer Flag Streatham Hill 03 Jun 24 7.48am

Originally posted by thetopgeezer

Can't have this thread without mentioning Wright and Bright.

Bright:
Paid 75k, sold for 1.3m, 91 goals

Wright:
Paid 1 set of weight lifting equipment, sold for 2.5m, 117 goals

There is so much to say about each of them but perhaps the most interesting is comparing what we witnessed with our exciting forward line just recently to what Wrighty and Brighty did for us back in the late eighties.

Just realised the OP was since Parish but hey ho, it's worth a mention.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 03 Jun 24 10.56am

At least Rakip helped with training.

 


Red and Blue Army!

palace99 Flag New Mills 03 Jun 24 11.22am

Originally posted by thetopgeezer

Can't have this thread without mentioning Wright and Bright.

Bright:
Paid 75k, sold for 1.3m, 91 goals

Wright:
Paid 1 set of weight lifting equipment, sold for 2.5m, 117 goals

There is so much to say about each of them but perhaps the most interesting is comparing what we witnessed with our exciting forward line just recently to what Wrighty and Brighty did for us back in the late eighties.

Obviously this is a CPFC2010 thread so before their time.

Did we even pay that for Wright? When we signed him i don't think he had a club. It is often reported he signed from Greenwich Boro but my understanding is he was playing Sunday football and was on trial with Greenwich when they played a pre-season friendly at Dulwich and was spotted by Palace.

IMHO the best ever non league signing, not just for Palace but across all clubs. Others get mentioned such as Vardy, Ferdinand and Pearce who all went on to play for England but all involved transfer fees etc.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 03 Jun 24 11.30am

Originally posted by palace99

Obviously this is a CPFC2010 thread so before their time.

Did we even pay that for Wright? When we signed him i don't think he had a club. It is often reported he signed from Greenwich Boro but my understanding is he was playing Sunday football and was on trial with Greenwich when they played a pre-season friendly at Dulwich and was spotted by Palace.

IMHO the best ever non league signing, not just for Palace but across all clubs. Others get mentioned such as Vardy, Ferdinand and Pearce who all went on to play for England but all involved transfer fees etc.

I heard 20k at the time but could be anything.

 


Red and Blue Army!

palace99 Flag New Mills 03 Jun 24 12.34pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I heard 20k at the time but could be anything.

so who did we pay?

He never signed for Greenwich Boro

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC 2010's best and worst signings