Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2014 11.04pm
Since Wednesday, I've been busy at work (you got a job yet?) and mainly doing other stuff in the evenings. I don't get major kicks from crafting out message board posts as some.
Another pointless personal jibe. Aren't these sorts of posts largely what make a lot of "debates" on here completely unreadable? I never thought I'd hear myself say this, but can we not attempt to exclusively discuss UKIP?
Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2014 11.04pm
Where do you live? You clearly are unaware of towns such as Boston who have been invaded by Poles - the type I was referring to - nor do you care.
Given the nature of this debate, I'd rather not feed you with further personal information so that we can discuss how legitimate my experience is rather than the actual topic of discussion. If you're happy to provide a list of market towns where residents can't hold a credible view on immigration, I'd be interested to see it.
Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2014 11.04pm
And it IS about life experience and you have bugger all. How can you judge credibility without such.
You outlined the life experience requirement as "living in a market town" and I met it. To now claim that is of no relevance is moving the goalposts in the most blatant sense, surely?!
Also, I think it's quite obvious that you hold opinions on subjects that haven't directly affected you. Presumably you have a view on asylum seekers, abortion, policing and so on.
If you're going to insist on life experience being present for someone to have a credible opinion in a discussion, you're going to end up having fairly brief debates that you (and the other participants) will have to frequently excuse yourselves from.
Quote Penge Eagle at 16 May 2014 11.04pm
Farage has more than you and doesn't have the blinkers because he sees that is an issue in many parts of the country. You failed to see that is the case at all. Even your party Labour admitted they got it wrong on immigration but you refuse to accept it.
So which market town has Nigel Farage lived in? I fail to see what lived experience he has of immigration. You mentioned privilege earlier, I think it's quite obvious Farage has had it pretty easy.
Obviously I disagree with the Labour party, who at the end of the day are just trying to represent their supporters who tell them that they have concerns about immigration. Nobody's denying immigration isn't a big issue; I believe only the economy is seen as more important.
I would humbly suggest that you're judging people's life experience on the basis of whether they agree with you, rather than judging whether people have life experience before you decide whether they are credible, as you seem to be suggesting.
"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee
|