You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 22 2026 12.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 30 of 44 < 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 >
Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 17 Dec 16 11.52am

Originally posted by 7mins


It's a disciplinary offence to use a mobile phone for personal reasons in a train cab (the rules were changed slightly a few years ago, as rules were made before widespread mobile phone use)
Staff are risking their job by getting these images out there.
But off the top of my head I can think of a few get outs a smart union rep could use if any action was taken.

The rule book stats phones can't be used for personal use. If they are taking pics of failed safety equipment, it could be argued that it was documenting a safety issue that might be useful to fleet control.

They could also say, the pic was taken with a tablet.. that had no communication capability.

But drivers/guards need to be careful.


Edited by 7mins (17 Dec 2016 11.42am)

So safety only applies when it suits?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 17 Dec 16 11.57am

Originally posted by 7mins

Also, drivers are soon to be given company iPads, one of the reasons they want to do this is to take away the need for drivers to write reports after shifts about faulty equipment. (A driver doesn't have to stay behind to write reports, so fleet might not be made aware of problems for a few days )
With iPads the driver can take pics, and email off instantly. The iPad roll out was meant to happen before xmas, but has been put on hold. The last thing Southern need now is drivers reporting more issues with in cab CCTV. We wanted to do the iPad thing years ago. Drivers get issued weekly operating notifications (WONs) and periodically operating notices (PONs) these are A5 size documents with over 100 pages, that every driver gets every week. Putting that info on to a iPad at a click of a button seemed very cost effective.

And that's happening - so their lives are being made easier but I suspect that using it, whilst the train is operational and picking up passengers, may be frowned upon?
I don't know any industry where new technology isn't held up for some reason or another.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 17 Dec 16 12.02pm

Originally posted by 7mins


It's a disciplinary offence to use a mobile phone for personal reasons in a train cab (the rules were changed slightly a few years ago, as rules were made before widespread mobile phone use)
Staff are risking their job by getting these images out there.
But off the top of my head I can think of a few get outs a smart union rep could use if any action was taken.

The rule book stats phones can't be used for personal use. If they are taking pics of failed safety equipment, it could be argued that it was documenting a safety issue that might be useful to fleet control.

They could also say, the pic was taken with a tablet.. that had no communication capability.

But drivers/guards need to be careful.


Edited by 7mins (17 Dec 2016 11.42am)

So they're risking their jobs and potentially compromising passenger safety to take photos in a cab whilst a train is operational to identify the faulty equipment that they are shortly to be getting iPads to report immediately, so said faults are fixed quicker?
So any faulty cctv will be sorted out a lot quicker so it will start to get safer as all cameras will work.
Their job will be made easier by cutting out extensive end of shift reporting of faults.
They will have a conductor on the train - who will, I assume, deal with internal passenger issues - so the ratio isn't 1200:1 in reality (although granted it will be on some trains).
Yet they strike?

Edited by Helmet46 (17 Dec 2016 12.10pm)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 17 Dec 16 12.59pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

So they're risking their jobs and potentially compromising passenger safety to take photos in a cab whilst a train is operational to identify the faulty equipment that they are shortly to be getting iPads to report immediately, so said faults are fixed quicker?
So any faulty cctv will be sorted out a lot quicker so it will start to get safer as all cameras will work.
Their job will be made easier by cutting out extensive end of shift reporting of faults.
They will have a conductor on the train - who will, I assume, deal with internal passenger issues - so the ratio isn't 1200:1 in reality (although granted it will be on some trains).
Yet they strike?

Edited by Helmet46 (17 Dec 2016 12.10pm)

You can easily make a train safe and use a camera in a safe manner.
(DRA, Master Switch to neutral)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 17 Dec 16 1.02pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

So safety only applies when it suits?

No, if a driver or guard used their camera to take pics of failed safety equipment, while the train was at a stand, they'd be no safety implications, if a driver was on Tinder while train doing 90 up the brighton main line, they'd be safety implications

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 17 Dec 16 1.25pm

Originally posted by 7mins

You can easily make a train safe and use a camera in a safe manner.
(DRA, Master Switch to neutral)

But, in any case, this issue has been recognised and they're getting iPads to make the fault reporting clearer so they don't need to use their own phones. (Plus if they were using their phones to report an issue it'd be ok but I still think it's disciplinary if they are using them to post pictures of the companies property on social media with a view to criticising their employer).

 

7mins Flag In the bush 17 Dec 16 2.04pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

But, in any case, this issue has been recognised and they're getting iPads to make the fault reporting clearer so they don't need to use their own phones. (Plus if they were using their phones to report an issue it'd be ok but I still think it's disciplinary if they are using them to post pictures of the companies property on social media with a view to criticising their employer).

You're closer to making a valid point about posting on social media, Southern certainly had a Social Media Policy when I was there.

Be hard to find out who it was thou, as no crime has been committed, I guess Facebook/twitter wouldn't release details.

Personally I'm glad the drivers/guards are doing this, more info lets people come to a more informed decision.


[Link]

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 Dec 16 4.33pm

Originally posted by 7mins

You're closer to making a valid point about posting on social media, Southern certainly had a Social Media Policy when I was there.

Be hard to find out who it was thou, as no crime has been committed, I guess Facebook/twitter wouldn't release details.

Personally I'm glad the drivers/guards are doing this, more info lets people come to a more informed decision.


