You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace for England - Match Thread
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace for England - Match Thread


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
taylors lovechild Flag 21 Jun 24 8.18am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Wharton got 10 minutes in one of our pre tournament friendlies. He was superb. 100% pass accuracy. Really noticed by everyone.
What does Southgate do? Nothing. We haven't even heard about him again.
Managers moods in interviews always seems to translate into team performance.
Look at Glasner, Guardiola, Klopp and then Roy and Southgate. Chalk and cheese.
Southgate has become a nervous wreck. In interview, he has developed a forehead twitch. He is nervous, unsure and muddled. He talks as though he is trying to convince the world he knows what he is doing. Hasn't got a clue. Never has had.
He has got a great bunch of players who he simply cannot mould because he doesn't know how to.

Didn't he come on around 60 minutes? Weird to hear Southgate saying he has no natural replacement for Philips when he has Wharton on the bench. Last night was weird as England's biggest problem was they couldn't get control of the midfield but then he brings on Gallagher who is a box-to-box high-energy player, not someone you bring on to get control of a game. It didn't help that Rice was really poor. Guehi was up there for MotM, although that was perhaps supported by how awful everyone else was, especially the more senior players like Walker and Kane. Foden showed that when he comes into the middle he's a big threat. The problem was he was supposed to be on the left so England lacked balance. Eze came on and did the same, constantly trying to come inside. I really want Eze to play but surely Gordon is the more natural choice in this system?

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 21 Jun 24 8.25am

I'm beginning to think I don't want to see our players ruined by forcing them into this Hodgsonesque nightmare of an England team and 'strategy'.

Of course, I still want England to win the thing, but increasingly I just want our guys to come back uninjured.

Edited by Sansbup (21 Jun 2024 8.26am)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Jun 24 8.52am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Wharton got 10 minutes in one of our pre tournament friendlies. He was superb. 100% pass accuracy. Really noticed by everyone.
What does Southgate do? Nothing. We haven't even heard about him again.
Managers moods in interviews always seems to translate into team performance.
Look at Glasner, Guardiola, Klopp and then Roy and Southgate. Chalk and cheese.
Southgate has become a nervous wreck. In interview, he has developed a forehead twitch. He is nervous, unsure and muddled. He talks as though he is trying to convince the world he knows what he is doing. Hasn't got a clue. Never has had.
He has got a great bunch of players who he simply cannot mould because he doesn't know how to.

Through my red and blue specs, the answer to CM is obvious.

I suspect because of the age and limited experience GS really does not want to throw the kids in. Hence the TAA experiment. If you've got the ability you have the ability.

Unfortunately for England, Connor is the safer option. He'll add some energy, but he isnt technically good enough to play the role effectively.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Jun 24 8.56am

Originally posted by DenTyler

I have said before that Eze is great with Olise. I am more convinced than ever that if he leaves then the Eze we saw last night for England will be what people see. He seems to have found a place at palace and for his sake I would stay. He flourished under Roy and again under OG but was not great under PV.

As for England… I was screaming for Wharton. But possibly under Roy Southgate it could ruin him. But as it’s our country… stick him in and watch the team suddenly find rhythm and class.

I do wonder that as well. He really needs someone to play off. He (as do all attackers) benifit from getting the ball early. Every time he got hte ball last night it was at a standstill and he was expected to start from nothing.

Its why Foden is struggling, he need a fluid and dynamic system to operate in.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Jun 24 8.58am

Originally posted by Sansbup

I'm beginning to think I don't want to see our players ruined by forcing them into this Hodgsonesque nightmare of an England team and 'strategy'.

Of course, I still want England to win the thing, but increasingly I just want our guys to come back uninjured.

Edited by Sansbup (21 Jun 2024 8.26am)

The only upside I can see is they should be overjoyed to come back and be playing under Glasner, a proper manager, that's if they stay of course.

I think the Southgate and Hodgson comparisons are appropriate.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 21 Jun 24 12.27pm

As a Scotland fan I hesitate to intrude on private grief, especially after the Germany game, but I can’t see England winning this tournament. They should still top the group and be good enough to beat Poland but if they come up against Germany or Spain I don’t fancy their chances. Southgate’s squad selection was all wrong. There’s no balance in the team. Too many number 10s and he’s too conservative to play Wharton alongside Rice. Alexander-Arnold isn’t savvy enough to play in midfield, and selecting an injured left back with no cover was criminal.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Jun 24 2.06pm

Originally posted by Palacesince64

As a Scotland fan I hesitate to intrude on private grief, especially after the Germany game, but I can’t see England winning this tournament. They should still top the group and be good enough to beat Poland but if they come up against Germany or Spain I don’t fancy their chances. Southgate’s squad selection was all wrong. There’s no balance in the team. Too many number 10s and he’s too conservative to play Wharton alongside Rice. Alexander-Arnold isn’t savvy enough to play in midfield, and selecting an injured left back with no cover was criminal.

Thanks P64 some good comments. By the way the manager of the hotel where Scotland is staying has asked if the team can vacate their rooms by noon Monday seeing as how they wont be needing them.

 


One more point

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 21 Jun 24 4.54pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Thanks P64 some good comments. By the way the manager of the hotel where Scotland is staying has asked if the team can vacate their rooms by noon Monday seeing as how they wont be needing them.

To the Scot’s there’s no such thing as a knockout stage, it’s just called July…….the old ones are the best

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 21 Jun 24 9.01pm

-.-' I knew I shouldn’t have intruded on private grief

 

Fanofzhiyi Flag Kent 21 Jun 24 9.44pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

I'm beginning to think I don't want to see our players ruined by forcing them into this Hodgsonesque nightmare of an England team and 'strategy'.

Of course, I still want England to win the thing, but increasingly I just want our guys to come back uninjured.

Edited by Sansbup (21 Jun 2024 8.26am)

Like wise I am having similar feelings.

Southgate is lost tactically and always has been. He lifted the national team initially and enabled the players to enjoy it again but he has been found out long ago.

I read a good comment on TAA, of course he is not a midfielder but one thing he is good at his finding runners at Liverpool, Dias, salah etc. England only had saka against denmark. He then takes TAA and bring on Bowen and Watkins …….surely it should be then that we use TAA with them. Says a lot

This team is crying out for Wharton but without balance to the team even Wharton will struggle to lift them. Like watching palace under Hodgson again. Painful watching hoping we nick a goal. I didn’t even celebrate kanes goal, it was clearly thanks to walker doing a Munoz and a bit of luck. Could see what would happen after we score first

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Jun 24 11.41am

Originally posted by DenTyler

I have said before that Eze is great with Olise. I am more convinced than ever that if he leaves then the Eze we saw last night for England will be what people see. He seems to have found a place at palace and for his sake I would stay. He flourished under Roy and again under OG but was not great under PV.

As for England… I was screaming for Wharton. But possibly under Roy Southgate it could ruin him. But as it’s our country… stick him in and watch the team suddenly find rhythm and class.

Eze is icing, Olise is cake, i.e. he's not just decoration he affects the pattern of play in games - in a game of tactical insensity Eze can be useless - if it's flowing and he's getting service he can show off his undoubted talent, but a clever side could quite easily nullify him.

 

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 22 Jun 24 3.35pm

I think he'll play Bellingham deeper alongside Rice with Foden moved into the middle. Wharton is the answer but Southgate can't see it. He would prefer Mainoo to him, even though he is not a holding player.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

Putitout Flag Oxford 22 Jun 24 5.26pm

Wondering why he took Wharton, the boy gave a perfect example of his style and ability in twenty minutes or so against Bosnia, yet he doesn’t get a mention.
Wharton is not a cure all for Englands problems but he is Southgate’s best bet to partner Rice. The game now demands you defend from the front ,the four that make up the main attacking threat don’t do that, all good attacking players , but in two games not a clue how to press and win the ball bringing constant pressure in our own half of the pitch, which Wharton would still have to deal with, never the less Whartons speed of thought and passing ability would improve what we have seen so far. It needs more aggression in front of him and Rice if we are going to retain the ball and appear to play better.

 

pssguy Flag 22 Jun 24 5.42pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Wondering why he took Wharton, the boy gave a perfect example of his style and ability in twenty minutes or so against Bosnia, yet he doesn’t get a mention.


I wouldn't say he doesn't get a mention. Wright wants him in the team as do several of the Telegraph writers, amongst others. The consensus is Southgate doesn't have the balls

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 22 Jun 24 6.09pm

Originally posted by pssguy


I wouldn't say he doesn't get a mention. Wright wants him in the team as do several of the Telegraph writers, amongst others. The consensus is Southgate doesn't have the balls

Only one voice matters, Southgate’s, and he doesn’t mention Wharton. As for doesn’t have the balls, then as said why take him if frightened to use him.?

 

pssguy Flag 22 Jun 24 8.30pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Only one voice matters, Southgate’s, and he doesn’t mention Wharton. As for doesn’t have the balls, then as said why take him if frightened to use him.?

You didn't mention Southgate in your previous comment, He very rarely mentions players as being a possible inclusion. He might just have taken Wharton as cover for Rice if he got injured, similar to Henderson only being there for emergencies

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 22 Jun 24 9.07pm

Originally posted by pssguy

You didn't mention Southgate in your previous comment, He very rarely mentions players as being a possible inclusion. He might just have taken Wharton as cover for Rice if he got injured, similar to Henderson only being there for emergencies

I didn’t need to specify Southgate, The people you say talk of Wharton, don’t pick the team, It’s doubtful Southgate, has any regard for any of their opinions. Only What Southgate says ,or doesn’t say is what counts. And he says nothing on Wharton doesn’t give him a mention as said. If you disagree fair enough. Yes he may only see Wharton as cover for Rice, but , and this is just an opinion , Wharton could complement Rice, the situation cries out for a player of Whartons type to do just that.

 

pssguy Flag 23 Jun 24 12.33am

Originally posted by Putitout

I didn’t need to specify Southgate, The people you say talk of Wharton, don’t pick the team, It’s doubtful Southgate, has any regard for any of their opinions. Only What Southgate says ,or doesn’t say is what counts. And he says nothing on Wharton doesn’t give him a mention as said. If you disagree fair enough. Yes he may only see Wharton as cover for Rice, but , and this is just an opinion , Wharton could complement Rice, the situation cries out for a player of Whartons type to do just that.

Your original comment just lacked clarity to me

As regards Wharton, I agree he should be picked

He has just given an interview reported in the major papers implicitly suggesting to Southgate that he needs to be in the team. He certainly does not lack in confidence and I can see him on the Olise trajectory

I wonder what the protocol is on players giving interviews and whether they are given a script to adhere to. Not sure Adam stuck to it

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 23 Jun 24 5.45am

Very likely the last tournament for Southgate thankfully. Wharton has time on his side and hopefully the next England manager will see him for what he is and build the team around him, Rice and Bellingham.

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 23 Jun 24 8.07am

Wharton talking himself up.

[Link]

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace for England - Match Thread