[Link]

Don't upset Stuk by posting one sides argument. Apparently RMT press releases are irrelevant and all lies (despite no evidence to back this up or if it's even been read)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 17 Dec 16 5.13pm

Originally posted by 7mins

No, if a driver or guard used their camera to take pics of failed safety equipment, while the train was at a stand, they'd be no safety implications, if a driver was on Tinder while train doing 90 up the brighton main line, they'd be safety implications

What about a video showing members of the public around the cab?

Where you got the still from?

[Link]

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

7mins Flag In the bush 17 Dec 16 6.16pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

What about a video showing members of the public around the cab?

Where you got the still from?

[Link]

Was it filmed on a phone? Was it at a stand? It would nearly impossible to prove what it was filmed on. He could even say it was in airplane mode. The rule is using a communication device for personal use.
It could have been a test train.
Too many variables... to be certain of a disciplinary.

He would however fall foul of the social media policy if he was saying something derogatory. That would be easy to prove.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 17 Dec 16 6.22pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Was it filmed on a phone? Was it at a stand? It would nearly impossible to prove what it was filmed on. He could even say it was in airplane mode. The rule is using a communication device for personal use.
It could have been a test train.
Too many variables... to be certain of a disciplinary.

He would however fall foul of the social media policy if he was saying something derogatory. That would be easy to prove.


Well you deemed a still from the video of good (or not) enough quality to back up your argument.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

7mins Flag In the bush 17 Dec 16 7.09pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch


Well you deemed a still from the video of good (or not) enough quality to back up your argument.

I'm not sure I understand your point?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 Dec 16 7.38pm

Originally posted by 7mins

I'm not sure I understand your point?

It's called whataboutery, it's a sort of 'look over there ' distraction technique.

The CCTV images look s***ty, but it's not just about doors it's train despatch which the guard replacement role will not fulfil.

Edited by nickgusset (17 Dec 2016 7.40pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 17 Dec 16 8.02pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

It's called whataboutery, it's a sort of 'look over there ' distraction technique.

The CCTV images look s***ty, but it's not just about doors it's train despatch which the guard replacement role will not fulfil.

Edited by nickgusset (17 Dec 2016 7.40pm)

Haha pathetic. The only distraction technique is yours as you don't like the fact that the video that image comes from

A) shows that the CCTV is not as unclear as the still would suggest.

B) shows there are in fact two screens for a driver to look at both perfectly clear

C) that drivers seem to pick and choose where passenger safety Is applied.

So stick your whataboutery, it wasn't me that posted the original image.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 18 Dec 16 1.16am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Haha pathetic. The only distraction technique is yours as you don't like the fact that the video that image comes from

A) shows that the CCTV is not as unclear as the still would suggest.

B) shows there are in fact two screens for a driver to look at both perfectly clear

C) that drivers seem to pick and choose where passenger safety Is applied.

So stick your whataboutery, it wasn't me that posted the original image.


It's really not worth the bother. The world is flat!!!
I think if this argument were the other way around and the Company were trying to give on board conductors additional safety responsibility then the union and some on here would be citing the CCTV images as being more than adequate - arguing that this constitutes additional responsibility and that they are taking work away from the drivers, need more money etc etc.
It's just blind union support irrespective on one hand and an anti company agenda from a disgruntled ex employee, trying to atone for shafting loads of people at the behest of an irresponsible Employer on the other.
As I keep saying, both sides are to blame here but no one is thinking of the passenger.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Dec 16 1.35am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Haha pathetic. The only distraction technique is yours as you don't like the fact that the video that image comes from

A) shows that the CCTV is not as unclear as the still would suggest.

B) shows there are in fact two screens for a driver to look at both perfectly clear

C) that drivers seem to pick and choose where passenger safety Is applied.

So stick your whataboutery, it wasn't me that posted the original image.

The fact you sidetracked about point 3 in taking a photo of the CCTV screens is what I thought was whataboutery. You paint it as if the photo was taken by a driver whilst hurtling through the countryside!

Your other points may be valid but I don't recall you mentioning them before. Correct me if I'm wrong.

However, read back through the testimonies from drivers on here, you'll see the job of train despatch can involve much more than checking a tiny monitor. What if it's foggy?

The trains are long and full. If southern can't spend some of their profit and guarantee safer journeys. They've been commissioned to run a safe public service. All Aslef and the RMT want is for their members to feel they are working to a very high safety standard. Southern want to compromise this therefore they're not fulfilling their duty as a service provider.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Dec 16 1.37am

Originally posted by Helmet46


It's really not worth the bother. The world is flat!!!
I think if this argument were the other way around and the Company were trying to give on board conductors additional safety responsibility then the union and some on here would be citing the CCTV images as being more than adequate - arguing that this constitutes additional responsibility and that they are taking work away from the drivers, need more money etc etc.
It's just blind union support irrespective on one hand and an anti company agenda from a disgruntled ex employee, trying to atone for shafting loads of people at the behest of an irresponsible Employer on the other.
As I keep saying, both sides are to blame here but no one is thinking of the passenger.

See my previous post.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 2.13am

.

IMG_1815.JPG Attachment: IMG_1815.JPG (59.89Kb)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 2.14am

.

IMG_1421.PNG Attachment: IMG_1421.PNG (931.04Kb)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 18 Dec 16 2.14am

.

IMG_1761.JPG Attachment: IMG_1761.JPG (2,194.45Kb)

 

Page 30 of 44 < 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong